Podcast Summary: MickeyJoTheatre – "Jesus Christ Superstar (The Watermill Theatre, Newbury) - ★★★ REVIEW"
Release Date: July 11, 2025
Introduction
In this episode of MickeyJoTheatre, host Mickey Jo delves into his latest theater review: a production of "Jesus Christ Superstar" at the Watermill Theatre in Newbury. Known for his insightful critiques and extensive experience in theatre criticism, Mickey Jo provides a comprehensive analysis of this intimate revival, highlighting both its strengths and shortcomings.
Overview of "Jesus Christ Superstar"
Mickey Jo begins by contextualizing "Jesus Christ Superstar" within his recent observations of Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice's revivals, including "Evita" and other global productions.
Mickey Jo [05:30]: "It's really interesting seeing it in the shadow of the very loud conversation around Evita..."
He emphasizes the challenge of reviving such iconic works, balancing respect for the original material while offering a fresh perspective.
Production and Venue
The Watermill Theatre, known for its actor-musician productions due to space constraints, presents a unique setting for this rock opera. Mickey Jo explores how the venue's intimate space shapes the production's dynamics.
Mickey Jo [10:15]: "When they do stage musicals, they are actor musician productions, which is to say that the performers on stage in the cast are also playing instruments."
He notes that the venue's limitations necessitate creative staging solutions, influencing the overall feel of the performance.
Set Design and Direction
David Woodhead's set design receives commendation for its thoughtful integration with the Watermill's chapel-like interior.
Mickey Jo [22:47]: "The inside of the Watermill has this sort of chapel like feel... making the whole thing feel like a completely designed bespoke space."
Under Paul Hart's direction, the production attempts to balance traditional rock opera elements with the intimate theater setting. However, Mickey Jo feels the innovation is inconsistent.
Mickey Jo [24:30]: "There is a certain awkwardness in terms of how long it takes for us all to get from this outdoor setting back to our seats."
Performance Highlights
Mary Magdalene (Parissa Shamir)
Parissa Shamir's portrayal of Mary Magdalene stands out as a highlight, showcasing her vocal prowess and emotional depth.
Mickey Jo [30:10]: "Parissa Shamir... really puts a song across brilliantly when accompanying herself as well."
King Herod (Samuel Morgan Grimm)
Samuel Morgan Grimm's King Herod is described as "devilish and sinister," bringing a much-needed energy boost to the production.
Mickey Jo [35:25]: "King Herod's song Wrong is far and away the most high energy moment of the show."
Judas (Michael Collwadia)
Although Michael Collwadia delivers impressive vocals, Mickey Jo felt a disconnect in conveying Judas's internal turmoil, impacting the character's emotional resonance.
Mickey Jo [40:50]: "I wasn't particularly convinced by Michael Collwadia's performance as Jesus... it was though he was just mildly inconvenienced by the whole thing."
Musical Arrangement and Score
The adaptation of the original score to fit the actor-musician format is a focal point. While some arrangements work seamlessly, others feel constrained by the limited instrumentation.
Mickey Jo [45:00]: "I kind of wish that the whole arrangement and orchestration of the score could have been adapted a little bit more to give it more of that feel."
He praises specific numbers like "Heaven on Their Minds" and "I Don't Know How to Love Him," highlighting their emotional impact despite the production's limitations.
Innovative Staging and Promenade Elements
The production incorporates promenade theater, especially during the transition to the second act, enhancing the immersive experience.
Mickey Jo [50:30]: "They created the Shire location outdoors... It's a little bit of a promenade performance in Jesus Christ Superstar, of all things."
However, he notes that these innovations occasionally disrupt the narrative flow.
Mickey Jo [52:15]: "The momentum of the second act does get pierced a little bit..."
Conclusion and Final Thoughts
Mickey Jo concludes that while the Watermill Theatre's production of "Jesus Christ Superstar" boasts strong performances and creative staging, it ultimately falls short of delivering the powerful impact expected from such a seminal work.
Mickey Jo [60:45]: "It is full of huge rock anthems and power chords... but the actor-musician format limited its usual impact."
He encourages listeners to experience the production firsthand, acknowledging its unique charm despite its flaws.
Mickey Jo [63:10]: "If you haven't visited this venue before, if you haven't seen this show on stage, all good reasons to go and check it out for yourself."
Key Takeaways
- Venue Influence: The Watermill Theatre's intimate space and actor-musician format offer a distinct take on the classic rock opera.
- Performance Strengths: Standout roles like Mary Magdalene and King Herod elevate the production.
- Musical Adaptation: While some of the score's adaptation works well, others feel constrained, affecting the overall impact.
- Innovative Staging: Promenade elements add an immersive layer but sometimes disrupt narrative flow.
- Overall Assessment: A commendable effort with notable highlights, yet lacking the full emotional heft of the original.
Notable Quotes
- Mickey Jo [10:15]: “When they do stage musicals, they are actor musician productions…”
- Mickey Jo [22:47]: “The inside of the Watermill has this sort of chapel like feel…”
- Mickey Jo [30:10]: “Parissa Shamir… really puts a song across brilliantly…”
- Mickey Jo [35:25]: “King Herod's song Wrong is far and away the most high energy moment…”
- Mickey Jo [40:50]: “I wasn't particularly convinced by Michael Collwadia's performance as Jesus…”
- Mickey Jo [45:00]: “I kind of wish that the whole arrangement and orchestration of the score could have been adapted…”
- Mickey Jo [50:30]: “They created the Shire location outdoors…”
- Mickey Jo [60:45]: “It is full of huge rock anthems and power chords…”
- Mickey Jo [63:10]: “All good reasons to go and check it out for yourself.”
Conclusion
Mickey Jo's review offers a nuanced perspective on the Watermill Theatre's rendition of "Jesus Christ Superstar." While acknowledging the production's innovative approaches and standout performances, he remains critical of its inability to fully capture the original's emotional depth. Theater enthusiasts looking to experience this production are encouraged to see it firsthand, appreciating both its creative ambitions and inherent limitations.
For more in-depth reviews and theater insights, subscribe to MickeyJoTheatre on YouTube or your preferred podcast platform.