Bestie catch-up: evil exes & the 4am going out debrief

Thu Jan 29 2026

Fresh off a bender with the gays, Hallie, Liv, and Lauren are cuddled up on the Extra Dirty couch! The girls dive into recent winter happenings: a man lovingly nicknamed "Lexapro C*ck" and his Low M status, Hallie's apartment having zero feng shui, and the struggles of being an iPad kid. The girlies answer questions from the DMs and respond to YOUR submitted confessions: a toe being reattached to a man’s hand as a thumb, "rubbing men," and more. Munching box, Hallie’s body count list, and Liv’s evil ex... it’s all on the table this week. Enjoy babes, besos!! 💋

Transcript

Commercial Announcer (0:00)

Everyone deserves to be connected. That's why T Mobile and US Cellular are joining forces. Switch to T Mobile and save up to 20% versus Verizon by getting built in benefits they leave out. Check the math@t mobile.com switch and now T mobile is in US cellular stores.

Commercial Disclaimer Voice (0:20)

Savings versus Comparable Verizon plans plus the cost of optional benefits plan features in Texas. And fees vary. Savings with three plus lines include third line free via monthly bill credits. Credit stop if you cancel any lines. Qualifying credit required.

Host (Hallie) (0:30)

Meeting new people just got way more fun. Because now you don't have to do it alone. With Tinder's new Double date feature, you and your bestie can match together. Tap the Double date icon to see profiles built for two. When two pairs match, the group chat kicks off. Scope the profiles, send memes, keep the chat fun. Hype each other up. Flirt a little. Maybe plan a hang. It's always better when you're in it together. Try the new Tinder Double date. Explore all the possibilities. Tinder. It starts with the swipe. Download Tinder today.

Lauren (1:05)

Have you ever gotten by a toe? I feel like if guys put his foot in there at one point.

Liv (1:09)

Okay, you.

Lauren (1:11)

Yeah, maybe.

Liv (1:12)

Who? What do you mean?

Holly (1:13)

I don't know.

Liv (1:13)

If I was by a toe, I would know.

Lauren (1:17)

What up, you little freaks? Okay, guys, I'm doing something really stupid right now. We have an emergency debrief situation. Hi, this is Hallie from the streets of New York. Guys, I had every intention of staying in last night, Okay?

Host (Hallie) (1:40)

Hi, everyone. Welcome back to Extra Dirty. I'm here with my two favorite, Lauren and Liv.

Lauren (1:47)

Say hello.

Liv (1:47)

Hello. Hi.

Lauren (1:51)

Yeah, we're gonna just do like a little bit of a bestie catch up. Because I feel like we haven't done this in a while. We haven't sat on this couch in a while. And I said we're gonna sit on this couch today. I brought my materials. I made a Bloody Mary. We sat here for an hour and a half and now we're cozy.

Summary

Extra Dirty with Hallie Batchelder

Episode: Bestie Catch-Up: Evil Exes & the 4am Going Out Debrief
Date: January 29, 2026
Host: Hallie Batchelder
Guests: Lauren Fishbein & Liv

Episode Overview

This episode of Extra Dirty is an unfiltered, hilarious, and personal bestie catch-up, with Hallie, Lauren, and Liv spilling everything about wild NYC nights out, ex drama, relationship confessions, and friend group dynamics. It's the ultimate late-night-style apartment debrief—heavy on chaos, light on censorship. The trio recounts late nights, toxic exes, tequila-fueled fights, and answer listener confessions—peppered with gossip, tangents, sex talk, and raw vulnerability about why evil exes shape your dating life.
Tone: Messy sleepover energy, genuine best-friend warmth, sharp wit, and the “who cares, let’s share everything” attitude.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The 4am Going-Out Debrief

Hangover Vibes & the Night Before:
- The girls gather hungover, calling this an “emergency debrief.” (01:17)
- Lauren and Liv admit to staying out until 4am, despite Hallie claiming she’d stay in.
- Quote, Lauren: “We have one big fight a year. It’s always on my birthday, always on July 23rd.” (02:59)
- Memorable: They joke about only fighting once a year, always on Lauren’s birthday.
Why Friend Fights Are Different:
- The group discusses their fight patterns—infrequent, always resolved, often fueled by alcohol, always about minor misunderstandings.
- Lauren suggests not inviting her to Liv’s birthday to avoid annual drama.
Deciding to Stay Out:
- Liv recounts being ready to leave the party, but Connor Wood convinces her to stay—sparking an ongoing joke about how easy they are to peer pressure. (03:36)

2. The “Daddy” Who Brags About Money

Story:
- Lauren shares a wild story about an older, rich “daddy” she’s been flirting with, who called her at 5am bragging about making $2.5 million last year—expecting her to be impressed (04:17-06:46).
- The group roasts the guy for oversharing and overestimating the allure of his wealth.
Quote, Lauren: “He thought I would just, like, come over in that moment, put a baby in me. Absolutely not.” (06:14)
“M” vs. “B” Conversation:
- Running joke: calling millionaires “M” and billionaires “B,” shaming the guy for being a “low-tier M.”
- Quote, Lauren: “I’m sorry, I thought at least he was a B. He’s the lowest of animals.” (07:33)

3. Apartment Talk: Snowballs, Feng Shui & Real Housewives

Lauren calls snowflakes “snowballs” (08:26)—the girls lose it over her word mix-up.
Apartment Feng Shui:
- Debate about whether Lauren’s apartment has good vibes or not, leading to a funny aside about tarps and TV setups (09:03-10:00).
Hallie's TV Habits:
- Hallie is revealed to be an “iPad kid with Real Housewives,” watching three episodes in each room for sensory comfort, with everyone playfully roasting her obsession (11:04).
Quote, Hallie: “It calms me down to hear middle-aged women fight. If you don’t get the vibes, you don’t get the vibes.” (11:53)

4. Drinking Cultures, Genetics & Hangovers

Who’s the Bigger Hangover Baby?
- Hallie confesses she avoids drinking because her hangovers are brutal (16:09).
- Discussion shifts into cultural/familial drinking habits—Ashkenazi Jewish genetic differences, Irish/Italian cocktail culture, parents with wine collections, etc.
- Mini science lesson: Hallie explains the “Adh genetic mutation” that means Ashkenazi Jews may process alcohol poorly (16:48).

5. Listener DM: The Work Hookup Gone Weird

Scenario:
- Listener shares a workplace hookup story: made out with a 6’7” security guard, no longer being texted but having to see him every day at work (19:31-20:36).
Advice:
- “Pull away, look hot, don’t give him attention, act like he’s invisible, and flirt with other guys”—embracing healthy toxicity and boundaries (20:36-21:01).
- The trio roleplays likely interactions—full of sass and deadpan delivery (21:07-22:35).
Quote, Liv: “You need to stay strong. Like, just so you know, it’s over with him. Like, no more.” (21:01)

6. Listener Confessions Rapid Fire

Craziest Truths Shared:
- “Helped a high school classmate smuggle illegal animals” (23:11)—group is bamboozled.
- “Guy had a toe attached as a thumb” sexual encounter (24:09): reaction is horror and disgust.
  - Quote, Hallie: “That’s the craziest thing I’ve ever heard.” (24:17)
Robbing Men at Work:
- Confessor says she “robs men nightly” at her job—girls debate if it’s literal or “robbing” via gifts in relationships (25:11-26:15).
Head for Jet Skis:
- One listener admits to giving a guy oral just to use his lake house and jet skis (31:03), the group agrees, “Sounds like a great Saturday.”

7. Evil Exes & Dating Damage

Evil Ex Stories:
- Lauren and Liv share “evil ex” stories—abusive, narcissistic high school boyfriends whose behavior left lasting damage (32:37-35:36).
- Liv’s ex sent friends to destroy a sweet kid’s car with a baseball bat out of jealousy (34:12).
- Both reflect on how brutal early relationships shape later dating, and how they’d never tolerate that behavior now.
Quote, Lauren: “I honestly really think he, like, damaged my outlook on men and how I approach men.” (33:31)
Quote, Liv: “That shaped it. Ruined my next relationship with my great boyfriend...I just didn’t know how to be normal in a relationship.” (35:08)

8. NYC Dating: Multiple Jakes & Lexapro Side Effects

**Hallie admits to dating two “Jakes” at once—labeling them Jake 1 & 2 in her phone—while Liv reads off Hallie’s hilarious running list of former hookups (“Uncle Hockey,” “The Blonde,” “Firefighter”). (36:22-37:52)
Lexapro Discussion:
- Quick debate: would you rather be “mentally well but no orgasms,” or “mentally unwell but great sex,” due to classic SSRI side effects. (36:57)

9. The Girls, Drinking, and Being Each Other’s Angels/Devils

The Dynamic:
- Hallie is Liv’s party devil: “Let’s have a martini!”
- Lauren is the sober angel: “You’ll hate yourself tomorrow.”
- Liv: “I want mini Lauren and Hallie on my shoulders, like cake toppers.” (38:48)

10. Relationship Red Flags: Cheating With a Guy or Girl?

Which Hurts More?
- The girls agree: being cheated on with another girl hurts more than if your boyfriend hooks up with a guy (40:23-41:06).
- Quote, Hallie: “I’d be more offended if it was a girl. If it was a guy, I was like, I can’t really blame him. It’s his sexuality.” (40:53)

11. Sex, Secrets, and “The Muncher”

Revealed:
- Lauren finally gets “her box munched” (oral sex)—she doesn’t usually like it; the group teases her for missing out.
- Hallie’s fiancé Jordan is dubbed “The Muncher” after bragging about his skills at dinner, and the group jokes about their unusual, codependent friend circle where he goes everywhere with them (44:03-45:58).
Gym Hijinks:
- Running bit about sharing gym fobs and Jordan pretending to be Liv’s brother to sneak in.

12. Brunch Plans & Friendship

Planning their next brunch and reflecting on how the episode was “the most raw and authentic we've ever been” (53:19-53:36).
The group is grateful for being able to share and laugh about their crazy lives and messy pasts together.

Notable Quotes & Moments with Timestamps

Annual Fight Tradition:
- Lauren: “We have one big fight a year. It's always on my birthday, always on July 23rd.” (02:59)
Millionaire Brag Gets Roasted:
- Lauren: “He thought I would just, like, come over in that moment, put a baby in me. Absolutely not.” (06:14)
“Lowest of Animals”:
- Lauren: “I'm sorry. I thought at least he was a B. He's the lowest of animals.” (07:33)
Hallie’s Sensory Show Binge:
- Hallie: “It calms me down to hear middle-aged women fight. If you don't get the vibes, you don't get the vibes.” (11:53)
Ashkenazi Alcohol Gene Mini-Lesson:
- Hallie: “Studies suggest Jews, particularly Ashkenazi Jews, process alcohol differently due to a genetic mutation.” (16:48)
Listener DM, Hot Security Guard:
- Liv: “You need to stay strong. Like, just so you know, it's over with him. Like, no more.” (21:01)
Evil Ex Reflection:
- Lauren: “I honestly really think he, like, damaged my outlook on men and how I approach men.” (33:31)
- Liv: “That shaped it. Ruined my next relationship with my great boyfriend...I just didn't know how to be normal in a relationship.” (35:08)
Party Angel/Devil:
- Liv: “I want mini Lauren and Hallie on my shoulders, like cake toppers.” (38:48)
Cheating Debate:
- Hallie: “I'd be more offended if it was a girl. If it was a guy, I was like, I can't really blame him. It's his sexuality.” (40:53)
On Being ‘Raw & Authentic’:
- Lauren: “I feel like this is the most raw and authentic we've ever been.” (53:19)
- Liv: “I just love being raw for sure and authentic. It's kind of like my brand.” (53:26)

Main Takeaways

Friendship is Messy but Vital:
- The episode’s heart is about how close friendships survive fights, nights out, heartbreak, and bizarre confessions.
NYC Dating is Surreal:
- From “low-tier M’s” to hot security guards and old high school evil exes, the modern dating grind is revealed in all its ridiculousness.
Healing From Toxic Exes:
- Early relationships shape future dating—sometimes in scarred, suspicious ways.
Humor as Survival:
- Whether dealing with dating disasters, hangovers, or Real Housewives obsessions, laughter is how these besties cope.
Being Unfiltered is the Brand:
- The girls proudly share, overshare, and remind us that life is more fun—and healing—when you’re extra dirty and extra real.

If you missed this episode:
Expect a wild ride of NYC party tales, relationship deep-dives, sharp one-liners, scandalous listener confessions, and a candid, comfy window into weekday brunches and weekend chaos with your favorite girl gang.