Old Time Radio Westerns Podcast Summary

Episode: Neal Butler’s Stage Ride | The Lone Ranger (10-13-39)
Host: Andrew Rhines
Release Date: February 1, 2025

Introduction

In this gripping episode of the Old Time Radio Westerns podcast, host Andrew Rhines presents a digitally restored classic Western radio drama from October 13, 1939, titled Neal Butler’s Stage Ride. This installment features the legendary masked hero, The Lone Ranger, as he delves into a tale of tragedy, redemption, and justice on the perilous trails of the Wild West.

Setting the Scene

The episode opens with a vivid description of the treacherous stage routes in the early western United States, highlighting the constant threat of outlaws and the challenging terrain:

Narrator [04:27]: "Travel was dangerous in the early days of the western United States. The stage routes crossed rough country where outlaws made their hideout, and the trails themselves were poorly marked and so narrow that only an expert could handle the lumbering coaches."

This sets the stage for the introduction of The Lone Ranger, whose mission is to bring safety and justice to these lawless areas.

Neal Butler's Turmoil

The central character, Neal Butler, is introduced in a state of distress:

Narrator [05:25]: "Neil Butler had slumped to his bed, far too exhausted to undress. But in spite of his exhaustion, he soon began to toss and turn, muttering in his sleep."

Neal is haunted by guilt over a tragic accident that occurred during his time as a stage driver, where a storm led to a disastrous derailment resulting in the deaths of passengers and fellow guards. His torment is palpable as he grapples with nightmares and the relentless accusations from the townsfolk:

Neal Butler [05:49]: "The devils can't sleep. Always seeing them. I'm hearing them going crazy. Get away."

The Rescue

The Lone Ranger intervenes as Neal's despair deepens. Leading his trusted horse, Silver, and his Native American companion, Tonto, The Lone Ranger locates Neal and attempts to comfort him:

Lone Ranger [07:24]: "Silver."

Narrator [07:39]: "Two hours later, a blanket clutched to his shoulders, Neil Butler stared glumly into the campfire the masked man had built."

The Lone Ranger encourages Neal to share his story, believing that understanding the past is key to moving forward:

Lone Ranger [08:07]: "It won't harm you unless you have something to hide."

Neal reluctantly begins to recount the harrowing events that led to the accident, providing crucial details about the stage ride and the severe weather conditions that plagued their journey.

Unraveling the Mystery

As Neal narrates, flashbacks reveal the tense atmosphere during the fateful stage ride. The severe storm, slippery trails, and Neal's determination to uphold his duty despite warnings create a backdrop ripe for disaster:

Neal Butler [09:56]: "Maybe I don't take the stage on weather like this as a rule, but them passengers inside was dead set on getting through."

The Lone Ranger discerns that the accident may not have been a mere result of poor judgment but hints at possible foul play intended to sabotage the stage route and rob the carriage of its valuable cargo.

Confrontation with Jensen

The plot thickens as The Lone Ranger and Neal follow the damaged trail to uncover evidence of deliberate tampering. Their investigation leads them to Jensen, a former colleague who appears suspiciously wealthy despite his modest past:

Lone Ranger [16:25]: "You understand that this goes to prove the trail had been deliberately weakened before you came over it with a stage."

Confronting Jensen, it becomes evident that he orchestrated the accident to steal a large sum of money being transported by the stagecoach. The tension culminates in a dramatic showdown where Jensen admits his guilt but pleads for mercy:

Jensen [28:47]: "I did it. I admit it. But I don't want to die."

The Lone Ranger swiftly neutralizes the threat, ensuring Jensen faces justice while clearing Neal's name.

Resolution

With Jensen apprehended and the truth unveiled, Neal Butler is relieved of the wrongful accusations against him. The Lone Ranger's intervention not only restores Neal's reputation but also reaffirms the masked hero's commitment to protecting the innocent and upholding justice in the Wild West:

Lone Ranger [30:45]: "Neil is cleared."

Neal expresses his gratitude to The Lone Ranger, acknowledging the hero's pivotal role in resolving his turmoil:

Neal Butler [30:45]: "You're done more for me already than I can ever replace."

Conclusion

Neal Butler’s Stage Ride is a compelling narrative that intertwines themes of guilt, redemption, and the relentless pursuit of justice. Through the masterful restoration, listeners are transported back to the golden age of radio Westerns, experiencing enhanced audio that brings the Wild West to life with vivid soundscapes and authentic performances. Andrew Rhines successfully honors the legacy of iconic shows like The Lone Ranger, delivering a timeless story that resonates with both new audiences and longtime fans.

Notable Quotes

• Lone Ranger [08:07]: "It won't harm you unless you have something to hide." (08:07)

• Neal Butler [05:49]: "The devils can't sleep. Always seeing them. I'm hearing them going crazy. Get away." (05:49)

• Jensen [28:47]: "I did it. I admit it. But I don't want to die." (28:47)

• Neal Butler [30:45]: "You're done more for me already than I can ever replace." (30:45)

This episode exemplifies the enduring appeal of Western dramas, combining suspenseful storytelling with rich character development. Whether you're a seasoned listener or new to Old Time Radio Westerns, Neal Butler’s Stage Ride offers an immersive experience into the heart of the Wild West.