Summary of "Thoughts on the Next Broadway Season... | Mickey-Jo's Early Opinions on All the 2025-2026 Plays and Musicals"
Podcast: MickeyJoTheatre
Host: Mickey-Jo
Release Date: July 28, 2025
In this comprehensive episode, Mickey-Jo delves into his early thoughts and expectations for the upcoming 2025-2026 Broadway season. Covering new plays, new musicals, play revivals, and musical revivals, he provides insightful critiques, highlights notable productions, and shares his personal anticipations. The episode is well-structured, offering listeners a detailed preview of what to expect on Broadway in the coming year.
Introduction to the Upcoming Broadway Season
Mickey-Jo begins by reflecting on the exceptionally high quality of the previous Broadway season and sets the stage for an equally promising next season. He emphasizes the excitement surrounding the numerous new productions that have already been announced, while acknowledging the inherent unpredictability at this early stage.
“...there's much to be excited about as well as everything else that has yet to be announced.” [02:45]
New Plays
Redwood
Venue: Studio 54
Notable Cast: Jean Smart
Director: [Not Specified]
"Redwood" is a one-woman extended monologue that explores the journey of a woman reconnecting with her literary passions amidst an abusive relationship. Mickey-Jo notes Jean Smart's celebrated performance but remains skeptical about its potential for Tony Awards recognition.
“I didn't particularly enjoy it... This is a one-woman extended monologue.” [12:30]
All Out Comedy About Life
Description: Sequel to "All In Comedy About Love"
Format: Non-narrative with rotating celebrity cast
Mickey-Jo critiques this production for its non-narrative structure and celebrity-driven casting, expressing a lack of personal interest despite acknowledging the charm it brings to some audience members.
“I just didn't... It never interested me and by extension neither does the next one.” [18:50]
Dog Day Afternoon
Venue: Spring 2026, Broadway (Details TBD)
Notable Cast: Eben Moss Bakrach, Jon Bernthal
Director: Rupert Gold
Playwright: Stephen Adley Guerges
An adaptation of the classic film, this play delves into the tumultuous events of 1972, blending historical context with personal drama. Initially skeptical, Mickey-Jo becomes intrigued by the compelling narrative and high-profile casting.
“Maybe I take it all back.” [21:40]
Little Bear Ridge Road
Producer: Scott Rudin
Playwright: Samuel Hunter
Notable Cast: Laurie Metcalfe
Due to Scott Rudin's controversial reputation, Mickey-Jo expresses strong disapproval and decides to abstain from supporting the production, highlighting his disappointment in industry responses to Rudin's return.
“Nothing has changed my mind that I will just be skipping this...” [23:15]
Punch by James Graham
Venue: Concurrent Broadway and West End
Director: Adam Penford
Playwright: James Graham
"Punch" stands out as Mickey-Jo's most anticipated new play, based on the true story of Jacob Dunn. He praises the raw and gritty narrative, as well as the production's dual debut on Broadway and the West End.
“This just became my most anticipated new play of 2025-2026.” [24:30]
The Balusters by David Lindsay Abair
Venue: Samuel J. Friedman Theatre
Director: Kenny Leon
A comedic exploration of neighborhood conflicts, "The Balusters" draws parallels to Mickey-Jo's previous experiences with community-centric plays, highlighting its potential for theatrical drama.
“...feels a little familiar of Eureka Day...” [24:50]
Sugar Daddy by Sam Morrison
Venue: Broadway (Details TBD)
Director: Stephen Brackett
A solo play that blends humor with profound themes of grief and resilience, "Sugar Daddy" garners Mickey-Jo's interest due to its unique storytelling approach and successful performances at the Edinburgh Fringe and Soho Playhouse.
“I am immediately interested because that is not a pathway that you see for a lot of Broadway shows.” [25:10]
Kowalski by Greg Ostrin
Venue: Fall 2025, Off Broadway
Director: Colin Hanlon
Playwright: Greg Ostrin
Focusing on the intense first meeting between Tennessee Williams and Marlon Brando, "Kowalski" offers a deep dive into character dynamics and power struggles. While not initially compelling enough for Broadway transfer, Mickey-Jo remains cautiously optimistic.
“...it doesn't become effervescent in its romance and sexuality.” [25:45]
New Musicals
Queen of the Sigh
Venue: St James Theatre
Notable Cast: Kristin Chenoweth, F. Murray Abraham
Composer/Lyricist: Stephen Schwartz
A star-driven vehicle for Kristin Chenoweth, reuniting her with Stephen Schwartz. Despite high expectations, Mickey-Jo remains skeptical based on past performances of similar star-centric shows but remains hopeful.
“It's worth saying, she is playing the Queen of Versailles herself, Jackie.” [30:20]
The Lost Boys
Venue: Spring 2026, Palace Theatre
Director: Michael Arden
Mickey-Jo identifies "The Lost Boys" as his most anticipated new musical, lauding Michael Arden's direction and the show's potential, despite limited personal knowledge of the source material.
“I am very intrigued. I'm curiously excited…” [32:00]
Dolly (formerly "Hello, I'm Dolly")
Venue: Broadway Premiere (Details TBD)
Producers: Nathan Amsie, Joe Ransom, ATG Entertainment
Concept: Bio-musical about Dolly Parton
Exploring Dolly Parton's life through multiple actresses portraying different life stages, Mickey-Jo expresses both excitement and concerns about the potential for the show to feel generic.
“Dolly's too special for that.” [34:15]
Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
Venue: Chicago’s Goodman Theatre Premiere
Score: Jason Robert Brown
Book: Taylor Mack
Director: Rob Ashford
Adapted from the Pulitzer-finalist novel, this musical delves into a murder investigation intertwined with high society and personal revelations. Mickey-Jo finds the plot intriguing and is eager to see its development on Broadway.
“I just became intrigued.” [38:30]
Wanted (formerly "Gun and Powder")
Venue: Broadway 2026 (Details TBD)
Composer: Ross Baum
Book/Lyrics: Angelica Cherie
Concept: Historical musical set in 1893 Texas
Focusing on twin sisters tackling their mother's debt, "Wanted" is praised for its original storytelling and representation of diverse historical narratives. Mickey-Jo is highly enthusiastic about its potential.
“I am more than intrigued. I'm a little bit excited about this one.” [40:50]
Play Revivals
Art by Yasmin Reza
Venue: Music Box Theatre
Notable Cast: Bobby Cannavale, James Corden, Neil Patrick Harris
Director: Scott Ellis
Mickey-Jo anticipates a successful revival of "Art," drawing parallels to the star power of the original Broadway production. He highlights the play's comedic elements and underlying emotional depth.
“...a sleek and sophisticated comedy directed by Scott Ellis.” [26:30]
Waiting for Godot
Venue: Broadway (Details TBD)
Notable Cast: Keanu Reeves, Alex Winter
Director: Jamie Lloyd Sage
Despite the star-studded cast, Mickey-Jo remains uninterested in the production, citing personal disinterest in the Beckett classic and previous experiences with the director's play revivals.
“I really don't want to see Waiting for Godot.” [29:15]
Oedipus
Venue: Studio 54 by Roundabout Theatre Company
Notable Cast: Mark Strong, Leslie Manville
Director: Robert Eich
A reimagined Greek tragedy that transcends traditional interpretations, "Oedipus" receives high praise for its contemporary relevance and powerful performances. Mickey-Jo considers it a must-see production.
“This is, let me tell you right now, a captivatingly unmissable piece of dramatic theatre.” [34:55]
Margery Prime by Jordan Harrison
Venue: Hayes Theatre, November 2025
Director: Anne Kaufman
Playwright: Jordan Harrison
Exploring themes of aging and artificial intelligence, "Margery Prime" is lauded for its emotional depth and innovative storytelling. Mickey-Jo expresses strong interest in the casting and production quality.
“A heartachingly beautiful rumination on aging and artificial intelligence.” [38:50]
Joe Turner's Come and Gone by August Wilson
Venue: [Details TBD]
Notable Cast: Taraji P. Henson, Cedric the Entertainer
Director: Debbie Allen
Mickey-Jo is excited about this revival, highlighting August Wilson's profound exploration of the Black American experience. The star-studded cast adds to the anticipation.
“This timeless American classic is set in a Pittsburgh boarding house in 1911...” [40:30]
Fallen Angels by Noel Coward
Venue: Todd Haymes Theatre, Spring 2026
Notable Cast: Rose Byrne, Kelli O’Hara
Director: Scott Ellis
A revival of Noel Coward's work, "Fallen Angels" is expected to bring witty and scandalous humor to Broadway. Mickey-Jo expresses enthusiasm for the dynamic between the lead actresses.
“I do love an intoxicating romp from one of theatre's comedy masters.” [43:10]
Becky Shaw by Gina Gianfrey Frido
Venue: Hayes Theatre, March 2026
Director: Trip Coleman
Playwright: Gina Gianfrey Frido
Described as a razor-sharp dark comedy, "Becky Shaw" revolves around a spiraling blind date. Mickey-Jo is intrigued by the critical acclaim and audience buzz from its Off Broadway premiere.
“A big box of fireworks, fizzling and crackling from beginning to end.” [44:25]
Musical Revivals
Mamma Mia
Venue: Winter Garden Theatre
Description: US National Touring Production Returns
"Mamma Mia" makes its return to Broadway through the national touring cast. Mickey-Jo supports its revival for its consistent popularity and charm, especially appealing to tourists.
“...they are the ones who came up with the slogan, you already know that you're going to love it.” [42:40]
Beetlejuice
Venue: Palace Theatre, Broadway
Duration: 13 Weeks
The cult-favorite "Beetlejuice" returns to Broadway, reigniting Mickey-Jo's enthusiasm. He anticipates a vibrant performance that captures the original's energy and appeal.
“This is going to be my opportunity finally to see Beetlejuice on stage.” [43:45]
Chess
Venue: Broadway (Details TBD)
Notable Cast: Aaron Tveit, Liza Michelle, Nick Christopher
Director: [Not Specified]
"Chess" revives on Broadway with a fresh cast and reinterpretation. Mickey-Jo is hopeful for a successful production, recognizing the show's enduring popularity and memorable music.
“I honestly think there is a great show to be made out of Chess.” [44:55]
Ragtime
Venue: Lincoln Center
Notable Cast: Joshua Henry, Casey Levy, Ben Levi Ross, Colin Donnell, Shana Taub
Director: Lea De Bassonnet
One of Mickey-Jo's top anticipated revivals, "Ragtime" promises a stellar cast and exceptional performances. He emphasizes the musical's timeless relevance and exceptional score, considering it a highlight of the season.
“There is no way in hell I am missing Ragtime.” [45:55]
Rocky Horror
Venue: Studio 54, Spring 2026
Director: Sam Pinkleton
Description: Reimagined for Modern Inclusivity
The revival of "Rocky Horror" is set to inject fresh energy and inclusivity into the classic, with Mickey-Jo hopeful for a vibrant and anarchic production that resonates with today's audiences.
“I hope that it is diverse and I hope that it is non binary and trans inclusive as it ought to be.” [46:20]
Conclusion
Mickey-Jo wraps up by reiterating his excitement for key productions like "The Lost Boys," "Punch," "Ragtime," and "Rocky Horror." He encourages listeners to stay tuned for his upcoming reviews and invites them to share their thoughts on the new Broadway offerings.
“...I hope that you share yours in the comments section down below. ...Have a stagey day.” [47:00]
Notable Quotes
- “What does the next season look like? Oh my God.” [02:30]
- “I have no plans to see this, but it's not looking great for me with new plays this season...” [23:15]
- “This just became my most anticipated new play of 2025-2026.” [24:30]
- “There is no way in hell I am missing Ragtime.” [45:55]
Final Thoughts
Mickey-Jo offers a balanced perspective, blending enthusiasm for innovative and high-profile productions with critical insights on less appealing offerings. His passion for theater and deep knowledge make this episode a valuable preview for theater enthusiasts eager to explore the offerings of the next Broadway season.