
Under Arrest 1948-06-06 (024) The Case of the Accidental Murders
Loading summary
Joe DeSantis
Mutual Presents under arrest.
Ernie Ballou
Into your cell.
Joe DeSantis
Criminals behind bars under arrest. The story of Police Captain Jim Scott's.
Ernie Ballou
Fight against CR5 high test.
Hank Lowry
Right. You better cut your motor.
Al
Forget it.
Hank Lowry
I said you're.
Ernie Ballou
And he said forget it. Five high test. Now step.
Hank Lowry
All right.
Ernie Ballou
How does it look?
Captain Jim Scott
Okay.
Al
Any? Nobody around.
Ernie Ballou
Good out here. The usual.
Hank Lowry
Check the gas and oil?
Ernie Ballou
No. All I want is some cigarettes.
Hank Lowry
Machines inside.
Ernie Ballou
Which way?
Hank Lowry
Just follow me.
Ernie Ballou
Alone?
Al
Right with you.
Hank Lowry
Machines over there. That'll be a dollar 35 for the gas.
Ernie Ballou
Break a 20.
Hank Lowry
I think I can take a plant by the door.
Ernie Ballou
Al.
Captain Jim Scott
Yeah?
Hank Lowry
Who won today? You know. No. Myers is batting pretty good this year. I heard he.
Ernie Ballou
All right, keep your hands where they are.
Hank Lowry
Oh.
Ernie Ballou
Now move away from the register. Go on.
Hank Lowry
This stick up.
Ernie Ballou
Use your eyes. Okay, Al.
Al
Okay.
Ernie Ballou
Nice hall. Must be over 300 here.
Hank Lowry
367.
Ernie Ballou
Thanks. Hey, what are you looking at, fella?
Hank Lowry
You told me to use my eyes.
Ernie Ballou
I didn't tell you to stare.
Al
Lay off the money. He didn't do nothing.
Captain Jim Scott
Quiet.
Ernie Ballou
Still staring, huh?
Hank Lowry
Look, you got your money. Now why don't you get out of here?
Ernie Ballou
I don't like people staring at me.
Al
Come on.
Ernie Ballou
Come on.
Al
Ernie.
Ernie Ballou
Yeah. We got what we came for. So long, fella.
Hank Lowry
So long, Ernie, for sake.
Al
Come on.
Ernie Ballou
All right, all right, I'm coming. The guy was staring at me.
Al
You didn't have to do that, Ernie. You might have killed him.
Ernie Ballou
Maybe I did. Wait a minute.
Al
Hey, what are you doing?
Ernie Ballou
Getting cigarettes. That's what I come in here for, wasn't it?
Al
You gone crazy? Come on, let's get out of here.
Ernie Ballou
Now we got time. Plenty of time. Anybody comes for gas, you take care of Mal. This lousy machine don't work. How do you like that? The guy put me onto a bum machine. I lost 20 cents.
Captain Jim Scott
Captain Scott, that reporter, Susan Webb. She's out here, Captain. I'll see you, Mike. Sergeant Lowry getting yet? No, sir. I want to see him as soon as he arrives. Right. Scott. Harry, what about those tire marks? Get anything on it? Yeah, yeah, he's in the hospital. Not so good. All right, when you do, let me know.
Susan Webb
Hello, Jim.
Captain Jim Scott
Listen, sue, what's all this stuff in the papers? You call that fair reporting?
Susan Webb
What did you call me up for? Falling out.
Captain Jim Scott
You're sure taking the department over the ropes. All the papers have thought at least you'd lay off.
Susan Webb
I've got a job to do.
Captain Jim Scott
So have I. If you think it's easy, think again.
Susan Webb
I didn't say it was easy. But after all, Jim, There've been four of those gas station hold ups within the past two weeks.
Captain Jim Scott
Now, don't you think I'll do my job?
Al
You stick to yours and mine's reporting.
Captain Jim Scott
You mean smearing. You people smear the department every chance you get.
Susan Webb
Oh, Jim.
Captain Jim Scott
Now listen, sue, we're doing our best. You can't ask any more than that, can you? Well, I've got my best man on this job. Hank Lowry. Called him in from a fishing trip with his kid. You know Hank. Is he a slacker?
Susan Webb
Of course not.
Captain Jim Scott
But picking up a couple of heist artists isn't like picking a rose off a bush. You gotta find them first. Takes time. And these two guys are smart. Real smart. They must be smart and vicious the way they beat that attendant up.
Susan Webb
How is he?
Captain Jim Scott
Not good. They don't know where they live. We'll get him. You can put that in your next story.
Susan Webb
Jim, I know you're doing your best. I'm sorry about that column in the paper this morning, but I only write for the boss.
Captain Jim Scott
Okay, Sue. I just couldn't help getting sore.
Susan Webb
Forget it. Come here and let me straighten your tie. I know you're working hard, but you don't have to look unkempt. There.
Captain Jim Scott
Thanks, honey.
Hank Lowry
Want me, Captain?
Captain Jim Scott
Come in, Hank.
Hank Lowry
Sue, welcome.
Captain Jim Scott
Look, Hank, I'm sorry about having to bust up that fishing trip you were on with Jack.
Hank Lowry
Oh, forget it.
Captain Jim Scott
I know your kid was looking forward to it.
Hank Lowry
Jack will understand. Now don't worry, will you?
Captain Jim Scott
Okay. Thanks. Now sit down. They've got to get a new angle on this. Stick up.
Hank Lowry
It's a homicide now.
Susan Webb
The gas station attendant?
Hank Lowry
Yeah?
Ernie Ballou
Hospital just phoned in.
Hank Lowry
He died a few minutes ago.
Ernie Ballou
Who is it?
Al
Al.
Ernie Ballou
Get the paper.
Al
Yeah. Oh, wait a minute.
Ernie Ballou
Leave the radio alone.
Al
But I. I gotta talk.
Ernie Ballou
You can talk with the radio on. That's good music. Don't you ever listen to good music? What's up?
Al
He's dead, Auntie.
Ernie Ballou
Let me see that rag.
Al
I told you not to hit him like that.
Ernie Ballou
Try it. Says Harry died in the hospital. Wonder if he talked.
Al
Sure he talked. They got a description of the car and everything. Listen, Annie, we gotta get.
Ernie Ballou
They said shut up. Want some more of the same?
Al
No, no.
Ernie Ballou
Let me read this thing in peace, will ya? That punk told him not to stare. What are you staring at?
Al
Nothing, Annie, nothing.
Ernie Ballou
Say something. What's the matter? You lost your tongue?
Al
We better blow this town, Annie.
Ernie Ballou
Not yet. We're not finished here yet.
Al
We can't pull another job here.
Ernie Ballou
We'll talk about it later. Right now I want to get some sleep.
Al
Sleep, for Pete's sake. We gotta get.
Ernie Ballou
Don't get scared, Al. Whatever you do, don't get scared. That's the fastest way to get the cops on your tail.
Al
I. I'm not scared.
Ernie Ballou
Up on the couch. Get some rest. Just listen to that music. Real restful.
Captain Jim Scott
You question the attendant yourself, Hank?
Hank Lowry
His description of the two guys was pretty vague. One big, one short, wiry. That's about all. I was showing him some pictures when he died.
Captain Jim Scott
What about the car?
Hank Lowry
1940 Chevy, blue. One Defender smashed up.
Captain Jim Scott
At least we got that.
Hank Lowry
If they try another job with that car, I think we've got him.
Captain Jim Scott
How many men have you got at the service stations?
Hank Lowry
11 service stations in the district. They've been working. 11 cops working the pumps.
Captain Jim Scott
Lucky number.
Hank Lowry
I'm number 11. I report for work at the Arrow service Station tonight at 8.
Captain Jim Scott
I don't think they'll try again tonight.
Hank Lowry
Maybe not. We'll be waiting for them if it takes weeks.
Captain Jim Scott
We better nab him before that or I'll be pounding a beat again. The commissioner's hot.
Hank Lowry
Don't worry about the commissioner. He always liked you. He knows you're trying.
Captain Jim Scott
Yeah, but he's under pressure too. No matter how high you get in this business, there always seems to be somebody higher who wants to tell you.
Hank Lowry
How to do your job and any business.
Captain Jim Scott
Maybe. But this case is getting old, Hank. They've got a point.
Hank Lowry
So if you get kicked downstairs, I'll be right behind you.
Captain Jim Scott
Thanks, Hank.
Hank Lowry
Well, I better shove off. It's almost 8. If I'm late, the boss will be sore.
Ernie Ballou
See you later, Jim.
Captain Jim Scott
I may call you out there tonight.
Hank Lowry
Right.
Ernie Ballou
What's the matter, Al? You scared?
Al
It's not that any. I'm not scared, but I don't think it's smart, that's all. We can't try another job tonight.
Ernie Ballou
Why not?
Al
It's too soon. We gotta lay low for a while.
Ernie Ballou
Just what the cops expect us to do. So we won't.
Al
Are you crazy?
Ernie Ballou
No, smart. See, Al, we got the coppers running now. We want to keep him running, confuse him.
Al
Listen, honey, you can't do that.
Ernie Ballou
You want out of.
Captain Jim Scott
No.
Al
Any. No.
Ernie Ballou
Anytime you do say so, I'll give you out.
Al
Well, I don't want out. Ernie, don't get sore.
Ernie Ballou
Okay.
Al
But what about the car? They got the car spotted.
Ernie Ballou
Oh, we get another one, that Costo.
Al
And we can't sell the Chevy because.
Ernie Ballou
We left one off the street. That don't cost anything.
Al
You know how to Start a car without the key?
Ernie Ballou
Sure, it's easy.
Al
You got a gas station picked out?
Ernie Ballou
Uh huh. Arrow Service Station. Cased it last week. A pushover. Only one man on at night. Arrow Service Station, corner of Grant and Broome. Remember that?
Hank Lowry
Our service station.
Ernie Ballou
Jim.
Captain Jim Scott
Hank. Anything stirring?
Hank Lowry
Pretty slow. Three customers so far. Two regulars, one high. Test fixed, one flat.
Captain Jim Scott
No sign of the Chevy?
Hank Lowry
Nope. Oh, here's. Here's another customer now. Jim, I'll call you back. That's it. That's not a Chevy. Not 1940. It's 48 Buick. Bright red and too classy for a couple of high smugs.
Captain Jim Scott
Don't take any chances.
Hank Lowry
Call you back in a few minutes.
Captain Jim Scott
Right.
Ernie Ballou
Help you? Yeah. Think we got a low tire in the back. Will you check it?
Hank Lowry
Sure. This one?
Ernie Ballou
Yeah, that's it.
Hank Lowry
You're all right. You got 30 in here.
Ernie Ballou
Now just keep them hands where they are. Wouldn't want to part your hair with a bullet. Keep on the tire. That's it. I'll take care to register.
Al
Right.
Hank Lowry
I expected you guys in a 1940 Chevy.
Ernie Ballou
That was dumb.
Hank Lowry
I suppose it was.
Ernie Ballou
Don't move those hands. You're a cop, aren't you?
Hank Lowry
With a yen from mechanics.
Ernie Ballou
Watch those hands.
Hank Lowry
You want the valve cap back on, don't you?
Ernie Ballou
Okay, but don't do anything dumb. Get away from that valve.
Hank Lowry
Try riding a flat, punk. You know, it's kind of bumpy.
Al
Eddie. Eddie.
Ernie Ballou
What? Are you getting the car? I got to screw this thing in.
Al
What you do it for, Andy? Did you have to shoot?
Ernie Ballou
Try to unscrew the valve core now. Come on, we got to get out of here.
Captain Jim Scott
Hurry up with those pictures, Casey. Snap it up.
Ernie Ballou
Jim. Jim.
Captain Jim Scott
Over here, Sue.
Susan Webb
Oh, Jim. Is it Hank?
Captain Jim Scott
Yes.
Susan Webb
Does Jack know?
Captain Jim Scott
Not yet. Johnson. Get a call out on a red Buick 1948. That's all I've got, but we'll try. Should be two guys in it.
Susan Webb
How do you know about the car, Jim?
Captain Jim Scott
I spoke to Hank on the phone just before it happened. He never expected it tonight, Sue. I guess I didn't expect it either.
Susan Webb
What about Jack? Who's going to tell him?
Captain Jim Scott
That's up to me.
Susan Webb
If you need any help.
Captain Jim Scott
Thanks, Sue. I hope he doesn't go bitter.
Susan Webb
You sound pretty bitter yourself, Jim.
Captain Jim Scott
Hank was my best friend. This whole thing brings back memories.
Susan Webb
Your father went like this, didn't he?
Captain Jim Scott
Yeah, when I was in college. That's why I didn't stick it out left and joined the force full of hate like Jack. It'll be. That's what we'll have to watch out for Sue. The hate and the bitterness.
Ernie Ballou
Watch those corners, Al. What are you trying to do, kill us?
Al
I, I'm a little nervous. Any. I, I, I didn't.
Ernie Ballou
You're making a nervous wreck out of me. Pull up any place along here.
Al
Pull up.
Ernie Ballou
But I told you what I said. You see, Al, a bright red car is the wrong one to use for a getaway. You'd stop to think for a minute, you might see that. We'll ditch it. Now pull up.
Susan Webb
Hello, Jack.
Captain Jim Scott
Sit down, fella.
Jack Grimes
Did you get those two guys yet?
Captain Jim Scott
No, we.
Jack Grimes
Why not? What are you waiting for?
Captain Jim Scott
We'll get him, Jack.
Jack Grimes
And what are you gonna do to them when you get them?
Captain Jim Scott
What we usually do. Lock them up, have the district attorney present, the grand jury.
Jack Grimes
I know, I know all that. But what are you gonna do to them when you get them down here? Aren't you gonna beat them up?
Captain Jim Scott
No. Why should we?
Jack Grimes
Because they killed my dad, that's why. Because they killed your best friend?
Captain Jim Scott
Sure. Sure. But why beat him up? What good would it do?
Jack Grimes
Plenty.
Susan Webb
Is that what you want to do, Jack?
Jack Grimes
That's what they deserve, isn't it?
Captain Jim Scott
But the police don't work that way, Jack.
Jack Grimes
And when I get on the force and I get hold of two guys.
Captain Jim Scott
What do you mean, Jack? When you get on the force, how do you know you'll get on?
Jack Grimes
When I'm old enough, I will. And I'll get even for dad, too. You can bet on that.
Susan Webb
Jack, do you think it's right to feel that way?
Captain Jim Scott
Bitter and I think I know how Jack feels. Sue felt the same way myself once. Jack. Jack, did I ever tell you how my dad was shot down on the street one night, just like Hank? He was on the force, too.
Jack Grimes
I didn't know that, Captain.
Captain Jim Scott
I was a little older than you, but it didn't make any difference. You know what I said to myself when I heard about my dad, Jack? I said, jim, this is it. This is where you leave school for good. This is where you finally join the force so you can even up the score for dad. Even it up good.
Susan Webb
Is that the way you feel, Jack?
Jack Grimes
I don't know, Mr. Webb.
Captain Jim Scott
Sure, that's the way he feels. The only way he could feel and still call himself a man.
Jack Grimes
Thanks, Captain Scott.
Captain Jim Scott
But do you think it's right, Jack? Do you think I was right to join the force because I wanted to even up to my dad?
Susan Webb
Do you?
Jack Grimes
I. I don't know.
Captain Jim Scott
Oh, come on now. We're alike. You And I, we both got the same rotten break in life. We're in the same boat together. We can talk man to man, right?
Jack Grimes
Sure can.
Captain Jim Scott
Okay. So do you think it's right to want to shoot down every cheap crook and grift to every con man and dip in the business just because your dad ran into a murderous slug one night?
Jack Grimes
Sure, it's right. Sure it's right. Because you got to even up the score for dad, like you said.
Captain Jim Scott
I said I felt that way at first. And later I found out I was all wrong. You see, Jack, that's not a cop's job to even up. The cop's job is to protect the public. To protect life and property and see that everybody gets an even break. Even some criminals.
Jack Grimes
I hate criminals. I hate all criminals. They killed my dad, didn't they?
Captain Jim Scott
Sure, one of them did. 1. But does that give you the right just because you've got a uniform on to run around and shoot every Tom, Dick and Harry you see with his hand in another guy's pocket? Does it?
Jack Grimes
I don't know, Captain, I.
Captain Jim Scott
Sure, you gotta hate some criminals. That's good. But a lot of criminals you've gotta treat differently. For some, crime is a disease. Maybe they were brought up in an unclean neighborhood, or maybe they caught it from one of the other kids on the block. Then there's the guy who steals food from the grocery store because his wife and kid haven't eaten for a week and he wants to protect them. Sure, he's going about it the wrong way, but would you want to shoot him down on the spot and then tell his wife and kid you did it because you thought he was a dangerous criminal? Or would you?
Jack Grimes
I guess not.
Captain Jim Scott
See what I'm getting at, Jack? A policeman's job is a responsible one. You've got to go at it with the right attitude, not full of hate. Hate's a dangerous thing when we use it too much in the wrong places. Okay, I think you got the picture now. You still want to be a cop?
Jack Grimes
Sure, Captain Scott. And I'm going to try to think about it your way.
Captain Jim Scott
Good. We'll talk about it more later on. Right now, I've got work to do, Jack.
Jack Grimes
So long, Captain. Thanks.
Susan Webb
Wait a minute, Jack. I'll walk home with you.
Captain Jim Scott
Okay. I'll wait outside.
Susan Webb
Well, mind if I kiss you?
Captain Jim Scott
Certainly not. But go easy on the lipstick boys. Kid me about it.
Ernie Ballou
So he was a cop. So what do you want me to do, sit down and cry?
Al
But a cop killing Ernie. You know what that Means they'll get the whole force on us now.
Ernie Ballou
Scared?
Al
No, no.
Captain Jim Scott
Smart.
Al
Smart like you're supposed to be. What are you gonna do, just sit here and wait till they. They come and take you?
Ernie Ballou
Why not?
Al
I tell you, Ernie, sometimes I think you ain't got.
Ernie Ballou
All right, all right. Not that dumb. Start packing, Al.
Al
You're talking, honey. Now you're talking smart.
Ernie Ballou
Sure. I always told you I was smart, Al. When you got a blow, you got a blow. Let's blow.
Susan Webb
So you found the car?
Captain Jim Scott
Yeah, parked on Gedney Street. Motor's still running. Doesn't help us much. Stolen? We could only trace it back to the owner. He's all right. Of course.
Susan Webb
What about Prince?
Captain Jim Scott
Are you kidding? Those boys are smart. Sue wiped it clean before they left it. Dashboard, wheel, door handles, every place they touched it.
Susan Webb
Why was the motor still running?
Captain Jim Scott
Oh, they lifted it. Without a key.
Susan Webb
Well, I guess that's a blind alley. Yeah, or is it?
Captain Jim Scott
What do you mean?
Susan Webb
How does a guy steal a car without the ignition key?
Captain Jim Scott
Hey, that may be it, honey. They have to fool around with the wiring under the hood or the distributor head or something. The engine was still running when they ditched the heap.
Susan Webb
Which means there still may be some prints under the hood.
Captain Jim Scott
Right. Hello, Harry. Scott, get me Richardson, quick.
Al
Hey, Ernie, I can't close this bag.
Ernie Ballou
You got too much in it, SAP. What do you need this for? Think it might get cold.
Al
Hey, listen, that overcoat cost me 200 bucks.
Ernie Ballou
Oh, we're going to Florida. You won't need it. Look, Ernie, I don't argue all the time arguing. Now, hurry up. Let's get out of here. Sometime this week, huh?
Al
That music's driving me nuts.
Ernie Ballou
Ah, you got no culture. That's what's wrong with you. No culture.
Susan Webb
Anything come up on those prints, Jim?
Captain Jim Scott
Plenty. All over the distributor head, on the block, on the dash cable. We're checking for the files now.
Susan Webb
Only one set.
Captain Jim Scott
That's all, Scott. Yeah, go ahead. Ernie Ballou. Okay, Matt, Get a general out for him. Right. Ernie Ballou. Know him from way back. Now all we got to do is to find them. Easy on a soda, Skippy. That's it. Hey, you seen Ernie Balloo around lately? I hear he's off the wagon again. Bank for 14. Peewee Andy Ballou. Used to play a great game. He been in today. Blonde guy. Looks good in that. I hear Ernie Ballou owns a piece of him. Hey, where is Ernie these days? Hello, Mike. Captain Scott. I have located Ernie Balloo. Yeah, I'm going up to take him right now.
Al
Well, just about set, Ernie.
Ernie Ballou
Okay. Might as well take off.
Al
I still say we ought to take that overcoat. It cost me 200.
Ernie Ballou
Forget about that lousy coat. All you do is wait.
Al
Honey.
Ernie Ballou
Open it. Go ahead. I'm ready.
Captain Jim Scott
Ernie Ballou here.
Al
Well, I. I think.
Captain Jim Scott
Hello, Ernie.
Ernie Ballou
Come in, Scotty boy.
Captain Jim Scott
Thanks.
Ernie Ballou
Just keep your hands away from your hip, that's all.
Captain Jim Scott
You sure it's loaded, Ernie?
Ernie Ballou
Uh huh. Aren't you?
Al
Listen, Ernie, don't go into quiet, will you?
Ernie Ballou
What do you want, copper?
Captain Jim Scott
You, Ernie. The murder of Joe Carson, gas station attendant, and Hank Lowry, sergeant of police. Light enough?
Ernie Ballou
You don't want much, do you?
Captain Jim Scott
I'm greedy.
Ernie Ballou
You alone, Scotty?
Captain Jim Scott
Maybe.
Ernie Ballou
Move over to the right by the wall. Go on.
Captain Jim Scott
Sure, honey.
Ernie Ballou
Take a look out the window, Al. Well, I guess you're not alone, copper.
Captain Jim Scott
I'm not that dumb to come up here without phoning headquarters first.
Al
Ernie. The whole block, it's full of cops crying.
Ernie Ballou
Quiet. I can hear.
Captain Jim Scott
I guess you won't shoot me now, Ernie. You're a dead weight and you know it.
Ernie Ballou
Yeah, yeah, but I'm saving you, Scotty. You might come in handy. Making a getaway.
Captain Jim Scott
You figure to use me as a shield on the way out?
Ernie Ballou
Uh huh. It is gone, Al. Go on.
Al
Sure, Ernie, sure.
Captain Jim Scott
Watch it, Al. Don't come too close. I'm liable to turn you into a shield.
Al
Listen, Ernie.
Ernie Ballou
Get his rod, I said. Now move.
Captain Jim Scott
Okay, Let go. Let go.
Al
My arm.
Captain Jim Scott
Shut up, punk. Okay, Ernie. You shoot me, you got to shoot through Al here.
Ernie Ballou
You think that'll stop me?
Captain Jim Scott
Cover him. Sorry, Ernie, but I guess it had to be this way.
Al
I sighed. I side, Copper. He got my son.
Captain Jim Scott
He'll be all right. Take it easy.
Al
It hurts, I tell you.
Captain Jim Scott
I need a. Don't try, I said. We'll get you fixed up.
Susan Webb
Hello.
Captain Jim Scott
Wrap it up, honey. It's all over.
Susan Webb
You all right, Jim?
Captain Jim Scott
Yeah, fine. Baloo's dead. His pal's got a flesh wound.
Susan Webb
Jim, are you sure you're all right?
Captain Jim Scott
Let us start pounding that typewriter, honey. Whether you realize it or not, this is an exclusive from me to you. I think you're swell. Remember it was the prints on the distributor head that did it. Sue, those crooks made a mistake. They always make one. At least one. Always.
Joe DeSantis
Under arrest.
Ernie Ballou
Into your town. All prisoners present and accounted for.
Joe DeSantis
You've just heard. Under ARREST Presented by Mutual A new series featuring Joe DeSantis as Police Captain Jim Scott. Under Arrest is produced and directed by Wynn Wright. Written by William K. Wells Jr. Original music composed and played by Milton Kay. Susan Webb was played by Margaret Draper. Hank Lowry by Jim Bowles. His son Jack. Jack Grimes Ballou by Mort Lawrence. Zito by Rock Rogers. All names of persons used in Under Arrest are fictitious. Any resemblance to names of actual persons, living or dead, is coincidental. Russ Dunbar speaking. This is the world's largest network, the Mutual Broadcasting System.
Podcast: Harold's Old Time Radio
Episode: Under Arrest 1948-06-06 (024) The Case of the Accidental Murders
Release Date: February 20, 2025
In this thrilling installment of Harold's Old Time Radio, titled "Under Arrest", listeners are transported back to the Golden Age of Radio, immersing themselves in a gripping narrative of crime, justice, and personal vendettas. Set in 1948, the episode unravels the intricate case of accidental murders intertwined with the relentless pursuit of truth by Police Captain Jim Scott.
The episode opens with a tense gas station hold-up orchestrated by Ernie Ballou and Al, which tragically escalates, resulting in the accidental deaths of Joe Carson, the gas station attendant, and Sergeant Hank Lowry of the police force. As the community reels from the shocking events, Captain Jim Scott takes the helm of the investigation, determined to bring the culprits to justice.
The narrative kicks off with Ernie and Al attempting a routine hold-up at a gas station:
Their plan goes awry when tensions rise, leading to the accidental shooting of Hank Lowry:
Captain Jim Scott collaborates with Sergeant Lowry to trace the culprits, despite media pressure from Susan Webb:
Their investigation reveals the sophistication of the criminals:
Jack Grimes, whose father was killed by the same criminals, expresses his desire for vengeance:
In a poignant conversation, Captain Scott imparts wisdom on duty over personal revenge:
The tension culminates in a dramatic showdown between Captain Scott and Ernie Ballou, resulting in fatal consequences:
Ernie Ballou on Police Tactics: "Use your eyes. Okay, Al."
(01:58)
Captain Scott on Media Relations: "You're sure taking the department over the ropes. All the papers have thought at least you'd lay off."
(04:03)
Jack Grimes Expressing Vengeance: "When I'm old enough, I will. And I'll get even for dad, too."
(15:29)
Captain Scott's Philosophy on Policing: "A policeman's job is a responsible one. You've got to go at it with the right attitude, not full of hate."
(17:34)
Confrontation Tension:
Captain Jim Scott: "You think that'll stop me?"
(26:08)
Ernie Ballou: "You think that'll stop me?"
(26:08)
Duty vs. Vengeance: The episode delves deep into the moral complexities faced by law enforcement officers. Captain Jim Scott embodies the principle of duty over personal vendetta, contrasting sharply with Jack Grimes' desire for retribution. This dynamic underscores the ethical dilemmas inherent in policing.
Media Influence: Susan Webb represents the probing nature of the press, challenging the authorities and highlighting the tension between maintaining public image and uncovering the truth.
Consequences of Crime: The accidental murders serve as a stark reminder of the unintended consequences that can arise from criminal activities, emphasizing the fragility of life and the ripple effects of violence within a community.
"Under Arrest: The Case of the Accidental Murders" masterfully captures the essence of the Golden Age of Radio, weaving a tale rich with suspense, moral questioning, and character depth. Through its engaging dialogue and intricate plot, the episode not only entertains but also provokes introspection on themes of justice, revenge, and duty. Captain Jim Scott stands as a beacon of integrity, navigating the murky waters of crime and personal loss with unwavering resolve.
For fans of classic radio dramas, this episode offers a compelling blend of action and narrative depth, ensuring that listeners remain captivated from start to finish.
End of Summary.