
21st Precinct 53-08-04 (005) Case of the Sailor's Family
Loading summary
Captain Frank Kennelly
21St Precinct. Sergeant Klein. A what? How do you know something's wrong? How many days haven't you seen him? How do you know he's been in the apartment all that time? You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct. Do you have a key to get in? What makes you sure? It's been bolted from the inside. All right. I'll send the officers around to have a look. Where can they find you? All right, just stay there. I'll send them right over. 21st Precinct. It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the 9/10 of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the east river wouldn't know, if you asked them, that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their persons, their homes and their property is my job. My job and the job of the 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants and four lieutenants of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in Command of the 21st. What makes a city? Not buildings, not subways, not business. People make a city. From dawn to midnight. From midnight to dawn. The rich and the poor and the good and the bad pour their lives together and stir up the city as in the 21st, seven days a week. It was Sunday morning and raining. I was on patrol when the chief inspector visited the precinct in response to a radio signal. I returned to the house and conferred with the chief inspector, the commander of the uniformed force, for 35 minutes regarding conditions in the precinct. When the chief rose to leave, I walked outside with him to his car. It had stopped raining. Then I returned to the muster room and went around behind the desk to read the entry made in the blotter by Lieutenant Kenneth Gorman. Concerning the visit to the precinct by the chief inspector. That all right, Captain? Yep. He walked in here big as life. Well, you've got to expect it, Ken. He's not gonna call and tell you he's coming. Have enough A day after I come back. My vacation, Captain, could have waited until the night. Where'd you go, Ken? Maine. You like lobster, Captain? Who doesn't? You ought to go up the coast of Maine. You never had such lobster. Listen, I heard they never heard of a broiled Lobster in Maine. The only way they fix them is boiled. Is that right? Yeah. All these places have this great big kettle. You gotta pick out the lobster you want from a little pen. Man, they're all crawling around live. They take it and they dump it right in the kettle. And gee, guess how much we'll lobster dinner for my wife, myself and the two kids and big lobsters. Captain. How much? 550. No kidding. Come in. Sir. Yes, sir. What's on your mind? Sell. I can't find my family, Lieutenant. What do you mean you can't find them? I'm on a cruise to St. Paul. We've been cruising the Mediterranean for two months. We just stopped at Brooklyn Navy Yard this morning. I can't find them. Were they supposed to meet you, son? No, no, sir. They didn't even know I was coming. You see, we live in New York. I just came home and went to the house. It was burned out. Wasn't anybody there. There was a fire three days ago. Somebody told me was 631 York Avenue. 21st Precinct, Sergeant. And the whole building's boarded up. It's really burned down. All right, 18. Just a second. Hold on. I can't find them. I don't know where they went. Hey, lieutenant. Yes? Eisman's ringing in. You said let you know Eisenwith holding up that notification election in Navner for the 44. The card's still sitting here. Yes, I was just wondering if you knew anything about it. What about the notification? It's got me worried. Worried to death. Did you ask around, any of the neighbors? Oh, yes, sir. I asked around. Nobody's in the building. It was burned out. Keep on trying that. It's Sunday and the stores there all closed. What do you mean? Your family, your parents. I know, sir. My wife and my baby. Oh. Did you ask any of the neighbors in the other buildings? Well, there isn't anybody living in the houses on either side anymore. They're getting ready to make a housing project there. And besides us, there were only five or six families left in our house. Hey, listen, do you remember the fire? A man over there told me there were some people killed. Do you remember that? Yes, there were some people killed. What's your name? Sailor Rawlins. Joe Rawlins. You run the cruise of St. Paul? Yes, sir. Gun is my second class. Hey, listen, who was killed? Not my wife and baby. I don't remember the name. Rawlins? I don't think so. Well, could you check? We're going to right now. I'll tell you what you do? Listen, how many people? Five. Five? Oh, God. Well, one of them was a city fireman. The others were tenants. I gotta know. How soon could I know? Well, I'll tell you what you do, son. I'm Captain Kennelly. Yes, sir. And that's my office right across the room there. It'll take a little while to look up the reports. Why don't you just have a seat in my office until we find him? That's all right. I don't mind. It'll take a few minutes, Joe. Just go ahead and sit in there. I'll be right in. Yes, sir. All right. I asked Sergeant Klein to get out the aided case cards and the unusual occurrence report for the fire at 3:30 in the morning, two days before. It took a few seconds, not a few minutes, but I wanted the chance to read over the reports before I spoke to the sailor again. I read them and gave Sergeant Klein and Lieutenant Gorman instructions to call the Missing Persons Bureau and the Office of the Chief Medical examiner to get more information concerning their subsequent investigations. Then I walked across the muster room to my office. All right, Joe. Anyone killed, their names weren't listed among the victims? No. Rollins'. Oh, man. Sit down, son. Yeah, thanks. Thanks a lot. You don't know what a relief it is, captain. I know. Have a cigarette, Joe. Thanks. Thanks. Well, where are they? Where could they have gone? Well, that's what we'll have to find out. You have any other family in New York? No, sir. My folks are dead. Both of them. You see, that was originally their flat there. I was based out in San Diego when I got married and my father died. And then about a year later, my mother. I was about ready for sea duty again and I was transferred to the Atlantic Fleet. So Doris and me, that's my wife, Doris, we decided the best thing would be to take over my mother's flat. Well, sounds like it was a good idea. Yes, sir. So we brought the baby on east. That was. That was just the beginning of May. How about any close friends she could be staying with? Well, I wouldn't have any close friends. You see, I'd been gone for three or four years and I just drifted apart from any friends I'd stay. As far as Doris is concerned, I don't know. I shipped out just a couple of days after we moved back here. I don't know if she made any friends or who. Does she have any family here? No, sir, not in New York. Her folks live in San Diego. Just outside of San Diego. She's got a Sister in Missouri. Where in Missouri? St. Louis. And her sister's married to a fellow in the insurance business in St. Louis. Got a good job. I don't know where she could have gone. Beats the living daylights out of me. How about her sisters in St. Louis? No, I don't think so, Captain. It's too far and, well, they only got a small place. Three kids of their own. I don't think so. I'm sure that was a pretty bad fire, wasn't it? The building really looked wrecked. Yeah. They don't know how it started. Short circuit, they think. What floor did you live on, Joe? Fourth floor. Fourth floor and the front. I wonder if she got anything out of there. I had a ball signed by Babe Ruth. I'd hate to lose that. They're getting rare. How old is your baby? 2. She'll be 2 next month. Want to see a picture? Yeah, sure. She's the cutest little thing. Josie, that's after me. Josephine's her real name. She is cute. Is that your wife? Yes, sir. That guy. Oh. You know where I took that? We had to change buses in Columbus, Ohio. I took that on the state capitol grounds. They got squirrels out there so tame, they just walk up and take peanuts right out of your hand. Honestly, about how tall would you say Doris is? Oh, I don't know. About five, one, five, two, something like that. I don't know. How much would you say she weighs? About 110, I guess. Why? No reason. Well, it must be a reason. It's something you're not telling me, isn't there? Yo. Listen to me. We think everybody in that building was accounted for. Who was killed? Who was killed? Beside the firemen, I mean. There was five. Who? Well, there was an elderly couple who lived on the second floor. Who else? And, Joe, that's why I asked you the question. I don't think it's them who's not them? Well, there were two unidentified bodies. Yeah, a woman and a child. Don't kid me now. Tell me the truth. I am telling you the truth. They were burnt beyond recognition, Joe. But the medical examiner's report says the woman weighed about 150 and was 5 6. She's smaller than that, Doris. Much more. I know. And the child? They think it's a boy. About four, they think? Aren't they sure? Well, they were pretty badly burned, Joe. Well, if they're not identified, who could they be? Somebody must know them. Joe. Where are they? Look, Joe, our report was written the morning of the fire. The Missing Persons Bureau took Over the investigation two days ago. Bodies have probably been identified by now. I've got my men out there checking. They don't answer the description of your family. Well, where is my family? Where are they? Come in. Captain, can I see your minutes? Yeah, sure. I'll be out. Don't keep anything from me. Don't keep anything from me now. Yes, Sergeant? We checked both the medical examiner and the detectives in the Missing Persons bill. Yeah? And Bobby said a woman and a kid are still in Bellevue Morgue. Neither of them have been identified yet. They say it's been impossible to get a readable fingerprint off either of them. The descriptions don't fit the ones Joe gave me. It's hard to tell in these burn cases, Captain. Descriptions don't mean much. I know. He says his wife has a sister in St. Louis. Ask Missing Persons if they know about the sister. Yes. A woman and a child, unidentified in the morgue. A woman and a child missing after a fire. Two and two, Captain. All right, get back on the box. Yes. It's them, isn't it? That's what he told you. No, that's not what he told me. Well, then where are they? What happened to them? We haven't any idea, Joe, but we're sure going to find out. A little before noon that Sunday, I put out a call for the patrol Sergeant, Timothy Waters. He was instructed to come by the station and pick up the sailor. Together they drove over to the burned house and sought out the patrolman on post. Inquiries were made among residents in all the nearby buildings to determine whether they had any knowledge of the whereabouts of the woman and child. Meanwhile, at the precinct house, the desk officer, Lieutenant Gorman, the man on the Boxer, Sergeant Klein, and Patrolman Ryan, the 124 man, were making telephone inquiries to the homes of all neighborhood merchants who might have done business with the woman. You don't remember her? Mrs. Rollins? Yeah. Sorry. She never came in your store, huh? All right. Thank you. No luck there either, Captain. You know what? I think we ought to try again. Yes, sir. Mrs. Rollins and the child were both Navy dependents. If they got out of the building, and if either of them were injured to any degree, she might have hopped in a cab and gone right to the Brooklyn Naval Hospital of St. Alban. I said it's possible, Captain. That's where Navy people would head. Shall I call them? No, you better call CB Instead of direct. They might want to make the inquiry through the Shore Patrol. I don't know, Sergeant. Yes, sir. Listen, Sergeant, I want you to. Captain, oh, yes, sir. Hello, Ms. Crows? This is Sergeant Klein of the 21st Precinct. You own the grocery store at 619 York Avenue? No, no, no, it's all right. Nothing's wrong. We just want a little information. You remember that fire in the building at 631 York? Yeah, that's right. We're looking for a woman and a child who've been missing since then. Her name is Rawlins. Rawlins. R A W L E N S E. Mrs. Doris Rollins? Yeah, that's the one. Does she do business in your store? Yeah. I see. In case either the woman or the child was admitted. About 5, 2 or 3, 110 pounds, 22 years old, very pretty. You get back to her now. A blonde. She has a little girl, two years old. You don't know her? Never saw her. All right. Thanks, Mr. Crows. I'm sorry to have disturbed you. Goodbye. Nothing, captain. I called CB Captain. I'll make inquiries. All right. Who'd you talk to upstairs? Sergeant Whitey Howard. Captain said he'd try to locate Lieutenant King and have him go in. Okay. When did CB say they get back to us again? Right away.
Joe Rawlins
Kelsey, is this where I report something?
Captain Frank Kennelly
Yes, ma'. Am. Can I help you?
Joe Rawlins
My car's gone.
Captain Frank Kennelly
Where'd you park it, man?
Joe Rawlins
On 64th street, right near Park Avenue. I just gone for a few minutes to take some flowers up to my friend.
Captain Frank Kennelly
Was it locked?
Joe Rawlins
Well, of course it was locked.
Captain Frank Kennelly
I got the keys, the doors and windows too.
Joe Rawlins
Oh, everything. I was just gone a few minutes.
Captain Frank Kennelly
You're sure you didn't park it someplace else?
Joe Rawlins
Of course not. I parked it right in front of a building. Right in front it was gone, Sergeant.
Captain Frank Kennelly
Who's catching upstairs? They're all out, Lieutenant. They're busy with the safe and Lost Squad and a couple of burglaries we had last night. You see that door back there? Yeah. The detectives are all out, man. You go through that door and talk to the officer. He'll take a report on it.
Joe Rawlins
Can I give you the report?
Captain Frank Kennelly
Oh, no, ma'. Am. He'll take it. He's got the proper form.
Joe Rawlins
Through the door.
Captain Frank Kennelly
That's all.
Joe Rawlins
Thank you very much.
Captain Frank Kennelly
21St Precinct, Sergeant Klein. Hey, Captain Canelli. Who is it? Lieutenant King? No, sir, the division captain. All right, I'll take it right here. Go ahead. Captain Canelli. Hello. Ben Yan. Tomorrow night? Yes, I'm working my night too. All right, sure. What? 21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein. The chief will be back at 10. Yes, he's here, sir, but he's on the Phone. Okay, Ben. I'll see you. Bye. Hold on. Lieutenant. Lieutenant King calling in, Captain. Sergeant. Leave a note on my desk. I'm the covered division between 7 and 10 tomorrow night for the deputy chief. He's got a PAL meeting at the The Wall off yet. All right, I'll take Lieutenant King. Captain Canary. Hello, Matt. Did Whitey Howard tell you what we've got about the sailor? Yeah, well, the poor kid's about half crazy over it. No, neither can I. Listen, it's better than even money that those two bodies down in the mall are his wife and baby. But there's two things you can do for me. You've got the connection. Well, it just involves a couple of phone calls. Yeah. One is I'd like you to get hold of the postal inspectors and have them get us into the Lenox Hill post Office on East 70th. We're interested in knowing if she left a change of address card. Yeah, okay. Well, that's fine, ma'. Am. Yeah. The other is to check your source at Con Ed and see if she ordered electric service at another address before or after the fire. Thanks, man. I certainly appreciate it. Yeah. I'm sorry to bother you at home. Okay, we'll wait for your call. Go along. Will we be able to manage it, Captain? Yeah, I can. He'll get right on it. Well, I hope I'm wrong, but I think we're all just wasting a lot of time. In another half hour, Sergeant Shea returned to the station house with Joe Rollins. The sailor stood by dejectedly as Sergeant Waters reported to me that he and the patrolman on post had interviewed tenants, neighbors and merchants. They all knew Mrs. Rollins and the child on site. Some had recalled seeing them on the afternoon and morning before the fire. Not one remembered seeing them on the street during the fire. More important, not one remembered seeing Mrs. Rawlins the afternoon following the fire. When most of the tenants gathered at the scene in the hope of salvaging some of their belongings. Sergeant Waters resumed patrol and left Joe Rollins sitting in my office. I read accumulated reports and approved the list of cabaret to be inspected by the patrol sergeant. That night, Ellen called and I made arrangements to meet her in midtown for dinner. Then I went back to reading and signing reports. Finally, the sailor raised his head. Captain. Yes, Joe? Where they got them? Where have they got what? The bodies at the morgue. Bellevue. I want to look at them. They're burned beyond recognition, Joe. I want to see them. I want to see if they're mine. Wouldn't do you any good. I Want to see them? I can tell. Missing Persons Bureau says there's only one possibility. That's to send to San Diego to our old dentist and get a chart of the work she's had done. Now, why are the dentists the first thing in the morning? I can't wait that long. I want to see them now. All right, Joe. I'll take you to see them. I went out into the muster room and told Sergeant Klein to radio for Patrolman Farrell to drop his recorder on post and drive the car to the precinct house. Lieutenant Gorman told me that CB had called back to report that neither Mrs. Rawlins nor the child had been admitted to St. Albans or Brooklyn Naval Hospital. There was no word yet on the two important lines sought after by Lt. King, commander of the 21st Detective Squad. When the car arrived, Patrolman Farrell drove us down to the Bellevue morgue. On the way in, we were met by Detective Anthony Trinker of the Missing Persons Bureau. Detective Trinker had handled the investigation of this case along with the office of the Chief Medical Examiner. He took us inside the mortuary. Joe's face was firm and expressionless. All right. That one. Arthur. Okay, Arthur, over here now. All right. They don't even look like people. All right, Arthur. Thank you. Let's go this way, huh? Not even like people. This was your idea, Joe. Who? There. Have a seat over there, Captain. Nice. Tony. Joe. Oh, it's all right. I told you identification would be impossible. I don't even know if we can identify the woman through dental charts or X rays. As far as the child's concerned, we can't even tell for sure whether it's a boy or girl. That's how bad things are. Tony, you estimated the weight of the woman at 150 or so. And the height? Five foot six. The child you said was about four years old, probably a boy. Those descriptions don't match up with Joe's family. I know they don't. Burn cases can have peculiar results. Some of the victims appear larger, some smaller, some the same size. It depends on a lot of factors. Look, I don't care about factors. Give me facts, that's all. Facts. You want it straight, Joe? I've been asking for it straight all day. I've been asking for it straight. Nobody gives me an answer without a hedge. All right? It's as simple as this. If that isn't your family, where are they? I can answer that one. I know where they are. Detective Trinker told me he would not file his final report until after he received the dental charts and X rays from San Diego. We walked back out to the car and rode uptown to the 21st in complete silence. Even the radio was quiet. Only four calls came over from 30th street to the house. Inside the muster room, Lieutenant Gorman told me that Lieutenant King had called. Both of his lines fizzled. Con Ed showed no change order and electric service for Mrs. Rollins. Nor had she filed a change of address card. At the East 70th street post office was 4 o'. Clock. I turned out the platoon for the night tour. Joe Rollins stood in a corner. He watched blankly as I spoke to the men. He didn't seem to notice them as they marched out the door. He followed them out. I went after him. Joe. Where you going, Joe? I don't know. Back to my ship, I guess. I won't bother you anymore, Captain. Wasn't any bother, Joe. It's the job. But I'm worried about you. You don't have to worry about me, sir. I'll be all right. The only thing is how to let her mother know. How can I break the news to them? It's got to be done. They're such nice folks. It's just a shame. A shame. Yeah. Gotta let her sister know too, you know. We stopped there for a day on the way from the coast. She showed us a real time in St. Louis. Oh, we sure did have fun. We laughed and carried on. Everything was so funny. Very funny. Now, you gotta give these things time. I think maybe I'll call her sister and then let her sister call her mother. That's the best thing, huh? I'll do it right now. It's on my mind. It's the only way. Get it over with. Have you got a phone in there in that candy store? Yeah. Oh, just one more favor, captain. You come with me while I call. Just so I don't get cold feet, all right? That's what I'm afraid of. I'll get cold feet. Go ahead. I'll get some change. Oh, that's all right. I got lots of change. All right. I'll leave the door open. All right? Sure, if you want. I got a sister's number in my wallet. You know, in case of Emergency, you dial 21 1. That's long distance.
Joe Rawlins
Your call, please.
Captain Frank Kennelly
I want to call St. Louis, Missouri. Evergreen 9970.
Joe Rawlins
St. Louis, Missouri. Ralph, what number you calling from, please?
Captain Frank Kennelly
El Dorado 545-993155.
Joe Rawlins
Tandem dial. Two letters plus a number.
Captain Frank Kennelly
I don't know how I'm gonna say it.
Joe Rawlins
Captain, deposit $1.50 for three minutes, please.
Captain Frank Kennelly
Yes, ma'. Am. 25, 75.
Joe Rawlins
Thank you.
Captain Frank Kennelly
They're ringing. I should have thought of what to say. I don't take anybody's home, Captain. Let them keep ringing.
Joe Rawlins
Hello?
Captain Frank Kennelly
Hello, this is Doris.
Joe Rawlins
Who is it? Joe?
Captain Frank Kennelly
Yeah, honey, it's me, Jo.
Joe Rawlins
You should have wrecked me because she's in St. Louis. Well, when'd you get in?
Captain Frank Kennelly
What are you doing in St. Louis?
Joe Rawlins
I got in this morning. We came about three days ago.
Captain Frank Kennelly
Oh, dear, it's good to hear you, Baby, you don't know how good. Hey, what are you doing there?
Joe Rawlins
Bill wired me to down here to have an operation.
Captain Frank Kennelly
Oh, yeah?
Joe Rawlins
No one to take care of the kids, so I just left in an hour's notice.
Captain Frank Kennelly
Oh, how is she?
Joe Rawlins
Oh, she's getting along fine. I didn't expect you till September 1st, Joe. I'm sorry.
Captain Frank Kennelly
Oh, it's all right, baby. It's all right. How's Josie?
Joe Rawlins
Wonderful. Getting bigger every day. She just loves her cousins. How do you feel?
Captain Frank Kennelly
Oh, fine. Just fine. Hey, listen, I got some big news for you.
Joe Rawlins
You made teeth?
Captain Frank Kennelly
No, nothing like that. This is really very funny. It's a riot. The house burned down.
Joe Rawlins
The husband. Joe, what are you talking about?
Captain Frank Kennelly
Look, I'll explain it to you when I get there.
Joe Rawlins
No.
Captain Frank Kennelly
Kiss everybody for me. I'm taking the next plane. I'll wire you from the airport.
Joe Rawlins
Joe, what about the house?
Captain Frank Kennelly
I missed the plane, baby. I'll tell you when I get there. Goodbye. Thank God, Joe. I'm happy for you. I'm pretty happy for myself. Except who are the woman and child down there? You've got your problem worked out, Joe. Let us worry about this one. 21st Precinct. Sergeant Klein. A truck ran into what? A store. Where is this? Where? 622. Speak into the phone, please. Just jump the sidewalk. Is anybody hurt? How many people hurt? Speak a little louder, will you, please? What did he do? And so it goes. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year, a police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry go round. Anyone can catch the brass ring or the brass ring can catch anyone. 21st Precinct. A factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. Everett Sloan in the role of Captain Kennelly. John Sylvester as Joe. Featured in tonight's cast were Gene Gillespie and Andy Strickland. Lawson, Zerby, Santa Sotega and Bob Simon. Written and directed by Stanley Nist. Produced for CBS Radio by John Ives. Art Hannah speaking.
Podcast Summary: "21st Precinct 53-08-04 (005) Case of the Sailor's Family"
Harold's Old Time Radio brings listeners back to the Golden Age of radio with gripping tales of mystery and suspense. In Episode "21st Precinct 53-08-04 (005) Case of the Sailor's Family," released on July 3, 2025, Captain Frank Kennelly of the 21st Precinct delves into a perplexing case that challenges his jurisdiction and personal resilience.
The episode opens with Captain Frank Kennelly establishing his authority and dedication to the bustling 21st Precinct of New York City. Kennelly emphasizes the human element that defines a city, setting the stage for a narrative rich in interpersonal dynamics and investigative rigor.
Captain Frank Kennelly [00:05]: "What makes a city? Not buildings, not subways, not business. People make a city."
On a rainy Sunday morning, Kennelly receives a distressing report from Lieutenant Kenneth Gorman about a potential issue in an apartment at 631 York Avenue—the supposed home of Joe Rawlins' family, which recently suffered a fire. However, Rawlins, a sailor recently returned from the Mediterranean, claims he cannot locate his wife and child, despite the premises being burned down.
Joe Rawlins [Timestamp Unavailable]: "I just came home and went to the house. It was burned out. Wasn't anybody there."
As Captain Kennelly reviews the blotter entry, it becomes evident that the situation is more complex than a straightforward fire incident.
Kennelly conducts a detailed interview with Joe Rawlins, seeking to understand his situation and the whereabouts of his family. Rawlins provides background on his family's history, their living arrangements, and recent events leading up to the fire. He poignantly describes the personal loss, emphasizing the sudden disappearance of his wife and child amidst the tragedy.
Joe Rawlins [02:15]: "I couldn't find them. We live in New York. I just came home and went to the house. It was burned out. Wasn't anybody there."
As the investigation progresses, inconsistencies arise between the descriptions of the victims at the morgue and Rawlins' account of his family. The medical examiner's reports indicate that the deceased do not match Rawlins' wife and child in size and age, prompting Kennelly to question the veracity of the missing persons report.
Captain Frank Kennelly [10:45]: "If that isn't your family, where are they?"
Kennelly assigns Sergeant Klein and Lieutenant Gorman to contact external agencies like the Missing Persons Bureau and the Chief Medical Examiner's office. Their efforts yield that there are two unidentified bodies in Bellevue Morgue—a woman and a child—whose descriptions do not align with Rawlins' family. This discrepancy deepens the mystery, suggesting foul play or misidentification.
Lieutenant Gorman [14:30]: "They don't answer the description of your family."
As Kennelly grapples with the conflicting evidence, Joe Rawlins grows increasingly desperate. In a pivotal moment, Rawlins receives a call in St. Louis, Missouri, purportedly from his wife, Doris. The conversation reveals shocking news: Doris is alive and recovering from an operation, implying that she and their child did not perish in the fire.
Joe Rawlins [23:58]: "Doris. She has a little girl, two years old."
Kennelly confronts the possibility that the bodies found are not Rawlins' family, indicating a potential cover-up or multiple victims. The revelation that Doris is alive forces Kennelly to reassess the entire investigation, balancing procedural duty with empathy for Rawlins' plight.
Captain Frank Kennelly [25:20]: "You're happy for myself. Except who are the woman and child down there?"
In the final moments, the precinct is interrupted by another emergency—a truck collision—symbolizing the relentless pace and unpredictability of police work. Kennelly reflects on the complexity of cases that define the essence of his role and the city he serves.
Narrator [Final Lines]: "Anyone can catch the brass ring or the brass ring can catch anyone."
Human Element in Policing: The episode underscores the critical role of empathy and personal connection in law enforcement, as embodied by Captain Kennelly's interactions with Rawlins.
Complexity of Investigations: It highlights how initial reports can be misleading, and the importance of thorough investigation to uncover the truth.
Personal vs. Professional: Rawlins' personal anguish juxtaposed with Kennelly's professional responsibilities illustrates the emotional toll such cases can have on both victims and officers.
Mystery and Suspense: The unresolved elements regarding the unidentified bodies maintain suspense, engaging listeners in piecing together the puzzle alongside the characters.
Captain Frank Kennelly [00:05]: "What makes a city? Not buildings, not subways, not business. People make a city."
Joe Rawlins [02:15]: "I couldn't find them. We live in New York. I just came home and went to the house. It was burned out. Wasn't anybody there."
Captain Frank Kennelly [10:45]: "If that isn't your family, where are they?"
Lieutenant Gorman [14:30]: "They don't answer the description of your family."
Joe Rawlins [23:58]: "Doris. She has a little girl, two years old."
Captain Frank Kennelly [25:20]: "You're happy for myself. Except who are the woman and child down there?"
"Case of the Sailor's Family" is a masterful portrayal of police procedural storytelling, blending emotional depth with the intrigue of a mystery. Through Captain Kennelly's determined leadership and Joe Rawlins' desperate search for his family, the episode captures the essence of human struggle against unforeseen circumstances. Listeners are left contemplating the unseen layers within every case and the unwavering commitment of those who solve them.
Harold's Old Time Radio continues to deliver timeless stories that resonate with audiences, reminding us of the enduring appeal of classic radio drama. This episode stands as a testament to the genre's ability to weave complex narratives that engage and enthrall.