Call the Police 48-07-06 (23): The Case Of The Suntower Mystery Mansion (Case #42-08) Released on March 3, 2025 by Harold's Old Time Radio

Introduction

In this gripping episode of "Call the Police," listeners are transported to the enigmatic Suntower Mansion, the setting for a chilling mystery that intertwines wealth, occultism, and political intrigue. Hosted by Commissioner Bill Grant, the story delves into the investigation of a baffling double murder that shakes the foundations of the Ashland community.

The Murder at Suntower Mansion

The episode kicks off with the grim discovery of Mrs. Potter, the affluent and occult-obsessed mistress of Suntower Mansion, who is found strangled in her expansive home. Commissioner Bill Grant introduces the case, highlighting its eerie atmosphere:

"Case number 4208 in the Ashland police files was a nightmare. A black panic we try not to think of on moonless nights as the case of the Sun Tower Mystery Mansion." ([00:53])

G.F. Potter, Mrs. Potter's husband, is quickly identified as a person of interest. His alibi is shaky, claiming he was in New York and not present at the time of the murder. The presence of Michel Bruyler, Mrs. Potter's mystic servant, adds layers of complexity to the case.

Unveiling Shadows: Occultism and Secrets

As Commissioner Grant and his partner, Libby Tyler, delve deeper into the mansion's secrets, they uncover disturbing elements tied to occult practices. Michel Bruyler recounts a terrifying night when he encountered what he believes to be the "Master of Darkness":

"I think the Master of Darkness himself. I remembered the exorcistation of Balsami. Vade, vade. Magister Sinistrut." ([03:30])

This revelation introduces a supernatural angle to the investigation, suggesting that the murders may be connected to dark, otherworldly forces within the mansion. However, Grant remains skeptical, pondering the possibility of human machinations behind the eerie occurrences.

The Investigation Deepens

Commissioner Grant interviews Dr. Robert Martin, the first responder who discovered Mrs. Potter's body. Dr. Martin describes the crime scene:

"The woman was obviously strangled. Marks in her throat, face contorted." ([07:30])

Suspicion shifts towards G.F. Potter when discrepancies in his alibi emerge. A crucial piece of evidence surfaces—a letter found on Michel Bruyler:

"Relax, Gerald. My dear Brulee, I'm aware that there's a romantic relationship between you and my wife. You may think I will overlook this affront, but I assure you that I will avenge it if it means death for both of you. Signed, G.F. Potter." ([10:53])

This letter suggests a motive rooted in jealousy and betrayal, further implicating Potter in his wife's murder.

Supernatural or Human Deception?

As the investigation progresses, strange phenomena such as infernal music and apparitions at Suntower Mansion fuel rumors of supernatural involvement. However, Dr. Robert Martin challenges these notions, proposing that someone might be orchestrating ghostly scares to divert attention:

"We might make a simple assumption in this case. Possibly. Though I can't imagine the reason." ([20:03])

Commissioner Grant begins to piece together the puzzle, suspecting that the supernatural elements are a facade masking human greed and political ambitions.

The Revelation: Political Conspiracy Unveiled

The breakthrough comes with the discovery of a hidden room containing a valuable roll of 16mm film. Commissioner Grant connects this to Edmund Lefebvre, a political candidate from the Caribbean island of Hanai:

"Commisioner Grant: I made a beeline for the original architect of Sun Tower House and came away with the blueprints... I finally found it. There it lay." ([22:02])

The film reveals Lefebvre's illicit associations, which could jeopardize his presidential candidacy. It becomes evident that Dr. Robert Martin, working on behalf of rival political forces, orchestrated the murders to obtain and destroy the film, ensuring Lefebvre's rise remains unchallenged.

Conclusion: Justice Served and Mysteries Solved

In the climax, Commissioner Grant confronts Dr. Martin, unmasking his deceit:

"The Ghost scare was a very useful smoke screen... a hocus pocus... but essentially you and Bruy were mortal political enemies... you killed him when he was about to enlist Libby and the police on his side." ([25:26])

With the truth unveiled, the case concludes with the exposure of Martin's conspiracy. The valuable film is secured and sent to Hanai, guaranteeing that Lefebvre's scandal is exposed, thereby saving his presidential bid from ruin.

In a poignant final scene, Libby Tyler reflects on the intricate web of deception and the triumph of justice, solidifying her bond with Commissioner Grant:

"I got onto Martin. I contacted the New York Medical association, found out there was no listing at all for a Dr. Robert Martin. And I came looking for you." ([28:20])

The episode wraps up with a satisfying resolution, blending elements of mystery, suspense, and human ingenuity.

Notable Quotes

1. Michel Bruyler on the Supernatural Encounter

   "I think the Master of Darkness himself. I remembered the exorcistation of Balsami. Vade, vade. Magister Sinistrut." ([03:30])

2. Dr. Robert Martin Challenging Supernatural Theories

   "We might make a simple assumption in this case. Possibly. Though I can't imagine the reason." ([20:03])

3. Commissioner Grant Unveiling the Conspiracy

   "The Ghost scare was a very useful smoke screen... a hocus pocus... but essentially you and Bruy were mortal political enemies." ([25:26])

4. Libby Tyler on Uncovering the Truth

   "I got onto Martin. I contacted the New York Medical association, found out there was no listing at all for a Dr. Robert Martin. And I came looking for you." ([28:20])

Epilogue

"The Case Of The Suntower Mystery Mansion" masterfully weaves a tale of suspense, blending supernatural elements with a deep-seated human conspiracy. Commissioner Bill Grant and Libby Tyler exemplify unwavering dedication to uncovering the truth, ultimately delivering justice in the face of darkness and deception.

Listeners are left eagerly anticipating the next installment of "Call the Police," promising another enthralling mystery from the golden age of radio.

Music arranged and conducted by Ben Ledlow. Voiced by George Petrie as Commissioner Grant.