What does it actually mean to be a man today? For too long, Black culture has defined masculinity by what it isn’t. We’ve been told it’s about having the deepest voice, the biggest muscles, or being the “exclusive vessel” for strength. But on this episode of the Dear Black Gay Men Podcast, host Jai The Gentleman asks the tough questions: Is masculinity dead? And if it is, do we even want to revive it?

The “Utility” Trap

The conversation dives deep into how colonization forced Black men into a “utility” mindset—viewing our bodies only for labor or reproduction. This binary has left many brothers feeling like they are “nothing” if they aren’t filling a specific role for someone else. Jai and the DBGM family challenge the idea that Black gay men are a “detriment” to the community because they aren’t procreating, pointing out that many are successfully raising families or serving as essential “uncles” and mentors.

Healing the Fragile Ego

From reacting to the KevOnStage controversy to discussing the “cancer” of toxic behavior, the episode highlights a hard truth: many men are running from their problems and crashing into toxicity.

* Therapy works: We have to stop hiding from our feelings.

* Emotional awareness: You aren’t “less of a man” for feeling your feelings.

* Whimsy is allowed: Sometimes, you just want to be a “boy,” watch anime, and frolic without the weight of the world on your shoulders.

The Verdict

As listener Rolando put it: “Masculinity is not dead, but it’s scarce”. It’s time for a new definition—one that allows us to be whole, self-aware, and emotionally sound.

Listen to the full episode of Dear Black Gay Men on Apple Podcasts and Spotify!

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit dearblackgaymen.substack.com/subscribe

Is Masculinity Dead? Redefining Black Manhood in 2026