Podcast Summary: Ellery Queen's Minute Mysteries 017 – "Big Mistake"

Podcast: Harold's Old Time Radio
Host: Harold’s Old Time Radio
Episode: Ellery Queen's Minute Mysteries 017 "Big Mistake"
Date: January 27, 2026

Overview

This episode delivers a classic "whodunit" puzzle as part of the famed Ellery Queen's Minute Mysteries series. Listeners are invited to solve a brief, tightly woven mystery using clues provided in the dramatization, evoking the family listening traditions of radio's Golden Age. The story titled “Big Mistake” centers on the suspicious death of a wealthy farmer, with the spotlight on a farmhand whose shaky alibi is unraveled by Ellery Queen’s sharp observation.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Setting the Scene

• Narrator (Ellery Queen) introduces the central mystery: the murder of farmer Mayberry, with the farmhand as the prime suspect due to incriminating physical evidence.
• The farmhand claims innocence, providing an alibi and account of events during a rainstorm.

2. The Farmhand's Story

• The farmhand recounts:

  “It was raining hard and I was bringing in the tools when I saw him in the barn bleeding to death. I ran inside, but he died in my arms.”
  (Ellery Queen quoting the farmhand, 00:44)

• Physical evidence described: the farmhand’s overalls are smeared with “a mixture of dry mud and wet blood.”
• Ellery Queen voices skepticism but maintains suspense:

  “I told him, it's a good story, but you're a murderer just the same. In a moment I'll explain why.”
  (Ellery Queen, 00:54)

3. The Reveal: The "Big Mistake"

• Ellery Queen swiftly delivers the solution:

  “In the case of the Big Mistake, the farmhand said he ran in out of the rain and found his employer dying. Yet the mud on his overalls was dry and the blood wet. If he were telling the truth, the mud would have been wet too.”
  (Ellery Queen, 01:05)

• Listeners are challenged to spot the contradiction: the state of the mud indicated the farmhand hadn’t recently been outside in the rain, weakening his alibi and pointing to his guilt.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “It's a good story, but you're a murderer just the same. In a moment I'll explain why.”

  • Ellery Queen, 00:54
  • Captures the dramatic flair and deductive tone of classic radio mysteries.

• “If he were telling the truth, the mud would have been wet too.”

  • Ellery Queen, 01:08
  • The crucial logical deduction that solves the case, inviting listeners to exercise their own powers of observation.

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 00:32 – Introduction to the “Big Mistake” mystery
• 00:44 – Farmhand’s testimony and physical evidence recap
• 00:54 – Ellery Queen teases the puzzle’s solution
• 01:05 – Ellery Queen explains the key clue and the resolution

Podcast Tone & Style

• The pacing is brisk, with tightly scripted narration and a focus on logical deduction.
• Ellery Queen’s delivery is direct, confident, and subtly engaging, giving listeners the feeling of being “in the room” as clues are pieced together.
• The vintage audio feel and concise structure evoke nostalgia for radio’s heyday while delivering an interactive, cerebral experience.

This episode is an excellent illustration of Ellery Queen’s knack for crafting minute-long mysteries that reward careful listening and critical thinking, perfect for fans of classic detective fiction or those seeking a mental challenge in a quick format.