
Murder at Midnight 46xxxx (002) The Man Who Was Death
Loading summary
Nancy Craig
What do you think makes the perfect snack?
AM PM Spokesperson
Hmm. It's gotta be when I'm really craving it and it's convenient.
Nancy Craig
Could you be more specific?
AM PM Spokesperson
When it's cravinient.
Narrator
Okay.
AM PM Spokesperson
Like a freshly baked cookie made with real butter, available right down the street at a.m. p.m. Or a savory breakfast sandwich I can grab in just a second at a.m. p.m.
Nancy Craig
I'm seeing a pattern here.
AM PM Spokesperson
Well, yeah, we're talking about what I crave.
Nancy Craig
Which is anything from AM PM what.
AM PM Spokesperson
More could you want? Stop by AM PM where the snacks and drinks are perfectly craveable and convenient. That's cravenience. AM PM Too much. Good stuff.
Death
Murder at Midnight.
Harold Jordan
This.
Jan Rolfe
Yes, this is the place for it. Deep down under the city, under the earth. The concrete, cold and damp as the stone of a mausoleum. The question is, which one of them shall it be? You, sir. You with the gray hair and the briefcase. Allow me to introduce myself.
Death
I am Death.
Narrator
Midnight, the witching hour. When the night is darkest, our fears the strongest and our strength at its lowest ebb. Midnight, when the graves gape open and death strikes.
Death
How?
Narrator
You'll learn the answer in just a minute in the man who Was Death. And now, Murder at Midnight. Tales of mystery and terror by masters of the macabre. Our story by Robert Newman is the man who Was Death. It's late afternoon in the studio of Jan Rolfe, the sculptor. The rays of the setting sun come through the smoke filmed glass of the skylight at an angle, casting long dark shadows on the dusty floor. His face intense. Rolf stands before a more than life size head of gray granite, cutting away some of the hard stone, then pausing to examine his work.
Jan Rolfe
It's still not right. I still haven't got it. And I don't know where I've gone wrong. The eyes. They would be brooding and half closed. But shouldn't they be all seeing? Let's try it. Who's that? Who's there?
Nancy Craig
It's Aline, Mr. Hall. Aline Moffat.
Harold Jordan
Aline?
Jan Rolfe
Oh yes, just a second. What is it, Elaine?
Nancy Craig
I told you I wouldn't be able to get here until late, Mr. Rolfe. That I was going to be modeling for Clayton in the early afternoon. But you said it didn't matter.
Jan Rolfe
Oh yes, I forgot.
Nancy Craig
If you don't need me, don't feel like working.
Harold Jordan
No, no. It's.
Jan Rolfe
It's. It's. It's all right. Maybe it would help if I worked on something else for a change. Come on in.
Nancy Craig
Something else? Oh, that. That head.
Jan Rolfe
Is that the first time you've seen it?
Nancy Craig
Yes. You always kept it covered up before. It looks very powerful.
Jan Rolfe
Powerful, eh? Go on over to it. Closer. Tell me who you think it is.
Nancy Craig
All right. It's. Well, it's a man. Pretty big man.
Death
Man.
Jan Rolfe
I knew it wasn't right, but if that's all you get out of it. Where's that mallet?
Nancy Craig
Mr. Rolf, what are you going to do?
Jan Rolfe
This. I'm going to smash it. Almost six months work. But man. You know what that was supposed to be? Death.
Narrator
Yes.
Jan Rolfe
For centuries, man has been haunted and obsessed by the feet of death. I'm going to do something no artist has ever done before. Show mankind the face of death.
Nancy Craig
Mr. Ralph, I don't think I feel like modeling this afternoon.
Jan Rolfe
You're frightened.
Harold Jordan
Why?
Nancy Craig
I don't know the whole idea of you too.
Jan Rolfe
What I wanted to show was the beauty, the peace that lies in death. That strength and inevitability and. Wait a minute.
Nancy Craig
I'll phone you tomorrow. Mr. Rolf.
Jan Rolfe
I said wait. It's beginning to come to me. What was wrong? To do a study portrays something. You've got to understand it inside and out. You've got to know how your subject thinks, feels. Project yourself into it. To do a study of death, I've got to know all those things about him. I've got to become death. And that means.
Nancy Craig
Mr. Rolf. No. No, you can't.
Jan Rolfe
But I can, Elaine.
Harold Jordan
I must.
Jan Rolfe
How can I understand death become death if I don't kill?
Harold Jordan
Ms. Craig?
Nancy Craig
Yes? Nancy Craig?
Harold Jordan
I'm Jordan. Harold Jordan of Homicide. I imagine you know why I asked you to come down here into the morgue.
Nancy Craig
They. They said it had something to do with my roommate. Aline Moffat is.
Harold Jordan
If you think you can take it. We'd like you to make the identification.
Nancy Craig
I think I can.
Harold Jordan
Good girl. She's right here under the sheet. Ready?
Nancy Craig
Yes. Lee. How did it happen?
Harold Jordan
I'll cover her up. Well, we traced the laundry mark. We're pretty sure we knew who she was.
Nancy Craig
How did it happen?
Harold Jordan
She was found in the river, but she was dead before she went in.
Jan Rolfe
Strangled, murdered.
Nancy Craig
But why? By whom?
Harold Jordan
We don't know. We thought you might help us with that, too. Tell us what you know about her.
Nancy Craig
There's not much to tell. She was a wonderful girl. Came from out of town, out west somewhere. She. You wouldn't know it from the way she looks now, but she was beautiful. She used to do modeling.
Harold Jordan
Any boyfriends?
Nancy Craig
Oh, no one in particular. She went out with a lot of different men. Everyone liked her. That's why I can't understand.
Harold Jordan
Who does she model for?
Nancy Craig
A few photographers, but mostly painters and sculptors. Let me see. There was Jensen, Clayton, Rolfe. As a matter of fact, I. I think she was posing for both Clayton and Ralph.
Jan Rolfe
Better this time. Much better. Things I can put into it that I never knew, never felt before. Now, let's see. No. Still not right. Still something missing in not just a shade of expression, but something basic. One of the keys to the whole concept.
Nancy Craig
But what?
Jan Rolfe
Haven't I played death's role? Killed just as he does?
Harold Jordan
Haven't I?
Jan Rolfe
Wait, that's it. Of course. Is that how Death strikes? Without thought, on the spur of the moment?
Harold Jordan
No.
Jan Rolfe
He picks and chooses, Decides just who shall die and who shall not. What's missing is the consciousness of power. The knowledge that there is no appeal from death. That he is the supreme authority. And that means that, yes, I must kill again. And this time.
Harold Jordan
Who.
Jan Rolfe
Who's that?
Harold Jordan
Police department. Can we come in and talk to.
Jan Rolfe
You for a minute?
Harold Jordan
Why.
Jan Rolfe
Why, yes, of course. Just a second. Police. They don't know anything. They can't know, but I better cover this up.
Harold Jordan
Mr. Ralph?
Jan Rolfe
Yes.
Harold Jordan
I'm Jordan of Homicide. This is Nancy Craig. Sorry to bother you at this time of night.
Jan Rolfe
No bother at all. Please come in.
Nancy Craig
Thank you.
Harold Jordan
I'm. I'm investigating the murder of Ms. Craig's roommate, Aline Moffat.
Jan Rolfe
Murder?
Nancy Craig
You didn't know?
Jan Rolfe
Well, I know I never read the papers. The last time I saw her, two or three days ago.
Harold Jordan
Well, it happened just two days ago. Now, we've been checking back. We have an idea that you may have been one of the last people to see her alive.
Jan Rolfe
If there's anything I can do to help, anything at all.
Harold Jordan
Could you tell us what happened when you did see her last?
Jan Rolfe
Of course. She was due here at 3 o', clock, but actually came at about 5. She said another artist had delayed her.
Harold Jordan
Clayton.
Jan Rolfe
That's right. I had already started working on something else. And since she looks so tired, I suggested we call the whole thing off. She seemed pretty happy about it.
Harold Jordan
Left.
Jan Rolfe
And I'm afraid that's all I know.
Nancy Craig
Was there anyone else here? Anyone that actually saw her leave?
Jan Rolfe
I'm afraid not. You see, I'm the only tenant in the building who lives here. And I'm afraid everyone else had gone by then.
Harold Jordan
Well, that sounds pretty straight to me. I guess that's that. Thanks very much, Mr. Rolfe.
Jan Rolfe
Not at all. Afraid I haven't been much help. But if you can think of anything I can do.
Harold Jordan
We'll keep in touch with you. And in the meantime, well, maybe you should start reading the papers just every once in a while, huh?
Jan Rolfe
Right. I hope you read them too, my friend, especially tomorrow's papers. Because I have a feeling that there just might be something in them that will interest you. Night and a fine, small rain. Yes, this is how he would move. Walking slowly through the darkness, searching, weighing, selecting his victim.
Harold Jordan
I beg your pardon, sir, but could you tell me if that's the uptown subway over there? Why.
Jan Rolfe
Why, yes, I believe it is.
Hanrahan
Thank you.
Harold Jordan
Thank you very much.
Jan Rolfe
Not at all. Subway. What better place to make my choice than there, deep under the earth, the concrete, cold and damp as the stone of a mausoleum. Thank you, my friend. Thank you. Yes, this is it. This is the place. The tunnel, dark as a yawning grave. The platform edge like the verge of infinity. And this is how he must feel, studying, selecting. Which one of you shall it be? You, madam, with the worn coat and the draggled hat. Why are you looking at me like that? Do you know what's in my mind? Don't be afraid. It won't be you. You, young man, with the books and the glasses. No. Then what about. Yes, down there at the end of the platform. My friend has suggested this. My prosperous looking friend with the gray hair and the briefcase. Don't look up at the track so impatiently. A train is coming, but so am I. Good evening.
Harold Jordan
I beg your pardon, sir, but I'm afraid.
Hanrahan
Oh, I didn't recognize you at first.
Jan Rolfe
Well, you're the chap directed you down here. Yes, but I felt that you should know exactly who it was you spoke to. Allow me to introduce myself. I am Death.
Harold Jordan
What?
Hanrahan
What do you mean?
Jan Rolfe
What are you doing to me? Let go.
Nancy Craig
Let go.
Harold Jordan
Quietly.
Narrator
The man who is Death steps back from the edge of the platform as the train grinds to a stop. The woman screams. Somewhere in the distance, a clock strikes 12 for murder at mid.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Here we have the Limu emu in its natural habitat, helping people customize their car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual. Fascinating. It's accompanied by his natural ally, Doug.
Jan Rolfe
Limu is that guy with the binoculars watching us.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Cut the camera. They see us.
Only pay for what you need@liberty mutual.com Savings very unwritten by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company affiliates. Excludes Massachusetts.
Narrator
Time is precious. And so are our pets. So time with our pets is extra precious. That's why we started Dutch. Dutch provides 24. 7 access to licensed vets with unlimited virtual visits and follow ups for up to five pets. You can message a vet at Any time and schedule a video visit it the same day. Our vets can even prescribe medication for many ailments. And shipping is always free with Dutch. You'll get more time with your pets and year round peace of mind when it comes to their vet care.
And now back to the story of the man who was death. It's late the next afternoon and Jordan is alone in his bare cubbyhole in police headquarters when there is a knock on the door.
Nancy Craig
Hello, Mr. Jordan.
Harold Jordan
Oh, hello, Nancy.
Nancy Craig
You don't seem very happy to see me.
Harold Jordan
I am and I'm not. It's a nice change to have someone as pretty as you come down here. On the other hand, you haven't gotten.
Nancy Craig
Anywhere with the lean to murder.
Harold Jordan
No. No motive, no clue, no nothing. I'm afraid we're licked.
Nancy Craig
But you can't be. You can't give up.
Harold Jordan
I'm sorry, Nancy. I don't like it either.
Jan Rolfe
But.
Harold Jordan
Well, it happens sometimes.
Nancy Craig
But you can't let it happen. Not in this case.
Harold Jordan
You're pretty well wound up, aren't you? How about letting me take you out by your dad?
Nancy Craig
No. I am upset, yes, but.
Jan Rolfe
What's the matter?
Nancy Craig
Oh, maybe it's nerves. That trip down to the morgue, the whole atmosphere around the case. But would you think I was mad if I told you I. I felt that some horrible power was abroad? That Death himself was stalking through the city?
Harold Jordan
You and Mrs. Dolan.
Nancy Craig
Mrs. Dolan? Who's she?
Harold Jordan
Oh, I had an accident in the subway last night. A guy who fell or jumped in front of a train. Didn't you read about it?
Nancy Craig
No.
Harold Jordan
This Mrs. Dolan was one of the witnesses. And she swears that just before it happened she went all goose pimples. Felt as if death was breathing down the back of her neck and that she was going to die.
Nancy Craig
It's true, Hal. I know it is. I mean, well, that's exactly how I felt. I can't remember just where or when, but sometime during these past few days, I. I felt that I was in the same room with Death myself.
Death
Hmm.
Harold Jordan
Like you said, it's probably nerves, strain you've been under. Just the same, it's kind of a funny coincidence. I think maybe I'll go see Mrs. Dole and talk to her.
Hanrahan
Do you want to come?
Nancy Craig
I don't believe so, Hal. Somehow I feel we're awfully close to the answer. If I could just remember where and when it was I felt that way. That I was in death's presence. I think I'll go home.
Jan Rolfe
Okay.
Harold Jordan
Nancy, I'll call you there after I talk to Mrs. Dolan. And, well, maybe we'll find that we really have something.
Jan Rolfe
Just a little more off the cheekbones. Get the gaunt feeling of a skull under the flesh. No, no, it's still not right. Still something missing. But what is it this time? Didn't I stalk and select my victim? Didn't he recognize me for what I was? Death himself and didn't wait. Of course, it's never just the victim alone who knows fears and fights against death. It's all of society, medicine, science, the police. All of man's resources from time immemorial lined up against death and he still triumphs over them. That is the secret and the measure of his omnipotence. That is the last missing element. And that means that I must kill yet again. And this time not just. But the whole world must know it. And be powerless to stop me this time.
Harold Jordan
Who.
Jan Rolfe
Who's that? Who's there?
Nancy Craig
Nancy Craig. Mr. Ross. I don't know if you remember me, Nancy.
Jan Rolfe
Oh, yes, just a.
Nancy Craig
I'm awfully sorry to be bothering you again.
Jan Rolfe
That's perfectly all right. Isn't Mr. Jordan with you?
Nancy Craig
No, I came alone. Well, there was a little experiment I wanted to try.
Jan Rolfe
Oh, please come in.
Nancy Craig
Thank you.
Jan Rolfe
Just what was this experiment?
Nancy Craig
It. Well, it was probably pretty silly, but I had to try it. Thinking back, I had a queer feeling. What's that?
Jan Rolfe
I bust something. I'm working on something I hope will be my masterpiece. Do you like it?
Nancy Craig
I'm afraid I. No, it's awful. It's terrible. It was here that I felt it here in the studio. And you?
Jan Rolfe
Yes, Nancy, it was I who killed a lean Moffat. And also a gray haired gentleman with a briefcase in the subway last night.
Nancy Craig
At least in the paper, Mrs. Dolan.
Jan Rolfe
Exactly. You see, that bust over there is a study of them. And to do a study you must project yourself inside your subject. That meant I had to become this. Where are you going? No good, Nancy.
Hanrahan
No good.
Jan Rolfe
I locked the door when you came in.
Nancy Craig
Oh, but you can't. You can't.
Death
Help.
Harold Jordan
Help me.
Death
Help.
Narrator
Help.
Jan Rolfe
No good either. We're five stories up and all the other tenants have gone. You came here at a very opportune time for me. I had just decided I needed one final victim. And I'm afraid that's going to be you.
Nancy Craig
I'll Never forget it, Mr. Jordan. It was pretty late, about 12 o'.
Jan Rolfe
Clock.
Nancy Craig
And it was raining. There were only a couple of people on the subway platform 3 or 4. And I was standing by myself, not thinking about anything in particular, when suddenly this. This feeling came over me.
Harold Jordan
Now, what kind of a feeling?
Nancy Craig
Oh, a feeling that this was the end. A feeling that death was standing there right close behind me. I got so weak and shaky that I thought I was going to faint. I shut my eyes and leaned against one of the posts. And that's how it was that I didn't actually see the accident.
Harold Jordan
Well, did you. Did you turn around when you had that funny feeling? Did you notice whether there actually was anyone standing behind you?
Jan Rolfe
I did.
Nancy Craig
There was just a young fellow with glasses and another man. Kind of strange looking, now that I think of it.
Harold Jordan
Strange how?
Nancy Craig
He was about 35 or 40. Pretty big, I guess it was his hair. He wasn't wearing any hat. And, well, he was almost white and very long and bushy.
Harold Jordan
What did he have?
Jan Rolfe
A thin face, gaunt and deep set eyes.
Nancy Craig
Well, yes, I think he did have. Do you know him?
Harold Jordan
I'm not sure if I do. Then I may know a lot of other things too.
Jan Rolfe
Good Lord. Nancy.
Nancy Craig
What?
Harold Jordan
I. I've got to get out of here.
Hanrahan
Just a second, young fellow. Where do you think you're going?
Harold Jordan
In there. No one's going to. Hanrahan.
Hanrahan
Oh, there you are, Jordan. Where the blazes have you been?
Harold Jordan
What do you mean? What's going on?
Hanrahan
A devil of a business. A lunatic in the top floor studio there. He phoned headquarters, asked for you. Said that he had a girl there that he was going to murder. Said that he wanted us to know even though there was nothing we could do to stop him. We thought it was a gag at first.
Harold Jordan
Well, what are you doing about it?
Hanrahan
Everything that can be done. I've got men all around the building, up in the roof, across the street, outside his door.
Harold Jordan
Can't you break down the door?
Hanrahan
Sure, and finish her off quick. He said that if we tried it, he'd bash her brains out with that big hammer that he's working with.
Harold Jordan
But there must be something. A tommy gun from the roof across the street.
Hanrahan
He's got her right in front of him so that if you got him, you'd get her too. I tell you, there's nothing, absolutely nothing anyone can do.
Harold Jordan
You're wrong, Hanrahan.
Jan Rolfe
There's just one person, one thing that can stop him.
Harold Jordan
What's that?
Jan Rolfe
Death. You're getting impatient, my dear.
Nancy Craig
Oh, why are you doing this? You know you can't get away with it, you know.
Jan Rolfe
Get away with it? You think I care that it matters to me whether I live or Die. When I finish this, I'll never be able to surpass this. But neither will anyone else. I know now how death must feel. And I've caught it forever. For all men to see in stone.
Death
Yes, friend Rolf, you have. And you've made me very proud.
Harold Jordan
What?
Jan Rolfe
Who's that?
Death
You don't know? Even though I've been on your mind for months now? Even though you're just finishing my portrait.
Harold Jordan
You.
Jan Rolfe
Where. Where are you?
Death
Where would I be? Everywhere.
Harold Jordan
Outside.
Death
In the hall, down in the street. Here? In the studio with you.
Jan Rolfe
Can. Can you be seen? I. I must see you. I must.
Death
Very well. Walk this way. Over towards the door. A little further. A little further.
Harold Jordan
All right. Here I am. Ralph. Maybe I don't look the way you thought I would.
Jan Rolfe
Jordan.
Harold Jordan
Yes. Now drop that mallet and get your hands out.
Hanrahan
It was you.
Jan Rolfe
And I thought.
Harold Jordan
Get him up. Rolf.
Jan Rolfe
I said okay. If that's the way you want it.
Nancy Craig
Help. Help.
Harold Jordan
It's okay, baby. It's all over now. Have you loose in a minute. Jordan.
Hanrahan
Are you all right? Yes.
Harold Jordan
Break the door down if you want to come in. I'm busy.
Hanrahan
Oh, you got him.
Harold Jordan
But how? I talked to him through the vent pipe from up on the roof. I figured that if he was crazy enough to do all the things he did do, he might be crazy enough to believe death could pay him a visit. When I'd maneuvered him far enough away from Nancy here, I jumped through the skylight.
Nancy Craig
Hell. Hell. Look.
Harold Jordan
Good.
Jan Rolfe
Good Lord.
Hanrahan
What is it?
Harold Jordan
That. That bust he was working on. He said it was a study of death. And in a way, I guess it is. Because it's a self portrait.
Narrator
Two men and a girl staring down at the body of the dead sculptor lying next to his weird masterpiece. But is it possible there is still someone else in the studio? An unseen presence that has been there since the clock first struck 12 for murder at Midnight. Remember to be with us again when death walks through the darkened streets While the clocks strike 12 for murder at Midnight. The part of Jan Rolfe was played by Frank Behrens with music by Charles Pollard. Murder at Midnight was directed by Anton M. Leader.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
And Doug.
Here we have the Limu Emu in its natural habitat, helping people customize their car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual. Fascinating. It's accompanied by his natural ally, Doug.
Jan Rolfe
Uh, Limu is that guy with the binoculars watching us.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Cut the camera. They see us.
Only pay for what you need@libertymutual.com Liberty.
Jan Rolfe
Liberty. Liberty.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Liberty Savings Vary underwritten by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company and affiliates excludes Massachusetts.
Narrator
Time is precious and so are our pets. So time with our pets is extra precious. That's why we started Dutch. Dutch provides 247 access to licensed vets with unlimited virtual visits and follow ups for up to five pets. You can message a vet at any time and schedule a video visit the same day. Our vets can even prescribe medication for many ailments and shipping is always free. With Dutch, you'll get more time with your pets and year round peace of mind when it comes to their vet care.
Episode: Murder at Midnight – “The Man Who Was Death”
Date: October 19, 2025
Host: Harold's Old Time Radio
Original Airdate of Drama: 1940s (Murder at Midnight series)
This episode features the classic suspense radio drama Murder at Midnight, presenting “The Man Who Was Death.” Through macabre atmosphere and psychological intrigue, the story dives into an artist’s obsession with truly understanding, embodying, and ultimately becoming Death itself. The plot unravels as sculptor Jan Rolfe spirals from artistic obsession into murder, with police and potential victims scrambling to comprehend and survive his descent.
“Midnight, the witching hour. When the night is darkest, our fears the strongest, and our strength at its lowest ebb...when the graves gape open and death strikes.”
— Narrator (01:14)
“Man! You know what that was supposed to be? Death.”
— Jan Rolfe (04:06)
“How can I understand death, become death, if I don’t kill?”
— Jan Rolfe (05:09)
“This is the place. The tunnel, dark as a yawning grave...Which one of you shall it be?”
— Jan Rolfe (10:34–10:44)
“Allow me to introduce myself. I am Death.”
— Jan Rolfe (12:07)
"I felt that some horrible power was abroad. That Death himself was stalking through the city."
— Nancy Craig (14:45)
“Mrs. Dolan swears that just before it happened, she went all goose pimples...felt as if Death was breathing down the back of her neck.”
— Harold Jordan (15:04)
“Yes, Nancy, it was I who killed Aline Moffat. And also a gray-haired gentleman with a briefcase in the subway last night.”
— Jan Rolfe (18:03)
“I had just decided I needed one final victim. And I’m afraid that’s going to be you.”
— Jan Rolfe (18:29)
“I figured that if he was crazy enough to do all the things he did, he might be crazy enough to believe Death could pay him a visit.”
— Harold Jordan (23:10–23:14)
“That bust he was working on...he said it was a study of death. And in a way, I guess it is. Because it’s a self-portrait.”
— Harold Jordan (23:32–23:49)
“The Man Who Was Death” combines macabre thematic elements with psychological drama, focusing on the chilling consequences of a man’s obsession with personifying the ultimate force—Death. The episode’s script, moody score, and taut performances convey both a crime thriller and a meditation on mortality's allure and terror, all culminating in a final twist where art and identity become lethal.