
Witch's Tale (AU) 43-xx-xx (28) The Power of Lucifer
Loading summary
Narrator
Do you know what happens when you replace your regular old electric water heater with a new electric heat pump water heater? You boost your savings a lot. In fact, Energy Star estimates that a family of four will save an average of $550 a year on their electric energy bills. And your new heat pump water heater can pay for itself in as little as three years. Level up with a heat pump water heater. Go to levelupmywaterheater.com to learn more.
Warren
The Witch's Tale.
Ivan Orloff
The fascination of the eerie, weird, blood.
Warren
Chilling tales told by old Nancy, the witch of Salem and Satan, her wise black cat.
Ivan Orloff
They are waiting, waiting for you now.
Satan
106 year old, I believe today. Yes, sir. A hundred and six year old. Well, Satan, give word to doubt all rights and we'll get right down to business. That's right. Make it nice. And dark and cheerful are we like snowman shadow. Now roar up to the fire and gaze into the embers. Gaze in form deep and soon you'll see a crowded ballroom in a fine big house in New York City. And there, amidst happiness and laughter, begins our tale about the power of Lucifer, the power of Ro.
Catherine Warren
The next dance will be a wall stair. Sure you want to sit it out?
Warren
Yes, Katherine. I stepped on enough defenseless female toes this evening. And as I have to buy your shoes, I'll be economical as well as merciful. This definitely seems deserted.
Doctor Farmer
Let's go up there and gaze at the moon.
Warren
Now, here's an especially nice chair for moon gazing. Big enough for both of us.
Catherine Warren
Not unless I sit in your lap.
Warren
That's all right. I have a good, strong lap.
Ivan Orloff
Now give me a kiss.
Mrs. Brewster
Warren, don't mark my hair. Don't you ever get tired of making.
Catherine Warren
Love to your wife?
Ivan Orloff
No.
Warren
My wife ever gets tired of having me make love to her?
Catherine Warren
No.
Warren
No occasion for argument. Give me another kiss.
Mrs. Brewster
That's enough.
Catherine Warren
And I'm going to sit in this other chair before you crush my gown.
Mrs. Brewster
And I press the crease out of.
Warren
Your trousers all evening.
Satan
You've forsaken me.
Warren
And now you're doing it again.
Satan
I am.
Catherine Warren
And unless you curb your romantic ardor, I'll make you take me back in there and dance.
Doctor Farmer
I'll be good.
Warren
It's too nice to be out here with you and away from all those people.
Catherine Warren
You don't like the crowded here, do you?
Warren
Oh, they're all right, I suppose. But I don't understand them. I'm just a plain businessman. Hindu poets, Armenian artists and Turkish musicians are way over my head.
Catherine Warren
Since Mrs. Brewster decided to patronize the art. She certainly had some very strange people in her affairs.
Satan
Strange?
Warren
They seem lunatics to me. Fortunately, old Dr. Farmer's wife had deserted him, as you did me. So he and I sneak off in a corner and discuss politics, Wall street and baseball. That plebeian brand of conversation soon drove away any nut who came near us. What particular sort of culture does the chap go in for? Who's been monopolizing you all evening?
Catherine Warren
Mr. Orloff.
Ivan Orloff
That's his name.
Warren
I didn't catch it when we were introduced. Russian, isn't he?
Catherine Warren
I imagine so, though he didn't mention his nationality.
Warren
What did he do for a living?
Catherine Warren
I don't know.
Warren
I spent enough time with him to have learned his whole life's history.
Catherine Warren
You weren't jealous?
Ivan Orloff
Of course not.
Warren
I merely ask about him because, well, he's such a peculiar looking chap. And I'm curious to know what there is about him that held your interest for so long.
Catherine Warren
I don't know that either. He's a very strange person. He's talked a steady stream from the moment I met him, yet I know nothing about him at all.
Warren
What does he talk about?
Catherine Warren
Well, a subject that I've only heard of in a vaguer sort of way before. Devil worship.
Warren
Devil worship?
Catherine Warren
Yes. Not medieval witchcraft or anything like that, but something that exists. Cult of Lucifer, he called it.
Doctor Farmer
Cult of Lucifer?
Catherine Warren
It's a religious sect, he said, that has churches, ordained priests and a ceremonial.
Warren
And he said this cult of Lucifer is active now?
Catherine Warren
Yes, all over the world. Right here in New York. He talks so much about it. I've an idea he himself remembers I. Warren. There's something horrible about that man. Five minutes after I met him, he was absolutely repulsive to me.
Warren
Yet you danced with him all evening.
Catherine Warren
I don't know why. After the first dance, I wanted to get away. Yet when he asked me for another. I'd have been with him yet if you hadn't come for me. I made up my mind not to say anything about all this. It sounds so silly. Oh, I'm glad I've told you. I want you to stay with me for the rest of the evening. Don't leave me for a moment. And if Mr. Orlove asked me to dance with him again, you made some excuse. Don't let me.
Warren
Catherine, are you intimating that you can't refuse this man yourself?
Satan
Yes.
Warren
Don't ask me why.
Catherine Warren
I don't know. I'm afraid of that man Warren. Terribly afraid.
Warren
Oh, There they are.
Doctor Farmer
Mrs. Brewster.
Mrs. Brewster
My dear Catherine. We've been looking everywhere for you and Warren.
Warren
Oh, just sitting out of dance, Mrs. Brewster. Won't you join us?
Catherine Warren
Yes, he's with them.
Warren
Don't worry, darling. The honest Oloff won't bother you now.
Ivan Orloff
You and your husband have been enjoying the moonlight, Mrs. Grace.
Mrs. Brewster
Yes, Mr. Orloff. How gorgeously romantic. They're always running away from people so they can be by themselves, Mr. Olaf, as though they were sweethearts instead of husband and wife. In these two young people you see.
Ivan Orloff
The perfect marriage in most unusual things to see. Perfect things are there.
Doctor Farmer
I say they are.
Warren
But you played me a mean trick.
Doctor Farmer
When you disappeared with Catherine Warren, a Swedish poetist. Got me in the corner and nearly talked my arm off.
Warren
I tell you, My dear, that Dr. Farmer and I had organized a mutual protective association of two against artists.
Mrs. Brewster
Oh, you and the doctor are incurably bourgeoisy.
Doctor Farmer
Afraid we are, Mrs. Brewster. Your guests of this evening are too high brow for plain people such as Warren and myself. By that I mean no offense to you, mister.
Ivan Orloff
None is taken. I like you and plain people. It's not what you call high brow.
Mrs. Brewster
You're far too modest, Mr. Olog. You and Warren must become better acquainted with this gentleman, doctor. He's been everywhere, seen everything and oh, he's told me of the most interesting things. Catherine, my dear, did he tell you of that perfectly intriguing sect he called the cult of Lucifer?
Catherine Warren
Yes, Mr. Olof told me a great deal about it.
Doctor Farmer
What is the cult of Lucifer?
Ivan Orloff
Seems to be a group, or rather many groups of people who believe that evil is a more potent factor in this world than good. Consequently, they worship the Lord of evil and serve him not by what orthodox religionists call worthy acts, but by bringing sorrow and trouble wherever they can.
Mrs. Brewster
Did you ever hear of anything so perfectly fascinating?
Doctor Farmer
There are idiots in this world who go in for anything because of Lucifer.
Ivan Orloff
Is not composed of idiot stuffer. You may have heard it said that the devil takes care of his own. He endows his most ardent disciples with great power. So I am told. All rot. Perhaps. Of course, I am only speaking your sense.
Mrs. Brewster
Oh, naturally. It's delightfully interesting to think about. But one wouldn't wish to be acquainted with people who believe such things personally, would one?
Warren
I don't think so, Mrs. Bruce.
Catherine Warren
No.
Warren
Darn well, I wouldn't.
Mrs. Brewster
Now I simply must return to my other guests. You'll excuse me, won't you?
Doctor Farmer
By all means.
Mrs. Brewster
You four lovely people mustn't stay out here too long, don't we?
Warren
Well, no one Gets me back in.
Doctor Farmer
There while I'm in my right senses.
Ivan Orloff
May I hope that Mr. Craig will return to the ballroom very soon as my partner for the next dance corps.
Catherine Warren
I. I. Shall we go now?
Ivan Orloff
The music has begun.
Catherine Warren
Yes.
Warren
Catherine.
Ivan Orloff
I. I have your permission? Of course. Mr. B. Yes, thank you. I am Mrs. Green. We shall join you gentlemen later.
Doctor Farmer
What's the matter with you? You look as though someone had hit you over the head.
Warren
But Doctor.
Satan
What?
Warren
That man made me say yes when I wanted to say no. He walked away with Catherine when I wanted to stop him and she didn't want to go.
Doctor Farmer
What are you talking about?
Warren
By the Lord. He isn't going to get away with it. Warren. Where are you going? Ola. Ola.
Catherine Warren
Come back here.
Ivan Orloff
Ola. Are you calling me?
Catherine Warren
Yes.
Warren
Come back here with my wife.
Doctor Farmer
You're making a scene. What's the matter with you?
Warren
You will soon find out and so will he.
Ivan Orloff
Why have you called me? Mr. Gray?
Warren
You know well enough. But step out here on this balcony and I'll tell you. Let go of his arm. Catherine. Come here to me. Come here to me.
Ivan Orloff
I go to your husband?
Warren
Yes. What kind of a game are you playing? She couldn't even take her hand from your arm until you let her. When she told me you'd made her dance with you all evening against her will, I. I didn't know what to think. But now I do. Because you just worked the same hypnotic trick on me. I don't like to be tricked, Mr. Or. And I don't want hypnotists experimenting on my wife. She's not dancing with you anymore. That's all.
Ivan Orloff
Not quite all. Your tone has been both loud and insulting. Dr. Palmer has been a witness and others have been attracted by your words. It is your privilege to say I cannot dance with your wife. But I expect an apology.
Warren
You won't get it all.
Ivan Orloff
It may be in my power to compel it.
Warren
Not from me.
Ivan Orloff
You will apologize to Mr. Gray before Mortimer.
Satan
People.
Warren
I. I apologize to you, Mr. Olof.
Ivan Orloff
I thank you. But now that you have made it, I choose not to accept your apology. Mr. Ray. You will feel that IOF is a most vindictive man. Go.
Doctor Farmer
What in heaven's name is the meaning of all this? What's happened to you again? You look stunned. Like a man who has received a blow.
Warren
Doc. He did it to me a second time. Beat down my will as he did before.
Catherine Warren
It doesn't matter, dear. He's gone now. Let's get up in to leave here. We never met him before tonight. And we won't see him anymore.
Doctor Farmer
I'm not so sure of that. I didn't like the look of that fellow when he left.
Catherine Warren
He can't do us any harm, doctor. He. He can't.
Satan
Can't.
Warren
Darling, what's the matter?
Catherine Warren
I feel I catch her.
Doctor Farmer
Warren.
Ivan Orloff
She's falling.
Warren
Catherine, darling. What's wrong with you? Doctor, she's fainted.
Doctor Farmer
Carry her to that bench. Lay her down.
Warren
But what could have caused it?
Doctor Farmer
I don't know.
Warren
Catherine. Catherine, darling. She's so white and still. She's scarcely breathing. Doctor, what's the reason for this? She hasn't been sick.
Ivan Orloff
I know that.
Doctor Farmer
I'm her doctor. Someone telephone for the ambulance. Hurry.
Warren
An ambulance, doc?
Catherine Warren
Yes.
Warren
You don't think I'd better get her.
Doctor Farmer
To a hospital if I hope to save her life?
Ivan Orloff
Her life?
Satan
Yes.
Doctor Farmer
Her pulse is very weak. Her heart is beating and no more.
Warren
She can't die, doc. You won't let her die and talk to biker.
Catherine Warren
Help it.
Doctor Farmer
Hold on to yourself, my boy.
Warren
Catherine.
Catherine Warren
Catherine.
Doctor Farmer
I can't understand it. I examined her only last week. Her heart was red as a clock.
Warren
What's the reason.
Satan
Doctor?
Warren
Her lips are moving. She's trying to say something. What is it, dear? Oh, she hasn't even the strength to speak to me. What's the reason? What's the reason you still.
Doctor Farmer
Please, she is trying to say something. Catherine. What is it, dear?
Warren
I couldn't hear her, doc. What did she say?
Doctor Farmer
It was just a whisper. I think she said the power of Lucifer.
Warren
Isn't she any better, doctor?
Doctor Farmer
Just the same, my boy.
Warren
That's all. You've told me for three days that she's just the same. And she lies on this bed, never moving, scarcely breathing, dying. Oh, isn't there anything you can do to save her?
Doctor Farmer
I've done everything, tried everything. I know I'm at my wits end, boy. The specialist I brought in can't diagnose this condition and any better than I can. Nor recommend the treatment. We doctors know so little.
Warren
Then you haven't any hope she's going to die?
Doctor Farmer
No, I haven't given up hope. But doctors are only men. Where we fail, often something else steps in and saves God. He gives and he takes away, son. Everything in this universe is really up to him.
Warren
And he's forgotten her and me. Don't you think? I've prayed to him? Every moment since he collapsed that night a prayer has been on my lips or crying in my heart. A prayer of desperation. A cry of my whole being. For if I lose her, I have nothing in the world. He's forgotten me. He doesn't care.
Doctor Farmer
I don't think you or I or any other human being can say that. For we don't know his schemes, my boy. I'm not just trying to deaden your anxiety and heartbreak with a sugar coated anodyn of religion. I haven't any creed. I'm just talking what I sincerely believe. Catherine has been unconscious for three days. She hasn't suffered for a single moment of that time or felt the slightest pain. If she doesn't come out of this, I don't say she won't. I don't believe she won't. And I'll do all a human being can to bring her back to you. But if I can't, she'll simply pass from a light sleep into a deep one. She'll have been spared a lot of trouble that living holds for everyone. God will have been very kind to her, my boy. And you won't have lost Catherine. For there's another place where those who love are reunited.
Warren
Maybe three days ago I thought that believe was sure of it. Now I've lost all faith in the sort of providence that's true. My wife. Without a warning, Warren. I've lost all faith. I tell you, if there is a force for good, there's an evil force that counteracts it. An evil force that's the strongest.
Doctor Farmer
You don't know what you're saying.
Warren
Oh yes I do, Doctor. What did Catherine's whisper mean that night when she murmured the power of Lucifer?
Doctor Farmer
I don't know. Probably something about Olaf's filthy cult had lingered in her mind. Or it may have been in my mind so that I read her whisper as I did. I couldn't really swear. Her lips formed words she murmured too low to hear.
Warren
No, she said what you thought she did.
Ivan Orloff
All right.
Warren
She said the power of Lucifer. They were the last words she uttered. They were a message to me. A message I hadn't understood until now.
Doctor Farmer
What do you mean?
Warren
That devil all asked everything to her. Effie proved that he could bend our minds. Now he's proved his hellish power in her body.
Satan
You're a man.
Warren
No, I'm not. You haven't any explanation for whatever struck her down. Without cause, without a warning. I have.
Ivan Orloff
At last. Orloff threatened me.
Warren
He said the devil took care of his own. That he gave great power to his disciples. To him that power is killing my wife. The power of Lucifer, the God of evil. Who is stronger than the Lord of Good.
Doctor Farmer
You are beside yourself, my boy.
Ivan Orloff
You.
Doctor Farmer
You can't believe such a thing.
Warren
I do believe it. And if Catherine dies, then I know it, my boy. Catherine just moaned. The first sound she's made. Out of my way, Warren.
Satan
Let me see.
Warren
What's that rattling noise I hear? It's coming from the throat, Doctor. She looks different. She's lying so still.
Satan
There.
Warren
There's not the slightest movement. Her eyes are open, staring. Doctor, why are you pulling that sheet over her face, Doctor?
Ivan Orloff
Katherine.
Warren
Katherine.
Doctor Farmer
Son.
Ivan Orloff
Son.
Mrs. Brewster
Katherine, my darling.
Doctor Farmer
Don't lose face, my boy. You'll find her again if you don't lose your face. Who is it? Oh, I. I shan't need you now.
Mrs. Brewster
I've got an important message, doctor.
Catherine Warren
It's for Mr.
Satan
Grim.
Warren
Mr. Orlop. Orlop. What is the message?
Catherine Warren
Simply this slip of paper. His address, sir.
Warren
But he said it was a matter.
Catherine Warren
Of life and death. Oh, doctor. Mrs. Gregg.
Ivan Orloff
Yes, just now. His address. A matter of life and death.
Warren
Perhaps he meant he could have saved her, but this came too late. The gunfather of me thought.
Ivan Orloff
She's dead, boy.
Doctor Farmer
What do you must think yourself?
Ivan Orloff
He killed her.
Warren
He killed her. But this tells me where to find him, Warren. This tells me where to find him. Where to take his life for hers. Come back. Stop him, someone.
Catherine Warren
He's mad, Doctor.
Warren
All the power of Lucifer won't save him. His life for hers. His life for hers.
Ivan Orloff
Come in, gentlemen. We expected as a hive, Master. It was exactly 11 minutes past midnight when you let him in the downstairs door. I told you it would be. The master knows all things. Mr. Gregg has a pistol in his pocket, Headmaster. With his hand inside the pocket and his fingers on the trigger. Already I can see the outline through the clock. I see through these walls. I saw him by the gun four miles away. He means to shoot me the moment he and I are alone in this room. Show him in at once, Alexei, and leave us yet. Fools. Fools. The gentleman. Come in, Mr. Gray, please. Go, Alexei, and shut the door behind you. Yes.
Warren
You murderer.
Ivan Orloff
Wait. Before you press the trigger of the people, let me ask you one question.
Warren
No, you.
Ivan Orloff
It is a question. I summoned you to hear the question of life or death. Do you want your wife restored to you?
Warren
My. My wife?
Ivan Orloff
Do you want your wife restored to life?
Warren
You know she's dead. That proves you killed her. I do not deny it.
Ivan Orloff
I told you once that Ivan Orloff was a most vindictive man.
Warren
You fiend. Now you will pay your life for hers.
Ivan Orloff
Wait. First, answer my question. Do you want your Wife restored to life. No.
Warren
You are playing with.
Ivan Orloff
A man does not play when another holds a loaded pistol as he prays.
Catherine Warren
And?
Ivan Orloff
And I am very afraid of firearms.
Doctor Farmer
Really?
Ivan Orloff
Keep your pistol, Mr. Gregg. Keep it pointed at my body if you will. But you had better hear what I have to say before you shoot. Ayes, sir. You relax a little. That is better. I left a note telling you where to find my humble residence. As your dear wife breathed her last.
Warren
Wife?
Ivan Orloff
I left it because Ivan Olaf is also a forgiving man. When his vengeance is complete, the power of Lucifer can give as well as take. The power of Lucifer, which in that hospital room this evening, you'll realize was greater than the power of Fool. I am a priest of Lucifer. This is the power that I wield. To doubt, perhaps. That I can bring your wife to life as I have made her die. Take this piece of paper. Tear it up. Tear it up. Hold the pieces in your open hands. I have not touched them. I do not touch them. Yet.
Satan
Look.
Warren
Join together as they were before you took order.
Ivan Orloff
So I can restore the broken fragments of your dear one's life.
Warren
Give her back to me. I'll be your slave.
Ivan Orloff
I do not need a slave. But the master I adore needs loyal servants.
Warren
What do you mean?
Ivan Orloff
That the devil takes care of his own. But only his own. That he gives nothing for nothing. You must pay a price. That you must serve him. If you would have means of you to.
Warren
To regain Catherine. I must.
Ivan Orloff
You must be consecrated in my master's service. Tonight and forevermore. You must bow down and worship Lucife. You are very pale, my brother. For we are brothers now. By the virtue of the faith we share. You did not enjoy your consecration in our order.
Warren
It was horrible.
Ivan Orloff
Bestial.
Warren
Unholy.
Ivan Orloff
Holy and unholy are words we do not employ. The thing is either evil or uneval. For there are power lines.
Warren
If evil gives you power to bring back the warmth of life, that cold body on the bed. I accept your awful faith. To have her back, to have her love again. Is worth the eternal damnation of my soul. If I have a soul.
Ivan Orloff
You must not doubt the existence of your soul, my brother. Or to accept the creed of evil. A creed of good must also be believed. One cannot exist without the other. Our deity. Stronger, as you shall soon see. Or he will bring the dead to life.
Warren
How soon? How soon?
Ivan Orloff
In less than a minute, blood will course again. In those now so lifeless veins. Breath will return. And those closed eyes will open of themselves. In less than a minute, the dead will rise at War.
Warren
Oh, Catherine, it'll be worth my soul to have your love again.
Satan
Ah.
Ivan Orloff
You have not forfeited your soul. Souls are not my master's business.
Warren
You said if he restored her, I must pay a price.
Ivan Orloff
Of course. He gives nothing for nothing.
Warren
What will that price be? I do not know.
Ivan Orloff
I do not even know the price that I must someday pay for power. But I do not care. Power is all that matters, and I shall live many years to wield it, for I control the minds of men and nothing can destroy me.
Warren
Or off colours returning to her cheeks.
Doctor Farmer
By the power of Lucifer, she breathed.
Warren
You kept your promise. You're restoring her to life.
Ivan Orloff
Not I, but he, my sir.
Warren
Her flesh grows warm. She's coming back to me now, like you. I don't care what price I have to pay. I'll have Catherine once more nigh.
Ivan Orloff
Catherine.
Warren
All right. She's open. Her eyes Speak to me, darling. Let me hear your voice again. You look as though you didn't know me. I'm Warren, dear, your husband. Catherine. Why do you laugh like that? Why are you laughing like a. Like a baby? Olaf. Her eyes.
Ivan Orloff
What about them?
Warren
They're mink. Scary. Her body lives, but her eyes are dead.
Ivan Orloff
So they are.
Doctor Farmer
I forgot to tell you that though.
Ivan Orloff
My master can restore the dead to life, he cannot restore the brain.
Warren
You mean the Catherine?
Ivan Orloff
She is an imbecile, my brother. As I have said, the lord of evil has no province over souls. And without the soul, there can be no mind. Of course. But rest easy now. You have nothing more to fear. You have paid the devil's price.
Warren
You monster. You fiend. Drop that gun.
Ivan Orloff
Oh, you fool. I told you I had mastery of all created men. When I let you keep that gun this afternoon. I only played with you for amusement. I am a priest of Lucifer. With the power he has given me, I shall live forever. Catherine, he has picked up the gun you dropped. Take it from her and return it to your pocket. It pleases me to have you keep it. And no, you cannot use it.
Warren
Imbecile.
Ivan Orloff
Do not point that gun at me.
Catherine Warren
Cost her.
Warren
Please drop it. She has no mind. Or not. Your pearl is before her and her fingers on the trigger.
Catherine Warren
No. No.
Warren
Now, Olaf, you, like me, have failed your master's price. Only you bought power. Something evil had to sell. I tried to purchase love.
Satan
Well, that's the end of that. Satan. Now you and me have business to attend to. Botan business. Satan. Near midnight. Satan.
Podcast: Harold’s Old Time Radio
Host: Harold’s Old Time Radio
Episode Date: October 30, 2025
In this episode, "The Power of Lucifer," listeners are treated to a chilling tale from the classic radio horror anthology "The Witch's Tale." Set at a glamorous New York City ballroom, the story explores the terrifying influence of a mysterious stranger, Ivan Orloff, whose dark connections to devil worship and the cult of Lucifer threaten a young couple's happiness, sanity, and even their souls. Through encounters blending social intrigue, supernatural menace, and philosophical musings on good and evil, the episode delivers classic golden age radio suspense and gothic horror.
Timestamps: 01:24 - 04:45
"Five minutes after I met him, he was absolutely repulsive to me... After the first dance, I wanted to get away. Yet when he asked me for another... I made up my mind not to say anything about all this. It sounds so silly. Oh, I'm glad I've told you." (05:23, Catherine)
Timestamps: 04:45 - 08:27
Orloff's Doctrine: He chillingly explains the philosophy of the Cult of Lucifer:
"Seems to be a group, or rather many groups of people who believe that evil is a more potent factor in this world than good. Consequently, they worship the Lord of evil and serve him... by bringing sorrow and trouble wherever they can." (07:29, Orloff)
Social discomfort: Guests are both fascinated and alarmed by Orloff’s beliefs.
Timestamps: 08:33 - 13:20
Orloff’s Influence: Warren and Catherine discover that Orloff can manipulate their will, compelling actions against their desires.
Confrontation: Warren challenges Orloff, who demonstrates dominion over both minds, compelling Warren to apologize against his will.
"That man made me say yes when I wanted to say no... He did it to me a second time. Beat down my will as he did before." (09:13, Warren)
Catherine's Collapse: Suddenly, Catherine collapses, mysteriously struck down with no physical cause.
"Her pulse is very weak. Her heart is beating and no more." (12:15, Dr. Farmer)
Her Last Words:
"It was just a whisper. I think she said the power of Lucifer." (13:02, Dr. Farmer)
Timestamps: 13:20 - 16:42
Three Days of Despair: Warren is consumed by grief as Catherine lies in a coma, her condition undiagnosable.
Crisis of Faith: Warren debates with Dr. Farmer about the existence of good and evil.
"If there is a force for good, there's an evil force that counteracts it. An evil force that's the strongest." (15:20, Warren)
Fear and Supernatural Attribution: Warren becomes convinced Catherine is a victim of Orloff’s supernatural vengeance.
Timestamps: 17:06 - 23:02
Catherine’s Death: The moment of Catherine’s death is marked by chilling silence and despair.
A Tempting Message: Orloff sends Warren his address with a cryptic note, offering hope of reversing death.
Confrontation: Warren, armed with a pistol, confronts Orloff, who offers to return Catherine to life—for a price.
"Do you want your wife restored to life?... The power of Lucifer can give as well as take... But you must pay a price." (19:46, Orloff)
Deal With The Devil:
"To regain Catherine, I must...? You must be consecrated in my master's service. Tonight and forevermore. You must bow down and worship Lucife." (22:01, Orloff)
Timestamps: 23:02 - 26:43
Catherine Restored... Incomplete: Catherine is revived but left as a mindless shell.
"She is an imbecile, my brother. As I have said, the lord of evil has no province over souls. And without the soul, there can be no mind." (25:13, Orloff)
The Price: Warren receives his wife’s living body, but without memory, intellect, or affection—just haunting laughter.
"Her body lives, but her eyes are dead." (24:57, Warren)
Despair and Irony:
"I tried to purchase love... you bought power. Something evil had to sell." (26:13, Warren)
Ivan Orloff describing the cult:
"Evil is a more potent factor in this world than good... they worship the Lord of evil and serve him by bringing sorrow and trouble wherever they can." (07:29, Orloff)
Warren’s crisis of faith:
"If there is a force for good, there's an evil force... An evil force that's the strongest." (15:20, Warren)
Dr. Farmer’s compassionate realism:
"Doctors are only men. Where we fail, often something else steps in and saves God... Everything in this universe is really up to him." (13:47, Dr. Farmer)
The Deal:
"You must be consecrated in my master's service. Tonight and forevermore. You must bow down and worship Lucife." (22:04, Orloff)
The Price Revealed:
"She is an imbecile, my brother. As I have said, the lord of evil has no province over souls. And without the soul, there can be no mind." (25:13, Orloff)
The episode retains the melodramatic, atmospheric tone of golden age radio horror. Dialogue is earnest, sometimes florid, and laced with classic themes of supernatural temptation, marital devotion, good vs. evil, and the existential terror of powers beyond human understanding.
This episode is a stand-alone gothic horror narrative, ideal for fans of dramatic, supernatural radio plays. It offers a glimpse into the fears and moral anxieties of its era, staged with sinister suspense and haunting consequences.
Listener’s takeaway:
Be careful what you wish for, especially when the price may be your soul—or far worse.