
Adventure Theater 77-xx-xx A Case of Identity
Loading summary
American Express
With Blue Cash Preferred from American Express, you can earn cash back on groceries, gas and streaming from the checkout counter to the pump and finally back home again to stream your favorite shows. You can get more out of your everyday moments, earn on your errands and get rewarded with Blue Cash Preferred. Learn more@americanexpress.com US Explore. BCP terms apply.
Narrator
Good evening. Welcome to Radio's Adventure Theater. Like fine vintage wine that gets tastier with the years, radio's mystery and adventure stories out of the past are still vibrant and alive. Join us now as we reach into the dusty archives for tonight's exciting drama.
Announcer
Tonight we bring you a transcribed story of a man who tries to lose himself. So now, starring Parley Bear and Michael Ann Barrett, A case of identity.
Edna Burton
Harry? Harry, answer me.
Harry Burton
Well, I don't know, Edna.
Edna Burton
You don't know what?
Harry Burton
I don't know if it's such a good idea. It might not work.
Edna Burton
Are you crazy? You think I planned something that wouldn't work? You think that?
Harry Burton
No.
Edna Burton
Well, then, what is it?
Harry Burton
Well, how are you so sure the insurance company will do it?
Edna Burton
You try him, Harry. You try finding one that won't jump to insure your life for 100,000 doll.
Harry Burton
That's how it started. She'd brought it up at dinner, not all at once, but in little pieces, just enough to make me curious. Then later, when she'd done everything she could to put me in a good mood, she told me all of it. She'd gotten the idea weeks ago, but she didn't want to mention it until I started on my vacation. Just in case anyone at the office noticed I was unusually nervous. Oh, yes. She'd planned it. Well, she made it sound easy. So I agreed to go along with her. The next morning, I applied for a life insurance policy, one that would pay Edna $100,000 in the event of my death. A week later, the manager of that insurance company called and asked me to stop by his office.
Insurance Agent
Well, Mr. Burton, it's a pleasure to meet you personally.
Harry Burton
Thank you.
Insurance Agent
It is an often we're privileged to.
Harry Burton
Issue such a large policy when it has cleared.
Insurance Agent
I believe everything's in order. If you just sign here.
Harry Burton
There you are.
Insurance Agent
All right, Mr. Burton.
Harry Burton
That's it. Thank you.
Insurance Agent
Take care of yourself, Mr. Burton.
Harry Burton
Half an hour after leaving his office, I walked into that park in the center of town. I'd been spending a lot of time there, watching, waiting, feeding the pigeons. Then I'd spotted the particular pigeon I'd been waiting for. We were the same height, weight, same Color, eyes. We could have been brothers. Except that he was a mousy gray the color of all stumble bums. For three days now I'd been watching him. Getting to know his habits. He showed up every morning about 11. First he'd take a walk looking for butts. Then he'd plop on the grass and sleep. This morning I wasn't going to let him sleep.
Insurance Agent
Hi.
Harry Burton
Nice day.
Insurance Agent
Yeah. Smoggy.
Harry Burton
Yes, it is. It gets your eyes.
Insurance Agent
Sure does. Isn't doing my head much good neither.
Harry Burton
Bad night, huh?
Insurance Agent
You don't have to have a drink on you, do you?
Harry Burton
No, but here's a buck.
Insurance Agent
Hey, how come you give me a buck, mister?
Harry Burton
I've got a job for you.
Gas Station Attendant
Job?
Insurance Agent
Oh, I'm not looking for no job. I've been sick. Real bad sick. Oh, you don't know?
Harry Burton
Well, there's not much work involved. I have a cabin up in the San Berdu Mountains. It's kind of run down. I need somebody to help me fix it up.
Insurance Agent
Oh, no, no, no. That sounds like. That sounds like heavy work. My doctor said I'll do the heavy work.
Harry Burton
Okay. It'll mean 50 bucks to you. How about it?
Insurance Agent
50?
Harry Burton
Half now and half when the job's finished. Well.
Insurance Agent
Well, as long as there's no heavy work then. Well, when do we go?
Harry Burton
Right now.
Insurance Agent
Now? Sure.
Harry Burton
Anything wrong? Do you have a business appointment?
Insurance Agent
Well, now, you don't have to get sassy. Okay, we go soon as I get that 25. You are. Oh, just one thing more. What's that about that drink. I could sure use it.
Harry Burton
You'll get it. I bought him a 49 cent bottle of wine which he opened before we got to the car. Then he insisted I drive him around to a flop house so he could pay a week's rent. Finally, we turned onto the freeway and headed for home.
Edna Burton
Harry?
Harry Burton
Yep?
Edna Burton
You're late. Why didn't you call?
Harry Burton
I was busy. I've got him in the car.
Edna Burton
What?
Harry Burton
He's in the car.
Edna Burton
Who is he? What's he like?
Harry Burton
His name's Wallace. He's a bum. A stew bum. We'll be doing him a favor. I backed the car out of the garage, careful that no one saw me. Then we started. My traveling companion wasn't feeling any pain. He polished off his bottle and passed out. No sign of anyone on that mountain highway. No houses, no cars. Not until I reached the 4,000 foot level where there was a little rundown gas station. At 12:30 we reached the cabin. I parked on the slope, pulled the emergency brake Tight. And then reached over into the back seat for the jack handle. I switched clothes with him. My keys, watch, wallet. Everything but my matches. Then I saturated the upholstery with. With gasoline, left the can in the back seat and got out. Move over. I'll drive.
Edna Burton
I saw was beautiful.
Harry Burton
Yeah, A real fire. Hot.
Edna Burton
There's blood on your coat. His coat.
Harry Burton
It's all right. I'm a drunk. I fell down. It's the usual thing. Light me a cigarette.
Edna Burton
Harry.
Gas Station Attendant
What?
Edna Burton
Did you leave the car in here?
Harry Burton
No.
Edna Burton
You forgot.
Harry Burton
Take it easy, will you? I didn't forget. The old figure I was sitting there drinking, fell asleep. The brake slipped. It'll be all right.
Edna Burton
When? When do you think they'll find him?
Harry Burton
Tomorrow, the next day? Now, when the police come, you know what to do. They'll ask a lot of questions, but don't lose your nerve. And don't. Don't What?
Edna Burton
What's wrong?
Harry Burton
I don't know. The motor's missing.
Edna Burton
We're stopping.
Harry Burton
Oh, shut up, will ya?
Edna Burton
Well, Harry, do something. Please do something. If they find us here like this.
Insurance Agent
Shut up.
Harry Burton
Well, it's no use. It won't.
Insurance Agent
You fool.
Harry Burton
You stupid, ignorant fool. Why didn't you notice?
Edna Burton
Notice what?
Harry Burton
We're out of gas.
Edna Burton
What?
Harry Burton
Oh, never mind. You still got a chance. There's a gas station a couple of miles from here. I'm gonna try to coast down to it.
Edna Burton
But if somebody see this, they won't.
Harry Burton
Get in the back. On the floor. Hurry up, for heaven's sake. Don't argue. Get in the back. Put that blanket over you and don't. Their lights are out. But somebody's got to be inside.
Insurance Agent
All right, all right. Heard you the second time. What do you want? 10 gallons of gas. Sorry. Close at 11 pumps. Locked.
Harry Burton
Then unlock it.
Insurance Agent
Now, wait a minute.
Harry Burton
I've got to have some gas. Do you understand?
Insurance Agent
Sure, I understand. But I ain't giving you none.
Harry Burton
You're not?
Insurance Agent
Now you listen to me. You listen, mister. I don't like your order and ways. Coming down here like high and mighty, blowing your horn like it was judgment day. Now, you better get.
Harry Burton
What do you mean by that?
Insurance Agent
Just what I said. Keep coasting, brother.
Harry Burton
Okay. I. I don't want any trouble. Only I thought maybe you'd be interested in $20.
Insurance Agent
Huh? How much? $20 for just 10 gallons of gas?
Harry Burton
That's right.
Insurance Agent
Reckon you do want to get home. That's a little regular.
Harry Burton
Anything, only hurry. Okay.
Insurance Agent
Okay.
Edna Burton
Mary, do you have enough money?
Harry Burton
Yes. No.
Edna Burton
What?
Harry Burton
The money I gave him isn't Here. Nothing's in these pockets but my matches and that key to that stinking flop house.
Edna Burton
What could he have done with it? You gave him $25, didn't you?
Insurance Agent
Yes.
Harry Burton
Quiet. He's coming back.
Insurance Agent
You want me to check your oil and water?
Harry Burton
No, no, it's not necessary.
Insurance Agent
Just thought I'd ask.
Harry Burton
What did that dirty bum do with my money?
Edna Burton
Here, Harry.
Insurance Agent
What?
Edna Burton
Take this. Here. It's all I have.
Harry Burton
Five bucks.
Edna Burton
It's all I have, Harry.
Insurance Agent
Okay. That's it. Ten gallons.
Harry Burton
Fine. Here's your money.
Insurance Agent
Hey, you said.
Harry Burton
When we got away from there, I noticed my throat was dry. My hands were beginning to shake. I was having trouble keeping the car on the road. Then Edna climbed up into the front seat and took the wheel. She didn't say a word. We turned onto the freeway that would take us into the city.
Edna Burton
You handled that very nicely, Harry.
Harry Burton
Thank you, Edna. Coming from you, that's a compliment.
Edna Burton
How do you feel?
Harry Burton
All right now?
Edna Burton
Worried about anything?
Harry Burton
No. Are you?
Edna Burton
Nothing. I'll let you off near Main Street. Keep out of sight until your beard grows out like the one Wallace has.
Harry Burton
Okay.
Edna Burton
You'll be able to learn what's happening from the newspapers.
Harry Burton
How will I know when you got the money?
Edna Burton
Call me Tuesday. If I don't have it, then I'll probably know when they're going to give it to me. And Harry.
Harry Burton
Yeah?
Edna Burton
I'll never forget what you've done for me. Never.
Harry Burton
You're already forgetting one thing, Edna.
Edna Burton
What's that?
Harry Burton
I didn't do it all for you.
Edna Burton
Didn't you, Harry?
Harry Burton
She stopped the car a couple of blocks from skid row. I got out and disappeared. The torn suit, bloodshot eyes and my beard put me in that mousy gray color. Few hours later, I was just another stumblebum. Three days went by before they found the body. Naturally, the newspapers played it up big.
Gas Station Attendant
Real big.
Harry Burton
With a picture of me and an obituary half a column long. There was also picture of Edna, the grief stricken wife. Taken right after she'd identified my body. I turned the page and kept on reading. And then I saw it. Only a small paragraph, but it said my widow would receive her hundred thousand immediately. Hello, Edna.
Edna Burton
Harry.
Harry Burton
Did I frighten you? I'm sorry.
Edna Burton
What are you doing here? How did you get in?
Harry Burton
You still leave that key under the back door? Matt, how many times have I told you about that?
Edna Burton
You shouldn't have come here. Why didn't you call?
Harry Burton
I did. All day and no answer.
Edna Burton
What if they're watching the house?
Harry Burton
Why should they, the police, are satisfied that I'm dead. You've got the insurance. How'd the company take it?
Edna Burton
I think they were suspicious. They asked me an awful lot of questions.
Harry Burton
Yeah, they figured to. But they could hardly go against the police findings. Death by misadventure.
Edna Burton
I don't want to talk about it anymore, Harry.
Harry Burton
No, you're right, Oliver. We've got the money now.
Edna Burton
I've got the money.
Harry Burton
What?
Edna Burton
And I'm going to keep it.
Harry Burton
Edna. Edna, you're not making sense.
Edna Burton
I'm not? Well, let me clarify the situation for you. I've got a hundred thousand dollars and you're dead. You're very, very dead.
Harry Burton
Are you? You had this idea all along, right from the very beginning. You never had any intention of sharing that money. And you made me kill a man.
Edna Burton
Stay right where you are, Harry. You take one more step and I'll scream. And you know how loud I can scream.
Harry Burton
Well, go ahead.
Edna Burton
Remember, you've lost your identity. I'll say you're a prowler. You broke in.
Harry Burton
And I'll spill the whole work, including.
Edna Burton
How you killed a man. No, I don't think you will. Will you, Harry?
Harry Burton
You're smart, isn't it? You're smarter than I ever gave you credit for. She'd always been the strong one, the aggressor. Always gotten her way up to now. That evening, after making sure she'd been picked up by her cousin to go to a movie as I usually did on Wednesdays, I entered the house again. I'd attended a sales convention the month before, and while I was away, I'd written her twice. Those letters were still on her desk. As quickly as I could, I lifted the old letters from their envelopes and replaced them with some I'd written that afternoon. In one of them, I said, darling, I can't understand why you insist I take out such a large insurance policy. If I didn't know you better, I might think you were planning to murder me. And I put the envelopes back in the desk and went into our bedroom. The keys to her coop were on the dresser. I put them in my pocket, picked up one of her shoes and started for the mountains. I reached the cabin about midnight, broke the heel from her shoe, tossed it into the ravine. Then I spattered mud on the shoe and put it back in the car. When I reached Palmdale, I made a long distance phone call.
Gas Station Attendant
Johnson Homicide.
Harry Burton
Hello. I've been reading about that Burton case in my newspaper and I thought maybe I should tell someone that I was driving Over Crestline, the night it happened.
Gas Station Attendant
Who's calling, please?
Harry Burton
I saw this car parked by a cab, and there was a man and a woman in it. And they. They seem to be arguing.
Insurance Agent
Arguing?
Harry Burton
That's right.
Gas Station Attendant
You remember what time it was?
Harry Burton
Oh, just after midnight, maybe 12:30.
Announcer
I see.
Gas Station Attendant
Could I have your name now, please?
Harry Burton
Well, I. I'm a family man. I wouldn't like to get involved.
Gas Station Attendant
But, sir, it's very.
Harry Burton
It was the next afternoon before I could get back in the house. But when I did, I took out Mud's battered shoe with me, planted it in her closet. I was about to look in her dresser where she usually kept her cash, when I heard edna come in.
Gas Station Attendant
Mrs. Burton?
Edna Burton
Yes.
Gas Station Attendant
Sergeant Johnson, Homicide Department. May I come in?
Edna Burton
Well, yes, certainly.
Gas Station Attendant
Thank you. Sorry to bother you again, Mrs. Burton, but something has come up.
Edna Burton
Yes?
Gas Station Attendant
You stated at the inquest that you were home the night of your husband's death.
Edna Burton
I was.
Gas Station Attendant
Can you furnish proof to that effect?
Edna Burton
I. I suppose so, but I really don't know how at the moment. I've told you everything before.
Gas Station Attendant
Some additional information has come to our attention. We'd like your help in clearing it up.
Edna Burton
Well, naturally, I'm always ready to cooperate with the police.
Announcer
Fine.
Gas Station Attendant
Then you'll answer my questions, won't you? Did anyone see you here that evening? Can you furnish any proof at all? I'm afraid I'll have to have you come along with us, Ms. Burton.
Edna Burton
But why? I haven't done it.
Gas Station Attendant
I'm sorry.
Edna Burton
It's utterly ridiculous.
Gas Station Attendant
It's necessary, Mrs. Burton. Now, if you will, please.
Edna Burton
Oh, all right. Let's get it over with.
Gas Station Attendant
Oh, Ms. Burton, before we leave your house, do you recognize this?
Edna Burton
What is it?
Gas Station Attendant
The heel of a shoe. We found it at the scene of the accident. Could it possibly have broken off one of yours?
Edna Burton
No.
Gas Station Attendant
You're positive?
Edna Burton
Quite positive.
Gas Station Attendant
Very well. I'll leave the door open. Please. My partner and a policewoman are waiting outside. They have a warrant to search your house.
Harry Burton
The police were going to search the house while I was there. That was almost funny. I was going to be caught in my own trap. For a moment, I panicked, and I realized the search team hadn't entered the house. As quickly as I could, I moved back to her bedroom. I was at the window, forcing it open when I heard them. And then I was out, ducking low, running along the side of the house until I reached the street. It wasn't until I reached Edna's coop two blocks away that I remembered I hadn't taken any Money from the dresser. I was broke now. Nowhere to go, nowhere to sleep, except in the car. I parked on the boulevard a couple of hours and watched the people walking by. Then later, while driving around looking for a place to park for the night, a place where I could sleep, I turned on the car radio.
Announcer
Insurance case of the late Harry W. Burton. Police have uncovered evidence which they say links Mrs. Edna Burton to her husband's death. The widow, when confronted with letters written by her husband and a broken shoe identified as hers, turned up in a recent search, became hysterical, blurted out a fantastic story about her husband still being alive. Authorities discrediting the rantings of the troubled woman have requested her transfer to the psychiatric division of the General Hospital for examination. You will recall her husband's car crashed into a ravine near the Angeles Crest Highway. Police at the time thought the death of Mr. Burton was accidental. Meanwhile, police have issued an all point bulletin for the car alleged to have been used in the murder plot. The car is described as a black Ford coupe, license number JGC150. It's believed.
Harry Burton
I've got to get rid of this car. I've got to before it's spotted. But where'll I sleep? No money. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. I've got a key to a hotel room. Sure. Wallace's room. And he paid a week's rent in advance.
Edna Burton
Sure.
Harry Burton
If I'm lucky, I've got a chance. I haven't much choice.
Insurance Agent
Hey. Hey. Where you going?
Harry Burton
To my room. I. I live here, you see? Here's the key. Number 47.
Insurance Agent
What's your name?
Harry Burton
Wallace. Don't you remember?
Insurance Agent
No. I'm just a relief clerk.
Harry Burton
Oh. Well, I. I've been sick a few days. I haven't been in, so if I owe you any money, I'll pay it tomorrow.
Insurance Agent
You don't owe nothing.
Harry Burton
I don't? No.
Insurance Agent
Can I?
Harry Burton
Dude.
Gas Station Attendant
All right, Wallace.
Harry Burton
Reach. What is this?
Insurance Agent
Come in all the way. That's.
Gas Station Attendant
We've been waiting for you, Wallace. My name's Johnson, Homicide. This is my partner, Sergeant Barton. He's clean.
Harry Burton
Well, what do you want with me?
Gas Station Attendant
We'll ask the questions, Wallace. Last Tuesday you showed up here with enough money to pay your rent a month in advance.
Harry Burton
A month?
Insurance Agent
Don't tell us. You did some honest work, Wallace. You got a fine record. Don't ruin it by admitting you actually did some work.
Harry Burton
But I did. It was only $25. Can't a man make a little money?
Insurance Agent
Sure.
Gas Station Attendant
Sure, he can. Only this happened last Tuesday. And last Tuesday afternoon you came Bouncing, bragging about how lucky you were. You paid a month's rent in advance and said there'd be plenty more where that came from. Your drinking buddies told some of our boys about it. They were worried when you didn't come back. That may be something that happened to you on that job up in Crestline. You did this at work up in Crestline last Tuesday night, didn't you?
Harry Burton
No, no. No, I didn't.
Gas Station Attendant
Try again, Wallace. You can try all night. You're not going to beat this one. We got a description from a gas station attendant up there. Fits you to a tee.
Harry Burton
But you've got the wrong man, believe me.
Insurance Agent
Oh, sure, Wallace. Well, he's not satisfied, Johnny. Give him some more.
Gas Station Attendant
Okay. Woman. You don't know a woman called Edna Burton? Today, just before she blew her stack, she was yelling your name like crazy. All about a flaming rocket. Or was it a fireball? Whatever it was, you were the star of, it was.
Harry Burton
But I am not, Wallace. I'm Burton. Edna. Ask her. Can't.
Gas Station Attendant
At least not till she's allowed to have visitors at the state hospital.
Insurance Agent
Okay, let's go, buddy.
Harry Burton
No, wait, wait, wait. Please. I'll tell you the truth. You're arresting me for my own murder? I'm Burton.
Gas Station Attendant
That's so. If you're Burton, where's Wallace?
Insurance Agent
Where's.
Harry Burton
Where's what?
Insurance Agent
Well, he thinks it's funny, Johnny.
Gas Station Attendant
Yeah, Wine sure does some crazy things to him.
Harry Burton
It is funny. It's funny. Don't you see? It doesn't matter. Burton and Wallace, it doesn't matter. It doesn't matter at all.
Narrator
And that's Adventure Theater. Join us each week at this time as we reach into the dusty archives for another thrilling story of mystery and adventure from out of the past. This is the American Forces Radio and Television Service.
Podcast: Harold's Old Time Radio
Host: Harolds Old Time Radio
Release Date: February 13, 2025
In this gripping episode of Adventure Theater, titled "A Case of Identity", listeners are transported back to the Golden Age of Radio, immersing themselves in a tale of deception, betrayal, and unexpected twists. The story revolves around Harry Burton and his wife Edna, whose seemingly innocent life insurance plan unravels into a complex web of deceit.
The story begins with Edna Burton urging her husband, Harry, to take out a substantial life insurance policy. Despite Harry's initial reservations, Edna persuades him to proceed.
Edna Burton [02:00]: "She'd gotten the idea weeks ago, but she didn't want to mention it until I started on my vacation."
Harry recounts how Edna meticulously planned the insurance scheme, presenting it in small, manageable pieces to gauge his response before fully revealing her intentions.
Harry decides to execute a plan to simulate his own death, ensuring that Edna benefits from the policy. His strategy involves an elaborate ruse with a coincidental encounter at a local park.
At [03:48], Harry notices a pigeon that strikingly resembles himself, symbolizing the impending chaos of dual identities.
Harry Burton [03:48]: "We were the same height, weight, same color, eyes. We could have been brothers."
Harry approaches an unsuspecting insurance agent, offering him a seemingly harmless job to fix up a rundown cabin in the San Bernardo Mountains.
Harry Burton [04:08]: "Well, there's not much work involved. I have a cabin up in the San Berdu Mountains. It's kind of run down. I need somebody to help me fix it up."
The agent, intrigued and desperate, agrees to the job for a fee, unwittingly becoming a pawn in Harry’s intricate plan.
Once at the cabin, Harry executes his plan by switching clothes with the insurance agent and setting the cabin ablaze to create the illusion of an accidental death.
Harry Burton [06:00]: "Then I saturated the upholstery with gasoline, left the can in the back seat and got out. Move over. I'll drive."
A meticulously timed fire engulfs the cabin, and Harry ensures that his appearance aligns with the insurance company's records to solidify the facade of his demise.
Edna, upon receiving news of Harry's supposed death, appears devastated. However, subtle inconsistencies begin to surface, hinting at deeper layers of deception.
Edna Burton [07:45]: "There's blood on your coat. His coat."
As the story progresses, Harry returns, revealing that Edna orchestrated the entire scheme to benefit from the life insurance policy without intending to share the proceeds.
Harry Burton [13:35]: "Edna, you're not making sense."
The revelation that Edna never intended to uphold their marital trust turns the narrative on its head, showcasing her manipulative nature.
Law enforcement, represented by Sergeant Johnson and Sergeant Barton, starts piecing together the inconsistencies in the Burton case. Edna's frantic behavior and contradictory statements raise red flags.
Sergeant Johnson [17:39]: "Mrs. Burton, something has come up."
Edna's inability to provide alibis and her evasive responses during the investigation further implicate her involvement in the deception.
Harry, leveraging his understanding of the plot, manipulates the situation to expose Edna's true intentions. By planting evidence and altering correspondence, he unravels the tangled web they had spun together.
Harry Burton [14:03]: "She made me kill a man."
In the climactic confrontation, Edna's facade crumbles as Harry confronts her with undeniable proof of her betrayal.
Edna Burton [23:18]: "She's smarter than I ever gave you credit for."
The police, now fully aware of Edna's machinations, secure her involvement in the scheme. The episode concludes with Edna facing the consequences of her actions, while Harry reclaims his identity and the narrative rests on the triumph of truth over deceit.
Narrator [23:18]: "The widow... became hysterical... Authorities discrediting the rantings of the troubled woman... Police have issued an all point bulletin..."
A Case of Identity masterfully explores themes of trust, deception, and the lengths individuals will go to secure financial gain. The narrative delves into the complexities of marital relationships and the perilous consequences of manipulating trust for personal benefit. The episode serves as a cautionary tale about the fragility of identity and the importance of honesty in relationships.
This episode of Adventure Theater stands as a testament to the enduring allure of mystery and adventure stories from radio’s golden era. Through its intricate plot and well-developed characters, it offers listeners a compelling journey into the shadows of human intentions and the pursuit of truth.