When a respectable Victorian doctor became Britain’s most feared poisoner

Victorian England believed murder belonged to the gutters. Then Dr William Palmer shattered that illusion.

In this gripping episode of History Rage, award-winning journalist and author Stephen Bates exposes the dark truth behind the case of William Palmer — the Midlands doctor hanged in 1856 for poisoning his friend John Parsons Cook.

Known as the “Rugeley Poisoner”, Palmer was a churchgoing professional, a gambler drowning in debt, and a man suspected of killing far more than the one murder for which he was convicted. His weapon? Newly available strychnine — a terrifying poison that left victims writhing in agony and Victorian society gripped by fear.

What You’ll Discover in This Episode

Why Victorian Britain refused to believe a middle-class doctor could be a killer
How strychnine changed the landscape of 19th-century murder
The explosive Old Bailey trial that required a special Act of Parliament
The role of celebrity pathologist Alfred Swaine Taylor
How press sensationalism helped create one of Britain’s first “serial killer” panics
The disturbing class bias in Victorian (and modern) murder trials

Stephen also explores parallels with later cases, including Herbert Rouse Armstrong, the subject of his book The Poisonous Solicitor, and reflects on how professional status has long influenced public perceptions of guilt.

This is Victorian true crime at its most unsettling: insurance fraud, gambling debts, missing betting slips, botched inquests, and a public execution witnessed by 30,000 people.

About Our Guest – Stephen Bates

Stephen Bates is an award-winning journalist and former political correspondent. He is the author of:

The Poisoner: The Life and Crimes of Victorian England’s Most Notorious Doctor
https://uk.bookshop.org/a/10120/9781837730285
The Poisonous Solicitor
https://uk.bookshop.org/a/10120/9781785789601

The Poisoner was shortlisted for the prestigious Agatha Award for True Crime in the United States.

🔗 Website: https://stephenbateswriter.com

Why This Case Still Matters

Palmer’s trial raises urgent questions that still resonate:

Do we judge murder differently depending on class?
Are professionals given more benefit of the doubt?
How much does media coverage shape public opinion before a verdict is reached?

From Victorian strychnine to modern medical murderers, the uncomfortable truth remains: monsters don’t always look like monsters.

Follow & Support History Rage

If you enjoy fearless myth-busting history and passionate debate:

🔥 Join the Rage on Patreon

Ad-free listening and livestream access for just £3 per month:

👉 https://www.patreon.com/historyrage

🍎 Prefer Apple? Subscribe directly via Apple Podcasts for ad-free episodes.

📱 Follow History Rage:

Twitter/X: https://twitter.com/historyrage
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/historyrage
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/historyrage

📩 Contact: historyragepod@gmail.com

The simplest way to support the show? Share the episode and bring someone else aboard the Rage Train.

Victorian crime wasn’t just about back alleys and desperation. Sometimes it wore a respectable face, attended church — and carried a vial of poison.

Listen now and stay angry.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

278. The Victorians’ OTHER Serial Killer with Stephen Bates