Choice Classic Radio Detectives | Old Time Radio
Episode: Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar: The Virtuous Mobster Matter
Release Date: June 2, 2025
Original Air Date: June 22, 1958
Host/Author: Choice Classic Radio

Introduction

Choice Classic Radio presents one of old time radio’s most intriguing detective stories in this episode of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar. Titled "The Virtuous Mobster Matter," the episode delves into Johnny Dollar's investigation intertwined with past alliances and present dangers. The narrative is rich with suspense, betrayal, and unexpected twists, capturing the essence of the Golden Age of Radio’s detective dramas.

Act One: Unsettling Developments

The episode opens with Johnny Dollar receiving a call from his old friend, Lefty, who expresses concern over their mutual acquaintance, Joe Picatello. Lefty reveals that after purchasing the Caraway plantation in South Carolina, they intend to secure new insurance for the property. However, Johnny senses something amiss when Lefty admits that Joe has been unresponsive despite multiple attempts to meet.

Notable Quote:

Lefty: "There's something wrong about it, Johnny. And if I was you, I'd come down here and find out."
[02:45]

Suspecting foul play, Johnny decides to take matters into his own hands, planning to visit Georgetown to investigate Joe's sudden disappearance. This decision sets the stage for the ensuing mystery, hinting at deeper connections between Johnny, Lefty, and Joe.

Act Two: The Confrontation at Georgetown

Johnny's journey leads him to Georgetown, South Carolina, where he documents his expenses and proceeds to Joe Picatello's office. Upon arrival, Johnny knocks but receives no response. The situation grows tense as he notices suspicious activities inside the darkened building.

Johnny confronts Joe, only to be met with hostility and aggression. A struggle ensues, and Johnny ends up seemingly beaten by Lefty and Flippy, Joe’s associates. However, in a dramatic twist, Johnny discovers that the assailants are impostors impersonating Joe and his friends. This deception raises suspicions about who is truly behind the attacks.

Notable Quote:

Johnny Dollar: "I can't believe it, but I could see him in the light from the street."
[14:39]

As Johnny regains consciousness, it becomes clear that a deeper plot is unfolding. The appearance of Shep Lock, known as "the Twin," introduces a new layer of complexity, revealing that the true criminals have orchestrated the attack to discredit Joe.

Act Three: Unmasking the Truth

The final act intensifies the conflict as Johnny confronts the real Joe Picatello and the twin betrayals by Lefty and Flippy. In an intense dialogue, Joe explains his predicament, revealing that he was used as bait by the Secret Service to lure out the real criminals, Shep and Willie. This revelation exposes the manipulation by law enforcement and the intricate web of alliances and betrayals.

Johnny navigates the hazardous situation, managing to turn the tables on the impostors. The resolution sees Johnny surviving the ordeal, gathering crucial evidence, and ultimately bringing the true culprits to justice.

Notable Quote:

Joe Picatello: "He knew that'd flush them out. Get Shep and Willie out. Looking for me. Gunning for me."
[21:15]

Conclusion

"The Virtuous Mobster Matter" stands out as a compelling episode that masterfully blends suspense, character development, and plot twists. Johnny Dollar's unwavering determination and keen investigative skills shine through as he unravels the conspiracy against him and his old friend Joe. The episode underscores themes of loyalty, deception, and the thin line between right and wrong.

Notable Quote:

Johnny Dollar: "In this insurance business, you never know what you'll run into."
[23:21]

Listeners are left with a vivid portrayal of Johnny Dollar’s resilience and the complexities of navigating a world where past alliances can resurface with deadly consequences.

Key Takeaways

• Complex Relationships: The episode highlights the intricate relationships between Johnny, Lefty, and Joe, emphasizing how past associations can impact present circumstances.

• Deception and Betrayal: The use of impostors and the revelation of Joe's predicament showcase the pervasive nature of deceit within the narrative.

• Detective Ingenuity: Johnny Dollar exemplifies the quintessential detective, using his wit and resourcefulness to uncover the truth amidst chaos.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Lefty: "There's something wrong about it, Johnny. And if I was you, I'd come down here and find out."
  [02:45]

• Johnny Dollar: "I can't believe it, but I could see him in the light from the street."
  [14:39]

• Joe Picatello: "He knew that'd flush them out. Get Shep and Willie out. Looking for me. Gunning for me."
  [21:15]

• Johnny Dollar: "In this insurance business, you never know what you'll run into."
  [23:21]

Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar continues to be a cornerstone of old time radio detective stories, and "The Virtuous Mobster Matter" encapsulates the essence of the genre with its engaging plot and memorable characters. Whether you're a longtime fan or new to Johnny Dollar’s adventures, this episode offers a captivating glimpse into the world of radio detective fiction.