Summary of "What to see on BROADWAY in 2025 | Mickey-Jo's Guide to the Plays and Musicals of the New York Theatre Season"

Podcast Title: MickeyJoTheatre
Host: MickeyJoTheatre
Episode Title: What to see on BROADWAY in 2025 | Mickey-Jo's guide to the plays and musicals of the New York theatre season
Release Date: January 20, 2025

MickeyJoTheatre's latest episode provides an extensive and insightful guide to the upcoming Broadway season in 2025. As a leading voice in theatre criticism with a vibrant presence on YouTube, Mickey-Jo shares his expertise on the latest shows, casting changes, and what audiences can expect in the bustling New York theatre scene.

Introduction

Mickey-Jo kicks off the episode by expressing excitement over the plethora of brilliant shows currently gracing Broadway. He emphasizes the difficulty in choosing between numerous high-quality productions, setting the stage for a comprehensive rundown of what's to come.

Mickey Jo [00:00]: "The thing is, there are so many brilliant shows on Broadway telling so many important stories, featuring so many extraordinarily talented performers. How could you possibly choose between them?"

He invites listeners to engage by sharing their thoughts and recommendations in the comments, fostering a community of theatre enthusiasts.

Current Broadway Productions

1. O Mary at the Lyceum Theatre

An anarchic queer comedy by Cole Escola continues to captivate audiences. Notably, Betty Gilpin has replaced Cole Escola in the role of Mary Todd Lincoln, sparking intrigue about the fresh dynamic she brings to the performance.

Mickey Jo [02:30]: "But as brilliantly maniacal as Cole's performance was, the writing has always been the most celebrated thing about this play. So I dare say it's going to go on to have continued Broadway success and it's great that it's able to outlive its creator, Cole Escola."

2. Death Becomes Her at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre

A campy and hysterically funny comedy featuring Megan Hilty and Jennifer Simard delivers standout diva performances. Mickey-Jo praises its perfected formula, likening it to successful predecessors like The Addams Family and Beetlejuice.

Mickey Jo [05:45]: "It's perfected the formula that the Addams Family on Broadway was kind of to find that Beetlejuice then got right, but was sort of a little ahead of its time... Death Becomes Her is doing very nicely."

3. A Wonderful World at Studio 54

Jamie Lloyd's musical about Louis Armstrong offers a vibrant portrayal of the jazz legend, navigating his professional life and personal relationships across various cities.

Mickey Jo [08:15]: "I think it's a wonderful time. If you like this kind of a show, then there is Jamie Lloyd's revival of Andrew Lloyd Webber's Sunset Boulevard..."

4. Sunset Boulevard at the St. James Theatre

Starring Nicole Scherzinger, this revival reinvents the classic by minimizing grandiose set pieces in favor of a modern, screen-focused stage design. While divisive, Mickey-Jo lauds its creativity and excitement.

Mickey Jo [11:00]: "It has still proved a little bit divisive, but I think it's doing some of the most creative and exciting and thrilling work in musical theatre revivals right now."

5. Gypsy at the Majestic Theatre

Audra McDonald headlines this iconic musical, bringing her unparalleled talent to one of Broadway's most celebrated roles. Mickey-Jo highly recommends witnessing this historic performance.

Mickey Jo [19:30]: "But you have to go and see Audra ji Gypsy on Broadway. How could you possibly not?"

6. Other Open Productions

• Left on 10th at the James Earl Jones Theatre: A heartfelt play starring Peter Gallagher and Julianna Margulies, inspired by Delia Ephron’s memoir.

• Cult of Love at the Hayes Theatre: Features Zachary Quinto and Shailene Woodley in a family drama set during the festive season.

• Romeo and Juliet at Circle in the Square Theatre: A contemporary take starring Rachel Zegler and Kit Connor, tailored to resonate with younger audiences.

Upcoming Broadway Shows

1. English at the Todd Haimes Theatre

A Pulitzer Prize-winning play by Sanaz Toosi explores Iranian immigrants learning English, set to open on January 23rd. Mickey-Jo anticipates it as a strong contender for the Tony Award for Best New Play.

Mickey Jo [22:45]: "It's definitely one of the big contenders this year for the Tony Award for Best New Play."

2. Redwood at the Nederlander Theatre

Idina Menzel returns to Broadway in this musical about a woman's journey into the mysterious world of redwood trees. Opening officially on March 20th, Mickey-Jo notes its thematic similarities to If/Then and praises Menzel's return.

Mickey Jo [25:10]: "It feels like it has shades of the If Then about it, but Idina Menzel is coming back to Broadway in another star vehicle for her..."

3. Operation Mincemeat at the Golden Theatre

An West End transfer, this show recounts a true WWII deception mission by MI5 agents. Mickey-Jo enthusiastically recommends it, highlighting its blend of humor and intelligence.

Mickey Jo [28:50]: "It's a huge recommendation from me. It's an Olivier Award winning best new musical... Please, please go and see this on Broadway."

4. Buena Vista Social Club at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre

Based on the Cuban band, this musical spans decades and explores the impact of communism on musicians. It's slated as a potential Tony Award contender.

Mickey Jo [31:20]: "It's developed and directed by Tony Award winner Alex Timbers... I am excited to see Jonathan Groff do this."

5. Othello at the Barrymore Theatre

Starring Denzel Washington and Jake Gyllenhaal, with Molly Osbourne as Desdemona, this Shakespearean drama promises a fresh take on the classic, particularly through its casting choices.

Mickey Jo [34:10]: "I think she might just surprise audiences as one of the highlights of this production."

6. Purpose at the Hayes Theatre

Written by Brandon Jacobs Jenkins, this family drama delves into themes of faith and black radicalism. Directed by Felicia Richard, it promises a mix of humor and intrigue.

7. Glengarry Glen Ross at the Palace Theatre

Featuring Kieran Culkin, Bob Odenkirk, and Bill Burr, this Pulitzer Prize-winning play brings fresh energy to Mamet's intense narrative. Mickey-Jo expresses personal reservations but acknowledges the stellar cast.

Mickey Jo [40:30]: "I am likely to be putting that aside and will hope to catch this this season. If nothing else, I'm sure the performances will be brilliant."

8. The Picture of Dorian Gray at the Music Box Theatre

A one-person adaptation starring Sarah Snook, this production utilizes innovative staging with cameras to enhance the narrative, exploring themes of youth and vanity.

9. Boop at the Belasco Theatre

Set to open on April 5th, this musical brings the iconic Betty Boop to life with direction by Jerry Mitchell. Mickey-Jo describes it as vibrant and enchanted.

Mickey Jo [45:50]: "It's utterly beautiful and enchanting... It's the most utterly beautiful and enchanting show."

10. Smash at the Broadhurst Theatre

An adaptation of the NBC series, this musical comedy stars Robin Herder and Krysta Rodriguez, focusing on the behind-the-scenes creation of a Marilyn Monroe musical.

11. Goodnight and Good Luck at the Winter Garden Theatre

George Clooney headlines this stage adaptation of the critically acclaimed film, depicting Edward R. Murrow's confrontation with Senator Joseph McCarthy.

Mickey Jo [50:00]: "I think the premise sounds a little stronger than the likes of McNeill... Obviously, George Clooney's presence is going to make this a hot ticket."

12. The Last Five Years at the Hudson Theatre

A musical song cycle starring Nick Jonas and Adrienne Warren marks its Broadway debut. Mickey-Jo expresses confusion over the casting choices but remains intrigued by the creative team.

13. John Proctor at the Booth Theatre

Starring Sadie Sink, this play offers a modern take on The Crucible, blending contemporary themes with classic narratives. Directed by Danya Taymor, it's praised for its vitality and urgency.

14. Old Friends at the Samuel J. Friedman Theatre

A Stephen Sondheim revue featuring Bernadette Peters and Lea Salonga, celebrating Sondheim's legacy with a mix of classics and lesser-known pieces.

15. Floyd Collins at Lincoln Center Theatre

Featuring Jeremy Jordan, this musical recounts the true story of a cave explorer trapped in Kentucky in 1925. With music by Adam Gettel and direction by Tina Landau, it's highlighted for its emotional depth.

16. Just In Time at Circle in the Square Theatre

A jukebox musical about Bobby Darin, starring Jonathan Groff. Directed by Alex Timbers, it promises a lively homage to Darin's musical legacy.

17. Stranger: The First Shadow? at the Marquee Theatre

A prequel to Stranger Things, this production incorporates extensive use of cameras on stage, enhancing the storytelling with modern visual effects.

18. Real Women Have Curves at the James Earl Jones Theatre

Based on Josefina Lopez's play, this musical set in 1987 East Los Angeles explores themes of ambition, family expectations, and community resilience.

19. Pirates! The Penzance Musical at the Todd Haimes Theatre

An adaptation of Gilbert and Sullivan's classic, starring Ramin Karimloo, Jinkx Monsoon, and David Hyde Pierce. Directed by Scott Ellis, it infuses New Orleans' jazzy bluesy vibes into the traditional narrative.

20. Outlaw at the Longacre Theatre

Winner of Best Musical at multiple Off-Broadway awards, this darkly hilarious musical delves into the true story of Elmer McCurdy, exploring fame, legacy, and the meaning of life.

Long-Running Shows to Revisit

1. Hadestown

With the addition of Hayley Kilgore as Eurydice, this beloved musical continues to draw audiences with its compelling storytelling and dynamic performances.

2. Moulin Rouge

New cast members John Cardoza and Solea Pfeiffer bring fresh energy to this vibrant production, which Mickey-Jo considers worth revisiting for their exceptional casting.

3. Cabaret

Featuring Adam Lambert alongside new cast members Eva Noblezada and Orville Peck, this classic musical receives a modern twist. Jessica Vosk and Erika Jayne add further star power, with Mickey-Jo highlighting the unique casting dynamics.

4. The Great Gatsby at the Broadway Theatre

Starring Ryan McCarten and Sarah Hyland, this adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel offers fresh performances that Mickey-Jo encourages listeners to experience.

5. Additional Mentions

Mickey-Jo briefly touches upon All in Comedy and other ongoing productions, suggesting listeners explore based on their interests.

Recommendations and Insights

Mickey-Jo advises audiences to consider various factors when selecting shows, such as:

• Star Performers: Leveraging the appeal of renowned actors like Idina Menzel, Denzel Washington, and George Clooney.

• Creative Teams: Highlighting the importance of directors, writers, and composers behind the scenes.

• Genre Variety: Encouraging exploration across different genres, from dark dramas to light-hearted comedies and innovative musicals.

• Community Engagement: Sharing thoughts and experiences to enhance the collective theatre-going experience.

Mickey Jo [58:00]: "Look to the creatives, look to the writers, whose plays you have enjoyed previously. Look to the directors, look to the composers of those musicals."

Conclusion

Mickey-Jo wraps up the episode by reiterating the abundance of quality Broadway offerings for Spring 2025. He encourages listeners to engage with the vibrant theatre community, revisit beloved shows with new casts, and explore fresh productions that push creative boundaries.

Mickey Jo [1:00:30]: "I hope that this has been helpful. Let me know if you are making Broadway plans and you have any other adjacent questions."

He also promotes his YouTube channel for those interested in more in-depth reviews, vlogs, and theatrical content, emphasizing the multifaceted approach of MickeyJoTheatre in celebrating and critiquing the world of theatre.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• On Choosing Shows:

  "How could you possibly choose between them?"
  [00:00]
  Mickey Jo

• On Continued Success of O Mary:

  "The writing has always been the most celebrated thing about this play. So I dare say it's going to go on to have continued Broadway success and it's great that it's able to outlive its creator, Cole Escola."
  [04:10]
  Mickey Jo

• On Death Becomes Her's Humor:

  "It's perfected the formula... Death Becomes Her is doing very nicely."
  [06:45]
  Mickey Jo

• On Sunset Boulevard's Innovation:

  "Whether it's Nicole Scherzinger's barnstorming central performance... It has still proved a little bit divisive, but I think it's doing some of the most creative and exciting and thrilling work in musical theatre revivals right now."
  [14:20]
  Mickey Jo

• On Gypsy's Star Power:

  "You have to go and see Audra ji Gypsy on Broadway. How could you possibly not?"
  [18:50]
  Mickey Jo

• On Operation Mincemeat's Recommendation:

  "It's a huge recommendation from me. It's an Olivier Award winning best new musical... Please, please go and see this on Broadway."
  [28:55]
  Mickey Jo

• On Purpose's Epic Nature:

  "Purpose is an epic family drama from one of the country's most celebrated voices."
  [38:15]
  Mickey Jo

• On Goodnight and Good Luck's Compelling Themes:

  "As McCarthyism casts a shadow over America, Murrow and his team... choose to confront the growing tide of paranoia and propaganda."
  [49:20]
  Mickey Jo

• On Real Women Have Curves' Heartwarming Story:

  "It's a funny, joyous and empowering new show coming to Broadway this April."
  [59:45]
  Mickey Jo

• On Outlaw's Exploration of Fame:

  "The show explores fame, failure and the meaning or utter meaninglessness of legacy."
  [1:03:10]
  Mickey Jo

Final Thoughts

Mickey-Jo concludes by acknowledging the vast array of shows available, encouraging listeners to delve into productions that resonate with their personal tastes and interests. He reminds audiences to stay engaged, explore diverse narratives, and support the thriving Broadway community.

Mickey Jo [1:04:50]: "I hope that this has been helpful. Let me know if you are making Broadway plans and you have any other adjacent questions."

With a blend of enthusiasm and professional insight, MickeyJoTheatre continues to be an invaluable resource for theatre lovers navigating the dynamic landscape of Broadway.