Podcast Summary: MickeyJoTheatre Episode on "Calamity Jane" (UK & Ireland Tour) – ★★★ Review

Introduction

In the February 26, 2025 episode of MickeyJoTheatre, host Mickey-Jo delves into his review of the UK and Ireland tour production of the musical "Calamity Jane", starring the talented Carrie Hope Fletcher. As a prominent theatre critic with a substantial following on YouTube, Mickey-Jo brings his extensive knowledge and passion for theatre to dissect the latest rendition of this classic musical.

Overview of the Show

Mickey-Jo begins by situating the production within its historical context, noting its origins as a 1953 film starring Doris Day and its subsequent adaptation into a stage musical in 1961. He observes, “Normally that would have happened the other way around, and I do think that that origin story can be perceived in some of the show's material and some of its quirks” ([06:15]). This highlights the unique trajectory of "Calamity Jane" from screen to stage, setting the stage for his detailed analysis.

Plot Summary

The narrative centers on the real-life frontier woman Calamity Jane, portrayed by Carrie Hope Fletcher, and her complex relationship with Wild Bill Hickok (Vinnie Coyle). Mickey-Jo provides a concise synopsis:

“Calamity Jane was a real life historic sharpshooter and frontier woman who lived during the second half of the 19th century. She was a contemporary of Wild Bill Hickok, who also features in this show... [they] deeply loathe each other. But perhaps there's something else significantly more passionate happening beneath the surface” ([04:30]).

He further explains the plot's romantic entanglements and mistaken identities that drive the story forward, encapsulating the show's central "love rectangle."

Themes and Interpretations

Mickey-Jo explores underlying themes, particularly the portrayal of Calamity Jane's defiance of traditional femininity. He notes:

“This has always been one interpretation of Calamity Jane because you have this leading female character wearing trousers, wielding a shotgun and defying anyone who tells her that she ought to act in a more ladylike fashion” ([12:45]).

Additionally, he touches on the subtle queer reading of the narrative, especially in the relationship dynamics between Calamity and Katie Brown, adding depth to the character interactions.

Production Design and Staging

A significant portion of the review is dedicated to the production's design elements. Mickey-Jo praises the actor-musician format, where the cast doubles as the musical ensemble, creating an intimate and dynamic stage environment. He states:

“Rather than bringing on a set piece to look like the Deadwood stage instead, Carrie Hope Fletcher as Calamity Jane sits atop an upright piano and they create it out of wooden chairs and twirling umbrellas” ([20:10]).

He commends Matthew Wright's dual role in set and costume design, highlighting the clever replication of the proscenium and the bustling saloon atmosphere that fosters a sense of community on stage.

Musical Elements and Songs

The musical score, rooted in its 1950s origins, features both classic and adapted songs from the original film. Mickey-Jo critiques the pacing and integration of songs within the narrative:

“The songs are of that era. There are some knee slapping tunes in there... The songs are quite short. It's an interesting feature of the show that they get into a great groove with these songs” ([25:50]).

He also mentions lyrical adjustments made to address racially insensitive content from the original, noting the production's effort to modernize and sanitize the material without compromising its essence.

Performances

Carrie Hope Fletcher's portrayal of Calamity Jane is a focal point of the review. Mickey-Jo contrasts her performance with that of Jodie Prenger, praising Fletcher's ability to infuse the character with both strength and vulnerability:

“Carrie plays it a little clueless and a little convinced that Dany already really likes her. So she doesn't try too hard around him in an awkward way. She just smiles real big and rushes to take care of him when he's injured” ([33:20]).

Vinnie Coyle as Wild Bill Hickok receives accolades for his vocal prowess and nuanced performance:

“Vinnie’s singing the crooning is just wonderful. He immediately needs to be catapulted from this show to a lot of those regular gigs at the Royal Albert Hall” ([37:40]).

Supporting cast members, including Samuel Holmes and Sandom Davies, are highlighted for their comedic timing and heartfelt portrayals, adding layers to the production's ensemble dynamic.

Critical Analysis

Mickey-Jo offers a balanced critique, acknowledging the show's nostalgic charm while pointing out areas where it falls short. He remarks on the plot's simplicity and pacing:

“It is not fast paced, it is not high octane... It is sweet and romantic if not particularly breathtaking” ([45:00]).

Despite these critiques, he appreciates the production's ability to maintain charm and wit, making it a delightful experience for fans of classic musicals.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Wrapping up his review, Mickey-Jo emphasizes that "Calamity Jane" is best suited for audiences who cherish traditional musical theatre and enjoy a romantic, heartwarming narrative set against a Western backdrop. He encourages listeners to experience the show firsthand:

“If you're looking for a warm, romantic story played amongst these slightly cartoonish frontier characters... Then look no further and check it out” ([50:30]).

He concludes with an invitation for audience interaction, urging listeners to share their thoughts and experiences with the production.

Notable Quotes

• Mickey-Jo on staging creativity: “Carrying the instruments on stage really integrates the music into the fabric of the performance” ([20:10]).

• Mickey-Jo on Carrie Hope Fletcher’s performance: “Carrie feels entirely natural in this characterization and manages to marry all of those qualities” ([35:50]).

• Mickey-Jo on the musical's pacing: “It is sweet and romantic if not particularly breathtaking” ([45:00]).

Final Remarks

This episode of MickeyJoTheatre offers a comprehensive and engaging review of "Calamity Jane" on its UK and Ireland tour. Mickey-Jo's insightful analysis, enriched with detailed observations and personal reflections, provides valuable guidance for theatre enthusiasts considering this production. His balanced perspective highlights both the production's strengths and its minor shortcomings, ensuring that listeners receive an honest and thorough critique.

For those interested in classic musicals and the evolving landscape of theatre productions, MickeyJoTheatre's review serves as an informative resource, encouraging deeper appreciation and conversation within the theatre community.