Batman: Dark Victory - Chapter 12

Summary

---

DC High Volume: Batman

Episode: Batman: Dark Victory – Chapter 12

Date: October 15, 2025
Host: DC | Realm

Episode Overview

This episode plunges deep into Batman: Dark Victory’s penultimate intrigue. Chaos has erupted in Gotham after Two-Face’s courthouse escape. The hunt for answers in the deadly Hangman killings draws Batman, Gordon, and Robin into a web spun by betrayers, old allegiances, and new faces of villainy. Lines blur between justice, corruption, and madness as key players make desperate choices, and another chilling murder rocks Gotham's crime hierarchy.

---

Key Discussion Points & Story Progression

1. Two-Face’s Escape and Joker’s Chaos

• [01:44-02:14] Commissioner Jim Gordon's Journal Entry: Gordon recounts Two-Face’s (Harvey Dent) bold escape into Gotham’s sewers, and the Joker’s slaughter of his ambulance guards—leaving victims literally "laughed to death."
• Quote:
  • "Their faces were contorted into hideous grins. Their hearts had stopped beating. They literally laughed themselves to death."
    — Jim Gordon [02:14]

2. Janice Porter, Joker, and Two-Face: The Tangled Web

• [03:15-04:27] Sewer Confrontation: Janice Porter meets a captive Two-Face, the Joker, and other costumed criminals. There are confessions of secret relationships and threats.
• Quote:
  • "You're supposed to say, who's there? But apparently you two already know each other."
    — Joker [03:23]
  • "Not this time, Harvey. I think I'll keep your little girlfriend around. Think of her as my get out of jail free card."
    — Joker [03:57]

3. The Wilcox Tape and Janice Porter’s Disappearance

• [05:04-05:36] Staff Meeting: Gordon and allies listen to a tape made by a murdered officer, suspecting she recognized her killer. Porter is now missing, deepening suspicions.
• Quote:
  • "Janice Porter is missing... No one at her office or her apartment has seen her for two days."
    — Jim Gordon [05:36]

4. Porter's Secrets & Connections to Dent and Falcone

• [06:01-06:20] Batman & Gordon Investigate: Batman and Gordon unearth that Porter and Dent were once close at law school, intertwined with Alberto Falcone’s history.
• Quote:
  • "That's his handwriting. 'Porter, good luck at Harvard.' Signed, Harvey. Porter transferred out the year he married Gilda Dent."
    — Jim Gordon [06:12]

5. Janice Porter’s Death: A Framed Suicide

• [07:43-08:42] Falcone Estate: Alberto Falcone wakes to find Porter’s corpse and a used gun in his hands, framed for her murder. A sinister voice urges him toward suicide as shame and paranoia mount.
• Quote:
  • "If you can't use the gun to destroy your enemies, then use it to destroy yourself. That's it. For once, make me proud of you."
    — Carmine Falcone's voice (as heard by Alberto) [07:50]

6. Calendar Man’s Brutalization and Clues at Falcone Estate

• [11:13-13:16] Investigation at the Estate: Calendar Man is found battered outside; clues suggest Alberto was manipulated via fear toxin, encountering the specter of his father. Mr. Freeze’s chilling chemicals are found in Porter's bloodstream.
• Quote:
  • "Cigarettes laced with fear toxin. Something the Scarecrow could have provided... That's why Alberto thought he heard his father."
    — Jim Gordon [12:45]

7. The Hangman Mystery: Robin’s Insight

• [14:47-16:17] Batcave Analysis: Dick Grayson (Robin) proposes a pivotal reinterpretation of the Hangman clue: "None of you are safe" may read as "Nine of you are safe," aligning with the nine heads in Gotham’s criminal underworld.
• Quotes:
  • "You see this first note? None of you are safe with the O blanked out... What if it's supposed to read nine of you are safe?"
    — Robin [15:10]
  • "The boy shows promise."
    — Jim Gordon, on Robin's deduction [16:19]

8. Batman’s Discovery in the Falcone Penthouse

• [16:17-18:24]: Batman breaks into the Falcone penthouse, discovering a hidden alcove filled with nooses and executioner masks—a macabre den for the Hangman and a new puzzle: "Y _ U L _ U lose. Careless."
• Quote:
  • "A hidden alcove. Nooses of every kind dangle from the ceiling like so many vines... a single hangman puzzle for me: Y blank U L blank... You lose. Careless."
    — Batman [17:50]

---

Notable Moments & Character Dynamics

• Joker's sardonic taunts throughout the sewer standoff.
• Revelations about Janice Porter’s relationships and potential complicity.
• Robin's transformation from sidekick to key detective asset—his childhood games offering insight into the Hangman’s riddles.
• The psychological torment of Alberto Falcone, manipulated through toxins and his own guilt.

---

Key Timestamps

| Timestamp | Segment Description | |------------|----------------------------------------------| | 01:44 | Gordon's journal: Escape recap | | 03:15 | Sewer confrontation with Joker & Porter | | 05:04 | Wilcox tape & Porter's disappearance | | 06:01 | Porter's yearbook, Dent connection | | 07:43 | Falcone Estate: Porter framed for suicide | | 11:13 | Calendar Man found battered | | 12:45 | Fear toxin revelation | | 14:47 | Robin cracks Hangman clue | | 16:17 | Batman discovers hidden alcove & new puzzle |

---

Overall Tone & Atmosphere

The episode brims with noir tension, moral ambiguity, and psychological depth. The cast’s performances evoke the intensity and layered relationships signature to Loeb & Sale’s original comics. Gotham feels both haunted and alive as the heroes race to uncover truth in a city riddled with secrets and betrayal.

---

For listeners and Batman fans alike, this episode marks a turning point in Dark Victory—where every riddle, murder, and alliance edges Gotham closer to its next dark chapter.

Transcript

[Narrator]

When did making plans get this complicated? It's time to streamline with WhatsApp, the secure messaging app that brings the whole group together. Use polls to settle dinner plans. Send event invites and pin messages so no one forgets. Mom 60th and never miss a meme or milestone. All protected with end to end encryption. It's time for WhatsApp message privately with everyone. Learn more at WhatsApp.com At New Balance, we believe if you run, you're a runner. However you choose to do it. Because when you're not worried about doing things the right way, you're free to discover your way. And that's what running is all about. Run your [e-mail] Running. Running. You're listening to DC High volume. Batman 2 face is free again. After a bold attack on Gotham City Courthouse. Aided by costumed criminals Mr. Freeze, Poison Ivy and Solomon Grundy, District Attorney Janice Porter lost her files on the Hangman Killer and prepares to confront her illicit lover. But she'll get more than she bargains for in the Gotham sewers. And now, dark victory. Chapter 12.

[Jim Gordon]

August 4th. It has been 48 hours since Harvey Dent brazenly escaped from the Gotham City Courthouse and vanished into the maze of sewers beneath the city.

[Narrator]

Harvey.

[Jim Gordon]

While being moved from the Gotham City Hospital back to Arkham Asylum, the Joker killed two paramedics and the ambulance driver.

[Narrator]

Ari, Is that you?

[Jim Gordon]

Their faces were contorted into hideous grins. Their hearts had stopped beating. They literally laughed themselves to death. Now the Joker is nowhere to be found.

[Narrator]

Harvey?

[Jim Gordon]

Guess again.

[Joker]

Don't be scared. Just kidding.

[Jim Gordon]

You can pat a cake. Pat a cake. Former DA Harvey Den, now going by Two Face, muses over one of the Hangman puzzles. This one scribbled on a photo of his wife Gilda. Guilty as sin.

[Joker]

Knock, knock.

[Jim Gordon]

Hello, Porter. I was wondering when you'd show up.

[Joker]

You're supposed to say, who's there? But apparently you two already know each other.

[Dick Grayson (Robin)]

Tell them, Harvey.

[Jim Gordon]

Tell them what, Porter?

[Janice Porter]

Tell them who I am to you.

[Jim Gordon]

Pat a cake. Pat a cake.

[Joker]

Good one, Scarecrow. Have you been playing pat a cake with the new DA Harv? When this is all done, were you planning on turning us over to her while you go off and live happily ever after?

[Jim Gordon]

Shut up, Joker.

[Joker]

Not this time, Harvey. I think I'll keep your little girlfriend around. Think of her as my get out of jail free card.

[Narrator]

No, tell them, Harvey. Tell them that I love you and that you.

[Janice Porter]

Love.

[Jim Gordon]

Yeah.

[Joker]

Tell someone if you're going to do that.

[Jim Gordon]

Harvey Dent is a married Man Porter. Don't ever forget that. Now I want to see the Calendar man and Mr. Freeze right away. We need to clean up this mess. Two NIGHTS LATER Commissioner Gordon's office. Yes, Commissioner. I'm going up to the eighth floor.

[Narrator]

To get Judge Harkness. Now. Over.

[Janice Porter]

Those were Wilcox's last words to me just before she was hanged. But purposely or not, she left her walkie talkie on the radio. Dispatcher made me this tape. Listen.

[Dick Grayson (Robin)]

If you can't.

[Narrator]

She definitely either knew or recognized her attacker. But we.

[Janice Porter]

It's not much, but we thought you were dead.

[Jim Gordon]

But we have a much more immediate problem. Janice Porter is missing.

[Janice Porter]

How do you. Never mind.

[Jim Gordon]

No one at her office or her apartment has seen her for two days.

[Narrator]

You entered her apartment.

[Jim Gordon]

I found this there.

[Janice Porter]

Porter's yearbook.

[Jim Gordon]

Do you remember when I asked Porter if she had known Alberto Falcone at Harbor?

[Janice Porter]

She said something about Falcone having left for Oxford by the time she got there. Batman.

[Jim Gordon]

Specifically, she said by the time she transferred to Harvard, Falcone had left for.

[Narrator]

Oxford from Gotham University. H. Janice Porter Law School.

[Jim Gordon]

Where she knew a young professor named Harvey Dent.

[Narrator]

That's his handwriting. Porter good luck at Harvard.

[Jim Gordon]

Signed Harvey Porter transferred out the year he married Gilda Dent. Jim, it's possible. Everything you shared with Porter. Two face. Nose. Two weeks later, Alberto Falcone's bedroom the Falcone Estate. At 2:16am Alberto wakes to realize he is holding a gun. Oh, what? A gun. Which has been fired twice. And that both bullets are lodged deep in the skull of the late DA Janice Porter. Whose body lies at the foot of his bed. Oh. Oh, no. He stumbles out of the blood soaked satin sheets, spilling the spent bullet casings. No. How. How you disappointed me. Papa. I didn't kill this woman. I. They won't believe you. They'll see the gun. They'll know it was you.

[Janice Porter]

What? What should I do?

[Jim Gordon]

Come closer to the mirror.

[Janice Porter]

Why?

[Jim Gordon]

If you can't use the gun to destroy your enemies, then use it to destroy yourself. That's it. For once, make me proud of you.

[Janice Porter]

Suicide? My father wouldn't.

[Jim Gordon]

You were not my father. No, I'm not.

[Janice Porter]

The Calendar man is being forgotten and that is unacceptable.

[Jim Gordon]

Put down your gun. Holiday. We need to talk. We've talked enough.

[Shopify Advertiser]

If you've shopped online, it's extremely likely that you've bought from a business powered by Shopify. You know that purple shop pay button you see at checkout? The one that makes the process from. I think I'm ready to buy to. I can't wait till it gets here. So incredibly easy. That's Shopify. And there's a reason so many businesses sell with it. Because Shopify makes it easy to start and run your business. Shopify is the commerce platform behind 10% of all e commerce in the US from household names like Mattel and Gymshark to brands just getting started. It gives you a leg up from the very beginning with hundreds of beautiful ready to go templates to express your brand style so you don't have to spend time coding a website. Shopify allows you to tackle all the important tasks in one place, from inventory to payments to analytics and more. Plus they have built in marketing and email tools to help find and keep new customers so you can easily spread your brand's word. And did I mention that iconic purple shop pay button that's used by millions of businesses around the world? It's the reason why Shopify has the best converting checkout on the plane planet. Your customers already know it, love it and actually use it. If you want to see less carts being abandoned, it's time for you to head over to Shopify. Sign up for your $1 per month trial and start selling today at shopify.com realm go to shopify.com realm shopify.com realm.

[Narrator]

Imagine fast hydration combined with balanced energy. Perfectly flavored with zero artificial sweeteners. Introducing Liquid Ivy's new energy multiplier. Sugar free. Unlike other energy drinks, you know the ones that make you feel like you're glitching. It's made with natural caffeine and electrolytes so you get the boost without the burnout. Liquid IVs. No new energy multiplier. Sugar free hydrating energy. Tap the banner to learn more.

[Jim Gordon]

Two hours later outside the Falconia State, Julian Day, AKA Calendar man lies face down on the ground.

[Janice Porter]

Batman.

[Jim Gordon]

Jim, he's still alive? Barely. His jaw has been broken. To keep him from talking, Alberto cut off his monitoring band and strapped it to the Calendar Man's leg.

[Janice Porter]

Why?

[Jim Gordon]

So that we would find him.

[Janice Porter]

He did this all by himself. Falcone never struck me as a physical type.

[Jim Gordon]

This shoe print is Alberto's size. The sole and heel are worn on the left side, which he favors due to his damaged army. And he's bleeding. There's a trail leading all the way back to the house. The entire house was wired. That's how Alberto heard his father's voice. This took time planning. Walls were open for the Calendar man to walk through.

[Janice Porter]

The house could have been rigged before Alberto was even set free. Oh God. Two Face had Porter C2 at Alberto was sent here. And these.

[Jim Gordon]

Cigarettes laced with fear toxin. Something the Scarecrow could have provided. I'm willing to believe it was the Scarecrow, being a former psychiatrist who did Alberto's profile. That's why Alberto thought he hurt his father. It's what he feared the most. Follow me upstairs. No sign of Sophia either in the house or on the grounds.

[Janice Porter]

But her wheelchair is still here. What would he want with his paralyzed sister?

[Jim Gordon]

The Master. Better. Alberto.

[Narrator]

Ah.

[Janice Porter]

Porter.

[Jim Gordon]

Two shots from a.22. Like a holiday killing.

[Janice Porter]

Alberto Falcone killed her?

[Jim Gordon]

Difficult to tell. There's a chemical in her blood system. It crystallized the arteries, preserving her. The same thing Mr. Freeze did to his wife.

[Janice Porter]

A conspiracy against one man.

[Jim Gordon]

Not just a man. Holiday. Labor Day in Gotham City. Eleven months have passed, and I feel like I am no closer to solving the Hangman killings. Following his altercation with the calendar man 12 days ago. Alberto Falcone is still missing, as is his sister, Sophia Falcone Gigante, who inherited the Falcone crime empire after the passing of her father, Carmine the Roman Falcone. I cannot help but wonder in her absence, who sits at. Who sits at the head of. Don't you ever stay still?

[Dick Grayson (Robin)]

You tell me. My mom used to call me Robin because I was always bobbing along. Are these clues from the Hangman murders? Maybe I could help Alfred.

[Janice Porter]

Master Dick, perhaps your time will be better spent with your studies or.

[Dick Grayson (Robin)]

I'm serious. Look, we used to play games like this all the time on the road. Dots, tic, tac, toe. Hangman.

[Jim Gordon]

This isn't a game.

[Dick Grayson (Robin)]

Sorry. Hey, just listen for two seconds, okay? You see this first note?

[Jim Gordon]

None of you are safe with the O blanked out.

[Dick Grayson (Robin)]

What if it's supposed to read nine of you are safe? You know, like a message, not a clue. This screen on your wall.

[Jim Gordon]

A map of the Falcone crime empire? Yes.

[Dick Grayson (Robin)]

Start with the Maroni family. Zuko, Edward, Skeevers. The Maroni brothers. That's four. Plus the ones labeled Falcone, Sofia, Mario and Alberto.

[Jim Gordon]

The Holiday killer.

[Dick Grayson (Robin)]

Sure. That's seven. Right.

[Janice Porter]

And with the inclusion of their associates, Ms. Lucia Viti of the Chicago Vitis and Mr. Bobby Gutso of the Metropolis Gutsos.

[Jim Gordon]

Nine of you are safe.

[Janice Porter]

Huh?

[Jim Gordon]

Huh?

[Dick Grayson (Robin)]

What do you think?

[Jim Gordon]

The boy shows promise. The Falcone penthouse. After the shootings on Mother's Day, Mario Falcone has had the penthouse vacant and under repair. The front door is under guard, but not the rooftop. I let myself in. The carpet fibers have been worn in a particular spot in front of the bookcase. But the books themselves have a thin layer of dust indicating they have not been removed. Why stand in front of a bookcase when the books aren't being touched? A hidden alcove. Nooses of every kind dangle from the ceiling like so many vines. Knotted ropes of hemp and jute of nylon and synthetics, a row of medieval executioner masks displayed on mannequin heads, and a single hangman puzzle for me. Y blank U L blanket. You lose. Careless.

[Narrator]

Well, well, well, well. Look what the cat dragged in. You've been listening to DC High volume Dark Victory Batman Dark Victory Comic written by Jeph Loeb with artwork by Tim Sale Directed by Fred Greenhalge Audio adaptation by Fred Greenhalgh, Roshan Singh Sambhi and Scott Lee Chua Batman Created by Bob Kane With Bill Finger Starring Jason Spisak as Batman, Jay Paulson as Jim Gordon, Adam o' Byrne as Two Face, Reba Burr as Catwoman, Dan Gill as the Joker, Tessa Monroe as Janice Porter and Christina Rosado as Sofia Falcone. Also starring Jessie Burch, Joel Brady, Ian Cardoni, Tomaso, John De Blasi, Nick Fisher, Rachel Rosenblum and Simon Vance. With additional voices by Robert Bettle, James Sacconi, Andy Cowell, Matthew Quern, Darren DePaul, Richard Doyle, Rebecca Falkenberry, Brian Finney, Jean Francois Donaldson, Jonathan Freeman, Fred Greenhalgh, Erin Hendry, Cassidy Caston, Michelle Lukes, Katherine McNamara, Byron, Mark Newsome, Joe Ockman, Gabriel Oliva, Spencer Olson, Jason Pace, Valerie Ortiz, Greg Roman, Devin Shepherd, Kevin Smith, Mike Starr, Regina Toffen, Austin Trow, David Uslin, Nora Wyman and Johnny Williams. Casting by Sunday, Boling Kennedy and Meg Moorman. CSA produced by Fred Greenhalgh and Roshan Singh Sambhi Executive producers for DC Mike Pallotta and Victor Diaz, Executive producers for Realm Molly Barton and Carly Milori Director of production operations for Realm Devin Shepherd Production manager Jordan Accancia Music composed by Sam Ewing Additional music by Marcus Thorne Bagala Supervising sound design and mix by Jonathan Roberts Additional sound design and mix by Daniel Ramirez and Daniel Brunel Dialogue editing by Joey Fishground Additional production support by Andas Productions Assistant editors Chia Yam Chong and Jamie Leidwinger Associate producer Andrew Kwan Video editor Tasha Carter Production services provided by Realm Recorded at Real Voice la, the Invisible Studios, City Vox and Edge Studios. This podcast was recorded under a SAG AFTRA agreement based on characters from dc. The characters and events depicted in this podcast are fictional. Any similarity to any actual person, living or dead, or to any actual events, firms, places and institutions, or other entities is coincidence, incidental and unintentional. This podcast is protected under the laws of the United States and other countries, and its unauthorized duplication, distribution or exhibition may result in civil liability and criminal prosecution. Copyright and trademark D.C. all rights reserved.