
Crime Doctor 1945-04-08 Substitute Hero
Loading summary
Jean Albertson
Halt.
Bob Mason
Halt. About you.
Narrator
Johnny presents the philip morris crime doctor. Here comes Johnny, ladies and gentlemen, in his red coat and brass buttons. Johnny stepping out of store windows and counters all over America to introduce the Philip Morris Crime Doctor program to all you people at home as well as our men and women in service wherever this program reaches them.
Jean Albertson
Papa Philip Mori.
Narrator
You're listening to radio. Yes, Radio.
Jean Albertson
Hello, everybody. This is Johnny bringing you greetings from Philip Morris. For over 97 years, creators of famous cigarettes.
Narrator
And now another of Max Morrison's crime doctor dramas brought to you by the makers of Philip Morris cigarettes.
Bob Mason
What are you doing, Gene?
Jean Albertson
Mixing Mr. Albertson. Medicine. I heard him come in.
Bob Mason
Yeah, I just brought him back. Yeah, I'm getting sick of driving that old bird around. No matter how I drive, if I drive slow, I get balled out for crawling along. If I go fast, I get called down for speed.
Jean Albertson
Well, the doctor said he must be driven carefully and avoid any jolting to him.
Bob Mason
I sure could have given him a jolt in the eye this afternoon. You know what he said to me? He said if it wasn't for my wife, he'd fire me today. So now I'm holding down my job because you're working for him.
Jean Albertson
Look, Bob, we don't have to work in the same place. If you don't like it here, why don't you find yourself another job?
Bob Mason
Look, baby, the war will be over soon. There'll be plenty of chauffeurs around looking. Besides, we've worked in the same places together since we were married. And that's how it's gonna stay.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Gene. Gene.
Jean Albertson
Yes, sir. I'll be right in calling for his medicine. I've got to go.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Didn't Bob tell you I was back?
Jean Albertson
Yes, sir. It took me a few moments to mix the medicine.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Oh, Ready for it? No, I'm never ready to swallow the darn stu.
Jean Albertson
Oh, come on, now. You know you've got to take it here.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Oh, well.
Bob Mason
Oh.
Jean Albertson
You should be used to it by now.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
You try taking it for a year. Doesn't get any better with time. I'm wondering, too, if it really is doing me any good.
Jean Albertson
Well, you haven't had an attack in nearly a month now.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Gene, I. I've been waiting to ask you something. Gene. I don't think Bob's very happ here. I'm sure he's not good for me. His driving makes me nervous. I was wondering, if I decided to let him go, would you feel that you had to leave with him?
Jean Albertson
No, sir. I like it here.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Thank you, Jean. I'm very pleased to hear that.
Jean Albertson
Hey, Charlie, a little attention down this.
Archie Moran
End of the bar.
Charlie
I'll be there in a minute, Mike. Are you a science, Bob?
Bob Mason
Yeah. Like I was saying, Charlie, you can't depend on women. There's no loyalty among them. Now, you take my wife.
Charlie
Oh, your wife. So that's what's the matter.
Bob Mason
You know what she's done now?
Charlie
What?
Bob Mason
She lets the boss fire me and she goes right on working for him. She ain't even unhappy about it.
Charlie
Oh, gee, Bob, that's tough.
Bob Mason
Give me another drink, huh?
Archie Moran
Make it a double.
Charlie
Oh, no, no. Drinking ain't gonna bring your wife back, Bob. You know, if she was my wife, I'd go there and get her if I had to.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Drag her out with her hair. That's right.
Bob Mason
That's just what I'm gonna do. Drag her up by the hair.
Inspector Jackson
Come on, get in here.
Bob Mason
Come on, you. Come on, get in there.
Inspector Jackson
Don't argue with me.
Bob Mason
You can't lock me up. Get in there. All right.
Inspector Jackson
What's the matter, Riley?
Narrator
Drunk and disorderly, Sergeant.
Bob Mason
This is an outrage. A man's got a right to go see his own wife without having the door slammed in his place. That's what she's done to me. That's just what she done.
Charlie
What did he do?
Inspector Jackson
Threw a brick through the window when she wouldn't let him in. What's your name, mister?
Bob Mason
What do you want to know for?
Inspector Jackson
I'm signing you in for the night.
Jean Albertson
Excuse. Mr. Albertson.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Yes, Jean?
Jean Albertson
That lawyer who telephoned is here.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Well, ask him to come in.
Jean Albertson
Will you come in, Mr. Moran?
Archie Moran
Thank you.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Oh, don't go, Jean.
Jean Albertson
Yes, sir.
Archie Moran
I presume you're Mr. Albertson.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Yes.
Archie Moran
I represent Mr. Mason, this young lady's husband.
Jean Albertson
Well, I don't understand, Mr. Moran, why my husband should want you to see Mr. Albertson.
Archie Moran
My client believes he has some sort of a grievance against Mr. Albertson. He feels that he's responsible for breaking up his home.
Jean Albertson
Bob broke it himself by his own conduct.
Archie Moran
That would be for a court to determine. Mr. Mason is suffering great anguish of mind, and if Mr. Albertson is in any wise, responsible.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Mr. Moran, I consented to see you because I thought I might help to straighten out a situation between Jean and her husband. Jean tells me she will not live with him again. She intends to obtain a divorce.
Archie Moran
So I understand. And my client feels, Mr. Albertson, that you have persuaded her to take the step.
Jean Albertson
That's not true.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
I've interested myself in this matter, Mr. Moran, for purely selfish reasons. Mrs. Mason has no evidence with which to obtain a divorce in this state. I told her that. She insists that she'll go to some other state to obtain it. But she's my nurse and I can't spare her. I told her if she could arrange with her husband for him to obtain the divorce in another state. Yes, I'd be willing to pay his expenses and in addition, give him a sum of money.
Archie Moran
Well, Mr. Albertson, that seems like a reasonable suggestion. I'll talk it over with my client.
Bob Mason
Three grand. Three thousand bucks. Is that all you could get out of a margin?
Archie Moran
Yes, Bob. Yes. He says that includes the divorce expenses.
Bob Mason
Why do you owe. Cheapskate.
Archie Moran
Well, you better take it, Bob. I got his check. I'll cash it and we'll split it. 1500 for you, 1500 for me.
Bob Mason
Where do you come in for half?
Archie Moran
Look, I could get into a bad jam going up there and posing as a lawyer. I took a big chance.
Bob Mason
Maybe I should have got a real lawyer.
Archie Moran
No lawyer could do for you what I'm gonna do. If you sit tight and follow what I tell you, you're not going to renew and you're not gonna get any divorce. You're gonna lay low for six weeks. And if things happen as I think they will, brother, we're both gonna be.
Jean Albertson
Yes?
Bob Mason
I just thought I'd phone you and let you know I'm leaving for Reno tonight. I'll be back in six weeks with a decree. Charlie, I'm buying the drinks for the house. I'm celebrating.
Archie Moran
Oh, yeah.
Bob Mason
Juan.
Archie Moran
Hey, Fire.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
What are you doing in here?
Bob Mason
Oh, now watch. You love it.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Fool.
Archie Moran
You're supposed to be in Reno. Come on, I'm taking you out of here. Proceeding started. We'll keep you informed. Signed, Bob.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Yeah.
Archie Moran
There's the first telegram we'll send her, Bob.
Bob Mason
But how are you going to send it from Reno?
Archie Moran
I got a friend of mine working out there.
Jean Albertson
Yes, I'm back from Reno.
Bob Mason
Jean, I suppose you'll be glad to hear I've got the divorce.
Jean Albertson
Thank you, Bob. It was nice of you to phone me. What are your plans?
Bob Mason
Oh, I've got my plans. Don't worry about me. Goodbye.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Who was it, Jean?
Jean Albertson
Bob called me. He's back from Reno. He got the divorce. I'm free.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
I'm glad to hear it, my dear. Now, I feel free to speak to you. Yes, I've grown very fond of Eugene. I know I'm much older than you, but I hope you've grown to like me a little.
Jean Albertson
I like you a lot, Mr. Albertson.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
I'd like to feel that we could be together always. Do you think you care enough for me to be my wife?
Archie Moran
Hey, Pop.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Huh?
Archie Moran
Pop, you see the paper?
Narrator
What?
Archie Moran
Look, there it is. They were married, all right. I told you they'd do it.
Bob Mason
They didn't waste any time.
Archie Moran
Oh. Hey, where's that phony divorce decree you took up to show her?
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Oh, I got it.
Archie Moran
Well, let me have it.
Bob Mason
Oh, I'm gonna tear it up right here and now. Fling the pieces out the window. Oh, Bo.
Inspector Jackson
We sitting pretty?
Narrator
Before continuing with the Philip Morris crime, doctor, you all remember the old saying which goes, for want of a nail, a shoe was lost. For want of a shoe, a horse was lost. Such a small difference. But because of it, an important battle in some old time war was lost all for the want of a horseshoe nail. Yes, differences sometimes bring tremendous results. For example, in cigarettes, there is weighty scientific proof that Philip Morris cigarettes are vastly different. I refer to the findings of distinguished doctors in repeated clinical tests. Findings which show that when smokers change to Philip Morris substantially every case of irritation of the nose and throat due to smoking either cleared up completely or definitely improved. These findings were reported in a leading medical journal for the information of doctors. Now, it's true you enjoy Philip Morris for the grand flavor and aroma of the world finest tobaccos. But extra protection is an added enjoyment in this cigarette proved less irritating. Safer for the nose and throat. No curative power is ever claimed for Philip Morris. But an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Yes, differences change results. Philip Morris superiority is recognized by eminent medical authorities. No other cigarette can make that statement. We now continue with the Philip Morris Crime, Doctor.
Jean Albertson
Come in. There's a man to see you, Mrs. Albertson. Who is it, Mary? Mr. Moran. Mr. Moran.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Don't you remember, dear? He's the lawyer who arranged the Reno matter with Bob.
Jean Albertson
Oh, yes, yes. Ask him to come in. Yes, ma'. Am. Will you go in, please?
Narrator
Thank you.
Archie Moran
Oh. Oh, excuse me, Mrs. Albertson. Could. Could I see you alone, please? I have a little matter to discuss.
Jean Albertson
Well, I'm sure there's nothing we have to discuss. My husband can't hear well, it's going.
Archie Moran
To be rather embarrassing to speak before him.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
I'm sure, Mr. Moran, that my wife has no secrets from me.
Archie Moran
Very well. The matter I came about concerns Mrs. Albertson's marriage to you, sir.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Yes, what about it?
Archie Moran
Well, I. I learned a very astonishing thing this morning. Your marriage is illegal.
Jean Albertson
What? How do you mean?
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Bob came to see Me?
Archie Moran
The other day he said he was broke, needed some money, sort of. Incidentally, he mentioned that he'd never been to Reno and never obtained a divorce.
Jean Albertson
Why, that's impossible. I have telegrams he sent me from Reno.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Yes, he said that he had some.
Archie Moran
Friend of his working out there to send you the telegrams. I couldn't believe he was speaking the truth, so I wired the clerk of the court out there for a copy of the divorce record. I got his answer this morning. Here it is.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
May I see it?
Archie Moran
Oh, certainly, Mr. Hobson.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Hmm? No record of Mason versus in the court files.
Archie Moran
I thought it was my duty to bring the facts to your knowledge, Mrs. Albertson.
Jean Albertson
I can't understand Bob doing a thing like that.
Archie Moran
No, I couldn't understand it either at first, but I see his purpose now. Over the telephone this morning, he used the word bigamy.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Bigamy? He must be out of his mind. He showed Gene the divorce decree.
Jean Albertson
I had him come here on purpose to show it to me.
Archie Moran
Well, if he ever showed you such a decree, Mrs. Albertson, I'm sure it was not genuine.
Jean Albertson
But.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
But this is shocking, Mr. Moran.
Jean Albertson
What can we do about it?
Archie Moran
Sorry, I can't advise you. I can only tell you that I've had great difficulty in preventing Bob from complaining to the authorities.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
You mean that he is contemplating making a charge of bigamy against my wife?
Archie Moran
He feels his wife wronged him and he's desperate for money, Mr. Albertson.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Oh, that's it. Hmm. He sent you up here to arrange another settlement?
Archie Moran
I'm simply acting in the capacity of a friend. Whose friend I am sorry for, Mrs. Albertson.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
I can't understand Bob needing money this soon.
Archie Moran
$3,000 doesn't last long these days.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Well, did he tell you what he did with the additional 47,000 that I paid him? What? I thought you knew. The day he got his divorce, I paid him the additional money to round out the 50,000 I said I'd let him have.
Archie Moran
Oh, when did you make that deal with him?
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Why, I spoke to him before he presumably left to Reno. I made him the offer to make it worth his while to expedite the divorce. Certainly. All news to me.
Archie Moran
I'm going to see Bob right away. Goodbye.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Goodbye, Mr. Moran.
Jean Albertson
Dear, I didn't know you paid Bob all that money.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Neither did I.
Jean Albertson
But you told Mr. Moran.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Yes, I know, dear. It's very obvious. He and Bob are working in cahoots.
Bob Mason
Well.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
When they get through fighting over the money Bob didn't get, I think we'll have all the facts in back of their duplicity.
Bob Mason
Now, look, put away that gun, Arch. Put that gun away. I tell you, the guy's a liar. I never got no 47 grand for you.
Archie Moran
You're gonna pay me my half share or not?
Bob Mason
How many times must I tell you? All I got was the dough you brought.
Archie Moran
How many times must I tell you you're a liar?
Bob Mason
Why would I double cross?
Archie Moran
Hey, jip me out of my share. Now, for the last time, are you gonna pay me or not?
Bob Mason
Now, look, yes or no? I'm trying to tell you.
Inspector Jackson
Yes or no?
Bob Mason
I can't pay you what I.
Archie Moran
I'm giving it to you straight, Inspector. I shot him in self defense. Man's got a right to shoot in self defense.
Inspector Jackson
Yes, that's right.
Narrator
He has.
Inspector Jackson
Moran, if his life is in danger.
Archie Moran
My life is in danger.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
All right.
Archie Moran
You think yours was too? Inspector, if a man stood four feet away from you pointing a gun at.
Inspector Jackson
You, I'd like to ask you. Moran.
Archie Moran
Yes, Dr. Ordway.
Inspector Jackson
Just where were you standing and where was your friend Bob at the time of the shooting?
Archie Moran
I was standing right over there near the wall. Bob was about in the middle of the room.
Inspector Jackson
How did he come to be pointing a gun at you?
Archie Moran
He had a quarrel over money. He got angry and suddenly pulled a gun and fired. The bullet passed over my shoulder and lodged in the wall. Before he could fire a second shot, I had my gun out and let him have it. He fell to the floor. I ran out to call a policeman, but there were people in the hall and they followed me down the street till I found a cop. And that. That's the truth, Mr. Crime Doctor, whether you believe me or not.
Inspector Jackson
Oh, Jackson.
Charlie
Yes, Inspector.
Inspector Jackson
Jackson, when you got here, what did you find?
Charlie
The dead man was lying in the middle of the room. According to the medical examiner, a.32 caliber bullet had shattered his spine and lodged in his lung. A.38 caliber pistol was lying near his hand. And a second pistol,32 caliber, was on the floor near the wall. One shot had been fired from each of the guns.
Inspector Jackson
Jackson, what was the caliber of the bullet in the wall?
Charlie
Well, that was a.38.
Inspector Jackson
And how far from the dead man's hand would you say the.38 caliber pistol was lying?
Charlie
Oh, I should say about an inch from the right hand.
Inspector Jackson
How far from the wall was the.32 caliber pistol lying? Oh, the.
Charlie
The butt of the pistol was touching the wall.
Inspector Jackson
Touching the. In what direction was the barrel pointing?
Charlie
Pointing towards a dead man.
Inspector Jackson
Let's see, Jackson, did you question Any of the people who heard the shots?
Charlie
Oh, yes, sir. They all say they heard two shots. Some say there was a difference of five seconds between the two shots and others say the second shot came fully 10 or 15 seconds after the first.
Inspector Jackson
Oh, indeed. Well, what do you say about that, Moran?
Archie Moran
I fired right after Bob fired at me. I didn't count the seconds.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
No.
Inspector Jackson
Moran.
Archie Moran
Yes, Dr. Ordway?
Inspector Jackson
You told the inspector that you and the dead man quarreled over money.
Archie Moran
That's right. I accused Bob of holding onto me in a deal we were in. He denied it and I called him a liar.
Inspector Jackson
That's what started the fight. What sort of a deal was it?
Archie Moran
I acted for him in negotiating a settlement for his domestic affairs. He and his wife agreed to get a divorce so she could marry the man she she was working for. Bob didn't have any money and I arranged for the settlement with Mr. Albertson. That's the wife's employer.
Inspector Jackson
How much did Mr. Albertson pay?
Archie Moran
$50,000. Bob and I agreed we were to split the money.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
50. 50?
Archie Moran
He claimed he only got $3,000.
Inspector Jackson
Is that why you killed him?
Archie Moran
I told you why I killed him in self defense.
Inspector Jackson
Nevertheless, Morad, and the fact that remains that your life never was in danger.
Archie Moran
There's the bullet hole right there in the wall to prove he fired at me.
Inspector Jackson
No, Moran, that shot was never fired at you. You wanted it to appear that way as confirmation of the story you thought up. But unfortunately for you, you overlooked one little detail that proves conclusively your shooting of Bob was an act of cold blooded murder. Ladies and gentlemen, in exactly 59 seconds, Dr. Ordway, the Philip Morris crime doctor will be back to tell you the little detail overlooked by the suspect. In the meantime, maybe it happened yesterday or today. You asked for Philip Morris and your dealer hasn't any. He can't help it. Neither can we, because we're providing all the Philip Morris humanly possible. But perhaps tomorrow your dealer will have Philip Morris. But they is coming when once again, when you call for Philip Morris, you will get Philip Morris. And once again you smoke and enjoy the cigarette that gives extra pleasure plus extra protection. Remember too, that package of Philip Morris you failed to get today has gone to some fighting American overseas. It's a contribution you are making to the comfort of some man or woman in our armed forces. So always remember Johnny's call for Philip Morris made by Americans for Americans to suit American taste. Philip Morris, America's finest popular price cigarette. We now return you to Dr. Ordway. The Philip Morris crime, doctor. Well, now, Dr. Ordway, you mentioned a little detail that was overlooked by this suspect, Archie Moran. Yes, Inspector. He made a fatal mistake in telling how the murdered man was killed. The facts contradict the story told by this suspect.
Archie Moran
The facts are just as I told them, Dr. Rodway.
Inspector Jackson
In order to fire at you, Bob would have had to stand facelessly.
Archie Moran
Well, who said he wasn't facing me?
Inspector Jackson
He couldn't have been, Moran, because the bullets that killed him shattered his spine and lodged in his lungs. That means the bullet entered his back. After you killed him, you heard people in the hallway. So you got Bob's gun and fired a shot into the wall.
Archie Moran
I don't care what you say, Dr. Moran.
Narrator
Hold it, will you?
Jean Albertson
I want to go right in. I'm Mrs. Albertson.
Inspector Jackson
Oh, oh, yes, yes. Come right in, Mrs. Albertson. I. I had one of my men telephone to you.
Jean Albertson
Yes, he asked me to come down here, Inspector. He said Bob had been killed.
Inspector Jackson
Yes, that's true. Mrs. Albertson. Do you know this man?
Jean Albertson
Yes, he's Mr. Moran. He came to our house today and said a divorce which Bob obtained was fraudulent. He hinted Bob needed money.
Archie Moran
Yes, and you bear me out, Mrs. Albertson. Your husband told me he had paid Bob $47,000 besides the three grand he.
Dr. Eugene Albertson
Gave me for Bob.
Inspector Jackson
Well, $50,000 was a large settlement to make.
Jean Albertson
Oh, my husband didn't pay the other 47,000.
Narrator
What's that?
Jean Albertson
He only told Mr. Moran he had.
Inspector Jackson
Well, why did he tell him that?
Jean Albertson
Thought if he could get two thieves quarreling among themselves, the truth might come out.
Archie Moran
Hey, wait a minute. You mean Bob never got the 47,000?
Jean Albertson
No, he didn't. Why, that old liar. I oughta.
Inspector Jackson
Hold it, Moran. Hold it. It's my duty to warn you. Anything you say may be used against you because pending further investigation, I'm holding you on suspicion of murder.
Jean Albertson
This is Johnny again, returning now to the thousands of store windows and counters all over America. Look for me. I'll be waiting for you. Come in and.
Inspector Jackson
Goodbye, Johnny. We'll be seeing you in the windows and on the counters during the week and hearing you over this same station next Sunday at this same time. Be sure to tune in next week this week for another of Max Martian's thrilling crime dusted dramas brought to you by Philip Morris. All names and characters used on this program are fictitious and any similarity to persons living or dead is purely coincidental. Here's some good news for all smokers. It's about that grand pipe mixture revelation. The pipe tobacco you can inhale. Thousands who never smoked pipes before are turning to revelation and find they can inhale it just like cigarettes. Ask for revelation. Only 15 cents. Join us again next week at this time for the Philip Morris crime.
Jean Albertson
Dr.
Inspector Jackson
Listen also on Friday night when Johnny presents, it Pays to the Ignorant. Brought to you over these same states. When you buy a poppy, your money goes toward helping men disabled in this war in the last and their families. Buy a population tomorrow and wear it as a glowing tribute to the men who sacrificed so much for you. This is Ken Roberts saying goodnight for Philip Morris. This is cbs, the Columbia Broadcasting System. These programs have come to you from radio yesteryear.
In this classic episode of "Crime Doctor," host Harold takes listeners back to the golden era of radio drama. The story, "Substitute Hero," unfolds around a love triangle, a fraudulent divorce, deception, greed, and ultimately, murder. Dr. Eugene Albertson, his nurse Jean, her husband Bob Mason, and the scheming pseudo-lawyer Archie Moran become entangled in a web of lies and blackmail—culminating in a deadly confrontation unraveled by the incisive mind of Dr. Ordway, the Crime Doctor.
Bob is upset after being let go by Dr. Albertson. He drinks at a bar, vents about Jean staying employed by Albertson after his firing, and threatens dramatic action to get her back.
Bob’s frustration leads to a drunken incident, resulting in his arrest for throwing a brick through Jean’s window when denied entry. (05:00)
Later, Moran arrives to inform Jean and Dr. Albertson that Bob never went to Reno, and their marriage is illegal.
Moran produces proof from the Reno court. The telegrams had been sent by Bob’s friend as part of the ruse. (13:16)
Moran doubles down, hinting Bob may charge Jean with bigamy unless paid off, now desperate for cash. (14:07, 14:18)
A twist emerges when Dr. Albertson claims to have paid Bob $50,000 total ($3,000 initially plus $47,000 extra) to expedite the divorce, a figure Moran claims to be unaware of—revealing collusion and potential double-cross. (14:43)
The bullet that killed Bob entered his back, meaning he could not have been shooting at Moran.
Details about the sequence and position of shots reveal that Moran staged the scene to look like self-defense by firing an extra shot into the wall after killing Bob. (21:26–21:47)
Inspector: “He couldn't have been, Moran, because the bullet that killed him shattered his spine and lodged in his lungs. That means the bullet entered his back. After you killed him, you heard people in the hallway. So you got Bob's gun and fired a shot into the wall.” (21:33–21:47)
| Timestamp | Quote | Speaker | |-----------|-------|---------| | 03:23 | "No, sir. I like it here." | Jean Albertson | | 04:02 | "She lets the boss fire me and she goes right on working for him. She ain't even unhappy about it." | Bob Mason | | 06:15 | "If she could arrange with her husband for him to obtain the divorce in another state... I'd be willing to pay his expenses and... give him a sum of money." | Dr. Eugene Albertson | | 09:13 | "I'm glad to hear it, my dear. Now, I feel free to speak to you. Yes, I've grown very fond of you, Jean. I know I'm much older than you, but I hope you've grown to like me a little." | Dr. Eugene Albertson | | 13:02 | "I learned a very astonishing thing this morning. Your marriage is illegal." | Archie Moran | | 16:20 | "I'm giving it to you straight, Inspector. I shot him in self defense. Man's got a right to shoot in self defense." | Archie Moran | | 21:47 | "He couldn't have been, Moran, because the bullet that killed him shattered his spine and lodged in his lungs. That means the bullet entered his back. After you killed him, you heard people in the hallway. So you got Bob's gun and fired a shot into the wall." | Inspector Jackson | | 22:35 | "Thought if he could get two thieves quarreling among themselves, the truth might come out." | Jean Albertson |
"Substitute Hero" is a classic radio mystery fusing emotion, greed, and justice under the familiar, comforting tones of 1940s radio drama. The episode’s suspense builds around a con gone wrong—where Bob and Archie's plot to swindle Dr. Albertson unravels, leading to murder and a forensically satisfying conclusion by the Crime Doctor.
Listeners are left with classic noir themes: the dangers of greed and manipulation, the sharp instincts of the sleuth, and the comeuppance of wrongdoers. The period’s language, pacing, and performances shine throughout, evoking the social and moral dilemmas of wartime America.