Heart Starts Pounding: Horrors, Hauntings and Mysteries
Episode 2: Haunted House Tales From Listeners
Host: Kaylin Moore
Release Date: November 10, 2022
Overview
In this chilling episode of Heart Starts Pounding, host Kaylin Moore invites listeners into the haunted corners of everyday lives with two real-life haunted house stories submitted by listeners. The episode explores the mysteries that linger in old homes, the blurred line between supernatural encounters and psychological hauntings, and how family history and tragedy can shape—or perhaps attract—the unexplained. The stories take listeners from rural Illinois to Staten Island, unearthing everything from comforting voices in a vent to vengeful ghosts said to have followed someone home from a cemetery.
Key Discussion Points and Insights
1. Introduction: Can Walls Talk? (02:19)
- Kaylin sets the tone with existential questions about memory, spaces, and haunting:
“Can walls talk? And if they could, what would they say? … Nothing likes to die. Not even a room.”
- The theme is the thin veil between the living and the dead within the places we call home.
2. First Listener Story: The Man in the Vent
Speaker: Taylor
Segment Begins: 04:12
Kaylin introduces Taylor's story: A childhood in a small Illinois town, an uncle who took his own life in her grandparents’ old farmhouse, and a mysterious, comforting voice from the upstairs vent.
Story Highlights
- Taylor’s uncle, a troubled military vet, dies by suicide in the grandparents’ house (04:16).
- Taylor describes the old farmhouse, focusing on its unique upstairs-downstairs vent (06:56).
- As a small child, Taylor had long conversations with a man’s voice coming from the vent. The voice resembled her dad’s or uncle’s—low, comforting, raspy:
“[He] would just, like, ask me about my day... ask me what I looked like... what my favorite color was... He would talk about how he was really big into computers, and he's really happy that I was really big into computers.” (08:25)
- Their conversations go on for years, until Taylor starts asking more pointed questions about the man's identity. The conversations grow less frequent and eventually stop.
- Years later, Taylor and her family come to believe the voice was her late Uncle Jim trying to reach out:
“Do you think maybe all that was like... Uncle Jim? And [my dad] was like, ‘Yeah, most definitely. Like, he loved you to pieces. It wouldn't surprise me if he was like your guardian angel...’” (13:39)
Reflective Insights
- Kaylin poses a chilling question:
“Was there ever any part of you that thought maybe a stranger was in your home talking to you through the vent?” (14:01)
- Taylor confirms the impossibility: the vent was a straight hole, visible end to end, making a physical intruder extremely unlikely.
3. Second Listener Story: The Ghost from the Cemetery
Speaker: Taylor
Segment Begins: 15:12
Taylor relates a series of haunted happenings centering on her brother, who returned from Staten Island’s Moravian Cemetery believing something followed him home.
Story Highlights
- Taylor’s brother, Michael, confessed to disrespecting a grave during teenage mischief, after which supernatural events began:
“Either they hid behind someone's grave, or... put their joints out on somebody's grave... Whatever he did, he remembers disrespecting somebody in particular. That is when things started for him.” (15:12)
- Michael experienced shaking beds, knocks, and other disturbances. Initially, the family laughed off his claims—until Taylor and her friend both spotted a tall shadowy figure in the hallway:
“I looked up and I saw a figure... it was very clearly about 6 foot. It was just a shadow, but it was removed from the wall... That’s where it was.” (16:03)
- Michael believed a girl ghost haunted the upstairs, tormenting him at night by crawling in bed, pulling the covers over his face, and scaring the dog.
- Taylor describes one harrowing encounter:
"He came in my room and told me that he woke up because he felt someone lay down next to him and cuddle up behind him on his back. It felt like long hair... then the covers pulled up over his face and behind his head, freaking him out." (19:39)
The Ghost Responds—a Recording
- After Michael’s most frightening experience, Taylor challenged the ghost aloud in his room. When she awoke, she found a 3-second video on her phone, capturing a woman’s eerie voice whispering “just shut up.” (21:37)
- Kaylin plays this disturbing audio for listeners.
Family Trauma & the Persistence of Haunting
- Michael struggled with addiction throughout his life. Taylor’s mother speculated that the haunting entity was draining and exacerbated his problems:
“My mother since then has always held this idea that whatever problems my brother had, she made them worse. That she was draining to be around and that she maybe messed with him and his mental health because she could.” (19:39)
- After Michael died on Valentine’s Day, the house grew quiet for months before the haunting resumed. Taylor speculates the ghost may have been waiting, or perhaps was only tied to Michael:
“She was quiet for a while... but she started right up again.... We assume she left. Honestly. Yeah. Without him there to hold her there. But no, she's back. She's still here.” (23:39)
Notable Quotes
-
Kaylin Moore:
“It's a rare occurrence, but sometimes the supernatural explanation is the less terrifying of the two.” (14:38)
-
Taylor (on the ghostly voice):
“It was like lower and raspy, but like... a comforting, like, grandpa kind of raspy, if you know what I mean... it sounded like my family.” (13:39)
-
Taylor (on the recording):
“There was a three-second long video... So I played it and it was her saying, just shut up.” (21:37)
Timestamps for Important Segments
- Intro and episode theme: 02:19
- Taylor’s haunted vent story begins: 04:12
- Discussion of vent design and the voice: 06:56–08:25
- Reflections with family, supernatural vs. mundane fear: 13:39–14:38
- Taylor’s Staten Island/ghost story begins: 15:12
- Michael’s ghostly torment: 16:03–19:39
- The ‘just shut up’ ghost recording: 21:37
- Aftermath, the haunted house post-brother’s death: 23:39
- Closing thoughts and family humor: 24:42–26:28
Memorable Moments & Tone
- Throughout the episode, Kaylin maintains a tone both empathetic and suspenseful, often pausing to reflect on the psychological implications of hauntings or to question which explanation—supernatural or mundane—is more frightening.
- The inclusion of actual audio claimed to be from a ghost amplifies the creepiness factor.
- Humorous relief is provided near the end with a story from Kaylin’s sibling Leo about raccoons in a college room’s vent, grounding the supernatural tales in the tangible anxieties of old houses and unexpected roommates.
Conclusion and Reflection
The episode leaves listeners pondering whether hauntings are the echoes of troubled souls, family trauma made manifest, or simply the tricks of time, grief, and old architecture. As Kaylin asks in her conclusion:
“Is it scarier to believe a spirit of a loved one is making contact with you? Or that a stranger may be inside of your home? Is it more terrifying to think your demons are from another realm or that you carried them inside you your entire life?”
Listeners are encouraged to decide for themselves—and invited to submit their own stories for future episodes.
Follow Heart Starts Pounding on:
Submit your story: https://www.heartstartspounding.com/stories