Podcast Title: Extra Dirty with Hallie Batchelder
Host: Hallie Batchelder
Co-Hosts: Lauren Fishbein & Graydon Cutler
Episode Title: Cross-eyed h*ndjobs & my experience in rehab
Release Date: January 9, 2025

Introduction

In this candid and unfiltered episode of Extra Dirty with Hallie Batchelder, Hallie delves deep into her personal life, balancing tales of New York City’s vibrant nightlife with heartfelt discussions about her mental health journey. Joined by her best friends Lauren Fishbein and Graydon Cutler, the trio navigates through a blend of humor, drama, and raw honesty, making this episode a compelling listen for both regular followers and newcomers.

Personal Updates and Stories

Hair Extensions Removal

Timestamp: [02:15]

Hallie opens up about significant changes in her appearance, notably the removal of her hair extensions. She shares her vulnerability and the emotional impact of going without extensions, saying, “Without hair, I feel like I should just put on a wig. Oh, should I just put on a wig? What if I just sat down here today, guys, and I go, hi.” Her contemplation on switching to darker hair colors reflects her desire for authenticity and a fresh start.

First Credit Card Milestone

Timestamp: [05:40]

Shifting to financial independence, Hallie proudly announces getting her first credit card after years of using only her debit card. She humorously questions the necessity of building credit, stating, “I didn’t feel the need to get a credit card. Everyone's like, well, you have to build credit... I'm not Bob the Builder out here.”

Christmas Stroll Adventures

Timestamp: [08:50]

Hallie recounts her chaotic experience during the Christmas Stroll weekend in Nantucket with Graydon. From power outages forcing unexpected gatherings at family-friendly restaurants like Sea Grill to wild nights at the Chicken Box, her stories encapsulate the mayhem and festive spirit of the event. A standout moment includes her awkward encounter in an Uber:

“I ended up giving this man like a full-on hand job in front of everyone in the Uber.”
(10:02)

Lauren humorously visualizes the scene, enhancing the episode’s comedic tone:

“I'm picturing Hallie, mid Uber ride, making eye contact with Graydon while just giving the guy a hand job.”
(10:02)

Transition to Serious Topics

Mental Health and Eating Disorders

Timestamp: [12:21]

Hallie shifts the conversation to a more serious note, discussing her struggles with mental health and eating disorders. She reflects on the pressures of maintaining her career while battling OCD and anxiety:

“It just seemed like I found myself declining a bit this year. It’s one of those things that just ebbs and flows.”
(12:21)

Her honesty about her journey encourages listeners to acknowledge their own struggles:

“Without health, I feel like you have nothing. You could have everything, but without your health, you have nothing.”
(24:20)

Hallie's Journey and Insights

Timestamp: [16:00]

Delving deeper, Hallie shares her history with food issues starting at age 12 and the complex relationship between weight, self-worth, and societal expectations. She narrates her battles through high school, her experiences in residential programs, and the ongoing efforts to prioritize her mental and physical health:

“You never really understand it unless you’re in it. You cannot simply avoid it. Obviously, you need food to survive.”
(16:00)

Interaction Between Hallie and Lauren

Timestamp: [25:06]

Lauren commends Hallie for her vulnerability, fostering a supportive and empathetic atmosphere:

“It makes me so happy to have people hear you talk about that stuff.”
(25:06)

Their interaction underscores the importance of friendship and support in navigating personal challenges.

Dirty Questions Segment

Transitioning back to the show’s signature unfiltered style, Hallie and Lauren engage in a playful and revealing Q&A session, tackling risqué topics with humor and openness.

1. Oral Sex Experiences

Timestamp: [25:45]

Q: Has a guy ever made you finish from oral or did you fake it?

Hallie shares her experiences with oral sex, emphasizing personal preferences:

“Oral is like the worst way to finish... I faked it... the first time I ever had an orgasm with a guy was from that.”
(25:45)

Lauren adds her perspective, highlighting her control during such encounters:

“I feel like I have to be in control, and I feel like when it's happening, I'm not in control.”
(27:02)

2. Handling Sexual Comments

Timestamp: [27:53]

Q: He said, “You like it when Daddy fills up all your holes.” Should I be offended?

The hosts navigate the provocative nature of the comment with humor, discussing boundaries and personal comfort levels:

“It's something daddies say. I just don’t like that.”
(28:07)

Hallie continues with her own playful anecdotes, maintaining the show’s light-hearted yet honest tone.

3. Approaching Guys at Bars

Timestamp: [37:55]

Q: How to approach guys at the bar?

Lauren reminisces about past attempts at flirting, while Hallie shares her skepticism about modern dating dynamics:

“It's an epidemic. And they need to be studied. Men don’t approach girls anymore.”
(39:50)

4. Most Disgusting Thing During Sex

Timestamp: [41:28]

Q: What's the most disgusting thing you've ever done during sex?

Hallie reveals her alter ego, Patricia, and shares a particularly vivid experience:

“I turned into Patricia. I can suck the soul out of a man.”
(41:36)

Lauren contributes with her own intriguing insights, keeping the conversation engaging and unabashed.

5. Hooking Up with a Coworker

Timestamp: [32:49]

Q: Hooking up with a coworker. Yes or no?

Both hosts discuss the complexities and potential pitfalls of workplace romances, emphasizing professionalism and personal boundaries.

Conclusion

Timestamp: [44:33]

As the episode draws to a close, Hallie and Lauren reflect on the day’s blend of heavy and light-hearted topics. Hallie expresses gratitude for re-recording the episode to include Lauren, enhancing the dynamic and depth of their conversation:

“I love you all, and thank you for listening.”
(44:33)

Lauren echoes the sentiment, reinforcing the strong bond between the hosts and their commitment to authentically sharing their lives with their audience.

Key Takeaways

• Authenticity: Hallie’s openness about her struggles with mental health and eating disorders highlights the importance of being genuine and seeking help.

• Friendship and Support: The dynamic between Hallie and Lauren underscores how strong friendships can provide essential support during challenging times.

• Balancing Fun and Seriousness: The episode masterfully balances entertaining, risqué discussions with profound personal insights, offering a holistic view of the hosts’ lives.

• Modern Dating Challenges: Conversations about approaching partners and the complexities of modern relationships reflect broader societal shifts and personal adaptations.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Hallie on Vulnerability Without Hair:

  “Without hair, I feel like I should just put on a wig. Oh, should I just put on a wig? What if I just sat down here today, guys, and I go, hi.”
  (02:15)

• Hallie on Building Credit:

  “I didn’t feel the need to get a credit card. Everyone's like, well, you have to build credit... I'm not Bob the Builder out here.”
  (05:40)

• Hallie on Power Outage Chaos:

  “I ended up giving this man like a full-on hand job in front of everyone in the Uber.”
  (10:02)

• Hallie on Health Prioritization:

  “Without health, I feel like you have nothing. You could have everything, but without your health, you have nothing.”
  (24:20)

• Lauren on Hallie’s Honesty:

  “It makes me so happy to have people hear you talk about that stuff.”
  (25:06)

• Hallie on Situationships:

  “The ambiguity of situationships is what makes them so exciting.”
  (35:18)

• Hallie on Her Alter Ego:

  “I turned into Patricia. I can suck the soul out of a man.”
  (41:36)

Extra Dirty with Hallie Batchelder continues to deliver an engaging mix of personal anecdotes, heartfelt discussions, and unapologetic candidness, making it a standout podcast for listeners seeking both entertainment and genuine conversations.