Jay'sAnalysis – Pt 2 IT'S PLANNED & PREDICTED: US CIVIL WAR, DAVOS & LIBERTARIAN FAILURE

Host: Jay Dyer | Date: January 28, 2026

Episode Overview

In this episode, Jay Dyer and his co-hosts explore the deliberate planning behind recent sociopolitical shifts in the US, focusing on immigration policies, the influence of religious NGOs, the role of Catholic organizations, the entanglements between church and state intelligence, ongoing culture-war drama within the Catholic apologetics scene, and critiques of libertarian philosophy. The episode is both serious and irreverent, blending cutting analysis with biting humor and inside jokes, while fielding Superchat questions from audience members.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Catholic Charities and Mass Immigration

Timestamps: 00:35–07:39; 26:08–29:34

• NGOs as Human Trafficking Fronts: Jay and Candace argue that organizations like Catholic Charities and the US Conference of Catholic Bishops act as profitable trafficking channels for illegal migration—"Roman Catholic NGOs, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Catholic Charities, all of these are human trafficking organizations that serve to resettle migrants from outside of the country." (Jay Dyer, 03:07)
• Financial Incentive: Billions have been spent on these resettlement programs during the Biden administration.
• Doctrinal Justification: Candace points out that the Vatican has openly supported open borders since Vatican II, referencing Gaudium et Spes as doctrinal support. “Is the Holy Spirit leading and guiding this institution? Why is it covering up crimes?” (Candace, 03:07)
• Critique of Catholic Coverups: Both hosts accuse the institutional church and its apologists of ignoring or suppressing the true scale and motives behind migration policies.

2. Culture War & Catholic Apologetics Drama

Timestamps: 07:39–26:08

• William Albrecht & Debate Avoidance: Jay recounts repeated failed attempts to debate Catholic apologist William Albrecht, labeling him “the biggest liar on the Internet” (Jay Dyer, 08:08).
• Grindr Scandal Mockery: Extended comedic riffing on Catholic YouTube figures embroiled in “Grindr profile” scandals. The hosts joke about the “research” invested by Catholic apologists into these profiles, using gay subculture references irreverently for satire.
  • “I've got top men and bottom men. Top men and bottom men are involved in this case. And we've come to the conclusion that Grindr is fully, first of all, a Catholic website... Cardnal Mahoney gave a Grindr an imprimatur.” (Researcher/Analyst, 10:30)
• Toxic YouTube Apologetics Circles: Critique of the infighting and narcissism among apologists.
  • “All these losers have is drama...if you implement a policy in these circles of removal for drama, they'd all remove themselves.” (Candace, 21:02)
• Aesthetic & Performative Criticism: The use of cassocks and gym-buff imagery among Catholic YouTubers is mocked as “LARPing” (Candace, 17:47–23:18).

3. Planned Social Engineering via Davos & WEF

Timestamps: 26:08–31:50

• Biometric “Terror” and COVID as Test Run: Jay connects recent pandemic policies to World Economic Forum documents, framing them as dry runs for global biosecurity states and top-down technocracy.
  • “What did I harp on over and over during the Koof? Psyop. Psyops. Psyops. I got tired of talking about it...This is a gigantic psyop test.” (Jay Dyer, 26:08)
• Globalist Authority: Attribution of mandates to the CDC, Rockefeller Foundation, and United Nations, leading to future “smart cities” and “sustainable” urban hubs.

4. Critique of Catholic Apologetics & Thought Leaders

Timestamps: 31:01–36:12

• Trent Horn & the Elite Apologetics Sphere: Specific attacks on Catholic apologist Trent Horn are made, poking fun at his positions and refusal to admit fault over COVID policies.

5. Critique of Libertarianism and Its Failure

Timestamps: 36:12–54:45

• Libertarian Philosophy as Leftism: Jay clarifies his frequent critique is not of libertarian politicians, but of the basic philosophy—specifically open borders.
  • “I am talking about the philosophy of libertarian ideas, which is leftism in the sense of open borders.” (Jay Dyer, 49:12)
• Libertarian Policy Enabling Globalism: Jay connects libertarian economic ideas with neoliberal, neoconservative strategies, accusing them of fueling the social dissolution visible today.
• Public Misunderstanding: The public (and even “smart people”) often misinterpret Jay’s nuanced critique, missing the difference between libertarian policy and philosophy.
  • “People are operating on two totally different levels of what they're talking about.” (Candace, 51:45)

6. CIA, Vatican & Deep State Collaboration

Timestamps: 36:12–45:00

• Historical Intelligence Ties: Jay references material from “The Old Boys” and David Wim Hof’s book, documenting ties between the CIA (especially James Jesus Angleton) and Vatican intelligence from the 1940s.
  • “By 1945, Angleton coordinated many matters with the Vatican's sophisticated intelligence apparatus...” (Jay Dyer, 42:23)
• Influence on Vatican II: Asserts that CIA and American intelligence influenced doctrinal and policy changes in the Catholic Church, fostering religious liberty and ecumenism.

Memorable Quotes & Notable Moments

• On Religious NGOs and Immigration:
  • “Have they not read the last 10 years of Papal statements about open borders in Europe? No, guess not. ... Catholic Charities makes a huge amount of money moving people, migrants around.”
    — Candace, 01:13 & Jay Dyer, 01:57
• On Catholic Coverups & Apologetics:
  • “Roman Catholicism is about covering it up over and over and over, which shows you. Now, wait a minute. Is the Holy Spirit leading and guiding this institution? Why is it covering up crimes?”
    — Candace, 03:07
• On Apologetics Drama:
  • “They're all gay. My theory is they're all in a big stupid gay fight because they're all jealous of their other butt buddies.”
    — Jay Dyer, 09:52
• Postmodern Truth & Papism:
  • “Postmodernism kind of falls into Nietzscheanism or will to power ... Actually, if you think about it, that is papism. The papacy is ... worship of authority, worship of geopolitical power and numbers.”
    — Jay Dyer, 36:14
• On Libertarian Failure:
  • “You are all witnessing in real time the failure of libertarianism in action, as I have critiqued for the last 15 years.”
    — Jay Dyer, 38:01
• On Church-State Collusion:
  • “By 1945, Angleton coordinated many matters with the Vatican's sophisticated intelligence apparatus.”
    — Jay Dyer, 42:23

Timestamps for Important Segments

• NGOs & Immigration Exposé: 00:35–07:39
• Catholic YouTube Apologetics Drama: 07:39–26:08
• Covid, Davos, and Social Engineering: 26:08–31:50
• Catholic Apologetics Critique: 31:01–36:12
• Libertarianism & Policy Critique: 36:12–54:45
• CIA-Vatican Ties: 36:12–45:00
• Audience Q&A & Superchats: 54:45–end

Overall Tone

The episode combines scathing critique of religious and political ideologies with irreverent humor, conspiracy analysis, and barbed personal anecdotes. The tone is blunt, combative, and often satirical, with Jay and his co-hosts using inside jokes and direct language to lambaste perceived hypocrisy, failures of philosophy, and the manufactured quality of culture war drama.

For Listeners New to Jay'sAnalysis

This episode is a fast-paced, sometimes chaotic blend of deep-dive geopolitical analysis, intra-Christian polemics, and lampooning of cultural phenomena, all delivered in Jay Dyer's trademark mix of sharp wit and academic rigor. The central thesis: current social upheavals—including mass immigration, post-pandemic technocracy, and the collapse of libertarian ideals—are coordinated, predictable, and profit-driven, abetted by powerful religious, governmental, and financial players.