No Indians {reused script} | Gunsmoke (03-26-61)

Summary

---

Old Time Radio Westerns: Gunsmoke – “No Indians {reused script}”

Podcast Host: Andrew Rhynes
Episode Date: October 25, 2025
Original Air Date: March 26, 1961

---

Episode Overview

In this episode, Andrew Rhynes presents a digitally restored classic from the legendary radio series Gunsmoke. The story, “No Indians,” explores violence and justice on the frontier, as Marshal Matt Dillon investigates a series of brutal homestead murders initially blamed on Pawnee Indians. As facts unravel, Dillon suspects the true culprits are white outlaws using the chaos of Indian raids as a cover for their crimes. This episode is a poignant reflection on prejudice, corruption, and the grim realities of frontier law.

---

Key Discussion Points & Storyline

Setting the Stage in Dodge City

• [03:10–05:04] The episode opens with Marshal Matt Dillon, Doc, Kitty, and Chester discussing the tense atmosphere in Dodge City after a series of violent homestead raids blamed on Pawnee Indians. Some settlers are fleeing, while others demand more protection.
• Quote:
  • "He says he's quitting… Pawnees wiped out another family up near his place on the Smoky Hill River… that's the second raid in the last two weeks…" – Doc (04:12)
  • "I'm not hired to fight Indians, Sam. That's the Army's job." – Matt Dillon (06:00)

Anger and Accusation

• [05:23–06:38] Sam Butler, a distraught settler, blames the law for failing to protect homesteaders. Dillon remains cautious but sympathetic, realizing there’s something odd about the raids.

Investigating the Raids

• [07:10–11:56] Matt Dillon and Chester join cavalry under Captain Star to investigate another attack. They discover a family slaughtered and scalped, including a young girl.
• Marshall Dillon begins doubting that Indians are responsible, noting inconsistencies in the attacks (use of rifles, no evidence of arrows, covering tracks, and victims killed in the open).
• Quote:
  • "All three of these settler families were killed in the open outside their cabins… not many arrows around… they were shot with rifles." – Matt Dillon (10:20)
  • "I don't think it was Pawnees that done this, Mr. Dillon." – Chester (11:16)

Critical Realization

• [11:36–12:52] Dillon explains to Captain Star that Pawnees would have captured a boy that age rather than kill him, reinforcing his suspicion that the killers are white outlaws, not Indians.
• Quote:
  • "It wasn't Pawnees that did this, Captain. Wasn't Indians at all. It was white men." – Matt Dillon (11:56)
  • "Captain, did you ever hear what Chivington did to the Cheyennes at Sand Creek...? There was white men that did it." – Matt Dillon (12:24)

Plan to Trap the Killers

• [13:20–14:44] Matt suggests setting a trap at an old corral by baiting it with cavalry horses. Captain Star wants to use his troops, but Dillon insists that only he and Chester should stay to avoid spooking the culprits.

The Trap is Set

• [14:54–16:48] During the stakeout, tension mounts. A lone cowboy, Lee Stapp, approaches, pretending to be lost and looking for work. Dillon notices discrepancies in his story and tricks him, revealing Stapp is part of the outlaw gang.
  • Memorable Moment:
    • Dillon observes that Stapp's horse is thirsty, exposing his lie about a “dry camp.”
    • "You said you made a dry camp last night. How come you tie your horse up without watering him while you stand here slopping up coffee?" – Matt Dillon (16:10)

The Confrontation

• [18:35–22:22] Soon, the rest of the gang approaches. Dillon and Chester prepare for an ambush, forcibly silencing Stapp to prevent him warning his pals. A tense gun battle ensues: four outlaws are killed, three survivors captured.
• Quote:
  • *"I'm going to do something I never did before in my life..." – Matt Dillon (19:12)
  • "When I start shooting, you start… you take whoever’s on your side first." – Matt Dillon (20:10)*

Evidence and Justice

• [22:18–24:17] Dillon confronts the prisoners, producing a yellow hair ribbon found in Stapp’s pocket—a piece of evidence taken from the murdered girl.
• Quote:
  • "That was just kind of a souvenir… I told you to root everything, you know, Stapp." – Stapp and gang member (23:41)
  • "It's that little girl’s yellow hair ribbon that's going to hang you." – Matt Dillon (24:08)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Misattributed Guilt:
  "It wasn't Pawnees that did this, Captain. Wasn't Indians at all. It was white men." – Matt Dillon (11:56)

• On the Harshness of Frontier Justice:
  "I'm going to do something I never did before in my life…" – Matt Dillon (19:12)

• The Clue that Unmasks the Killers:
  "I found this yellow hair ribbon in your friend Stapp's pocket… it's that little girl’s yellow hair ribbon that's going to hang you." – Matt Dillon (24:08)

---

Key Segment Timestamps

• 03:10 – Life in Dodge City, settler anxieties
• 05:23–06:38 – Sam Butler’s confrontation with Dillon
• 07:10–11:56 – Discovery of the massacre; initial investigation
• 13:20–14:44 – Planning the sting at the corral
• 14:54–16:48 – The encounter and exposure of Lee Stapp
• 18:35–22:22 – Ambush of outlaws, gunfight, and capture
• 22:18–24:17 – Item reveal, confession, and moral reckoning

---

Tone & Style

The episode maintains the somber, gritty realism characteristic of Gunsmoke. Marshal Dillon is resolute, morally grounded, yet haunted by the violence he confronts, while supporting characters provide moments of reflection, bitterness, and subtle humor. The pacing is methodical, building suspense toward a climactic confrontation.

---

Summary for New Listeners

This gripping episode of Gunsmoke delves into the complexities of justice in the Old West, challenging assumptions about crime and punishment. Marshal Dillon, refusing to accept the easy answer, uncovers a chilling scheme of murder and theft perpetrated by white outlaws hiding behind the shadow of indigenous raids—a powerful story of frontier law’s burden and the cost of prejudice.

---

Transcript

[ByHeart Formula Advertiser]

The questions start early how do I know when he's full?

Do babies hold grudges?

That's why we make one formula that feels right right away. Backed by breast milk science and built for babies brains, bellies and beyond. Learn [e-mail] the questions start early how do I know when he's full?

Do babies hold grudges?

That's why we make one formula that feels right right away. One that's clinically proven with immune supporting benefits in every scoop. Learn [e-mail] Foreign.

Welcome to the Old Time Radio Westerns. I'm your host, Andrew Rines, and I'm excited to bring you another episode absolutely free. This is one of over 80 episodes released monthly for your enjoyment. Now let's get into this episode.

[Narrator/Characters from Gun Smoke and OTRWesterns]

Around Dodge City and in the territory on west. There's just one way to handle the killers and the spoilers, and that's with a U.S. marshal. And the smell of gun smoke. Starring William Conrad. The story of the violence that moved west with young America and the story of a man who moved with it. I'm that man, Matt Dillon, United States Marshal, the first man they look for and the last they want to meet. It's a chancy job and it makes a man watchful and a little lonely.

[ByHeart Formula Advertiser]

The questions start early how do I know when he's full?

Do babies hold grudges?

That's why we make one formula that feels right right away. One that's clinically proven with immune supporting benefits in every scoop.

[Narrator/Characters from Gun Smoke and OTRWesterns]

Learn [e-mail] have you noticed you hear something new at Soda Thumbs today? People are saying, pepsi please. Pepsi please. Why don't you say it too? And enjoy a light, clean tasting fountain. Pepsi Cola. So stop in tune, get off your feet. Your fountain service can't be beat. Murky dance cheese say pipsy please. Now it's pips. Be for those who think. Yeah, Matt, I'd sure like to meet whoever's around. In the kitchen in this place. Oh, my kitty. A cook that can make antelope stew taste like prairie dog ought to be something to see. Well, at least it's. No, it's not. Well, mine is. You're forgetting you dumped half that bowl of chili peppers in yours, you spoiled kitty. Dodgers in St. Louis. St. Louis? I was there six months, four years ago. Hello, Doc. How are you, Doc? Oh, fine, fine. Sit down, sit down. What are you eating? Stew. Well, that's what they call it. Well, I'll try a little anyway. Then I'm gonna go to bed at noon I was up all night, Kitty, out at the brandt place. Ah, Mrs. Brant have a baby? Yes, boy. That's five I've delivered out there. Seems to me it's about time they gave you one, Doc. No. No, thanks. I've got enough trouble all by myself. But I'll tell you something, Matt. It's got so I'm afraid to be driving under the prairie at all. More Indians? I ran into Sam Butler just outside there. He drove in with his whole family and all his belongings loaded onto his wagon. He says he's quitting. Why? Pawnees wiped out another family up near his place on the Smoky Hill River a couple of days ago. That's the second raid of the last two weeks. No wonder he's scared, Matt. He's telling everyone who will listen that it's a shameful thing for the law to be hiding out in Dodge City while whole families are being slaughtered in the country. He is, huh? Yes, I thought you'd like to know. You sit with Kenny, Doc. I'm gonna go have a talk with Sam Butler. Sure. See you both later. I'm saying that any man that stays out there and exposes his family to them murdering savages is plum crazy. You can't fight a Pawnee war party all by yourself. And we sure ain't getting no help from the law around here. We can die and rot for all the law cares. Hello, Sam. Well, where have you been hiding, Marshall? I hear the Pawnees made another raid up near you. If you call shooting and scalping a man and his wife and her two boys a raid, those men never had a chance to fight. Far as I see men, the boys were cutting on 14 or 15 old enough to handle a rifle if they got caught outside. They never even made the house. Never made the house. I seen them with my own eyes, Marshal. And if you'd seen them, you'd be doing something about it instead of sitting around here and dodge. I'm not hired to fight Indians, Sam. That's the Army's job. Then you ought to be out helping Army. Every lawman in the country oughta. The army doesn't need help. But there's something strange about those on these. What's strange about him? He's killed white men before. I think I'll ride up there and look around. I'm sorry you're quitting, Sam. We need settlers out here. Not dead ones, you don't. No, that's right. Not dead ones.

[ByHeart Formula Advertiser]

The questions start early, and then they start multiplying.

Do babies hold grudges?

How do I know when he's full?

Logging poops, comma, necessary.

Raising kids raises enough questions. That's why we make one formula that feels right right away. One made by pediatricians and parents like you. Backed by breast milk science and built for babies, brains, bellies and beyond. You'll wonder about everything except this. The formula that answers. Learn [e-mail] A new week in the.

[Narrator/Characters from Gun Smoke and OTRWesterns]

CBS Radio Network calendar of events brings with it hourly on the hour, longer, stronger CBS News coverage to keep informed on developments near and far. Lend an ear here and keep in mind as your day and week progress. Not only the news, but its color and background are amply covered by this station. The CBS Radio Network features Sidelights with Douglas Edwards probes a new aspect of latest events each weekday in the lively feature of Woman's Washington. CBS newswoman Nancy Huntschman reviews the Capitol scene for stories of highest current interest. David Schoenbron serves amiably as your man in Paris to unlock secrets of the City of Light. Alan Jackson offers fascinating facts of every kind on Information Central. Zachary Scott reveals the romantic backgrounds of famous people in man and Wife. These are among your daily listening features on the network with the different sound in news and information. CBS Radio available where you're listening now. Chester and I left Dodge that afternoon and toward evening the next day we ran across a troop of cavalry camped on the Smoky Hill river and commanded by a young officer who was new to this part of the country, a Captain Star. He was anxious to make a success of his first expedition, but so far he hadn't even seen an Indian. I decided to stay with him for a while, and I'm glad I did. The next afternoon while we were on the march, his scouts reported another settler's cabin burned, the family killed. At my request, Captain Starr filed his troop out on patrols while he and Chester and I rode forward to the scene of the squad, the whole family, man and wife and their boy. Look over there, Chester, against the water barrel. Oh, my. It's a little girl. Yeah, they scalped them. Every one of them. Even that little girl. They even scalped her. At least they didn't torture them. Did they torture the other family, Captain? No, they didn't, Marshall. They shot them just like this. Scalped them. Where are you going, Marshall? What is it? Captain Starm, last night you told me this is your first tour of duty in Indian country. That's right, Marshal. Take a look around, Captain. I have. All right. All three of these settler families were killed in the open outside their cabins. Now does that mean anything to you? Well, I guess the Pawnees surprised them. They sure did. There are not many arrows around. If these people had had a chance to put up a fight, there'd be a lot of arrows. They were shot martial with rifles. Look at the ground, Captain. There are no tracks. Every sign of the track's been dragged out with a blanket. Yes, you're right. I hadn't noticed that. There's one other thing you hadn't noticed, or maybe you don't know about. What's that? That boy there. How old would you say he was? Oh, about the same age as the boy, as the last place, maybe 12, 13. Yeah, Captain, that's old enough to be a brave in a couple of years. If he was a Pawnee. Now, what do you mean, if he was a Pawnee? They usually keep a boy that age. They don't kill him. They take him and try to make a brave out of him. Oh. Oh, I didn't know that. You don't think it was Pawnees that done this, Mr. John? No, I don't, Chester. That Warren Moccasins doesn't care about his tracks. He's got nothing to hide. I'm afraid I don't understand, Marshall. It wasn't Pawnees that did this, Captain. Wasn't Indians at all. It was white men. Marshall Dillon. Yeah? No white man would shoot that little girl over there and then the scalper. Captain, did you ever hear what Chivington did to the Cheyennes at Sand Creek? Kill and scalp them all, he said. Big and little nits make lice. Congress has repudiated that whole affair, Martin. It still happened, Captain, and there was still white men that did it. Yes, I suppose you're right. Amorites. But why did they do it? That was horses. See that corral out there? This man must have had six, seven head of horses. Yes, the other settlers did, too. They stole the horses and probably whatever they could find in the cabins. And right now they're sitting around camp somewhere drinking coffee and laughing at all of us Indian hunters. I'll find them. It's a big country, Captain. I've got a troop of cavalry out there, Marshal. Over a hundred men. All right. Suppose you do find some riders with a bunch of horses. How are you going to know they're the men you're after? Those horses are branded, aren't they? What brands? I don't know, but they must be registered somewhere. Yeah, maybe while you're finding all that out, some of the families are going to be slaughtered. No, Captain, there isn't Time. I didn't realize how new I am at this game, Marshall. What would you suggest? Well, there used to be a corral about five miles up river from here. They'll stand in. We'll bait it with a couple of dozen head of good cavalry horses. They'll come to us. Good idea. And I'll have my troop deployed and ready to move in. No, that wouldn't work, Captain. You can't hide a hundred men. You'll have to keep your cavalry clear away. But how can be. Chester and I'll be there. We'll. We'll wait for him. Here's another. Green branches, Mr. Johnson?

[ByHeart Formula Advertiser]

Yeah.

[Narrator/Characters from Gun Smoke and OTRWesterns]

We'll throw them on the fire chest till. Let's have some more smoke. Yeah, that'll do it. How to see that? If they're anywhere this side of the Rocky Mountains, they're sure to be scouting around. They ain't stolen enough forces to leave the country yet. Besides, they're feeling mighty safe. They'll come. Mr. Dillon. Yeah? I've been thinking. It's dawn. That'll make you rich, Chester. Not thinking. I don't care so much about being rich as going on living. Now, what's bothering you? Well, sir, there's only two of us. I was wondering how many there are of them. You want to go back and find the cavalry? You didn't answer my question, Mr. Johnson. How many you think we're waiting for? There's no way of telling. Well, if there's a whole pass of them, how in the world are we going to take them? I don't really care how we take them. Just. You're pretty mad, ain't you? Just can't get that little girl out of my mind, huh? Look up somebody. He's all alone. Just some cowboy, probably. Maybe. Yeah, sure it is. He seen smoke bar fire. Now he's wondering what that old corral's doing full of horses. He might be scouting it for the others. Those men don't take many chances. How are we going to find out? Maybe we won't till it's too late. You heat up some coffee for him. Trust it. I think I'll have a cup of that, too. Morning. Don't you get on, stranger. We'll have some hot coffee up in a minute. Let d my horse here. Sure used some coffee. I had to make dry camp last night. Oh, you couldn't have been very far away. Why didn't you ride on down to the river here? I'll tell you why, mister. I was lost. Rode till after dark. Got lost. Your Horse could have found it for you, though. Maybe my horse ain't as smart as yours. No offense. Sit down. Chester's bringing the coffee now then sit in. All morning. Hey. Hi, mister. We ain't got no sugar. You've been traveling pretty light, ain't you? What do you mean? Here's your cousin. Oh, thanks. Seen all them horses? Mighty big. Remote of them. No wagons, not much grub. I can see they were driving those horses to Cheyenne. There's only two of us. We couldn't handle a wagon in the herd. Both. Oh, only two of you? Yes, sir. Well, I'm drifting, mister. Maybe you could use another hand. Maybe. Where you from? Dakota Territory. Name of Lee Stapp. And I'd sure like to see Cheyenne. I've never been there. Why don't you ride up there alone at a beat, chasing a herd of horses all the way? Yep. I'm broke, mister. I wouldn't have much of a party in Cheyenne, broke, would I? No, I don't guess you would. I'm a good hand. I work cheap. How about it? You're a good hand, huh? Yeah, sure. Of course I am, mister. I wouldn't hire you to herd sheep. What? You said you made a dry camp last night. How come you tie your horse up without watering him while you stand here slopping up coffee? Well, it's my horse, ain't it? Yeah, sure. How's the coffee? The coffee, is it any good? Well, sure. Sure it is. All right, then. Have some more of it. That's one chance, sir. Here. Catcher's gone. I got it now. Go get some rope. We'll tie him up while he's still out. Mr. Dillon, you sure he ain't just a cowboy like you said? I was pretty sure, Chester, but this made me realize sure it was sticking out of his pocket. I'll get the rope. And we are hanging with it.

[ByHeart Formula Advertiser]

The questions start early and then they start multiplying.

Do babies hold grudges?

How do I know when he's full.

Clogging poops, comma necessary.

Raising kids raises enough questions. That's why we make one formula that feels right right away. One made by pediatricians and parents like you, backed by breast milk science and built for babies, brains, bellies and beyond. You'll wonder about everything except this, the formula that answers. Learn [e-mail].

[Narrator/Characters from Gun Smoke and OTRWesterns]

Do you see speed laws and other regulations as restrictive or do you look upon them as protective? When a police officer writes a summons for traffic violations, do you see him as an enemy or friend? Your life May depend on your attitudes. Statistics clearly indicate that when laws are obeyed, deaths go down. It's no secret that emotional immaturity is the major factor in our accident rate. How else but childish can you describe the notion that breaking a traffic regulation is a way of getting away with something? What could be more infantile than believing one can prove his superiority by ignoring a stoplight? Unfortunately, too many drivers on the road subscribe to that kind of emotional outlook. The result is tragic. Almost 85% of all traffic accidents in America are caused by careless, childish driving. We hope sincerely that your attitudes are adult. We hope you know our traffic laws and the people who enforce them are there to help save your life. See anything yet, Chester? There's some dust about a mile away. Right this way. I reckon maybe half dozen riders. Your friends don't take many chances, do they, Steph? There ain't no friends of mine. I'll tell them that when they get here. You better turn me loose. You ain't gonna tell nobody nothing. You mean they won't like it? You're being all tied up that way? I mean you ain't got a chance, Marshall. Oh, you about right, Mr. Dylan. How are we going to fight six men? I've been thinking, Chester, but we can't stand up to six men. We wouldn't have a chance. No, we wouldn't. I'm going to do something I never did before in my life. What? Get your bandana and fix Step so he can't talk good. Well, I ain't going to do you no good. You shut up and get on your feet. Bandana. Yeah, I'll do it. On your feet, Step. Come on. Come on. All right, get. All right, Moose. Chester, turn around. That ought to keep you quiet, Step. All right, now walk. Your rifle. Oh, thanks. You get down behind that log over there. Trust her? Yes. I'm going to. Keep step with me right here. All right, Step. Lie down. If you make any noise, I'll speak with your skull, so help me. Now, go on, lie down. Okay, Chester. Keep the sun off your rifle. They're getting pretty close. Quiet. Now what? What are we going to do? Fight it out from here, Chester. I'd hate for either of us to get killed by men like them. When I start shooting, you start. You take whoever's on your side first and then work in. Yeah, so they'll never know it. Shut up now. Here they are. It might be over to the river. Go. Get down and wait here for them. Maybe stops killed them already. We didn't hear no shooting. Did we? I don't like this. Jake Stapp should have been back long time ago. Dap knows what he's doing. Them sure fine horses, ain't they? Bow. Jesse. Don't shoot no more. All right. Throw your guns away. Sure. Yeah. Now turn around. Get your hands up in the air. All right. Chester, come over here. We killed four of them, Ms. Dylan. Four of them. Bring staff up to the fire. I'll handle these. Yes. You two stop just in time. You can turn around now. Who are you? What'd you ambush us for? Why you done killed four men. I'm a U.S. marshal, mister. U.S. am I? What kind of marshal would ambush a bunch of men like that? My kind, mister. I don't tie the bandana, Mr. Dillon. No reason you shouldn't talk now. It was murder. That's what it was. That was plain murder. It sure was. Even if he is a marshal, he'll hang for this. He never give us a chance. You're right mister. I didn't give you a chance. There were too many of you. And besides, I never knew any men that deserved a chance less than you. Are you talking about we ain't done nothing. Uh huh. I found this yellow hair ribbon in your friend Staps pocket there. Take a look at it. Well, what's this? This ain't nothing. Just little yellow ribbon. There was more than just the ribbon, you blasted fool. Stap. No, I didn't take nothing else. That was just kind of a souvenir. I told you to root of everything you know. Step. I'm sorry you came in alone. I wish you had been with the others. But I'm going to see you hanged. All three of you. It's that little girl jello hair ribbon that's going to hang you.

[ByHeart Formula Advertiser]

The questions start early and then they start multiplying.

Do babies hold grudges?

How do I know when he's full?

Logging poops comma necessary.

Raising kids raises enough questions. That's why we make one formula that feels right right away. One made by pediatricians and parents like you, backed by breast milk science and built for babies, brains, bellies and beyond. You'll wonder about everything except this. The formula that answers. Learn [e-mail].

[Narrator/Characters from Gun Smoke and OTRWesterns]

Repeat after me, please. What do you want when you need brand? What do you want when you need brand? Reliability. Reliability. Now what do you get in Kellogg's All Brand? What do you get in Kellogg's All Brand? Reliability. Right. Hi, this is Dennis James. To explain why Kellogg's Way is the reliable way to get the effectiveness you want from bran with just half a cup a day. See, Kellogg's All Brand is the real Battle Creek formula, the one that millions of people depend on. And they depend on it because Kellogg's All Brand contains more vital brand bulk to help you keep regular. It's low in calories and it's mighty pleasant eating too. Kellogg's All Brand comes in crisp toasted shreds that have a wholesome brand muffin taste. I think you'll like it. So be sure you remember for the effectiveness you want from brand, get reliable Kellogg's All Brand. That's what you get in Kellogg's All Brand Reliability Gun Smoke, produced and directed in Hollywood by Norman McDonald stars William Conrad as Matt Dillon, U.S. marshal. The story was specially written for Gunsmoke by John Maston. Featured in the cast were Lawrence Dobkin, John D. And Harry Bartel. Harley Bear is Custer, Howard McNear is Doc, and Georgia Ellis is kidding. This is George Walsh inviting you to join us again next week when CBS Radio presents another story on gun smoke. For instant facts and fun, America listens Most to the CBS Radio Network. Hello there. I'm Art Link better with 8 year old Tommy, whose hobby is. What is it, Tommy? Collecting butterflies. Oh, that sounds like fun. What do you want to be when you grow up? A doctor. What kind of a doctor? A people doctor. Oh. Tommy is one of the many children carrying on a personal fight against a crippling handicap. And children like Tommy receive regular training at their local Easter Seal centers all over the country. And it's amazing to see all the things they can do. These children can be helped to use the abilities they do have with proper care. Easter Seals provide this care. From your contributions this year, I am pleased to be the national chairman of the Easter Seal Drive. If there's a crippled child in your community, give him the chance to show what he can do. You can help crippled children by giving to Easterseal Foreign.

[ByHeart Formula Advertiser]

This has been a presentation of OTRWesterns.com and we hope you enjoyed. Please take some time to like and rate this episode within your favorite podcast application. Follow us on Facebook by going to otrwesterns.com Facebook and subscribe to our YouTube channel by going to otrwesterns.Com Become one of our ranch hands and unlock some exclusive content. We want to thank our most recent ranch hands, Steve and Ron W. Who joined us recently. You too can join by going to otrwesterns.com donate send us an email podcasttrwesterns.com and you can call and leave us a voicemail. 707-986-8739 this episode is copyrighted under the Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike Copyright. For more information go to otrwesterns.com copyright have a great day and thanks for listening.

[Narrator/Characters from Gun Smoke and OTRWesterns]

Sam.