Buena Vista Social Club (Schoenfeld Theatre, Broadway) - ★★★★ REVIEW

Podcast Summary: "Buena Vista Social Club" – ★★★★ REVIEW

Podcast: MickeyJoTheatre
Host: MickeyJoTheatre
Episode Title: Buena Vista Social Club (Schoenfeld Theatre, Broadway) - ★★★★ REVIEW
Release Date: May 21, 2025

Introduction

In this episode, Mickey Jo delves into his review of the Broadway musical "Buena Vista Social Club", currently captivating audiences at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre. Transitioning from its Off-Broadway origins, the show has garnered several Tony Award nominations, including Best New Musical. Mickey Jo sets the stage by highlighting the show's unique position as a jukebox musical that adapts the acclaimed 1990s documentary of the same name, weaving a semi-fictional narrative around the legendary Cuban musicians featured in the iconic album.

“If you don’t know about the show, I will tell you a little bit more about it, how it works and why it's quite so special...” ([00:00])

Plot Overview

"Buena Vista Social Club" intertwines two timelines: the present-day (1990s) effort to record the album and the past memories of the musicians. Central to the narrative is Amara Potuando, portrayed in both her younger and older years, whose journey from a reclusive singer to a key figure in reviving lost Cuban musical traditions forms the emotional core of the story.

The plot navigates themes of love, loss, friendship, and the tough choices faced amidst the backdrop of the Cuban Revolution. A pivotal moment revolves around Amara's dilemma: whether to seek fame and safety in America with her sister or stay in Cuba to preserve the authentic musical heritage she has rediscovered.

“The music itself becomes a gateway to their memories... the enduring power of music...” ([15:45])

Themes and Storytelling

Mickey Jo appreciates the show's exploration of cultural identity, community, and immigration. He notes how the musical uses Cuban genres like Cubanzon, Danzon, and Bolero not just as musical styles but as narrative devices that reflect the characters' inner lives and histories.

A significant discussion point is the show’s use of diegetic music—songs performed within the story's world—allowing the music to enhance authenticity without relying on the audience's understanding of Spanish. This choice emphasizes the universal language of music while still celebrating its cultural roots.

“These old songs, they kick up old feelings... music is the main character here.” ([25:30])

Music and Performances

The musical boasts an exceptional ensemble cast, with standout performances by Natalie Venetia Belcon as the older Amara and Isa Antonetti as her younger counterpart. Mickey Jo praises their ability to convey deep emotional truths with minimal dialogue, highlighting moments where music transcends language barriers.

A particularly lauded scene features the band’s passionate performance, showcasing the talents of the musicians and underscoring the show's dedication to musical authenticity. The inclusion of a special Tony Award for the musical team's contribution further underscores the production's excellence.

“The most show-stopping sequence... just spectating extraordinary musicianship...” ([40:15])

Creative Elements

Direction and Choreography: Sahih Mali’s direction is commended for seamlessly blending the two timelines and utilizing music as a storytelling tool. The choreography by Patricia Delgado and Justin Peck is described as lively and soulful, reflecting the contrasting worlds within the narrative.

Set and Lighting Design: Arnulfo Maldonado’s scenic design creates a believable Cuban town, with intricate details that adapt to various settings within the story. Tyler Michelo’s lighting enhances the emotional and thematic depth, providing stunning visual moments that complement the musical performances.

“The scenic design... feels like a real town. The lighting design... really stunning.” ([50:45])

Costume Design: Didi Ayite’s costumes are highlighted for their vibrant Cuban fashion, effectively portraying different eras and adding to the overall authenticity of the production.

Cultural Authenticity and Language

Mickey Jo engages in a thoughtful critique regarding the show's use of the Spanish language. While he celebrates the authenticity it brings, he also raises questions about accessibility for non-Spanish speakers and representation for Spanish-speaking audiences on Broadway. He advocates for the inclusion of surtitles to enhance understanding and inclusivity, drawing parallels to successful foreign-language productions in film and television.

“I would really love a version of Buena Vista Social Club performed entirely in Spanish... it's a big win for Accessibility.” ([35:20])

Conclusion and Recommendations

Mickey Jo concludes by highly recommending "Buena Vista Social Club" as a compelling musical that combines heartfelt storytelling with extraordinary musical performances. He emphasizes the show's ability to resonate emotionally, even with language barriers, thanks to its universal themes and passionate execution. For theater enthusiasts and newcomers alike, Mickey Jo assures that this production is a must-see experience that honors the rich heritage of Cuban music and its enduring legacy.

“It's a brilliant piece of musical storytelling with some extraordinary artistry... If this sounds like something you would enjoy, make sure to go and check out Buena Vista Social Club on Broadway.” ([55:10])

Engagement and Future Content

Mickey Jo invites listeners to share their thoughts on "Buena Vista Social Club" and encourages them to subscribe to his YouTube channel for more theater reviews. He also hints at upcoming content related to other Broadway shows and the Tony Awards, fostering a community of theater enthusiasts eager to stay informed and engaged.

“Please feel free to share your thoughts... I hope that everyone is staying safe and that you have a stagey day.” ([59:50])

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

“Never before in my lifetime of going to the theatre do I think I've ever gone to a show, been completely unable to understand the meaning of any of the lyrics, and enjoyed it quite this much.” ([00:00])
“These old songs, they kick up old feelings...” ([25:30])
“The most show-stopping sequence... just spectating extraordinary musicianship...” ([40:15])
“I would really love a version of Buena Vista Social Club performed entirely in Spanish... it's a big win for Accessibility.” ([35:20])
“It's a brilliant piece of musical storytelling with some extraordinary artistry... If this sounds like something you would enjoy, make sure to go and check out Buena Vista Social Club on Broadway.” ([55:10])

Final Thoughts

Mickey Jo's in-depth review of "Buena Vista Social Club" offers listeners a comprehensive understanding of the musical's strengths—from its heartfelt narrative and cultural authenticity to its superb performances and creative design. Whether you’re a seasoned theatergoer or new to Broadway, this review provides valuable insights that highlight why "Buena Vista Social Club" is a deserving recipient of multiple Tony Award nominations and a memorable addition to the Broadway scene.

For more detailed discussions and future reviews, subscribe to MickeyJoTheatre's YouTube channel and follow them on social media.