
Original Air Date: April 10, 1960Host: Andrew RhynesShow: GunsmokePhone: (707) 98 OTRDW (6-8739) Stars:• William Conrad (Matt Dillion)• Parley Baer (Chester)• Georgia Ellis (Kitty)• Howard McNear (Doc) Special Guests:• Sam Edwards• Harry Bartell• Josep...
Loading summary
Chester Proudfoot
Plan on flying. In order to board domestic flights, your driver's license or state issued ID must be a real ID. Learn how to get your real ID today@tsa.gov realID or visit your local DMV.
Indeed Advertisement
You just realized your business needed to hire someone yesterday? How can you find amazing candidates fast? Easy. Just use Indeed. Stop struggling to get your job post seen on other job sites with Indeed sponsored Jobs. Your post jumps to the top of the page for your relevant candidates so you can reach the people you want faster. According to Indeed data, sponsored jobs posted directly on indeed have 45% more applications than non sponsored jobs. Don't wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed and listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit. To get your jobs more visibility at Indeed.com Arts, just go to Indeed.com Arts right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring Indeed is all you need.
Andrew Rines
Welcome to the Oldtime Radio Westerns. I'm your host Andrew Rines and I'm excited to bring you another episode absolutely free. This is one of over 80 episodes released monthly for your enjoyment. Now let's get into this episode.
William Conrad
Around Dodge City and in the territory on west, there's just one way to handle the killers and the spoilers, and that's with a U.S. marshal and the smell of gun smoke. Gun Sport starring William Conrad. The story of the violence that moved west with young America and the story of a man who moved with it.
Matt Dillon
I'm that man. Matt Dillon, United States Marshal, the first man they look for and the last they want to meet. It's a chancy job and it makes a man watchful and a little lone.
Indeed Advertisement
You just realized your business needed to hire someone yesterday. How can you find amazing candidates Fast? Easy. Just use Indeed Stop struggling to get your job posts seen on other job sites with Indeed sponsored jobs. Your post jumps to the top of the page for your relevant candidates so you can reach the people you want faster. According to Indeed data, sponsored jobs posted directly on indeed have 45% more applications than non sponsored jobs. Don't wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed and listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit. To get your jobs more visibility@ Indeed.com Arts, just go to Indeed.com Arts right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring Indeed is all you.
Kitty
Well hello Matt.
Matt Dillon
Oh hello Kitty.
Kitty
Something the matter? You look like you've lost your last friend.
Matt Dillon
And I could use a drink.
Kitty
Come on in, Sam. Bring Matt whiskey, will you?
Matt Dillon
Sure, Kenny.
Kitty
Sit down, Matt.
Matt Dillon
Yeah.
Kitty
Now, what's the trouble?
Matt Dillon
I just got word that couple of.
Kitty
Old friends, something happened to him.
Matt Dillon
Yeah. They're dead.
Kitty
Oh, I'm sorry, Matt.
Matt Dillon
Here's your whiskey, Marshall. Thanks, Sam. Yeah. It's a tough one, Kitty. They both took the fever and they left a kid. Young boy.
Kitty
That's a terrible thing.
Matt Dillon
Yeah, it is.
Kitty
Boy's parents both dying suddenly like that.
Matt Dillon
That's kind of funny in a way. Joe and Lyda could have been killed a lot of times. He was in the war. They were on a riverboat that was sunk one time. They'd been living on a ranch in Apache country.
Kitty
It was fever that finally killed him.
Matt Dillon
Yeah.
Kitty
Were you close friends, man?
Matt Dillon
Joe and I rode together on the border with his brother Will. Yeah, we were close friends.
Kitty
I'm sorry. I hope there'll be somebody to watch out after the boy.
Matt Dillon
I don't know about the rest of the time, but I know somebody will be riding hurt on him this summer.
Kitty
Somebody you know?
Matt Dillon
Mm. Me.
Kitty
You?
Matt Dillon
Yeah. Will figures the boy oughta get clear away for a while.
Kitty
So you're gonna take him?
Matt Dillon
Well, he asked me to in this letter. Doesn't seem like a lot to do.
Kitty
How old's boy?
Matt Dillon
Oh, 15. 16. Somewhere along there. He won't be any trouble.
Kitty
You're certainly changing your tune.
Matt Dillon
Oh? How's that?
Kitty
Seems to me you've always dodged being a family man up to now, kiddie.
Matt Dillon
The boy needs help.
Kitty
Sure, man. Of course he does. And I think you have it in you to be a real good father.
Matt Dillon
I always have, Kitty.
Kitty
I'm sorry, Matt. I couldn't resist it. I think it's fine.
Matt Dillon
Thanks. When does a boy come on tomorrow's stage?
Kitty
Well, Matt, let me know if there's anything I can do, huh? Who knows? I might be quite a mother if I had a chance.
Matt Dillon
Yeah, I think you might. K How'd you have a good trip, Dave?
Dave Barrett
Weren't nothing to it at all. I'd rather a road.
Matt Dillon
You what?
Dave Barrett
Well, the stagecoach wasn't bad, but I'd rather rode my own horse in.
Matt Dillon
That was kind of a long way for that, wasn't it?
Dave Barrett
That's what my Uncle Will said, but I could have done it.
Matt Dillon
Maybe you could at that.
Dave Barrett
We're heading for your office, Marshall.
Matt Dillon
Mm. That's where your headquarters will be most of the time. Might as well go there first.
Dave Barrett
Well, that's fine with me, Marshall. I Like to be around guns.
Matt Dillon
Oh, we keep the guns locked up in the office all the time. Well, unless we're using them or cleaning them.
Dave Barrett
Oh, well, then I can help clean them.
Matt Dillon
Yeah, maybe you can.
Dave Barrett
I know how, Marshall. My PA learned me.
Matt Dillon
He knew how to teach you, all right. Your PA was a good man with a gun. I'm sorry about that, Dave, about what happened. You must miss him a lot, your ma and pa.
Dave Barrett
I guess I do. I ain't gonna let it bother me none, though.
Matt Dillon
Kinda hard not to, isn't it?
Dave Barrett
You know, a fella's gotta do his growing up, Marshall. He can't be thinking on his ma and pa.
Matt Dillon
I suppose not.
Dave Barrett
I wouldn't have stayed home much longer anyhow. You know, Marshall, Pa used to wear two guns.
Matt Dillon
Yeah, I remember.
Dave Barrett
Why don't you, Marshal? Wear two?
Matt Dillon
I guess I figured one was heavy enough to pack around all the real.
Dave Barrett
Good men with a gun. Wear two? Why? Oh, I just meant you might get where you'd need to wear two sometime. I didn't mean.
Matt Dillon
No, that's all right, Dave. So far I just been lucky enough to get pie with one. Now here we are. Go on, walk in.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, hello, Mr. Dillon. And I guess this must be the boy.
Matt Dillon
Yeah. Chester, this is Dave Barrett.
Chester Proudfoot
I'm pleased to meet you, Dave.
Matt Dillon
Dave, this is Chester Proudfoot. He really runs things around the marshal's office. Well, Dylan, Chester will keep an eye on you for the next few days. I'm going to have to ride up to Hayes City.
Dave Barrett
I don't need nobody to watch out for me, Marshall.
Chester Proudfoot
No, it won't be no trouble. No trouble. Talk.
Matt Dillon
You show him around, Chester. I want to see Ed Brody before I go.
Chester Proudfoot
Yes, sir, I sure will do that, Mr. Dillon.
Dave Barrett
Can't I go along with you, Marshall, instead of staying here with him?
Chester Proudfoot
Now don't you worry, boy. It won't be nothing at all for me to make you feel at home.
Matt Dillon
You better stay here this time, Dave. Maybe you can ride with me another time before you go.
Chester Proudfoot
Sure. A nice young fellow like you. You and me will get along just fine.
Matt Dillon
Thanks, Justin. You all right, Dave?
Dave Barrett
Me? I'm always all right.
Matt Dillon
Good. I'm glad to hear it. I'll see you later.
Doc
Excuse me, boy.
Chester Proudfoot
I gotta sweep under that chair you're sitting in. Just put your feet out there.
Dave Barrett
You sure do do a lot of sweepin around here.
Chester Proudfoot
Not there. The fat boy. Seems like folks brings mud on their boots all the way from Texas and the territory. Just so I can sweep up after em.
Dave Barrett
That ain't no job for a lawman.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, lawman's got a right to live clean just like anybody else.
Dave Barrett
Well, if I was helping the marshal, I'd do better things than that.
Chester Proudfoot
Now, Dave, I guess you do just about what the marshal wanted you to do.
Dave Barrett
Well, I reckon a body has to do what he's fit for.
Chester Proudfoot
Now, just hold on a minute there.
Dave Barrett
I mean, it ain't like you could be no help in the gun fighting or nothing like that.
Chester Proudfoot
Now, listen here to me, Dave. You're a nice young fellow, but you need a little straightening out on the way things is around here.
Dave Barrett
The marshal needs somebody around him that can shoot.
Chester Proudfoot
I can shoot. Don't you worry nothing about that.
Dave Barrett
You don't even wear a gun.
Chester Proudfoot
A man don't need to wear a gun all the time to know how to shoot. Besides, them guns on the wall ain't the wearing kind. These ways they look mighty comical on a man's hip.
Dave Barrett
I know how to wear a gun.
Chester Proudfoot
Ain't no cause to you to show off. Me?
Dave Barrett
Somebody around this office ought to be wearing one.
Chester Proudfoot
Now, see here, I don't want to catch you parading around wearing no gun.
Dave Barrett
I bet the marshal will let me wear one.
Chester Proudfoot
Ain't likely.
Dave Barrett
Can't see how good I can shoot. He'll lemmy.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, just don't let me catch you wearing one.
Dave Barrett
Well, you ain't the marshal.
Chester Proudfoot
No, I ain't. But he left me in charge of things for the next couple days. And one of the things he left me in charge of is you.
Dave Barrett
I can draw real fast.
Chester Proudfoot
I don't want to hear no more about it. I don't want to see you wearing no gun, and that's all there are to it. Now, move away from them windows so I can read up the rest of this office.
Doc
Well, I tell you, Dave, there's no particular trick to taking out a bullet.
Dave Barrett
Not so, Doc?
Doc
Nope. The trick is keeping the man alive afterwards.
Dave Barrett
Well, how you do that?
Doc
Well, if I knew the answer to that, Dave, I'd be the most famous doctor in the West. And the richest to boot.
Chester Proudfoot
Sure would be nice.
Doc
There's so many things to consider. The size of the wound, how much blood has been lost. Infection superation.
Chester Proudfoot
Doc, I ain't so sure it's a good idea to go on about things like that.
Doc
Why not?
Chester Proudfoot
Well, we're eating our dinner, Doc.
Doc
Oh, what's the matter, Chester? You getting squeamish?
Chester Proudfoot
Me? Well, I'm as un squeamish as they come, Doc. I can listen to your Talk, even though I am eating rhubarb pie.
Doc
Well, what's the trouble then?
Chester Proudfoot
Well, Doc gets to. It's the boy. He ain't used to hearing that kind of loose talk.
Doc
Oh. Oh, well, you. Yes, you may be right.
Dave Barrett
Ain't no cost to worry about me. I ain't squeamish.
Doc
Oh, no, no, no, of course you're not, but. But Chester's right. It's a matter of good manner.
Dave Barrett
Yes, that ain't no bother to me.
Chester Proudfoot
It ought to be, boy.
Doc
It ought to be.
Chester Proudfoot
Chester, where incarnation have you been? Well, I've been right here eating my dinner. More trees. I ain't exactly hiding out, you know. Well, seems there ought to be somebody taking care of things in the marshall's office. Oh, just ease off, Mordheim and taking care of things. What's all the caterwauling about, anyway? Well, they want you down at the telegraph office. Why didn't you say so? I had to find you first. They got a message that's got to be answered right away. All right, Mort, all right. Keep your braces up. I'm coming. I'll take care of it. All right. I'll see you back over at the office. Dave. Shouldn't take me very long to handle this.
Dave Barrett
Do I have to go right back to the office? Ain't it all right if I mosey around a little? Well, now you know.
Doc
Oh, give the boy his head, for heaven's sakes. He's no child, Chester.
Dave Barrett
I sure ain't.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, I guess it'll be all right.
Dave Barrett
Come on, Chester.
Chester Proudfoot
I'm a coming. But mind you be back there for supper, boy, I hear.
Dave Barrett
Sure, sure, I'll be there.
Chester Proudfoot
Will you wander around all you like, Dave?
Doc
Chester gets more like a mother hen every day.
Dave Barrett
I don't need no mothering.
Doc
Crush it out sometimes, though. It seems Chester has more talent for that than for marshalling.
Dave Barrett
Yeah, it sure does. A horse kicked that down for you, huh?
Doc
Oh, hello, boy. Ah, some fool drove a rig right into the side of the door. Some folks rent a rig, just don't care what happens to it. Elsa just can't drive.
Dave Barrett
I can drive, that's all.
Doc
New boy in town, ain't you?
Dave Barrett
I'm visiting the marshall, Matt Dillon.
Doc
You better be good, boy, or he'll run you in.
Dave Barrett
I ain't afraid of him.
Doc
Better mind your manners just the same. I wouldn't want to start no nonsense with Matt.
Dave Barrett
I'm gonna help him.
Doc
Well, now, I'll bet he's glad about that. I wish I had Somebody to help me around this stable.
Chester Proudfoot
Hello, Feely.
Matt Dillon
Hello, Moss. Take care of the horse, will you?
Doc
You want us feed him?
Matt Dillon
Yeah, go ahead and feed him. I ain't fixing to be back for him till tomorrow.
Doc
Gonna make a night of it.
Chester Proudfoot
Are you feeling?
Matt Dillon
I sure am. I gotta find the marshal first though. He ain't in his office.
Doc
Ask the boy where he is. He's staying with him.
Matt Dillon
Why? So you know where he is, boy?
Dave Barrett
Sure do. Up to Hays City for two days.
Matt Dillon
I might've knowed trouble.
Doc
Feely.
Matt Dillon
That's Hob Frank. He's out there at the old Prentice.
Doc
Place shooting everything inside. He better get Chester then.
Dave Barrett
He ain't there either.
Matt Dillon
I seen that he wasn't.
Chester Proudfoot
You know where he went off to?
Dave Barrett
No. I don't reckon he'll be back for a while though.
Chester Proudfoot
Ah, maybe I'll run into him.
Matt Dillon
Somebody ought to get on out there.
Doc
That'S for sure uncertain.
Matt Dillon
Yeah.
Chester Proudfoot
See you later.
Doc
Go along. Come on, boy.
Dave Barrett
You know where the Prentice place is?
Doc
Sure. It's just south of the river about a mile. Got a big old falling down house on it. Nothing to see. What do you want to know for?
Dave Barrett
Why, I want to be able to tell Chester where it is. That's all.
Matt Dillon
Boy.
Doc
Chester knows the Prentice place. Everybody around Dodge knows it.
Dave Barrett
Yeah, sure. I should have known.
Matt Dillon
Here, boy, hold this.
Doc
Bridle.
Dave Barrett
Yeah. Say, mister, would you leave me have a horse?
Doc
I got only one rule about that, boy. I'll leave you have it if you can pay for it.
Dave Barrett
Oh, I can pay for it. I got money, see. Here.
Doc
Then you've got a horse. You can have that one in the back stall. You can ride him all right.
Dave Barrett
I can ride him all right. And I can do a lot of other things just as good.
Chester Proudfoot
All right, now you just standing here, boy. As soon as I see the old man Frank, I'll take you down forever for a drink.
Matt Dillon
Hob.
Chester Proudfoot
Could honey have chose a cooler day to start up Arucas?
Matt Dillon
Hob. Bob.
Dave Barrett
Frank.
Chester Proudfoot
All right, now don't you go playing no hiding games, old man. Not after I've rode all this way out here. And don't you start shooting off again neither. You'd ought to be ashamed of yourself. All a stirring up things the way you do. Well, I might have knowed. Liquored yourself up till you lost your senses.
Dave Barrett
Come on.
Chester Proudfoot
Gotta wake up some Hobble. Wake up so that I can ride you back to Dodge. Come on now. Oh, man, it's time again for you to spend a night or two in the lockup.
Dave Barrett
And then we'll get.
Chester Proudfoot
Oh, my gracious mercy. You've been shot.
Dave Barrett
He's dead.
Chester Proudfoot
Dave, what in the world are you doing out here?
Dave Barrett
I told folks I could help the marshal and I done it.
Chester Proudfoot
You done what?
Dave Barrett
Well, while you was lollygagging around town, I come out here and I rode right up through the gunshots and I took care of him.
Chester Proudfoot
You shot Hob Frank?
Dave Barrett
I know you couldn't have done it, not wearing a gun and all. He was shooting something fierce when I rode up, but I just kept on coming.
Chester Proudfoot
You blame young fool.
Dave Barrett
It was him or me. That's the way it has to be with a gunfighter.
Chester Proudfoot
Hob Frank ain't no gunfighter.
Dave Barrett
He would. What do you mean?
Chester Proudfoot
Hob Frank never harmed nobody in his whole life. There may be self the shooting. He used to get his self liquored up regular every two or three months or so and take his old gun and shoot it off just to hear the noise of it. But he never done it where folks was around. He never pointed it at nobody.
Dave Barrett
But I thought.
Chester Proudfoot
Yes, sir, you thought. You thought's all tarnation. Much as you just rode out here and killed a man.
Dave Barrett
I didn't mean.
Chester Proudfoot
It's too late to think about meaning. Come on now. Help me get him out of here.
Dave Barrett
No, no.
Chester Proudfoot
Come on now. Can't leave him. Just lay in here.
Dave Barrett
You ain't gonna take me in for no killing.
Chester Proudfoot
Go on in. Run away from the old man you killed. Right on running the rest of your life for all of me. All right, Hob. Pick you up sodas. Nice and decent for you. Nice and decent. I tell you the truth, Mr. Dillon, I think it's too good for him.
Matt Dillon
Oh, what do you mean by that?
Chester Proudfoot
For that days you're telling that old Hob didn't die after all. That document pulled him through somehow.
Matt Dillon
Yeah, maybe you're right.
Chester Proudfoot
It was no thanks to him, and that's a certain fact. It just served him right to go on thinking he'd killed him.
Matt Dillon
And if we don't find him, he will go on thinking it.
Chester Proudfoot
Mine's a sure we'd ought to find him. Spending all this time riding out here in this weather.
Matt Dillon
You'll live.
Chester Proudfoot
Just maybe I will. But I ain't at all sure we ain't just sending good money after bad, you might say.
Matt Dillon
That's enough, all right. But what I. I said that's enough, Chester. Now, you know we gotta find this boy.
Doc
Yes, sir.
Chester Proudfoot
I guess we do.
Matt Dillon
Then let's do it.
Chester Proudfoot
Mr. Dillon.
Matt Dillon
Yeah? What is it?
Chester Proudfoot
Ain't you veering some off the road?
Matt Dillon
I'm heading for that cave up there.
Chester Proudfoot
You think he's hid out there?
Matt Dillon
I know that if I was a boy running away, a cave would look pretty good to me as a place to hide.
Chester Proudfoot
Patrick.
Matt Dillon
Besides, this is the way his horse went. Yes, sir. All right, Chester, we'll stop here.
Chester Proudfoot
Want me to come up with you?
Matt Dillon
No, you stay with the horses.
Chester Proudfoot
I'd admire to help.
Matt Dillon
I'll call you if I need you, Chester.
Chester Proudfoot
Yes.
Matt Dillon
Dave. Marshall. Dillon. Come on out of there. You might as well come out, Dave. You left a plain trail.
Dave Barrett
I ain't coming.
Matt Dillon
Come on, Dave.
Dave Barrett
I ain't coming out. Never.
Matt Dillon
If I have to come in and get you, I'll do it.
Dave Barrett
I ain't gonna hang, Marshall. I ain't gonna hang.
Matt Dillon
No, you're not gonna hang. You're lucky.
Dave Barrett
Wha. What do you mean?
Matt Dillon
The old man didn't die. Now, come on out.
Dave Barrett
You. You ain't just trying to trick me?
Matt Dillon
I don't have to waste my time tricking a smart aleck kid like you. Now come out of there before I drag you out. All right, come on. All the way out. Now. Down here. Now, where's the gun?
Dave Barrett
I buried it back there ways.
Matt Dillon
You'll dig it up. It's one of mine, isn't it?
Dave Barrett
Yes, sir. I seen it hanging there in the back room.
Matt Dillon
And you stole it. I should have known better.
Dave Barrett
I was figuring to help.
Matt Dillon
You better explain that, Marshall.
Dave Barrett
When I heard about that fella shooting out at the Prentice place, I figured I'd need a gun, so I went back and got one.
Matt Dillon
Why didn't you tell Chester about it?
Dave Barrett
I. I didn't think he'd be no good taking care of it.
Matt Dillon
Oh, why not?
Dave Barrett
What?
Chester Proudfoot
Chester.
Dave Barrett
He don't even wear no gun.
Matt Dillon
I see. I left him in charge of things, didn't I?
Dave Barrett
Yes. But Marshall, I didn't ever see him do nothing much but just sweep out. I can shoot. Yeah, I figured I could take care of that feller better than Chester could.
Matt Dillon
And you nearly killed him.
Dave Barrett
Well, he was shooting. I had to do something.
Matt Dillon
You know what Chester would have done?
Dave Barrett
No, sir, I don't.
Matt Dillon
He'd have walked right up to that man, shooting or not, and he'd have talked the gun away from him and he'd have brought him back into Dodge or he'd be safe.
Dave Barrett
I didn't know.
Matt Dillon
Oh, you sure didn't know. You don't know much if you think the only way to measure a man is according to whether he wears a gun or not, you don't know much.
Dave Barrett
I. I guess maybe you're right.
Matt Dillon
Yeah, I'm right.
Dave Barrett
Well, what you gonna do with me?
Matt Dillon
Well, until this circuit judge comes to town, I'm gonna turn you over to and I've got ready to do a lot of sweeping. A lot of sweeping.
William Conrad
Gun Smoke, produced and directed in Hollywood by Norman Macdonald stars William Conrad as Matt Dylan, U.S. marshal. The story was specially written for Gunsmoke by Marion Clark with editorial supervision by John Meston. Featured in the cast were Sam Edwards, Harry Bartel, Joseph Kearns, and Ralph Moody. Marley Bear is Chester, Howard McNear is Doc, and Georgia Ellis is Kitty. This is George Walsh inviting you to join us again next week when CBS Radio presents another story on Gun Smoke.
Andrew Rines
This has been a presentation of otrwesterns.com and we hope you enjoyed. Please take some time to like and rate this episode within your favorite podcast application. Follow us on Facebook by going to otrwesterns.com Facebook and subscribe to our YouTube channel by going to otrwesterns.Com YouTube become one of our ranch hands and unlock some exclusive content. We want to thank our most recent ranch hands, Steve Technogod and Craig who joined us recently. You too can join by going to otrwesterns.com donate send us an email podcasttrwesterns.com and you can call and leave us a voicemail. 707-986-8739. This episode is copyrighted under the Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike Copyright. For more information go to ot otrwesterns.com Copyright have a great day and thanks for listening.
Matt Dillon
SA.
Podcast Information:
In the "Dave’s Lesson" episode of the classic Western drama Gunsmoke, listeners are transported to Dodge City, Kansas, during the tumultuous settlement of the American West. Hosted by Andrew Rhines, this episode delves deep into themes of responsibility, mentorship, and the challenges of maintaining law and order in a rapidly evolving frontier town.
The episode begins with Matt Dillon, the dedicated United States Marshal of Dodge City, grappling with personal loss. He receives the sad news that two old friends, Joe and Lyda, have succumbed to a fever, leaving behind a young boy. Matt, known for his solitary nature, is faced with the unexpected responsibility of caring for the orphaned teenager.
Matt Dillon (05:56): "The boy needs help."
This newfound responsibility sets the stage for the central narrative, highlighting Matt's internal struggle between his duty and his inherent reluctance to embrace familial bonds.
Enter Dave Barrett, the orphaned boy, whose arrival introduces a dynamic tension. Dave is eager to assist and prove himself, displaying a level of initiative that surpasses Matt’s expectations. His presence is met with a mixture of skepticism and hope from the townsfolk, particularly from Chester Proudfoot, who oversees the marshal’s office in Matt’s absence.
Chester Proudfoot (10:12): "The fat boy. Seems like folks bring mud on their boots all the way from Texas and the territory. Just so I can sweep up after 'em."
Dave’s enthusiasm and insistence on proving his worth set the foundation for the unfolding drama.
Dave’s eagerness quickly leads him into overstepping boundaries. Despite Matt’s instructions to stay under Chester’s supervision, Dave ventures out to assert his capability. His attempt to assist Matt showcases both his bravery and naivety.
Dave Barrett (08:03): "Come on, Chester."
However, this initiative soon spirals out of control, leading to unintended consequences that challenge Matt’s ability to maintain order.
The pivotal moment occurs when Dave confronts Hob Frank, a local troublemaker, leading to a deadly encounter. Believing he is acting to protect Dodge City, Dave discharges his weapon, resulting in Hob Frank’s death.
Dave Barrett (19:58): "I told folks I could help the marshal and I done it."
This incident forces Matt to navigate the complexities of justice, mentorship, and the harsh realities of frontier law enforcement.
Matt confronts Dave about the shooting, emphasizing the importance of restraint and the value of dialogue over violence. Chester Proudfoot steps in, attempting to mediate the situation, but the damage is done.
Matt Dillon (25:43): "You don't know much if you think the only way to measure a man is according to whether he wears a gun or not."
Through this confrontation, Matt imparts a critical lesson to Dave about the true essence of being a lawman — one that prioritizes wisdom and compassion over brute force.
Matt Dillon: Exhibits his steadfast dedication to duty while revealing a softer, more compassionate side as he takes on the role of a guardian.
Dave Barrett: Represents youthful impulsiveness and the struggle to find one’s place in a harsh environment. His actions underscore the perils of unbridled enthusiasm without proper guidance.
Chester Proudfoot: Acts as the voice of reason and stability within the marshal’s office, striving to maintain order amidst the chaos introduced by Dave.
Responsibility and Mentorship: The episode underscores the weight of responsibility that comes with mentorship, especially in environments where guidance is scarce.
Justice vs. Vigilantism: Dave’s decision to take the law into his own hands highlights the thin line between seeking justice and falling into vigilantism, a recurring theme in Western narratives.
Isolation vs. Community: Matt’s initial isolation is contrasted with the emerging sense of community responsibility, emphasizing the importance of collective effort in maintaining order.
Matt Dillon (05:56): "The boy needs help."
Chester Proudfoot (10:12): "The fat boy. Seems like folks bring mud on their boots all the way from Texas and the territory. Just so I can sweep up after 'em."
Dave Barrett (19:58): "I told folks I could help the marshal and I done it."
Matt Dillon (25:43): "You don't know much if you think the only way to measure a man is according to whether he wears a gun or not."
These quotes encapsulate the core conflicts and character motivations that drive the narrative forward.
"Dave’s Lesson" serves as a compelling exploration of the challenges faced by lawmen in the Old West. Through Matt Dillon’s interactions with Dave Barrett, the episode delves into the complexities of justice, the importance of mentorship, and the delicate balance between authority and empathy. As Matt navigates the repercussions of Dave’s actions, listeners are reminded of the enduring values that define true leadership and integrity.
This episode of Gunsmoke masterfully intertwines personal loss with broader societal themes, offering listeners a rich and nuanced portrayal of frontier justice. Andrew Rhines successfully captures the essence of the original radio series, bringing to life the rugged landscapes and moral dilemmas that define the American West.