Incredible but True xx-xx-xx ep12 The Lady and the Lake

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: "Incredible but True – The Lady and the Lake"

Podcast: Harold's Old Time Radio
Host: Harold's Old Time Radio
Episode: 12
Date: October 6, 2025

---

Episode Overview

This episode of "Harold's Old Time Radio" features an installment of "Incredible but True," delving into the mysterious, real-life disappearance of Dorothy Arnold on the streets of early 20th-century New York City. The story is presented in dramatic, radio-theater style, weaving the factual case with supernatural overtones and featuring an enigmatic connection to a swan at Central Park’s lake. The tone is suspenseful, reminiscent of classic radio mysteries from the golden age.

---

Key Discussion Points and Story Breakdown

1. Setting the Stage: The Ordinary Becomes Extraordinary

• The episode challenges the stereotype that mysterious disappearances require exotic settings.
  • Quote [00:00]:

    "Contrary to popular belief and to the conceptions of the writers of horror stories, strange and mysterious events do not require strange and mysterious settings."

• Introduces Dorothy Arnold’s disappearance as "one of the most remarkable incidents"—not from an ominous castle, but the busy streets of New York.

2. The Disappearance of Dorothy Arnold

• Initial Investigation:
  • The chief of the Missing Persons Bureau receives a frantic report on December 13, 1910.
  • Quote [00:38], Mr. Decker:

    "You people have got to help me find her. She's gone. Disappeared. I want you to start looking for her this very minute."

• Timeline of Events:
  • Dorothy is last seen after leaving her guardian’s office; she walks up Fifth Avenue, parts ways at 79th Street, and enters Central Park. She never returns for dinner, and no trace of her is found.
  • Quote [00:57]:

    "She went into the park. She always came home for dinner, but she didn't show up. I waited up for her all night, but there was no sign of her."

• Response:
  • Police move swiftly, publicize the case citywide, and check hospitals and morgues, with no leads.
  • Classic "missing person" tropes: is this a runaway, or is something more sinister at work?

3. Suspicion and Speculation

• The chief suggests absent-mindedly that Dorothy may have run away voluntarily, perhaps prompted by a romantic interest.
  • Quote [01:37], Missing Persons Chief:

    "We haven't found a single clue so far, Mr. Decker, but I wouldn't be too discouraged if I were you. It's been our experience that when girls disappear the way your ward disappears, it's usually because they want to."

• Mr. Decker insists Dorothy was happy, busy planning a social tea, and not disposed to run off.
  • Quote [01:56], Mr. Decker:

    "The only man she cared about, the only man she ever paid the slightest attention to, happens to be in Italy at the moment..."

4. A Bizarre Coincidence: The Swan on the Lake

• The narration abruptly pivots to a strange natural phenomenon:
  • On the very same day and near the exact spot of Dorothy’s disappearance, an unusual swan appears in Central Park.
  • Quote [02:42], Newspaper Report:

    "Scientists were baffled by an unprecedented occurrence in Central Park this morning. There has never been a swan on the park lake before, but one appeared there today... on that portion of the lake which borders the 79th street entrance."

5. Conclusion and The Unexplained

• The episode leaves listeners with this tantalizing link: Dorothy Arnold—missing; a beautiful, mysterious swan—appeared.
  • Quote [03:02], Narrator:

    "No, Dorothy Arnold's disappearance has never been explained, nor has anyone ever been able to explain the presence of the swan on the lake in Central Park. All that can be said is that the two events occurred at the same time and in the same place. This is a fact which leads one to certain inescapable and astonishing conclusions. A fact incredible but true."

---

Memorable Moments and Quotes

• Opening Statement on Mystery ([00:00]):
  "Strange and mysterious events do not require strange and mysterious settings."
• Plea for Help ([00:38]):
  "You people have got to help me find her. She's gone. Disappeared. I want you to start looking for her this very minute."
• Police Perspective ([01:37]):
  "It's been our experience that when girls disappear the way your ward disappears, it's usually because they want to."
• Anomalous Swan ([02:42]):
  "There has never been a swan on the park lake before, but one appeared there today."
• Closing Mystery ([03:02]):
  "All that can be said is that the two events occurred at the same time and in the same place. This is a fact which leads one to certain inescapable and astonishing conclusions."

---

Key Timestamps

• 00:00 – Introduction: Framing of ordinary settings as locations for extraordinary events.
• 00:38 – First report of Dorothy’s disappearance; family’s plea to police.
• 01:05 – Description of police investigation; Dorothy’s last known movements.
• 01:37 – Police suggest possibility of voluntary disappearance.
• 02:42 – Introduction of the strange swan anomaly in Central Park.
• 03:02 – Episode conclusion; mystery remains unresolved.

---

Summary

This atmospheric radio drama episode blurs the line between real mystery and the supernatural, as it recounts the haunting disappearance of Dorothy Arnold on a winter day in New York City, paired with the inexplicable arrival of a singular swan on Central Park Lake. The episode’s suspense lies in its unanswered questions and evocative storytelling—leaving listeners with a story "incredible, but true."

Transcript

[A]

Contrary to popular belief and to the conceptions of the writers of horror stories, strange and mysterious events do not require strange and mysterious settings. One of the most remarkable incidents in all the annals of the incredible took place on the teeming streets of New York City. It was there that the girl named Dorothy Arnold was last seen in human form.

[B]

Missing persons have long been a daily phenomenon in this largest city in the world. Consequently, the chief of the Missing Persons Bureau of New York City looked upon it as a matter of routine when on December 13, 1910, a middle aged man in a state of great agitation came bustling into the room.

[C]

You people have got to help me find her. She's gone. Disappeared. I want you to start looking for her this very minute.

[D]

That might be easier if we knew who she is.

[B]

It's my ward.

[C]

It's Dorothy. Dorothy Arnold.

[D]

How long has she been missing?

[C]

Almost 24 hours. She came to my office yesterday morning.

[B]

When she left, I walked up Fifth.

[C]

Avenue a few blocks with her. We separated at 79th Street.

[D]

Which way did she go?

[C]

She went into the park. She always came home for dinner, but she didn't show up. I waited up for her all night, but there was no sign of her.

[B]

Within a half hour, the elaborate police machinery had gone into motion. In every section of the city. It was known that Dorothy Arnold, age 25ft 5 inches tall, blue eyes, light blonde hair, was missing. The hospitalists were scrutinized. The recent arrivals of the municipal morgues were examined closely. Shadowy figures who were well known to the police were rounded up and questioned. The following morning, the chief of the missing persons department was ready to report to Robert Decker.

[D]

We haven't found a single Clue so far, Mr. Decker, but I wouldn't be too discouraged if I were you. It's been our experience that when girls disappear the way your ward disappears, it's usually because they want to.

[C]

You mean you think Dorothy ran away? She.

[D]

She doubtless had at least one male friend who wouldn't have been averse to the idea, didn't she?

[C]

The only man she cared about, the only man she ever paid the slightest attention to, happens to be in Italy at the moment. When she came to my office, she was planning a tea for some of her former classmates, about 60 of them. It was to be held in my home next Thursday, the 17th. We talked about it all the way up Fifth Avenue and Dorothy was tremendously pleased and excited about the whole thing. When she left me there at the 79th street entrance to the park, she was well and happy. And then something happened.

[D]

To her.

[B]

From that day until this, Dorothy Arnold has never been seen again. All this, one may say, is scarcely remarkable. But the case of Dorothy Arnold becomes remarkable when one considers an item that was printed in the pages of the New York sun on December 13, the day her disappearance was reported.

[E]

Scientists were baffled by an unprecedented occurrence in Central park this morning. There has never been a swan on the park lake before, but one appeared there today. The swan, a full grown and particularly beautiful specimen, was first observed on that portion of the lake which borders the 79th street entrance.

[B]

No, Dorothy Arnold's disappearance has never been explained, nor has anyone ever been able to explain the presence of the swan on the lake in Central Park. All that can be said is that the two events occurred at the same time and in the same place. This is a fact which leads one to certain inescapable and astonishing conclusions. A fact incredible but true.