Epic Casebook [SA] xxxxxx 414: "Too Close A Shave"

Release Date: March 7, 2025
Host: Harold's Old Time Radio
Episode Title: Epic Casebook [SA] xxxxxx 414 Too Close A Shave

Introduction

In this thrilling episode of Harold's Old Time Radio, host Inspector Carr from New Scotland Yard takes listeners on a gripping journey through the murky waters of a murder investigation titled "Too Close A Shave." Set against the backdrop of a gritty East London dock area, the story unfolds in the Wellington Hotel, a seemingly unassuming establishment that becomes the scene of a brutal crime.

The Murder at Wellington Hotel

The episode kicks off with Inspector Carr detailing the harrowing discovery of Ernest Longley, an American sailor, whose lifeless body was found with his head bashed in at room 16 of the Wellington Hotel, located at 164 East India Dock Road.

Inspector Carr [02:30]: "I better not tell you too much about it now. Except to say that I've called my story 'Too Close A Shave'."

Longley had just arrived from the Flying Albatross, a ship that had docked the previous night. Initial reports suggest no immediate witnesses, leaving the case shrouded in mystery.

Initial Investigation and Suspects

Inspector Carr, accompanied by Sergeant Thompson and Constable Jones, begins canvassing the hotel. Their primary suspect emerges as Frank Mills, the hotel manager, who exhibits suspicious behavior and a questionable alibi.

Frank Mills [05:15]: "I didn't do it. I swear it to you."

The interrogation reveals that Mills had little interaction with Longley after his arrival and claims no knowledge of any assailants. However, inconsistencies in Mills' statements and his dubious past make him a person of interest.

Additionally, Captain Ashton, the skipper of the Flying Albatross, becomes entangled in the investigation. His history of robbery with violence and his interactions with both Longley and his first mate, Ernie, add layers of complexity to the case.

Clues and Breakthroughs

As Inspector Carr delves deeper, he uncovers pivotal clues:

1. Shaving Brush and Soap Traces:
   Found at the crime scene, the presence of a shaving brush caked with soap indicates that Longley was preparing for a shave before his untimely death.

   Inspector Carr [12:00]: "There was a shaving brush still caked with soap. He couldn't have bought them himself."

2. Time of Death and Alibi Verification:
   Mills claims not to have seen Longley after midnight, but the timeline suggests otherwise, leading Carr to suspect Mills' movements around the time of the murder.

3. Nancy Topping – The Mysterious Woman:
   Enter Nancy Topping, a blonde and seemingly forthright woman connected to both Mills and Captain Ashton. Her interactions with Longley and her suspicious behavior place her under scrutiny.

   Nancy Topping [16:32]: "As soon as I heard she was in dock, I came over to say hello."

Confrontation and Resolution

The investigation takes a pivotal turn when evidence points towards Nancy Topping. Her involvement with Longley, coupled with the discovery of a stolen wallet and traces of diamond smuggling, solidify her as the primary suspect.

Inspector Carr [25:52]: "What you took from Ernest Lonley."

Nancy is apprehended and confronts her actions, revealing the motive rooted in smuggling diamonds intended for a fence in Hatton Garden. Her jealousy and betrayal upon discovering Longley's deceit lead her to commit the murder.

Inspector Carr [27:15]: "Whilst in his cups he showed Mrs. Nancy a diamond that he was smuggling into the country. It's worth many thousands. She had other ideas. She went round to the hotel that night. Had to be her."

The episode culminates with Nancy's arrest, wrapping up the case with a moral reflection on the perils sailors face when mingling with deceptive acquaintances.

Inspector Carr [28:59]: "The moral of the story? Sailors don't go on the spree with doctors' side ladies. They're inclined to give it too much of a bash."

Notable Quotes

• Inspector Carr:

  "This is too easy to verify. He must have gone out again, then returned later." [07:45]

• Frank Mills:

  "I didn't murder him, honest I did." [19:05]

• Captain Ashton:

  "I wasn't the skipper of the Flying Albatross, I'd pick you up and I'd throw." [18:43]

• Nancy Topping:

  "He gave it to me in the pub." [25:55]

Conclusion

"Too Close A Shave" masterfully blends suspense, character development, and intricate plotting to keep listeners on the edge of their seats. Inspector Carr's meticulous investigation and keen eye for detail ultimately unravel the mystery, showcasing the timeless allure of classic detective storytelling. The episode not only entertains but also offers insightful commentary on human nature and the unforeseen consequences of deceit and betrayal.

As Inspector Carr aptly concludes, the delicate balance between trust and suspicion is pivotal in solving crimes that penetrate the veneer of everyday life.

Thank you for tuning into Harold's Old Time Radio. Stay tuned for more adventures from the Golden Age of Radio.