Podcast Summary: Culture Apothecary with Alex Clark Episode: “Pitocin Gave My Daughter Brain Damage”: The Risks Moms Should Know | Katie Spinks
Date: March 17, 2026
Host: Alex Clark
Guest: Katie Spinks
Produced by: Turning Point USA

Episode Overview

This emotionally raw and informative episode features Katie Spinks, a mother whose daughter Jolene suffered severe brain damage after a hospital induction with high-dose Pitocin. Katie shares her journey from a history of smooth births to a preventable traumatic event that changed her family's life forever. The conversation explores the risks of Pitocin and elective induction, the lack of informed consent in American maternity care, and practical advice for mothers and advocates. The episode is a call for changing the culture of childbirth towards true informed consent and individualized care.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Katie’s Birth History and Expectations

• Katie had three healthy children before Jolene, all with smooth, uncomplicated hospital births.
  • [02:25] “They were great. I had beautiful pregnancies, great births...all vaginal.”
• Intended to have a large family (six or seven children).
  • [03:14] “So you wanted a big family?”
  • [03:16] “Yes, I did. This was always your dream? Yes, ever since I was a kid.”

Jolene’s Pregnancy and the Induction Decision

• Jolene’s pregnancy was low risk and healthy.
  • [03:58] “Her pregnancy was beautiful. I worked out into the day I had her.”
• Katie and her husband felt uneasy on the day of the scheduled induction, with a sense of foreboding.
  • [04:25] “I had some really strong intuitions on the way to the hospital… something just doesn't feel right today.”
• The induction was elective, encouraged at 39 weeks based on flawed studies (ARRIVE trial).
  • [06:30] “Thirty-nine-week inductions are encouraged in the US just because… ARRIVE trial... it was flawed.”

Notable Quote:

“Most of the hospitals that were asked to participate [in the ARRIVE trial] did not participate... in the real world doctors aren't at your feet the entire time.” – Katie Spinks [06:30]

Pitocin Use and Lack of Informed Consent

• Katie was given a very high dose of Pitocin (15, with 20 being the max), despite no medical need.
  • [18:10] “They could have kept my dose at six or eight… they had me at 15, and the max is supposed to be 20.”
• No risks were explained to her beforehand.
  • [12:12] “Most women are not told about the risks…they just sat there like a guinea pig.”
• Cascade of interventions was not discussed or explained.
  • [09:33] “Did anyone at any point ever explain the difference between waiting and inducing?”
  • [09:37] “Never.”

Notable Quote:

“Doctors are convincing women their bodies don’t know how to go into labor and that if they wait past 40 or even 41 weeks, their babies will die.” – Katie Spinks [10:47]

Trauma and Medical Negligence During Labor

• Signs of Uterine Rupture Ignored:
  • [15:32] “My uterus ruptured, and I felt a literal explosion in my abdomen... I kept begging her and pleading with her to just check me... and she kept saying... I don’t know how to deliver a baby. You’re just having pain because you’re fully dilated.”
• Nurse dismissed and belittled Katie's pain, calling her “dramatic.”
  • [16:55] “She used the word dramatic. She said, ‘You’re being dramatic. You’re gonna scare the other women down the hall because you are screaming so loud.’”
• No timely intervention, C-section delayed despite obvious distress.
  • [20:06] “I begged for them to… I even sat there telling the nurse… just give me a C-section... Nobody thought to ask or to do anything.”

Jolene’s Birth and Diagnosis

• Jolene was born pulseless with severe oxygen deprivation.
  • [23:42] “She had no pulse. She wasn’t breathing like she was born. She wasn’t alive.”
• Diagnosis:
  • [25:34] “Her main diagnosis is HIE, which stands for hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy…she has cerebral palsy, epilepsy, cannot suck or swallow… strictly G-tube fed... vision impairment, hypertonia and hypotonia… can’t crawl or walk.”
• Immense emotional and financial cost to family.
  • [53:29] “Everything, really. Everything. Our lives are just completely turned upside down…”

Systemic Problems in American Childbirth

• Widespread overuse of Pitocin and elective induction.
  • [46:39] “It’s like a meat factory, like a revolving meat factory. Nobody is treating birth like it should be anymore.”
• Lack of informed consent, education, and individualized care.
  • [32:19] “There’s no informed consent, and they just don’t feel like they’re in charge of their birth. Like, you’re at their mercy almost.”
• Medical record falsification prevented legal redress.
  • [37:07] “We tried... But my records are not… they don’t reflect what happened in real life... they put in there I was not complaining of pain... when I was screaming in agony.”

Notable Quote:

“If a woman does opt for a hospital birth, she needs to have cameras rolling the entire time.” – Alex Clark [38:19]
“Not only just a camera, but a third party person. That’s what I tell women all the time. Get a doula.” – Katie Spinks [38:26]

Advocacy, Remedies, and Practical Advice

• Importance of Knowledge and Informed Consent:

  • [56:37] “Information. Information. Knowledge is power. The more you know, the healthier you can be, the better decisions you can make.”

• Questions Women Should Ask Before Induction:

  • [51:12]
    • “Is this necessary?”
    • “What’s going to happen if I don’t do this?”
    • “What are my other options?”
    • “Do you run everyone on the same system or create individualized care plans?”
    • “Show me studies and literature that back it up.”

• Request the Hospital/Doctor C-section Rate and Bishop Score

  • [51:40] “If your doctor has a high C-section rate, that means something is going on there. That’s a red flag.”
  • [50:37] “Bishop score... determines if your body is ready or not… anything before that, you need cervical ripeners, you need a Foley bulb. No Pitocin.”

• Alternatives to Pitocin:

  • [49:10] “There are cervical ripeners... Foley balloon… it depends on the mom and what her pregnancy looks like.”

• Encouragement to Expectant Mothers:

  • [52:28] “I know the end of pregnancy is hard… but the alternative is to agree to an induction that could end in trauma and a C-section. Knowledge really is power.”

The New Normal and Moving Forward

• Life now is 24/7 caregiving for Jolene, with trauma affecting the entire family.
  • [39:13] “She needs 24/7 supervision... she’s fed through a G tube... It’s just very different, you know. Like it is the typical life of a caregiver. Like, I am no longer existent. I’m just a robot there to make sure she lives and has a good life.”
• Katie’s Remedy for a Sick Culture:
  • [56:37] “Information. Read everything.”
• Advice for Future Births: Home birth with a midwife and doula.
  • [55:44] “I would want that calming environment without all the bright lights… I would have a practicing midwife and a doula, and I would just want to do it at home.”

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• [06:30] Katie Spinks: “Most of the hospitals that were asked to participate [in the ARRIVE trial] did not participate... in the real world doctors aren't at your feet the entire time.”
• [12:12] Katie Spinks: “Most women are not told about the risks…they just sat there like a guinea pig.”
• [16:55] Katie Spinks: “She used the word dramatic. She said, ‘You’re being dramatic. You’re gonna scare the other women down the hall because you are screaming so loud.’”
• [38:19] Alex Clark: “This makes me feel like if a woman does opt for a hospital birth, she needs to have cameras rolling the entire time.”
• [56:37] Katie Spinks: “Information. Information. Knowledge is power. The more you know, the healthier you can be…”

Key Timestamps for Important Segments

• 04:25 – Katie’s intuition and foreboding before induction
• 06:30 – Discussion of ARRIVE trial, flawed data underlying elective induction
• 10:47 – Overmedicalization, cultural fears about postdates pregnancy
• 12:12 – Lack of informed consent for Pitocin use
• 15:32 – Signs of uterine rupture, ignored and dismissed by medical staff
• 16:55 – Nurse calls Katie “dramatic” while she’s in agony
• 20:06 – Desperate pleas for help, no emergency response from staff
• 23:42 – Jolene’s birth: no pulse, not breathing, round-the-clock resuscitation efforts
• 25:34 – Jolene’s diagnoses outlined
• 32:19 – Systemic lack of informed consent and gaslighting in labor
• 37:07 – Attempts at legal action thwarted by inaccurate medical records
• 38:19 – Advice for birth documentation and having a doula, “body cam” for labor
• 50:37 – Explanation of the Bishop Score and its importance
• 51:12 – Critical questions every woman should ask before induction
• 52:28 – Advice for women at 39 weeks: “Just keep going… knowledge really is power.”
• 56:37 – Katie’s remedy for a sick culture: Information
• 55:44 – Home birth advice if she could choose again

Conclusion

Katie Spinks’s story is a devastating example of how lack of informed consent, overuse of Pitocin, and system failures in American maternity care can lead to life-altering trauma. This episode is an urgent call for women and families to empower themselves with information, ask hard questions, demand individualized care, and advocate for change in birth practices and policies.

Follow Katie Spinks:

• Instagram: @katiespinksore
• Facebook: Katie Spinks