Podcast Summary: "Why Didn't Broadway Love SUNSET BLVD? | Review Roundup of the Revival Starring Nicole Scherzinger"
Host: MickeyJoTheatre
Release Date: October 23, 2024
Podcast: MickeyJoTheatre
1. Introduction and Background
In this episode, Mickey Jo delves into the mixed critical reception of the latest Broadway revival of "Sunset Boulevard," starring Nicole Scherzinger. Having experienced the show twice in the West End, Mickey Jo contrasts its successful run in London with its lukewarm reception on Broadway. He sets the stage by highlighting the show's accolades in the West End, including multiple Olivier Awards, and questions why the Broadway transfer hasn't mirrored this success.
2. Overview of the Sunset Boulevard Revival
"Sunset Boulevard" is a musical adaptation of Billy Wilder's classic film, featuring Nicole Scherzinger as Norma Desmond and Tom Francis as Joe Gillis. Directed by Jamie Lloyd, the production is noted for its minimalist staging, extensive use of onstage cameras, and a departure from the lavish sets traditionally associated with Broadway musicals. Mickey Jo emphasizes the stark differences between the London and New York productions, particularly in their aesthetic and technical execution.
3. Comparative Reception: West End vs. Broadway
While the West End production received significant acclaim, winning multiple Olivier Awards and captivating audiences with its modernized approach, the Broadway revival has faced a more divided response. Mickey Jo explores whether factors such as cultural differences, critical biases, or production choices have contributed to this disparity.
4. Detailed Analysis of Critical Reviews
a. New York Times - Jesse Green (Mixed Review) [Timestamp: 12:34]
Jesse Green offers a nuanced critique, acknowledging the innovative use of video projections but questioning whether the minimalist approach detracts from the show's emotional depth. He remarks:
“Nicole Scherzinger's performance is exceptional but feels more like a series of gestures rather than a cohesive characterization. [12:34]”
Green appreciates the technical prowess but feels the musical's lyrical and narrative elements fall short.
b. New York Times - Matt Wolfe (Positive Review) [Timestamp: 25:10]
Contrasting Green's perspective, Matt Wolfe praises the stripped-back aesthetic and Scherzinger's captivating portrayal:
“Jamie Lloyd’s streamlined approach has a power of its own. Scherzinger finds a predatory allure in the character that is both captivating and chilling. [25:10]”
Wolfe highlights the modern relevance and the fresh take on Norma Desmond, commending the production's boldness.
c. New York Post - Johnny Oleksinski (Highly Positive Review) [Timestamp: 40:22]
Johnny Oleksinski showers praise on Scherzinger and the overall production quality:
“Nicole Scherzinger Stuns in Scorching Brilliant Broadway Revival. [40:22]”
He lauds the emotional intensity, innovative staging, and suggests that Scherzinger's performance is Tony Award-worthy.
d. The Wrap - Robert Hoffler (Negative Review) [Timestamp: 55:45]
Robert Hoffler criticizes the overuse of cameras and minimalist set design:
“The camera work is so overused, it can only be hoped that it inspires a moratorium on utilizing such recording devices in the theatre. [55:45]”
Hoffler feels that these choices alienate traditional theatergoers and detract from the storytelling.
e. Vulture - Sarah Holdren (Mixed Review) [Timestamp: 1:10:30]
Sarah Holdren offers a balanced view, appreciating certain elements while critiquing others:
“Scherzinger's ravenous performance provides a great part of the adrenaline, but the show's also jolted into new life by the collision of the spartan aesthetics with Lloyd Webber's score. [1:10:30]”
She commends the integration of video design but finds some performances and narrative choices lacking.
f. Variety (Highly Positive Review) [Timestamp: 1:25:50]
Variety praises the visual and emotional impact of the production:
“This is the latest in the British director's series of provocations. [1:25:50]”
Highlights include the minimalist staging, dynamic choreography, and Scherzinger’s immersive performance.
g. Time Out - Adam Feldman (Positive Review) [Timestamp: 1:40:15]
Adam Feldman appreciates the show's ambition while noting minor flaws:
“Not for nothing has the title been shortened to Sunset Bloovered, which is a good point. [1:40:15]”
He commends the lighting and video design but critiques certain aspects of the musical score and character development.
h. New York Theatre Guide - Frank Scheck (Negative Review) [Timestamp: 1:55:40]
Frank Scheck expresses strong reservations about the production’s direction and design choices:
“The director of the new revival...gives us close-ups of not only all the principal actors but every chorister as well. [1:55:40]”
Scheck argues that the technical elements overshadow the narrative and character depth, deeming the production divisive.
5. Common Themes in Reviews
Minimalist Staging vs. Lavish Sets: The revival's departure from opulent set designs to a more stripped-down aesthetic has been a polarizing factor. While some critics laud this approach for its modernity and focus on character, others feel it diminishes the grandeur expected of a Broadway production.
Use of Onstage Cameras: The extensive use of live video feeds and projections has been a contentious point. Proponents see it as an innovative storytelling tool, while detractors believe it disrupts the theatrical illusion and distracts the audience.
Casting Choices and Performances: Nicole Scherzinger's portrayal of Norma Desmond has received widespread acclaim for its intensity and uniqueness. However, some critics question her age and appearance in relation to the character, leading to debates about authenticity and typecasting.
Director Jamie Lloyd’s Vision: Lloyd’s approach is acknowledged for its boldness and creativity, though not universally appreciated. His aim to modernize and infuse new life into a classic has been both praised and criticized for its effectiveness.
6. MickeyJoTheatre’s Perspective and Conclusion
Mickey Jo synthesizes these diverse critiques, acknowledging the subjective nature of theater and the inevitable divergence in opinions. He personally rates the Broadway revival highly, appreciating its innovative approach and Scherzinger’s standout performance. Mickey Jo encourages listeners to form their own opinions, emphasizing the importance of experiencing the production firsthand to fully grasp its nuances.
He also touches upon the possibility of Broadway critics' historical biases against Andrew Lloyd Webber's works contributing to the mixed reception. Mickey Jo concludes by inviting his audience to share their experiences and thoughts on the revival, fostering an engaging dialogue within the theater community.
Notable Quotes with Attribution and Timestamps
-
Jesse Green (New York Times):
“Nicole Scherzinger's performance is exceptional but feels more like a series of gestures rather than a cohesive characterization. [12:34]”
-
Matt Wolfe (New York Times):
“Jamie Lloyd’s streamlined approach has a power of its own. Scherzinger finds a predatory allure in the character that is both captivating and chilling. [25:10]”
-
Johnny Oleksinski (New York Post):
“Nicole Scherzinger Stuns in Scorching Brilliant Broadway Revival. [40:22]”
-
Robert Hoffler (The Wrap):
“The camera work is so overused, it can only be hoped that it inspires a moratorium on utilizing such recording devices in the theatre. [55:45]”
-
Sarah Holdren (Vulture):
“Scherzinger's ravenous performance provides a great part of the adrenaline, but the show's also jolted into new life by the collision of the spartan aesthetics with Lloyd Webber's score. [1:10:30]”
-
Variety:
“This is the latest in the British director's series of provocations. [1:25:50]”
-
Adam Feldman (Time Out):
“Not for nothing has the title been shortened to Sunset Bloovered, which is a good point. [1:40:15]”
-
Frank Scheck (New York Theatre Guide):
“The director of the new revival...gives us close-ups of not only all the principal actors but every chorister as well. [1:55:40]”
Final Thoughts
Mickey Jo effectively navigates through a spectrum of critical opinions, providing listeners with a comprehensive understanding of why "Sunset Boulevard" may not have resonated as strongly on Broadway as it did in the West End. By highlighting both the innovative elements and the contentious choices of the production, he offers a balanced perspective that encourages theater enthusiasts to engage critically and personally with the revival.
For a more in-depth analysis, including Mickey Jo's personal review and discussions on specific production elements, listeners are encouraged to watch the full episode on his YouTube channel.