Old Time Radio Westerns Podcast: Episode Summary

Episode: Trial by Tomahawk | The Cisco Kid (09-07-54)
Release Date: July 15, 2025
Host: Andrew Rhynes

Introduction

In this thrilling episode of Old Time Radio Westerns, host Andrew Rhynes brings to life an intense adventure featuring the legendary Cisco Kid. Through expertly restored audio, listeners are transported to the tumultuous frontier where loyalty, betrayal, and bravery intertwine in the struggle between settlers and the Nez Perce Indians.

Main Plot Overview

The episode, titled Trial by Tomahawk, delves into a plot orchestrated by the conniving Jack Coughlan. Coughlan, driven by greed, aims to seize the bountiful land of the Nez Perce by inciting war between the tribe and the U.S. Army. Utilizing corrupt connections, he manipulates an Indian agent to open Nez Perce lands for settlement, thereby setting the stage for conflict.

Key Characters

• Cisco Kid (Diablo): The protagonist, a heroic figure committed to maintaining peace between the Nez Perce and the Army.
• Pancho: Cisco's loyal companion who supports him throughout the ordeal.
• Chief Joseph: Leader of the Nez Perce, striving to protect his people and lands.
• General Howard: Represents the U.S. Army, caught between duty and conscience.
• Jack Coughlan: The antagonist, whose schemes threaten the fragile peace.
• Red Cloud: A young warrior whose challenge to Cisco escalates tensions.

Detailed Summary

Opening Conflict

The story begins with Jack Coughlan and his men plotting to ambush an army supply wagon. Coughlan instructs his men:

“[01:25] Coughlan: There’s only eight of them. When that army wagon comes into sight, swoop down and kill them all.”

Coughlan’s plan is to disguise his men in stolen army uniforms, making it appear as though the Army is responsible for attacking the Nez Perce. This deception is designed to provoke the tribe into waging war, thereby clearing the way for settlers like Coughlan to claim the land.

Cisco Kid’s Intervention

Cisco Kid and Pancho arrive, intent on preventing the impending conflict. They confront General Howard, seeking to uphold an agreement to keep peace:

“[07:40] Cisco Kid: I came to see you, General Howard, because Chief Joseph of the Nez Perce are friends of mine.”

General Howard is torn between following orders and his sense of justice. He acknowledges the gravity of the situation:

“[10:15] General Howard: It's imperative that the peace be kept on this frontier. It must be kept to prevent the bloodshed of many people.”

Cisco pledges to negotiate with Chief Joseph to avert war, demonstrating his commitment to peace.

Unveiling the Deception

As tensions escalate, Chief Joseph meets with Cisco and Pancho. Suspicion arises when sacred Appaloosa horses are stolen amidst the chaos:

“[21:50] Chief Joseph: The sacred horses of the Nez Perce have been stolen by soldiers.”

Cisco Kid deduces that Jack Coughlan is behind the theft, aiming to incite anger and distrust. The plot thickens as Red Cloud, a young and passionate warrior, challenges Cisco to a duel:

“[35:10] Red Cloud: The challenge for me is to fight him.”

Climactic Duel

The episode reaches its climax with a dramatic tomahawk duel between Cisco Kid and Red Cloud. The confrontation is tense, showcasing Cisco’s resolve and Red Cloud’s fury:

“[44:20] Red Cloud: Red Cloud ready. Cisco Kid ready to kill.”

Despite the intense battle, Cisco manages to defuse the situation, revealing the truth about Coughlan’s deceit to the Nez Perce:

“[56:35] Cisco Kid: The army did not take your leopard spotted horses. They were stolen by a band of evil men. Evil men wear uniform of soldiers.”

Resolution and Justice

With the truth unveiled, General Howard and his cavalry arrive, capturing Coughlan and his gang. Peace is restored as the stolen horses are returned, and the Indian evacuation order is rescinded:

“[1:10:45] General Howard: I received a letter from Washington rescinding the Indian evacuation order. And there’s first remaining on hunting grounds.”

Chief Joseph expresses gratitude towards Cisco and his companions:

“[1:12:30] Chief Joseph: We owe you our thanks, Nez Perce. Give appaloosa horse.”

Cisco and Pancho, acknowledging their bond with the Nez Perce, decide to continue their journey, embodying the spirit of true heroes.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Jack Coughlan: “[01:25] There's only eight of them. When that army wagon comes into sight, swoop down and kill them all.”

• Cisco Kid: “[07:40] I came to see you, General Howard, because Chief Joseph of the Nez Perce are friends of mine.”

• General Howard: “[10:15] It's imperative that the peace be kept on this frontier. It must be kept to prevent the bloodshed of many people.”

• Red Cloud: “[35:10] The challenge for me is to fight him.”

• Cisco Kid: “[44:20] Red Cloud ready. Cisco Kid ready to kill.”

• Cisco Kid: “[56:35] Evil men wear uniform of soldiers.”

• Chief Joseph: “[1:12:30] We owe you our thanks, Nez Perce. Give appaloosa horse.”

Themes and Insights

• Betrayal and Deception: Jack Coughlan’s manipulation highlights the destructive power of deceit in fueling conflict.

• Loyalty and Friendship: Cisco Kid’s unwavering loyalty to Chief Joseph and the Nez Perce underscores the strength of true friendship across cultural divides.

• Courage and Integrity: Both Cisco and General Howard showcase immense courage and moral integrity in the face of adversity.

• Peace vs. Conflict: The episode emphasizes the fragile balance between peace and war, and the profound impact that individual actions can have on broader societal dynamics.

Conclusion

Trial by Tomahawk is a masterful installment that combines suspense, action, and heartfelt moments. Through the Cisco Kid’s heroic efforts, the episode conveys a powerful message about the importance of truth, honor, and the courage to stand against injustice. Andrew Rhynes’ meticulous restoration brings the story to life, offering listeners an immersive experience into the golden age of Western radio dramas.

For those who have not yet listened, this episode is a quintessential representation of classic Western storytelling, enriched with vivid audio that captures the essence of the Wild West.

Stay Connected:

• Website: otrwesterns.com
• Facebook: otrwesterns.com/Facebook
• YouTube: otrwesterns.com/YouTube
• Join as a Ranch Hand: Visit otrwesterns.com for exclusive content and membership details.

Thank you for tuning into Old Time Radio Westerns. Be sure to like, rate, and subscribe to support our efforts in preserving these timeless tales.