Was England’s greatest medieval villain actually a misunderstood power broker?

Thomas Arundel has long been cast as one of the great villains of English history — a persecutor, a political schemer, even the man blamed for burning heretics. But is that reputation deserved, or is it a product of centuries of misunderstanding?

In this episode of History Rage, host Paul Bavill is joined by renowned medieval historian Chris Given-Wilson to challenge one of the most persistent myths of the Plantagenet era. Together, they unpack the life, career, and controversies of the Archbishop of Canterbury who stood at the centre of one of England’s most dramatic regime changes.

Arundel’s rise was meteoric — from a wealthy noble family to Bishop of Ely at just 20, and eventually Archbishop of Canterbury. But his true influence came during the turbulent transition from Richard II to Henry IV, where he played a decisive role in legitimising the overthrow of a king. Far from a shadowy manipulator, Arundel emerges as a crucial architect of political authority in a deeply unstable England.

The episode dives into the chaos of late 14th-century politics: rebellion, deposition, and the uneasy foundations of Lancastrian rule. Arundel wasn’t simply along for the ride — he helped provide the religious and legal justification that made Henry IV’s kingship possible.

But it’s Arundel’s association with the suppression of the Lollards that cemented his dark reputation. Were these early reformers brutally persecuted by a tyrannical churchman? Or was Arundel responding to what he genuinely believed was a dangerous and destabilising religious movement?

Chris Given-Wilson explores the reality behind the accusations — including the controversial introduction of heretic burning in England. The truth is more complex than the legend: Arundel did not create these laws, but he operated within a system determined to preserve religious unity at a time of crisis.

By the end of this episode, the image of Arundel as a pantomime villain begins to crumble. Instead, we see a deeply embedded medieval figure — a man shaped by the politics, religion, and fears of his time.

If you think you know the story of medieval power and persecution, think again.

👤 Guest Information

Chris Given-Wilson

Emeritus Professor of Medieval History, University of St Andrews

Book: Archbishop, Chancellor, Kingmaker: Thomas Arundel and the Politics of Late Medieval England
Academic profile: Available via the University of St Andrews website

📚 Buy the Book

Support independent bookshops and grab your copy here:

👉 https://uk.bookshop.org/a/10120/9780300286403

🎧 More from History Rage

Love challenging historical myths? There’s plenty more where this came from.

Episode 184 with Helen Castor on Medieval Royal Politics
Episode 220 with Michael Livingston on the Battle of Agincourt

📢 Follow & Contact History Rage

🌐 Website: https://www.historyrage.com
📧 Email: historyragepod@gmail.com
🐦 Twitter/X: https://twitter.com/historyrage
📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/historyrage
📘 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/historyrage
📧 Newsletter: https://historyrage.substack.com/

💥 Support the Podcast

Want more rage in your life?

🎟️ Join Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/historyrage
Monthly livestream access
Entry into the book draw
Submit questions to future guests
Exclusive History Rage merch
🍏 Apple Subscriptions: Listen ad-free for £3/month

Or simply share the podcast and bring someone else aboard the Rage Train 🚂

History isn’t just about what happened — it’s about who gets remembered, and why.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.