Podcast Summary: "Murder By Experts 49-07-18 006 The Creeper"

Introduction

In the August 15, 2025 release of Harold's Old Time Radio, listeners are transported back to the Golden Age of Radio with the gripping episode titled "Murder By Experts 49-07-18 006 The Creeper." Hosted by John Dixon Carr, a renowned mystery novelist, this episode delves into a suspense-filled narrative selected by guest expert Lawrence Blockman. The story, originally penned by Joseph Roscoe, unravels the chilling tale of a serial killer known as The Creeper, who targets redheaded women in New York City's Heights neighborhood.

Setting the Scene

The drama opens in the quiet pre-dawn hours of a sprawling metropolis. John Dixon Carr sets the atmosphere:

"[02:38] John Dixon Carr: ... It's the hour before dawn, that moment when the huge sprawling metropolis lies deep in slumber..."

We are introduced to Virginia Peters, a young and attractive waitress in her early 20s. Her apartment on the third floor is brightly lit, contrasting with the deserted streets below. As Virginia converses on the telephone, a sense of unease begins to build.

The Encounter with The Creeper

Virginia recounts a disturbing encounter with a man she describes as the "Gary Cooper type," who attempts to engage her at her workplace. The tension escalates when he ominously mentions trying to get into her apartment:

"[04:27] Virginia Peters: ... I'm scared. There's nothing to worry about. He'll go away when he finds his key."

Despite her reassurances, the situation spirals as the man successfully opens her door, leading to a confrontation where fear overtakes Virginia:

"[04:38] Virginia Peters: No. Stay away from me. I'm Vicki. What's wrong? Jenny?"

The Investigation Begins

The narrative shifts to Steve Grant, Virginia's husband, and Pearly Chase, a fellow investigator. They discuss the unsettling pattern of The Creeper's modus operandi—targeting redheaded women whose door locks have been tampered with prior to their murders. Pearly proposes a psychological profile of the killer, emphasizing the need to "play along crazy" to outthink The Creeper:

"[10:27] Pearly Chase: ... Play along, crazy Steve. Make out you're the Creeper. What's your compulsion? Go ahead."

This strategy leads them to deduce that the next victim would reside in apartment 4D, where Virginia Peters lives.

Confrontation and Revelation

As Virginia grapples with her fear, she interacts with Pearly Chase, who poses as a concerned neighbor. Their dialogue is fraught with tension and suspicion, revealing Pearly's true intentions:

"[19:03] Pearly Chase: Alias Pearly Valentine. Don't worry. You haven't a thing to be upset about now."

The climax unfolds when Pearly Chase confronts Virginia in her apartment, revealing himself as The Creeper. In a dramatic turn, Virginia's realization leads to the ultimate confrontation:

"[20:08] Pearly Chase: ... I could kill you when you deserve it. With the radio on, you could scream and no one would hear."

Resolution

The episode concludes with a swift resolution as The Creeper is apprehended. The final twist reveals that the locksmith, believed to be a potential suspect, was indeed the murderer. This ironic ending underscores the complexity of The Creeper's character and the cunning nature of his crimes.

"[27:22] Steve Grant: ... The Creeper was shot running from the building. ... the locksmith was the killer."

Conclusion

"Murder By Experts 49-07-18 006 The Creeper" masterfully captures the essence of classic radio dramas, blending suspense, psychological intrigue, and a compelling narrative. John Dixon Carr skillfully narrates the story, enriched by memorable quotes and dynamic character interactions, such as:

"[06:44] John Dixon Carr: Kiss."

And the haunting plea:

"[27:06] Pearly Chase: ... Hurry. Catch me before I kill more. For heaven's sake."

Upcoming Episodes

The episode wraps up with an announcement of future stories, promising listeners continued thrills:

"[28:38] John Dixon Carr: ... Next week at this time, Murder by Experts brings you a story in which three persons make a bet with death."

Final Thoughts

For aficionados of classic radio mysteries and newcomers alike, this episode offers a rich and engaging experience. It skillfully combines intricate plotting, character development, and atmospheric storytelling, making "The Creeper" a standout installment in the Murder By Experts series.