Loading summary
Josh Dean
This is an iHeart podcast.
Rory Scoville
Guaranteed Human.
Rory Scovel
This is Special Agent Riegel, Special Agent Bradley Hall.
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
In 2018, the FBI took down a ring of spies working for China's Ministry of State Security, one of the most mysterious intelligence agencies in the world.
Narrator / MSS Officer
The Sixth Bureau podcast is a story of the inner workings of the MSS and how one man's ambition and mistakes opened its vault of secrets.
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
Listen to the 6th Bureau on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcast.
Nancy Glass
I'm Nancy Glass, host of the Burden of Guilt season two podcast. This is a story about a horrendous lie that destroyed two families. Late one night, Bobby Gumprite became the victim of a random crime. The perpetrator was sentenced to 99 years until a confession changed everything.
Narrator / MSS Officer
I was a monster.
Nancy Glass
Listen to Burden of guilt season two on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get podcasts.
Josh Dean
What if mind control is real?
Rory Scoville
If you could control the behavior of anybody around you, what kind of life would you have?
Josh Dean
Can you hypnotically persuade someone to buy a car?
Rory Scovel
When you look at your car, you're going to become overwhelmed with such good feelings.
Josh Dean
Can you hypnotize someone into sleeping with you?
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
I gave her some suggestions to be sexually aroused.
Josh Dean
Can you get someone to join your cult?
Amanda Knox
NLP was used on me to access my subconscious mind games.
Josh Dean
A new podcast, exploring nlp, AKA neuro linguistic programming. Is it a self help miracle, a shady hypnosis scam? Or both? Listen to Mind Games on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Amanda Knox
I'm Amanda Knox and in the new podcast the Case of Lucy Letby, we unpack the story of an unimaginable tragedy that gripped the UK in 2023. But what if we didn't get the whole story?
Rory Scoville
Evidence has been made sufficient. The moment you look at the whole picture, the case collapsed.
Amanda Knox
What if the truth was disguised by a story we chose to believe?
Rory Scoville
Oh, my God. I think she might be inn.
Amanda Knox
Listen to Doubt the Case of Lucy Letby on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Rory Scoville
Can you spell syphilis? Hard word to spell.
Rory Scovel
S Y Phyllis.
Rory Scoville
Campsite media. Okay, Rory, I've got a great question for you this week.
Rory Scovel
All right, hit me. Hit me right, right in the earballs.
Rory Scoville
What's the best way to escape from prison?
Rory Scovel
I think Tim Robbins answered that. You spend a lot of time digging a hole behind a movie poster and eventually go through a sewer system and Climb through a pipe of shit and then come out in a creek somewhere. So, nice try, Josh. Nice try, But I already got it.
Rory Scoville
What are you digging that hole with? A spoon. Right?
Rory Scovel
With a spoon, right.
Rory Scoville
That you've smuggled from the cafeteria that
Rory Scovel
Matt Morgan Freeman helped get.
Rory Scoville
All right, you nailed it. Next question.
Rory Scovel
It's all right there. It's all right there.
Rory Scoville
Actually, I was going to say, how about tricking the prosecution back into court and convincing them to unlock the handcuffs themselves?
Rory Scovel
All right. I didn't know we were doing magic.
Rory Scoville
Here we go. This week, the story of one of the most prolific and creative escape artists of the 20th century. A guy who tried all kinds of things, but in the end won his freedom by tricking the cops into sabotaging their own case. Wait, is this guy too smart for Crimeless? I guess you'll be the judge.
Rory Scovel
Yeah.
Rory Scoville
This is Crimeless. Welcome back to Crimeless, the podcast that celebrates the amazing creativity of the world's dumbest criminals. I'm Josh Dean.
Rory Scovel
And I am Rory Scoville.
Rory Scoville
Okay, I got a treat for you this afternoon, Rory.
Rory Scovel
I'm very excited.
Rory Scoville
I'm going to tell you about a guy who became a folk hero in England in the 1960s for breaking out of prison many times.
Rory Scovel
Okay.
Rory Scoville
He spent a total of 841 days on the run, which doesn't even include his juvenile delinquencies. He was basically on the run most of his adult life.
Rory Scovel
Man.
Rory Scoville
What do you imagine that the master of escapes would look like? Tough question. I mean, it could be anything, but, like, do you have an image in your mind?
Rory Scovel
I'm picturing Hugh Jackman from the Prestige.
Rory Scoville
Good answer. Good answer. This guy's name is Alfred George Hines. And I use the past tense here because Alfred is no longer with us. When he was alive, he was a pale, balding guy with glasses who liked to wear suits. A 1962 Time magazine article described him as a, quote, peaceable chap, and everyone called him Alfie.
Rory Scovel
All right? Likability. So he had likability on his side.
Rory Scoville
He did. And a cute name. You don't hear a lot of Alfies anymore.
Rory Scovel
You don't. You don't get that a lot.
Rory Scoville
So to really understand this chap, we got a flashback to his childhood. Picture this. East London, 1920s. It's cold, it's dirty, it's probably raining. Everything is gray, even the people. And little Alfie's dad gets arrested for armed robbery and his sentence. Because the 1920s in England were apparently still. The medieval times was 10 lashes of a whip known as the cat. O9 tails.
Rory Scovel
Man.
Rory Scoville
This is the 1920s. So Alfie's dad died, it seems, from those lashes or the aftermath. And little Alfie gets sent to live in a children's home.
Rory Scovel
How old is Alfie?
Rory Scoville
Seven.
Rory Scovel
Okay.
Rory Scoville
And at just seven years old, he makes his first escape from the children's home.
Rory Scovel
Yep.
Rory Scoville
So he's a prodigy.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. And nothing new about a child of crime being wildly traumatized by quote, unquote, justice and leading to a life of crime. This story. This story follows a typical script here so far.
Rory Scoville
Are you saying that if your father had died from being whipped to death, you might have an effect on what would happen the rest of your life?
Rory Scovel
I think more than likely, yeah. I think I'd probably have an issue with authority.
Rory Scoville
So, sadly, the method of this first escape is a mystery. His own book just says that he ran away, which is probably right, because I don't think there's high security in a, like a home for seven year old boys because they, you know, assume you maybe would stay.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Especially if you have nowhere to go.
Rory Scoville
But anyway, he runs away. A few years later, he's arrested for petty theft, shoplifting. Basically, he's placed in a British home for troubled teens called a borstal. A borstal is apparently a thing established in 1902 as a sort of junior prison, a place for teen criminals to be quote, trained through hard work and discipline. Sounds fun.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. And to also share with each other their experiences so that everyone can face to face, gain more knowledge of how to break the law more effectively or ineffectively, I guess, if they're all in this prison together.
Rory Scoville
Yeah. Because we, we know that, like, what definitely works with troubled teens is putting them in, like, an austere place and making them work really hard.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. Surrounded by other troubled teens who are also upset at the exact same thing. Yeah.
Rory Scoville
Yep. Great idea, guys.
Rory Scovel
Yeah.
Rory Scoville
You're not going to be shocked when I tell you that Alfie broke out. How do you think he did it this time?
Rory Scovel
I mean, I feel like he probably just was like, hey, I'm gonna go get the mail. I don't know. I can't stop picturing the movie Annie where he just got in the dirty laundry and was carted out.
Rory Scoville
I mean, actually, the truth is, I don't know the answer. We couldn't find out. So we're just gonna go with your version.
Rory Scovel
Oh, great. Everyone picture Annie. And picture that the whole Borstol sang a song before he left.
Rory Scoville
So then World War II breaks out. He's drafted into the British Army. And the escape from that, too. It seems like his home gets bombed in 1941.
Rory Scovel
Also picture everyone that he escaped the army by getting in the dirty laundry. And everyone sing a song before that as well.
Rory Scoville
They just stop, put their guns down, and break into a little number. He had heard that his home had been bombed and he felt like he had to run home and help by deserting, apparently. Again, details a little fuzzy. This is an older story, so we weren't quite able to get some of the granular detail of his early years. But suffice it to say, he's broken out of basically every. The army's not a prison. I guess it's a kind of prison.
Rory Scovel
Yep.
Rory Scoville
You're not exactly allowed to just quit.
Rory Scovel
Yep, that's right.
Rory Scoville
So for the next few years, he's pretty much on the lam. He has a few stints in jail, and then he finally settles down and get married. But then in 1953, his quiet life is disrupted when he's accused of cracking a safe at a furniture store and stealing 38,000 pounds worth of cash and jewelry, which is more than 1.3 million in today's money.
Rory Scovel
Oh, man. Wow.
Rory Scoville
So he was on the up and up and then.
Rory Scovel
And he got married because he stole her heart. Thief through and through.
Rory Scoville
I shouldn't have laughed at that.
Rory Scovel
No, you should have. It was my best joke.
Rory Scoville
It was pretty good. Alfie claims he was framed, though. He says a buddy from his old crime days, a guy named Gridley Nichols, which is awesome.
Rory Scovel
Which we all know is not a real name at all.
Rory Scoville
So Gridley says he can get him a nice rug, which were very pricey at the time and still are. Have you bought a rug lately? Very surprisingly expensive rugs.
Rory Scovel
Look, all I'm going to say is it's. No, it's no surprise Gridley turned to a life of crime. Like, obviously, zero support from his parents. They're at the hospital. What do you want to name the baby? Gridley. All right. Well, he was. He clearly grew up unloved. I'm Gridley Nichols. You wouldn't believe that name in a musical.
Rory Scoville
I was going to say it. It seems like he's, like, holding a cane, Swirling a cane. Right.
Rory Scovel
Has an eye patch. I'm Gridley Nichols.
Rory Scoville
Well, the story Alfie said, he says, so Gridley wants to borrow his car to pick this sweet rug up. It was an offer Alfie couldn't refuse. So he lends Gridley his car, but Gridley never comes Back with the car or the rug. So Alfie calls the cops. Oh. Turns out Gridley and his crew had used the car to rob a furniture store. And Alfie pleads innocent. All the evidence against him is circumstantial, but of course, because of his life of crime, his long rap sheet, he's charged. And after a 30 minute deliberation, a jury declares that Alfie is guilty.
Rory Scovel
Yep.
Rory Scoville
He's deemed a most dangerous criminal, despite never really hurting anyone, and sentenced to 12 years in prison.
Rory Scovel
Man.
Rory Scoville
And not just any prison. Nottingham prison. I don't know anything about Nottingham prison, but it's. It's like a city that's in Robin Hood, I think.
Rory Scovel
I think don't mess with the Sheriff. That's all I know.
Rory Scoville
So he's in Nottingham. How do you think prison went this time?
Rory Scovel
Well, I assume everyone's in tights and earth tones and constantly having to watch bow and arrow competitions from afar.
Rory Scoville
Do you think he sticks around?
Rory Scovel
Of course not. This guy's life of crime, it's less a life of crime and it's more a. Honestly, a life of freedom. It just shows the human spirit cannot be contained. As Morgan Freeman said, some birds feathers are just too bright.
Rory Scoville
Is that an actual quote from I screwed it up.
Rory Scovel
But yeah, if. If the listeners are willing to hit pause, go back and rewatch Shawshank right now, and then come back and unpause it, you'll. You'll know that I'm right.
Rory Scoville
Sometimes it makes me sad though, and being gone, I have to remind myself that some birds aren't meant to caged. Their feathers are just too bright. All right, wow. How many have you seen Sha Shang?
Rory Scovel
A lot of times I've never seen it.
Rory Scoville
Okay, so Alfie breaks out, of course. Like I, you know, and this time, how do you. Any ideas for how you've already used your. You got laundry basket?
Rory Scovel
Yeah, they know. They know the not to not do the laundry system. I don't know. I honestly don't know. I'm surprised that anyone breaks out of prison, but yet at the same time, you find it happening more often than you'd ever think. But I don't know, back then I feel like it's so lackadaisical. Like just, you know, I picture Star wars where you just punch someone, put on their clothes, and walk straight out the front door.
Rory Scoville
Close. He memorized the shape of the key to the jail's workshop and made his own copy.
Rory Scovel
Oh, my God.
Rory Scoville
Wow.
Rory Scovel
Yep.
Rory Scoville
And then along with another inmate, he used pieces of wood from the Workshop to scale two walls, then rips through a metal fence and ran.
Rory Scovel
Good for him.
Rory Scoville
Nottingham police and a German shepherd named Frankie gave chase, but the dog quickly loses the scent. His one job, follow the scent.
Rory Scovel
Quickly loses the scent. Like he just didn't want to jog.
Rory Scoville
Yeah, because it's not even a hard thing for dogs to do. That's literally. That's what. That's all they do.
Rory Scovel
You think he'd be excited. Finally, an escapee.
Rory Scoville
Nope. Frankie fails. So cops question drivers and suspicious cars watch train stations around England. But Alfie's gone. And he's also now a bit of a legend with a nickname. Houdini Hines.
Rory Scovel
I like that a lot.
Rory Scoville
What would you do if you were locked up and you escaped? What would you do?
Rory Scovel
All I can think about is Harrison Ford quickly shaving his beard and cutting his hair and then trying to figure out who killed his wife. Now, whether that's happened to me or not, I still would probably pursue medical data to prove that I'm innocent. I don't know.
Rory Scoville
Well, Alfie decides to jaunt around Europe and Ireland, and he eventually lands in Dublin and starts a business as a builder decorator. So, again, getting back, landing on his feet, trying to start over, stay out of trouble. But while he's at large, he also wrote to politicians and newspapers proclaiming his innocence, which is maybe not a great idea if you're trying to stay under the radar.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, especially when you're including the return address on those envelopes.
Rory Scoville
And like, eight months later, Scotland Yard finally catches up with him and arrests him. So this time, Alfie goes to a prison in Chelmsford, which is a town in Essex known as the birthplace of radio. Side note, I've been there to make radio a podcast, so this is. I was very excited to see. That's all I can tell you about it. There was the first. I think radio signal was transmitted from there. Okay. It's in Essex. It's. Yeah. Not notable for. For much else. Do you have a favorite English town?
Rory Scovel
No, I feel like I haven't explored enough, so. No.
Rory Scoville
Can I offer you a few actual British town names and you could choose one.
Rory Scovel
Yes.
Rory Scoville
Chosen for no specific reason, and they are no order, but Bitchfield, Cockermouth, Netherwallop, Peniston. Which is spelled Pena Stone. Yeah. Wetwang and Titty Ho.
Rory Scovel
Well, I. What was the second one?
Rory Scoville
Cockermouth.
Josh Dean
All right.
Rory Scovel
What was the one before that?
Rory Scoville
Bitchfield.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. I'm either gonna go Bitchfield or. What was the titty one?
Rory Scoville
Titty Ho two.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. Titty ho or bitchfield Just feel like me.
Rory Scoville
Anyway, to get back on track, Chelmsford is where Houdini Hines has been put this time.
Rory Scovel
Okay.
Rory Scoville
But he decides to try a new tactic. He sues the prison commissioners, claiming they arrested him illegally, which was, of course, just a cover story for his next audacious escape.
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
Yes.
Rory Scoville
So while at the court appearance for his lawsuit, some of Alfie's buddies sneak him a padlock. So, Rory, you're a prisoner in court where you're supposedly suing your captors. You're handcuffed, and now you have a smuggled padlock in your pocket. How are you getting out of this one?
Rory Scovel
I mean, you're acting. You're asking this as though I have years of experience in this. I have no idea. I just love the fact that the friends showed up like, hey, hey.
Rory Scoville
Here you go, good buddies. The lesson here is friendship.
Rory Scovel
Hey, we brought you something.
Rory Scoville
Well, like so many great escapes, this one starts in the toilet.
Rory Scovel
Yep.
Rory Scoville
Alfie tells the guards he has to hit the loo. So they walk him over to the bathroom and unlock his handcuffs. Now, there's a couple different accounts of what happened next, but it seems like Alfie, possibly with the help of his brother, shoves the guards into the bathroom, padlocks the door and runs away.
Rory Scovel
That's it. That's what happened.
Rory Scoville
That's it. He lured them to court, said he had to use the bathroom. Shoves. It's like a cartoon scene, basically.
Rory Scovel
It does seem like this was like he saw this in a Marx Brothers film and thought, this is what I'll do.
Josh Dean
That's it.
Rory Scoville
That's.
Rory Scovel
These guys know what they're doing.
Rory Scoville
It works. And he makes it all the way to the airport. And he was buckling into his seat on the plane to Dublin when the cops found him and arrest him again.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Rory Scoville
So now it's back to prison for Alfie again. Yep. What's his next move? That's after the break.
Mind Games Host
What if mind control is real?
Rory Scoville
If you could control the behavior of anybody around you, what kind of life would you have?
Mind Games Host
Can you hypnotically persuade someone to buy a car?
Rory Scovel
When you look at your car, you're going to become overwhelmed with such good feelings.
Mind Games Host
Can you hypnotize someone into sleeping with you?
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
I gave her some suggestions to be sexually aroused.
Mind Games Host
Can you get someone to join your cult?
Amanda Knox
NLP was used on me to access my subconscious.
Mind Games Host
Nlp, AKA Neuro Linguistic programming, is a blend of hypnosis, linguistics, and psychology. Fans say it's like finally getting a User manual for your brain.
Rory Scoville
It's about engineering consciousness.
Mind Games Host
Mind Games is the story of nlp, its crazy cast of disciples, and the fake doctor who invented it at a New Age commune and sold it to guys in suits. He stood trial for murder and got acquitted. The biggest mind game of all, NLP, might actually work.
Josh Dean
This is wild.
Mind Games Host
Listen to Mind Games on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
China's Ministry of State Security is one of the most mysterious and powerful spy agencies in the world. But in 2017, the FBI got inside.
Rory Scovel
This is Special Agent Riegel, Special Agent Bradley Hall.
Narrator / MSS Officer
This MSS officer has no idea the US Government is onto him. But the FBI has his chats, texts, emails, even his personal diary. Hear how they got it on the Sixth Bureau podcast.
Rory Scovel
I now have several terabytes of an MSS officer. No doubt, no question of his life. And that's a unicorn. No one had ever seen anything like that. It was unbelievable.
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
This is a story of the inner workings of the MSS and how one man's ambition and mistakes opened its vault of secrets.
Narrator / MSS Officer
Listen to the 6th Bureau on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Amanda Knox
In 2023, a story gripped the UK evoking horror and disbelief.
Rory Scovel
The nurse who should have been in charge of caring for tiny babies is
Rory Scoville
now the most prolific child killer in modern British history.
Amanda Knox
Everyone thought they knew how it ended. A verdict. A villain, a nurse named Lucy Letby.
Rory Scoville
Lucy Letby has been found guilty.
Amanda Knox
But what if we didn't get the whole story?
Rory Scoville
The moment you look at the whole picture, the case collapses.
Amanda Knox
I'm Amanda Knox, and in the new podcast Doubt the Case of Lucy Letby, we follow the evidence and hear from the people that lived it to ask what really happened when the world decided who Lucy Letby was.
Rory Scoville
No voicing of any skepticism or doubt. It'll cause so much harm at every
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
single level of the British establishment of this is wrong.
Amanda Knox
Listen to Doubt the Case of Lucy Letby on the iHeartRadio Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Nancy Glass
I'm Nancy Glass, host of the Burden of Guilt season two podcast. This is a story about a horrendous lie that destroyed two families. Late one night, Bobby Gumprite became the victim of a random crime.
Rory Scoville
He pulls the gun, tells me to
Rory Scovel
lie down on the ground.
Nancy Glass
He identified Jermaine Hudson as the the perpetrator. Jermaine was sentenced to 99 years.
Rory Scoville
I'm like, lord, this can't Be real.
Rory Scovel
I thought it was a mistaken identity.
Rory Scoville
The best lie is partial truth.
Nancy Glass
For 22 years, only two people knew the truth. Until a confession changed everything.
Narrator / MSS Officer
I was a monster.
Nancy Glass
Listen to Burden of Guilt, Season 2 on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. This is crimeless.
Rory Scoville
So before the break, we learned that Alfie was back behind bars. And I'm sure you're on the edge of your seat because you can't possibly imagine what this unpredictable man is going to do next.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, I mean, he basically seems like Leo from Catch Me if youf Can. That's what I. That's the vibe I'm getting. This guy's just. He knows what he's doing.
Rory Scoville
He can't be contained.
Rory Scovel
Yeah.
Rory Scoville
So cops arrest him again and he escapes again. And yet again, he busted out by making a copy of the key. I feel like they got to fix this loophole.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, like.
Rory Scoville
Like, Jesus. It was a fucking key again.
Rory Scovel
This guy's really good at keys this time.
Rory Scoville
The key is for the prison bath house. Alfie and a fellow inmate climb over the prison's 30 foot wall and ran to a getaway car waiting for them. This is all seeming way too easy. What's wrong with England's prisons?
Rory Scovel
It seems cartoonish. I think you said that earlier. And every time I'm picturing sort of an animated escape.
Rory Scoville
Yeah, like, like a little British man wearing, I don't know, like knickers and like a top hat. Just like cram one over the wall. Yes.
Rory Scovel
30ft. And also you're saying 30ft, like, it's just no issue. Just like.
Rory Scoville
And we just.
Rory Scovel
Spider man right up the wall.
Rory Scoville
And the main source for a lot of this information is Alfie. So we can probably assume that some bit of, you know, exaggeration has been applied to his own legend. But, like, I prefer it this way.
Rory Scovel
No, I think you're right.
Rory Scoville
So assuming that Alfie's going to flee across the border to Ireland, because that's where he's gone before. The cops are monitoring routes from England, but they don't do a very good job because Alfie makes it this time to Belfast, where he assumes the identity of a used car dealer named William Herbert Bishop, which is, yeah, actually a much less colorful name than his real name, which I guess is not a bad tactic. Like, don't pick a ridiculous name.
Rory Scovel
I got to say, like, I'm blown away by Alfie's ability to be a criminal. Go to jail, escape sometimes start his own business, get arrested, go to jail, escape, and still manage to gain employment across a number of fields. You know, he's like, I'll just sell used cars like, like it's nothing to him.
Rory Scoville
Yeah. Most criminals, like, just return to the life of crime. He's just like, no, I'm going to start a new career now.
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
Yeah.
Rory Scovel
He literally has the most impressive resume that lives on both sides of the law.
Rory Scoville
Well, it's not going to shock you to learn that some of the used cars he sold were a little bit shady, perhaps. And so Alfie gets caught yet again when he's pulled over by cops in an unregistered car that turned out to be stolen.
Rory Scovel
God, it's like he's so good at getting caught and he's so good at getting away. If he could just tip the scales, he could have so some consistency in his life.
Rory Scoville
Like sell used cars that are actually just used, not stolen.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, yeah. Or just be better at not getting caught and then you don't have to be good at escaping.
Rory Scoville
It's almost like he wants to get caught. Maybe.
Rory Scovel
I think you're right.
Rory Scoville
So you know he's just gonna bust out of the Irish jail too. This time he opts for the most direct route. He smashes a window, but cuts himself so badly that he passes out before he can get away.
Rory Scovel
Oh, Alfie.
Rory Scoville
So escape for a very short amount of time, then passes out in his own blood and is caught. So this time they ship him back to England to yet another prison. What do you think happens next?
Rory Scovel
How can I. I mean, just given the pattern here, he escapes, but I. I have no idea how. I'm shocked that any of these methods have worked ever, the whole time.
Rory Scoville
Actually, Alfie taught himself the law.
Rory Scovel
Exactly, exactly. Actually, he learned how to represent himself and now he's a full fledged lawyer.
Rory Scoville
You're not far off.
Rory Scovel
Come on.
Rory Scoville
So Alfie, first he sells his story to a British tabloid for a small fortune, because of course, like, what a story. Yeah. Then he hunkers down in his cell and he studies the British legal system. He recruits the help of his common law wife, who spent hours reading dusty old legal books in the British Museum. This is an amazing montage, by the way, in the movie.
Rory Scovel
Also an amazing partner. She stuck with him this whole time. Get out of town. Yeah.
Rory Scoville
What a lady. Eventually, when he felt like he had this shit down, he files an appeal of his conviction. And for two years, Alfie fights in court representing himself. One of his most convincing arguments was the fact that escaping prison wasn't even technically illegal. According to British law at the time. So maybe some of those convictions are a little bit shaky.
Rory Scovel
Man.
Rory Scoville
During one appearance in 1960, he spends three hours stating his case in front of the House of Lords. That House of Parliament where everyone wears those big wigs.
Rory Scovel
Yep.
Rory Scoville
It's also the country's highest court of appeal. Actually, I want to pause on the wigs for a second. They're ridiculous and they're still required at all criminal trials in England, which is amazing. Yes. It turns out the tradition started in the 1600s after a syphilis outbreak. What do you think the correlation is between syphilis and.
Rory Scovel
I mean, whereas hair just falling out and people are like, we still need to. I want people to think I have hair. I can't.
Rory Scoville
You're right. I can't. You're exactly right. One of the symptoms of syphilis is hair loss, which you obviously knew for some reason. Something weird.
Rory Scovel
Oh, it's the only Google thing I have up on my screen right now.
Rory Scoville
Symptoms of syphilis. Yeah.
Rory Scovel
I was like, just in case this ever comes up, be ready.
Rory Scoville
So, yeah, it's. Syphilis causes hair loss. Wigs become fashionable to hide baldness as well as lice. Because that was also a problem back then. The trend spread to courts and eventually it became policy that lawyers and judges had to wear wigs in order to work in a court. Over years, members have complained that wigs are old fashioned or itchy or both. But the House of Lords, where Alfie was appealing his conviction, upheld this tradition for centuries. Until Covid
Rory Scovel
again. Covid strikes again.
Rory Scoville
Under Covid, they had to hire some temporary clerks and they didn't want to spend the money on temporary wigs. So hundreds of years of sacred tradition is just suspended. Not because the wigs were.
Rory Scovel
Oh, it's only suspended. They didn't just stop, they didn't stop
Rory Scoville
doing it all together, just suspended. But not because they're outdated or smelled bad or itchy. It's because the House of Lords are cheap.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Rory Scoville
But don't worry, wigs are back. They're still worn in criminal proceedings. Anyway, with Alfie, his 13th appeal is dismissed yet again by the venerable and itchy House of Lords. In 1962, everyone in England assumed this meant it was time for Alfie to escape again. Because, like, the lawyering thing just isn't working out. Right. Like, he tried, he, like taught himself the law.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. And I like that he took the MC Escher approach. Like, hey, escaping isn't even illegal. They were like, ah.
Narrator / MSS Officer
He.
Rory Scovel
The One loophole that's the easiest to close. He figured it out.
Rory Scoville
Yeah. I think it only got some charges reduced. Unfortunately, there was, like, the stolen cars and all the other stuff. So he failed. So.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. Yeah.
Rory Scoville
And he did seem to have something planned. Guards found that he'd messed with his cell door so that it opened and closed when he wanted it to. He even warned the head of the British court, saying, quote, I'm not going to remain in prison. It would be very hard for me to leave again, but I assure you, I'm going to.
Rory Scovel
Yeah.
Rory Scoville
Then, before he could bust out, he got a little sidetracked. The detective who had arrested him back in 1953, a guy named Herbert Sparks,
Rory Scovel
who, again, not a real name.
Rory Scoville
Not a real name. Even better, when I tell you that he had given, or more likely given himself the nickname Iron Man. I mean, he definitely made that up.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, that's. And also the audacity to go out to the guys, to go to the tavern and go, hey, you know, instead of calling me Herbert, let's try Iron man tonight. Kind of throw Iron man around the table a little bit. And his friends are like, I mean, okay. It just. It seems desperate.
Rory Scoville
So Iron man writes two newspaper articles claiming that Alfie's appeals are ludicrous because He Absolutely, definitely 100% robbed that furniture store. Which brings me to a new segment called Crimeless Law School. Oh, that's right. By the end of this episode, you're gonna be ready to take the bar in England. In Tidy Ho.
Rory Scovel
Yes, you're listening to Crimeless Law School.
Rory Scoville
So England has famously strict defamation laws. It's way easier to sue someone for writing something bad about you than it is here in the US and in England, the burden of proof is on the defendant.
Rory Scovel
Okay.
Rory Scoville
Which is kind. A little bit confusing. So we could do an example. You can make up a mean lie about me, Josh.
Rory Scovel
Often upper decks, the toilets of his closest friends. Oh, sorry, was that a little too abstract?
Rory Scoville
No, no, we'll take it. It works. So you've just made up this horrible offensive, offensive line.
Rory Scovel
So you assume. Go ahead.
Rory Scoville
Yeah, so. And I'm going to sue you. If I sue you in the uk you have to prove that your lie is true or I win. So tough one, right? Not.
Rory Scovel
Not easy.
Rory Scoville
Whereas if I sue you in the US I have to prove that you were lying and you lied intentionally.
Rory Scovel
Okay.
Rory Scoville
And you could say, you know, in US Court, you could say, like, well, I heard that from a guy, you know, and I seemed. That guy was a reliable source. And I truly believed that it was true. In England, you have to prove that your lie is true. You have to prove it. In the other case, I have to prove it. So anyway, now that you're basically a lawyer in Titty Ho, you'll understand Alfie's next move here, he sues Iron man for libel.
Rory Scovel
Yes.
Rory Scoville
Which forces him to prove in court that Alfie really did rob that furniture store. But the evidence was all circumstantial, so Iron man can't do that. Yeah, he can't convince the jury that Alfie is guilty. Houdini Hyde wins the lawsuit, which is about 400 grand in today's money. Nice little pickup for him.
Rory Scovel
Wow.
Rory Scoville
And even better, he's now been essentially ruled not guilty by a jury. Yeah, this is some serious 7D chess.
Rory Scovel
I mean, the question you asked at the beginning of this war, the curious statement you made is, I don't know if this guy qualifies for crimeless. We now know does not. That was that this guy's a genius.
Rory Scoville
I agree.
Rory Scovel
He's a genius. However, I think the. The crimelessness moniker goes to the law. It goes to all the people in charge of keeping this guy in jail.
Rory Scoville
Yeah, it's like in the cartoon, the big fat. He's like all the prison guards who are asleep, Right? Yeah. A bunch of boobs. Buffoons. And then Iron man, who's like, I got you. I'm gonna write a piece of the newspaper.
Rory Scovel
I've always wanted to be a journalist. And that will be my ultimate downfall.
Rory Scoville
Oh, man. So, so now the Home Secretary, which is the head of the Home Office, the UK government body in charge of security, like keeping it safe from crime, decides that Alfie should be released from prison. Like, what else are they going to do? So after losing 13 appeals of his robbery, he's finally free. And he got his freedom by suing the guy who put him there in the first place.
Rory Scovel
Perfect closure. Perfect closure.
Rory Scoville
This just wrapped this narrative up with a bow.
Rory Scovel
And he learned the law. He bettered himself. He got a little bit of scratch as he left.
Rory Scoville
Now here's a interesting little P.S. he would have gotten out of jail 73 days later anyway. And his conviction was never actually appealed. So he's still technically guilty in the eyes of the law. But who cares? He's a free man.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Rory Scoville
The. The great Houdini Hines final act of escape was legal.
Rory Scovel
And he did say, I will get out. I will escape again. And he was right.
Rory Scoville
He was right.
Rory Scovel
Yeah.
Rory Scoville
According to his New York Times obituary, Alfie later went on the speaker circuit giving talks, quote, arguing for a more intelligent police force. To your point, interesting. He also joined Mensa.
Rory Scovel
I mean, I don't know what else you do. You've done everything else. You're going to want to join Mensa.
Rory Scoville
So would you like to change your answer now? Has the story of Houdini Hines made you rethink at all your strategy for breaking out of prison?
Rory Scovel
I mean, a part of me wonders if I could just legally ask to leave and they might go, Ah, this guy's done his homework. If anyone asks to get to leave, we have to let him do it.
Rory Scoville
I mean, I think there's a big asterisk on this episode because this guy is not a dimwit at all. Brilliant man. Special. Maybe have a special canon of, like, you know, the crimeless hall of fame, most of whom will be idiots, I think.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Rory Scoville
But this guy, not an idiot.
Rory Scovel
Well, we do have to have somebody in first place. And so right now, it's Alfie. Let's see if anyone can dethrone Alfie in terms of not being smart enough to stop going to jail, but smart enough to know how to get out once you're there.
Rory Scoville
All right, number one spot has been claimed. It's your turn, Florida.
Mind Games Host
What if mind control is real?
Rory Scoville
If you could control the behavior of anybody around you, what kind of life would you have?
Mind Games Host
Can you hypnotically persuade someone to buy a car?
Rory Scovel
When you look at your car, you're going to become overwhelmed with such good feelings.
Mind Games Host
Can you hypnotize someone into sleeping with you?
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
I gave her some suggestions to be sexually aroused.
Mind Games Host
Can you get someone to join your cult?
Amanda Knox
NLP was used on me to access my subconscious.
Mind Games Host
Nlp, AKA Neuro Linguistic Programming, is a blend of hypnosis, linguistics, and psychology. Fans say it's like finally getting a user manual for your brain.
Rory Scoville
It's about engineering consciousness.
Mind Games Host
Mind Games is the story of nlp, its crazy cast of disciples, and the fake doctor who invented it at a New Age commune and sold it to guys in suits. He stood trial for murder and got acquitted. The biggest mind game of all, nlp, might actually work.
Josh Dean
This is wild.
Mind Games Host
Listen to Mind Games on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Amanda Knox
In 2023, a story gripped the UK, evoking horror and disbelief.
Rory Scovel
The nurse who should have been in charge of caring for tiny babies is
Rory Scoville
now the most prolific child killer in modern British history.
Amanda Knox
Everyone thought they knew how it ended. A verdict. A villain. A nurse named Lucy Letby.
Rory Scoville
Lucy Letby has been found guilty.
Amanda Knox
But what if we didn't get the whole story?
Rory Scoville
The moment you look at the whole picture, the case collapses.
Amanda Knox
I'm Amanda Knox, and in the new podcast, the Case of Lucy Letby, we follow the evidence and hear from the people that lived it to ask what really happened when the world decided who Lucy Letby was.
Rory Scoville
No voicing of any skepticism or doubt. It'll cause so much harm at every single level of the British establishment of this is wrong.
Amanda Knox
Listen to Doubt the Case of Lucy Letby on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
China's Ministry of State Security is one of the most mysterious and powerful spy agencies in the world. But in 2017, the FBI got inside.
Rory Scovel
This is Special Agent Regal, Special Agent Bradley Hall.
Narrator / MSS Officer
This MSS officer has no idea the US Government is onto him. But the FBI has his chats, texts, emails, even his personal diary. Hear how they got it on the Sixth Bureau podcast, I now have several
Rory Scovel
terabytes of an MSS officer. No doubt, no question of his life. And that's a unicorn. No one had ever seen anything like that. It was unbelievable.
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
This is a story of the inner workings of the MSS and how one man's ambition and mistakes opened its vault of secrets.
Narrator / MSS Officer
Listen to the 6th Bureau on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Nancy Glass
I'm Nancy Glass, host of the Burden of Guilt season two podcast. This is a story about a horrendous lie that destroyed two families. Late one night, Bobby Gumprite became the victim of a random crime.
Rory Scoville
He pulls the gun, tells me to
Rory Scovel
lie down on the ground.
Nancy Glass
He identified Jermaine Hudson as the perpetrator. Jermaine was sentenced to 99 years.
Rory Scoville
I'm like, lord, this can't be real.
Rory Scovel
I thought it was a mistaken identity.
Rory Scoville
The best lie is partial truth.
Nancy Glass
For 22 years, only two people knew the truth until a confession changed everything.
Narrator / MSS Officer
I was a monster.
Nancy Glass
Listen to Burden of guilt season two on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Rory Scoville
Okay, it's time for our final segment, and this week, Lane, what is our final segment?
Josh Dean
We have real or fake prison breaks. I'll tell you about an escape, and you got to tell me if it's real or fake.
Rory Scoville
Yes, as fake as in made up or from a movie.
Josh Dean
Or fake as in from a movie.
Rory Scovel
Okay.
Josh Dean
Fake as in from my mind.
Rory Scovel
Fake as in things I want to try.
Rory Scoville
All right, so we're doing real either real escape in real life or from a movie or TV show. Okay.
Josh Dean
Correct. All right, you ready? This con artist was already on the run when he faked a heart attack, was brought to a hospital, and then called the hospital pretending to be the FBI and told them that he could be released.
Rory Scoville
Rory, you go first. Real. I'm also gonna go real.
Josh Dean
That is right. That is Stephen J. Russell, who you might know because Jim Carrey played him in the film I love you, Philip Morris. This was one of his many escapes from the authorities.
Rory Scoville
Wait, so both answers would have been true in that case, right? I mean, it is real, but it
Special Agent Riegel / Narrator
was also
Josh Dean
a real movie.
Rory Scoville
Look at that loophole. Mr. Loophole right here. I studied the law, and I know the rules of this game mean it
Rory Scovel
was such a real escape, they decided to do a fake version in a movie.
Josh Dean
This woman escaped through a hole in a fence during a prison riot.
Rory Scovel
I mean it. Well, Josh, you're up first this time.
Rory Scoville
It feels like it's had to have happened. That's got to be real.
Rory Scovel
It does feel like that is real.
Josh Dean
It's fake. This was May Chang in Orange is the New Black. Apparently in the show, police found her sleeping in a dead deer.
Rory Scovel
Oh. So she went. She went full Star Wars.
Josh Dean
This man escaped prison by knotting sheets together and using them to climb over the prison wall.
Rory Scovel
I mean, that's probably both, right? I mean, you've definitely seen that in a movie, but I gotta assume art imitates life.
Rory Scoville
Isn't. Isn't that Rapunzel?
Rory Scovel
That's hair, Josh. That's hair.
Rory Scoville
Oh, okay. I'm gonna go. Yeah. I feel like this is definitely real.
Josh Dean
This is real. This was John Patrick Hannon, who still is at large today. He holds the record for longest time on the run after Prison Break.
Rory Scovel
What year was that break?
Josh Dean
December 1955.
Rory Scovel
I mean, at what point do you just go, all right, you got us. We're gonna stop looking?
Josh Dean
Have fun out there?
Rory Scovel
Yeah, you know what? You did it. Good for you.
Josh Dean
Maybe he's a fan of the show.
Rory Scoville
And that brings us to the first Crimeless Presents challenge. Can you find listeners? Can you find. What's his name?
Josh Dean
John Patrick Hannon.
Rory Scoville
He's like, God damn it. The podcast.
Rory Scovel
If you can find 93 year old John Patrick Hannon,
Josh Dean
he escaped in Britain. So, yeah, Gez. England's just not doing so good with their.
Rory Scovel
Well, they. They stopped doing the top sheet for sure. They're like, all right, fitted, only we. We screwed up.
Josh Dean
Yeah.
Rory Scoville
All right, next.
Josh Dean
This man spent Months growing a beard, then shaved it off, slicked back his hair, put on a prison guard outfit, and walked right out of prison. Real or fake?
Narrator / MSS Officer
What?
Rory Scoville
Gotta be real.
Rory Scovel
I'm gonna go real.
Josh Dean
It's fake. This is the show White Collar starring Matt Bomber Boomer.
Rory Scovel
Never seen it.
Josh Dean
Bummer. No idea how he got the guard uniform, but that's good storytelling.
Rory Scovel
You could have told us how he got it.
Rory Scoville
I like that. He grew a beard and then shaved it off. And that fooled people. Yeah.
Rory Scovel
And everybody was like, you look like that one guy before he grew a beard.
Josh Dean
Crazy.
Rory Scoville
That's my cousin.
Josh Dean
Yeah.
Rory Scovel
Also a beard. You know, full beard maybe takes a month at its, like, slowest. You look like Jeremy from 30 days ago.
Josh Dean
All right. After rampaging his hometown, this infamous fighter was locked up in a super maximum security prisoner and pick the lock with a feather.
Rory Scoville
The feather.
Rory Scovel
That sounds fake.
Rory Scoville
I'm going fake. Also.
Josh Dean
This is fake. This is a leopard, played by Ian McShane in the 2008 hit film Kung Fu Panda.
Rory Scovel
Yes. Not even. Not even live action. Good God. Thank God we got that right. That could have been bad. That could have been real bad. Rory.
Rory Scoville
Rory.
Rory Scovel
Josh, that was a cartoon.
Rory Scoville
It was Kung Fu Panda.
Rory Scovel
They grew wings because they made a wish and flew over the wall. God.
Rory Scoville
Real.
Josh Dean
All right.
Rory Scoville
Oh, boy.
Josh Dean
This lovable con artist convinced guards that he was an undercover agent who'd been placed there to review the prison. It worked, and he was allowed to walk out.
Rory Scoville
That's real. I think.
Rory Scovel
I think that's real, too.
Josh Dean
It is. It's Frank Abingale Abagnale.
Rory Scovel
Oh, there you go. From Catch me became.
Josh Dean
Yeah. He even got a fake business card to show the guards he was FBI.
Rory Scovel
They're to review the prison. Is there any space Yelp won't go? You know what I mean?
Rory Scoville
Also, though, dumb. Are those cards. You think that's the thing. They would, like, check with the warden. They'd be like, that guy's saying that he's here undercover.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. Like everybody looks sharp. We're getting reviewed today. By a guy who looks just like Frank without a beard. His hair is, like, back, and he's got really good looking hair.
Rory Scoville
It's gonna be so much harder to escape from prison after this episode. We're giving away all. Giving away all the tricks.
Rory Scovel
Yeah. These are a lot of good moves, England. You could just walk right out. Still fine. Totally fine.
Josh Dean
All right, this is the last one. You guys have a chance to redeem yourself.
Rory Scovel
Okay.
Josh Dean
This man, while incarcerated, was taken to a bar by a prison guard. Got drunk, and while the guard wasn't looking, he ran across the street and robbed a bank.
Rory Scoville
This sounds like Alfie.
Rory Scovel
It sounds so outlandish that you want us to say fake, but I'm gonna go real.
Rory Scoville
I also think it's real.
Josh Dean
Yeah, it is real. That's Robert Walters. He was on a re socialization break from prison. I guess that's a thing in Canada when he robbed that bank. But he was immediately caught, taken back to prison, and then charged with bank robbery.
Rory Scoville
Oh, man. So he was free only long enough to rob a bank and got caught again.
Rory Scovel
He was only re socialized enough to be like, oh, I remember how to drink at a bar, but I don't remember what not to do after.
Josh Dean
Crime is good.
Rory Scovel
Drinking is yummy. Crime is delicious.
Rory Scoville
Oh, my God. He's just. What a. He had a brief moment of freedom. All right, well, we'll have to total them up later. We all won. We're all winners here.
Rory Scovel
Yeah, sure, we're all winners. Just through the art of education, if
Josh Dean
you walk away learning something, you can't lose.
Rory Scoville
All right, see you all next week. Crimeless is a production of Smartless Media, Campside Media and Big Money Players in partnership with iHeart podcasts. It's hosted by Rory Scovel and me, Josh Dean. Our senior producer is Lane Rose. Emma Siminoff is our associate producer. This episode was written by Emma Siminoff and me, Josh Dean. We're sound designed and engineered by Blake Brook with support from Ewan lytram. Ewan. Mark McAdam composed our theme song. The executive producers at Campside Media are Vanessa Gregoriadis, Matt Sher and me, Josh Dean. The executive producers for iHeart podcasts and Big Money Players are Jack O', Brien, Lindsey Hoffman and Matt Apodaca. For Smartlist Media, the executive producers are Will Arnett, Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes and Richard Courson. Bernie Kaminski is head of production. The associate producer is Matty McCann. A special thanks to our operations team, Ashley Warren and Sabina Mara. Do you have a question, comment or confession for the Crimless team? Email us@crimelessampsidemedia.com and if you enjoyed Crimeless, please rate and review the show wherever you get your podcasts. It helps people find the show and also makes us feel validated. Unless you're mean, in which case keep it to yourself. We'll see you next week. Crimeless Nation.
Josh Dean
This is an iHeart podcast.
Rory Scoville
Guaranteed Human.
Podcast: CrimeLess
Episode: How to escape from prison (in England)
Hosts: Josh Dean & Rory Scovel
Date: February 25, 2026
This episode dives into the legendary escapades of Alfred George Hines—alias "Houdini Hines"—a British master escape artist of the 20th century. Josh and Rory break down Hines' remarkable ability to repeatedly break out of prisons in England during the 1950s and 60s, analyze the comic absurdities of the English justice system, and debate whether Hines was a criminal genius or simply facing incompetent jailers. The episode is part biography, part legal lesson, and full of the show’s signature humor and irreverence.
[03:36–05:10]
“He was basically on the run most of his adult life.”
—Josh Dean [04:29]
[05:18–08:51]
“The army’s not a prison… you’re not exactly allowed to just quit.”
—Rory Scovel [08:53]
[08:55–10:47]
[10:53–16:48]
[21:35–24:41]
[25:04–27:13]
“He spends three hours stating his case in front of the House of Lords.”
—Josh Dean [26:07]
[27:57–32:12]
“He’s now been essentially ruled not guilty by a jury… This is some serious 7D chess.” —Josh Dean [30:53]
On Hines' repeated escapes:
“He literally has the most impressive resume that lives on both sides of the law.”
—Rory Scovel [23:48]
On the absurdity of English prisons:
“This is all seeming way too easy. What’s wrong with England’s prisons?”
—Josh Dean [22:16]
On English legal traditions:
“They didn’t just stop...doing it all together, just suspended. But not because they’re outdated or smelled bad or itchy. It’s because the House of Lords are cheap.”
—Josh Dean on legal wigs, [27:28]
Alfie’s Lawyering:
“One of his most convincing arguments was that escaping prison wasn’t even technically illegal according to British law at the time.”
—Josh Dean [25:54]
On Iron Man’s nickname:
“And also the audacity to go out to the guys, to go to the tavern and go, hey, you know, instead of calling me Herbert, let’s try Iron man tonight.”
—Rory Scovel [28:49]
On the skill gap between Hines and the authorities:
“I think the ‘crimelessness’ moniker goes to the law...to all the people in charge of keeping this guy in jail.”
—Josh Dean [33:14]
A comedic quiz testing Rory and Josh’s crime movie knowledge.
Examples:
“These are a lot of good moves, England. You could just walk right out. Still fine. Totally fine.”
—Rory Scovel [43:39]
This episode is a hilarious, fast-paced look at one of Britain’s most creative criminals, blending historical detail with pop culture references, legal lessons, and the hosts’ signature wit. Listeners walk away entertained, a little wiser about English law, and maybe—just maybe—with a few escape tricks to share at parties.