Loading summary
Narrator
Run a restaurant and you learn pretty quick. The sound of a crisp fry starts way before the first bite, as delivery in to go keeps business booming. Order for pickup. McCain SureCrisp fries. Keep orders crispy. After the trip, the crispiness comes through. Mmm. McCain surecrisp fries. Go the distance. See how far our fries can take your business@surecrisp.com Delivery It's April 29, 1945, a Sunday. Just before dawn. We're in Mila, northern Italy, in the Piazzale Le Reto, a large square next to the railway station. In the early hours, it's quiet. In the dying days of the war, after years of destruction, eerily so. Through the empty streets comes the splutter of a two stroke engine. It's a truck, an old removals lorry. It grinds into the piazza and reverses across the cobbles. In the half light, men leap out. They're partisans, members of the Italian resistance. They flip down the tailboard and heave out their load. The lorry drives off again. Silence resumes. Later, as Milan wakes, a crowd begins to gather. Rumors are spreading like wildfire about this mysterious manifestation. In the spring sunshine, folks are coming out to see. By 9am The Piazzale Reto plays host to an excitable crowd. In normal times, the sight of dead bodies dumped in a heap would be sickening. But there is nothing normal about Italy. These cadavers are those of the partisan's enemy and one in particular. He is a big prize. The scalp of all scalps. It seems at first to defy the imagination. Dressed in plain jacket and military trousers, the man is not instantly recognizable. His famously bold features now grey, scrunched and battered. His signature shaven head is patchy, the once bear like physique reduced. But he is almost unbelievably one. Benito Mussolini. Il Duce, the formerly unassailable ironman dictator of Italy. His limbs are entwined with those of his young mistress, Clara Petacci. Around them lie a tangle of corpses, assorted loyalists and henchmen. They were apprehended in an Alpine pass, it is whispered, trying to flee to Switzerland. Their fate a summary execution, to be riddled with bullets from a submachine gun. With some still unable to comprehend the enormity of this moment, a second opinion is sought. A captured Mussolini sidekick is dragged forward. His name is Achilles Starace. As Starrace nods his head, yes, it's them. People surge forward to punch, kick and brutalize the corpses. Mussolini's in particular. In an act of communal Catholic stones and Rotten fruit are hurled. Some whack away with sticks. Others urinate on Mussolini's miserable remains. Someone stamps his head so hard the skull crunches. Shots ring out. Five people duck. An elderly woman dressed in black brandishes a revolver. She has pumped yet more bullets into Il Duce's body. For my five dead sons, she wails. With the situation getting out of hand, the fire brigade are summoned. They spray hoses to keep back the crowd. On the corner is a standard oil filling station. Its canopy is supported by an iron girder. Ankles trussed with ropes. The principal corpses are hoisted to hang from it, there for all to see, raised just above their reach. Starrace has played his part. He too is murdered and added to the gibbet. And there they swing upside down, strung like pigs in a butcher's shop, arms dangling, blood dripping down to pool on the pavement. Petacci's dress flops down over her face, revealing her silk underwear. A female onlooker climbs up to tuck the skirt between her legs, preserving her modesty. All day long, people come to view this gruesome tableau. Children are lifted on shoulders to witness history. For over 20 years, Benito Mussolini was the most powerful man in Italy. Wildly popular at home and for a while at least, revered abroad. He was the capo di capo, the godfather of a brand new totalitarian creed, fascism. It was meant to ensure his absolute power. At his peak, Il Duce was a virile, performative icon, the first rock star leader. Addressing crowds of adoring thousands, he seemed invincible, superhuman, godlike. Mussolini was Italy. No one in their wildest dreams could imagine it would come to this same Mussolini today. And there are certain preconceptions. He dragged ailing Italy into the modern world, establishing the country as a major power in a land famously indifferent to matters temporal. He even made the trains run on time. But that was then. In hitching his star to the Nazi war wagon, Mussolini is regarded as something of a buffoon, a clown, the hapless, bumbling foil to straight man Hitler.
Historian 1
The way he was portrayed in satirical journalism has really shaped popular opinion. Even today. There's this idea that, oh, well, Mussolini, he's a bit of a comic opera character, he's melodramatic. This is the dictator that the Italians deserve because they're all over emotional as well. Mussolini's an important historical figure because, of course, he was the ruler of a fascist dictatorship. He was also the first Fascist. The reason why he has many imitators and advocates. Even today among neo fascists, he is.
Historian 2
Absolutely Central to the 20th century, Mussolini invented fascism. So without Italy, you don't get fascism. Without Mussolini, you don't get Fascism and Hitler.
Historian 3
Hitler in fact borrows it, he plagiarizes it. It's the sorcerer's apprentice. Musadini is a sorcerer. The Musadini of popular imagination is the kind of person who might kick you to death in a slimy little dark alley in drag boots. And this is the frightening thing. He was both the jack booted thug and supreme intellectual. Mussolini is a huge enigma.
Narrator
Mussolini was, according to his colleague Fernando Mezzasoma, by turns shrewd and innocent, brutal and gentle, vindictive and forgiving, great and petty. He is the most complicated and contradictory man I've ever known. He cannot be explained. Winston Churchill, who had once chorused his approval, came to a more definite view, calling him the one man and one man alone, who plunged Italy into tragedy. 11 years before Hitler, 14 before Franco. It was Benito Mussolini who provided the dictatorial blueprint.
Historian 2
I'd say in our collective imagination, that no individual embodies dictatorship in his physical being more than Mussolini. His physique, his gestures, his glare, these are all archetypical traits of the modern dictator. He cast the mold.
Historian 1
I don't like considering personalities or single men as the change factor of history, but we have to in a way recognize that there are figures in history that are able to really change the course of it.
Narrator
From the Neuser Network. This is part one of the Mussolini story, and this is real dictatorship.
Historian 1
SA.
Narrator
It'S the summer of 1883, near the commune of Predapio in northeastern Italy. Nestling on a hillside is a collection of modest houses. The hamlet of Verano di Costa. It's hot, brutally hot. Among the square stone homes with their shuttered windows is one belonging to a young married couple, Alessandro and Rosa Mussolini. In the fertile province of Romagna, 60 miles from Bologna, life is fundamentally rural. The people till the soil, they sow the seeds. They are, in the main, God fearing, hard working. Alessandro is a blacksmith, Rosa, a local schoolteacher. The Mussolinis can trace their roots locally back to the 13th century century. Alessandro, a barrel chested man with an impressive mustache, has a fondness for women and drink. In a deeply macho culture, such things are tolerated. Rosa, meanwhile, is a devout Catholic. Alessandro has no time for God. He is something that not too long ago would have been deemed unthinkable on papal land. He is an atheist, more than that, an anarchic socialist. For these are turbulent times. Politically, northeast Italy is enthralled to a new revolutionary Doctrine Marxism. As a union agitator, Alessandro Mussolini is pegged as a troublemaker. Rosa, meanwhile, will strive for a life free from sin. The Mussolinis will have three children, two boys and a girl. The oldest, born on 29 July that year, is baptized into the Catholic faith, just as his mother insisted. But he is named not after a saint, as is customary, rather, at his father's insistence, a Mexican revolutionary, Benito Juarez. His middle names, too, are tributes to two leading Italian leftists. And thus Benito Amelcare Andrea Mussolini enters the world Bored at home? Head over to Chumba Casino and join some serious social casino fun. With hundreds of games at your fingertips, no purchase necessary. You can play anytime, anywhere. There's a special welcome bonus waiting for you when you sign up. Play for fun, play for free. And you can even redeem some great prizes. Visit chumbacassino.com and get ready to reel in the fun. Sponsored by Chumba Casino. No purchase necessary. VGW Group void where prohibited by law 18/ terms and conditions apply. This episode is brought to you by Amazon.
Historian 1
The holidays are here, and you know what that means.
Narrator
It's time to get your friends and.
Historian 1
Family the gifts they deserve.
Narrator
Take the stress out of shopping.
Historian 1
With Amazon's great deals and low prices.
Narrator
On a huge range of items, from.
Historian 1
Toys to tech and much more. Whoever you're gifting for, Amazon has great prices on everything you need.
Narrator
This holiday season, shop Amazon for all your gifting needs. Lisa Pyne is Associate Fellow of the Institute of Historical Research, University of London.
Historian 1
His mother, Rosa, was an ardent Catholic who had her children baptized. She took them to church every Sunday. She was also the local schoolteacher, so she provided the regular income to the family. In contrast to his father, Alessandro, a blacksmith who worked irregularly and because he was given to drinking and womanizing, wasn't really doing what he should have as the family man. Now, Benito Mussolini feared his father because he hit him to discipline him. But at the same time, he admired Alessandro for his ideals. And his father then had considerable influence on Benito's character and beliefs.
Narrator
Young Benito will find himself living something of a double life. On the one hand, there's his rambunctious, disciplining, proselytizing Papa. On the other is the mother who will cuss at her son, smothering the turbulence with maternal love. Where Alessandro will encourage Benito to drink, to argue, to fight, Rosa will drag her boy to a redemptive mass. Alessandro's idealism, his questionable work ethic, will be offset by Rosa's pragmatism graft and reliability. My greatest love was for my mother, her son will later write. She was so quiet, so tender, so strong. The worldview of Benito Amalcari Aldrea Mussolini will forever be coloured by this tug of war. Kindness versus cruelty, Karl Marx versus Jesus. Order versus chaos. My father was a blacksmith who bent red hot iron on the anvil, Mussolini will declare when acceding to power. Sometimes when I was a boy, I helped my father in his hard and humble work. And now I have the infinitely harder task of bending souls. Helen Roche is associate professor in Modern European Cultural History at the University of.
Historian 1
Durham, Verdappia, which is Mussolini's birthplace and part of Mussolini's whole cult. And Schick, if you like, was oh, you know, I'm the son of a blacksmith. I'm just an ordinary guy. My mother was a schoolteacher. You know, I've come from this small place, these humble origins, which made him very relatable.
Narrator
Young Benito grows up an individualist, brimming with self importance. He has a younger brother, Arnaldo, with whom he shares a room which doubles as the family kitchen, and a sister, Edwige. I was born at 2 in the afternoon on a Sunday. The sun had entered the constellation of Leo eight days before. He will later write, reflecting on the auspicious moment of his birth. One day, he tells his mother, I will astonish the world. Benito Mussolini is an intelligent youth, but he is also a violent one. Constantly brawling on the short side, but powerfully built. He could start a fight in an empty room. In an attempt to save him from himself. At age just nine, his mother removes him from local schooling. She gets him a place at a boarding school in the town of Faenza, 20 miles away, a strict religious institution run by Silesian monks. On the way, the donkey transporting him collapses and dies. It's regarded, unsurprisingly, as a bad omen. Indeed, the Catholic fathers are perplexed by their new ward, this misfit, this dark, foreboding presence.
Historian 1
Mussolini recalled just that sense of feeling isolated, crushed, being sent away from home. He considered this to be a punishment, contributing to his isolation, contributing to his sense of rejection. And as a child and a school pupil, he was grumpy, willful, bad tempered. He didn't get on well with other children. He could be violent. Bullying behavior was there. And he also, and I think this is important, he also had a strong sense of vengeance.
Narrator
On the one hand, here is a boy who can recite poetry so beautifully that it will move the class to tears in the playground Meanwhile, he'll whip out his pen knife and stab a fellow pupil in the buttock. Mussolini is duly expelled. His next school in Forlin Popoli, freed from the heavy religious vibe, is more to his liking. Nicholas O'Shaughnessy is emeritus professor of communication, Queen Mary, University of London.
Historian 3
He was originally what I call a stab kid. He stabbed another boy at boarding school. They sent him to a new school where he was much happier, where his teachers liked him, because this is the trouble. He was both a thug and very smart.
Narrator
He knuckles down this time, and in July 1901, at the age of 17, Signor Benito Mussolini, or as we should now say, Professore Benito Mussolini, qualifies as an elementary schoolteacher, just like Mama. Mussolini, however, has not shared his father's compulsion to stick it to the man. John Foote is professor of Modern Italian History at the University of Bristol.
Historian 2
I mean, Mussolini is born into a radical family. His names are all names of radicals. His father was a sort of anarchist blacksmith. And I think all of that marks him. You know, you can see traces of that even much later, when he's a fascist dictator. You can still see traces and elements of that kind of his youth, his radical youth.
Narrator
As the new master at a school in Gautieri, Mussolini tutors his seven year olds less in the three Rs and more in the glories of revolutionary socialism. He has swiftly shown the door. It doesn't help that he's had affairs with more than one of the schoolmaster's wives. Fists have been flying. Mussolini scraps as much in the schoolyard as a teacher as he did as a pupil. There is, fortunately, another outlet for Mussolini's rage. June 1902 sees the 20th anniversary of the death of Giuseppe Garibaldi, the great Italian patriot. Benito gives a rousing public speech in tribute. Local socialists take note. This fiery young man with his slicked dark hair is just the sort of performer they need. But Mussolini is skeptical. They're not serious enough, just playing at being revolutionaries, Tagliatelli socialists. As he taunts them flaccid. Mussolini's innuendo is never particularly sophisticated. Nor is his relationship with women. Rather, it remains prehistorically crude. Females exist for one thing only.
Historian 1
That combination of charisma and violence also seemed to extend to his relationships with women. So he was, as his father was, a womanizer. He was not particularly romantic in his relationships with women. He used them more for his own lust and his own desire, rather than a kind of loving or mutual relationship. And they were sometimes quite violent relationships too.
Narrator
He Celebrates the completion of his studies with the sexual assault of a 16 year old girl in his village. We know because he writes about it, boasts about it in a memoir. She was poor, but she had a nice complexion and was reasonably good looking. One day I took her up the stairs, threw her onto the floor, behind the door and made her mine. She got up crying and insulted me. Between her sobs, she said that I'd violated her honour. I probably had. HE SCOFFS but what sort of honour? Power, gratification. For most of his life, he's not in the need of something so frivolous as companionship, friendship.
Historian 2
He never has friends. I think that's one of the interesting personality traits of Mussolini. He has comrades, he has people, acolytes, entourage, who are absolutely, you know, faithful to him, will go to their death for him. But he doesn't have friends, he has lovers. And there's the whole kind of nexus of Mussolini. Family man, Mussolini Latin lover, Mussolini rapist. You know, there's all these different personalities which emerge in his private life, but yes, a violent personality, almost like on the level of borderline personality disorder.
Narrator
The incident with the young lady is followed by a steamy affair with the wife of a soldier who is away doing his duty. Mussolini stabs her in the thigh. Military service will soon be looming for Mussolini too. He is now eligible for the compulsory draft, something he has no intention of undertaking. He casts his gaze north. In July 1902, Benito Mussolini, kicked out of the teaching profession, crosses the Alps into Switzerland. Moving between Geneva, Freiburg and Berne. He will work as a stonemason, as a bricklayer, an errand boy in a chocolate factory. Mussolini must trudge through a gig economy, at one point living in a packing crate under a railway bridge, another time in a public lavatory. That said, there are the usual pleasures to indulge, including a romp with a female Polish refugee whose sexual prowess he scores highly. Switzerland, though, is becoming something of a haven for more than just draft dodgers. It's playing host to all manner of political exiles. Mussolini hurls himself wholeheartedly into the cells of revolutionary socialists who gather to plot the overthrow of capitalism from the luxury of one of the wealthiest countries in the world. 5ft 6, squat, with a large head and that slicked back hair, albeit already starting to thin, he proves again to be a charismatic speaker, someone who can hold a room. He's equally adept, perhaps even more so, at committing his thoughts to paper. He contributes in exile to various Italian socialist newspapers. His talents are enough to charm a Russian emigre named Angelika Balabanov, who introduces him to the works of Lenin and with whom he has the obligatory violent affair. But as ever, Mussolini just can't help himself. He is an illegal alien, but he shows no inclination to stay out of trouble. He derides his Swiss hosts as a bunch of sausage makers. Arrested more than once, he is eventually deported from the canton of Bern, though he does manage to sneak back in illegally on a falsified passport. In Geneva, penniless and starving, Mussolini hits rock bottom. One day, he recounts, he sees two visiting English women sitting on a park bench eating a picnic and attacks them. I threw myself upon one of the old witches and grabbed the food from her hands. If they'd made the slightest resistance, I would have strangled them. He's arrested again over his counterfeit papers, though this time he's given clemency. He somehow ends up gate crashing lectures at the University of Lausanne. But the Swiss adventure has run its course. In November 1904, the King of Italy makes a There will be an amnesty for those who've shirked military service, provided they make good on their obligation. And so, with 18 months in the army ahead of him, Mussolini, age 21, goes home now. AT T Mobile get four 5G phones on us and four lines for $25 a line per month when you switch with eligible trade ins. All on America's largest 5G network. Minimum of 4 lines for $25 per line per month with auto pay discount using debit or bank account. $5 more per line without autopay, plus taxes and fees and ten dollar device connection. Charge phones via 24 monthly bill credits for well qualified customers. Contact us before canceling entire account to continue bill credits or credit stop and balance on a required finance agreement due bill credits end if you pay off devices early. CT mobile.com did you know that the team behind this show has other podcasts too? Listen@noiser.com or wherever you get your podcasts. In January 1905, he joins a regiment of Bersaglieri riflemen in Verona. One month in, Mussolini has dealt a devastating blow. He is called aside by his captain. His mother, Rosa is seriously ill. He arrives home just in time to see her take her final breath. Succumbing to meningitis, she was just 46. Mussolini is deeply distraught. In his downtime, he channels his energies. He devours the works of all manner of philosophers and political thinkers. He is obsessed with the Italian futurist Filippo Tommaso Marinetti. He reads Dante, Schopenhauer, Kant, as well as every future dictator's set text Friedrich Nietzsche In Switzerland, Mussolini has learned decent French, passable German with some English and Spanish thrown in. Often he will translate from the original. Once demobbed, he channels his talents as an aspiring politico, honing his craft both as writer and public speaker, all the while jobbing as a teacher again, this time in Tolmezzo in the Karnic Alps. His students dub him Il Terano, the tyrant in the double life of Mussolini, the thug is never far from the surface. That compulsion for drinking, brawling and increasingly whoring. Almost inevitably, Mussolini contracts syphilis. Depressed, he threatens to shoot himself. But he's soon well enough to be having an affair with the wife of his landlord. He delights in sneaking into her house to have sex with her while her husband snoozes in the other room. No one knows quite why specifically, but Mussolini is soon back in jail. It's a pattern that will go on, repeat, on release. He does what those in recovery call doing a geographical relocating in the hope of a fresh start. Not Switzerland this time, but Trentino, the contested, Italian speaking Alpine region that lies within the borders of Austria. But he is far too open about his wish for it to be annexed by the new Italian state. In September 1909, he finds himself deported again. At age 26, Benito Mussolini is going nowhere fast. He slinks back to Bradapio to live off his dad. Widower Alessandro has had something of a turnaround. He is now an innkeeper and he's loved up. He has a new woman in his life. Her name is Anna Guidi. He seems quite settled. Anna comes with five kids, including a daughter just 16. Her name is Rachele. For the first time in his life, Mussolini is smitten. He has finally found the one, though not before bedding her older sister, Augusta. To demonstrate his love for Rakeli, he dashes off a novel for her, a romance called the Cardinal's Mistress, in which she is the central character.
Historian 1
Mussolini becomes obsessed with her, saying that he wants to live with her straight away and says he'll shoot himself in the head if he's not allowed to do so. So he's absolutely adamant and absolutely obsessed with the young Raquel.
Narrator
As you've probably already picked up, he can be a bit of a drama queen, but it does the trick. Parental consent secured, they move into a squalid apartment in Forli. There, Mussolini makes a meager living as a local Socialist Party official. According to his own legend, they will live on cabbages. It does not diminish their energy. Within a year, on September 1, 1910. Benito and Rachele have a child, a daughter named Edda. It's time for this new father to take some responsibility, to grow up. Or so you'd have thought. These are turbulent times. The tectonic plates of political power are shifting in Europe. Tsarist Russia has weathered one revolution and is bracing itself against a Bolshevik resurgence. The decaying Austro Hungarian Empire is clinging onto its multiethnic Balkan realms. The French and British, former foes, are now engaged in a bromance, the Entente Cordiale. And there are two new Germany and Italy. Both only unified in the last 50 years. They are now muscling in on the scene as an economic powerhouse. Germany is in the ascendancy. Prussia beat France in the War of 1870. It is the new dominant force on the continent. But Italy, until as recently as 1861, there was no such thing. It was, as one diplomat put it, a mere geographical expression, a collection of dukedoms, republics and microstates, many under the suzerainty of the Austrian Habsburgs. But during the Napoleonic wars, ideas about liberation and unity had been inculcated through the Risorgimento movement via two wars of independence. Italy was unified to be governed as a constitutional monarchy, the Kingdom of Italy. While it may hark back to the wonders of ancient Rome and the Renaissance, the modern variant is a work in progress. It's a hodgepodge of varying customs and differing languages. Economically, it's largely agricultural, relatively poor, technologically backward. But glories, riches and unity can be achieved. It is figured with some international adventuring. It casts a jealous eye at Britain and France in particular, with their bountiful overseas territories.
Historian 1
They were a new nation, but they wanted to have a new empire. And at the end of the 19th century, they kind of went for whatever spoils were left in the continent of Africa. Taking Somaliland, taking Eritrea, but being defeated by the Ethiopians at Adowa in 1896. This failure to take Ethiopia in the 1890s remained a thorn in the side of the Italians and was really a great wound to Italian national pride.
Narrator
It is one of the first ever defeats of a European colonizer by African forces. Undeterred, the Palazzo della Consulta, the Italian Foreign Office, shifts its interest to a territory much closer to home. Right across the Mediterranean in North Africa. It's November 1, 1911. We're in the azure skies of a Tripolitania. A monoplane cruises along. It's a German made Tauv, a glued together assembly of canvas, wood and string. Its wings. In these early days of aviation, are even shaped like a bird's. The pilot is a man named Giulio Gavotti of the Corpo Arenatico Militare, the Italian army air service. At 600ft off the ground, Gavotti circles the desert over Tag Aguirre. There was an oasis there he spotted some enemy troops. They are Ottomans, Turks. Under his seat is a leather bag containing four large grenades, each the size of a grapefruit. With one hand on the joystick, he pulls the pin on the first, Lobbing it over the side. He watches it spiral down to explode amid the palm trees. Continuing on to the Turkish army base at Aynzara, Gavotti offloads the others. His solo raid has just entered into the annals of military history. The first ever use of an aircraft as a weapon of war. The Turks will establish another new record soon after. Using rifles, they down one of Gavotti's comrades. And thus the Italians become the first to use and lose a plane in combat. The historic land that Gavotti has flown over Tripolitania is part of a region the Italians will refer to as Libya, the word the Romans had used for North Africa generally. To snatch it, Italy must first engineer a conflict with those who control it, the struggling Ottoman Empire. Gavotti's raid is an early engagement in what will become known as the Italo Turkish War. A year long conflict that runs into the autumn of 1912.
Historian 3
So the new countries, they needed to forge an identity which gave a premium on hyper nationalism as a way of integrating the country. It kicks off with the Italo Turkish War. And so this is a 19th century idea of empire transposed onto the 20th. The idea of empire had become terribly unpopular with senior powers by that stage. The idea of conquering peoples who didn't want to be conquered, whereas in Italy it was an Ozatz performance. In order to unite the nation and give it meaning was to acquire and consolidate a huge new empire. The idea of becoming a new Rome.
Narrator
Italian forces begin a brutal suppression of the largely tribal resistance. Mussolini is at first appalled. Any good socialist should resist imperialism. Those behind this atrocity are bourgeois lickspittles, he says. Back in Forl, he writes scathing pieces in the local press about the government, the church, the army, and makes inflamed speeches calling for a general strike. He even tries to block the embarkation of troops by starting a riot. As sure as night follows day, Mussolini ends up in prison again, this time for a five month stretch on a charge of inciting the people to strike and insurrection. But inadvertently, it's proven A good career move. He is a martyr to the cause. On release in December 1912, the war now over, Mussolini is embraced by his ideological kin. He is offered membership of the Directorate of the Italian Socialist Party, Partito Socialista Italiano, or psi Due to his impassioned journalism. He is also to be awarded the editorship of its national left wing newspaper, Avanti. The job necessitates a move to Milan. Unfortunately, his father will not live to witness the success, for he too will soon be dead, aged 57. But his son is going from strength to strength. Within six months, the circulation of Avanti has increased fivefold. In October 1913, Mussolini stands for election to parliament on the Socialist Party ticket. He's defeated, but ends up as a Milan councillor. It's his first political office as an orator. He's learning how to read the crowd, when to be soft, when to be loud, when to rise to a crescendo. The musicality of his performance is of interest. Mussolini, amid the blood and thunder, is also a keen violinist. He was taught to play as a youth by a fairground fiddler. When rehearsing his speeches, he's apt to break off and bow through a few bars at Paganini. He's certainly striking the right notes. As one reporter muses. I don't know what to make of this queer fellow Mussolini, but I know one thing, he's going to get somewhere. At 29, Mussolini is a rising star. If TV had existed, he would have been the ubiquitous talking head, the go to man for an alternative and explosive opinion.
Historian 2
He becomes very quickly one of the most popular socialists in Italy. He was an incredible speaker, but I think one of the key things was he was a journalist, a writer, he understood the press, he understood the media and he wrote these rabble rousing articles. When peasants were massacred by the state, he wrote these angry articles saying the state is a murderer. You know, this kind of very violent language which he'll carry through. So all of those things mark him out as a very important charismatic political figure well before fascism is even on anyone's minds.
Historian 3
This is truly extraordinary that he was eponymous, emotional and brilliantly successful Lefty. He was a commie. He was the most effective commie in Italy. So much so that Lenin said the Italian revolution can't happen if Mussolini isn't part of it. He's already a very, very important man and he's one of the biggest and most impressive figures on the European. European Left is certainly intellectually the most impressive figure that the European Left has to offer.
Narrator
Remember when we last checked in on Mussolini's domestic life with his young partner Rachele and infant daughter Edda. There had seemed to have been some stability. Well, not so fast. In 1914, Mussolini abandons Rachele and suddenly gets married to a woman named Ida Dalsa. The following year they have a son, Benito Albino Mussolini. It's a short lived union that is as tempestuous as all the others. Ida will turn up one day outside his office with the child on her hip, screaming and shouting at Mussolini. He will lean out of the window and threaten her with a pistol. She will set fire to the furniture in her room at the Hotel Bristol.
Historian 1
He'd married a woman called Ida and together with her had a son. And this became inconvenient for him during later years. So these two were quickly pushed out of the picture and swept very much under the carpet so that they didn't sully his reputation or get in the way.
Narrator
Ida will die in 1937, locked away in a lunatic asylum. Mussolini, the family man, will later have his son murdered, injected with coma inducing drugs. Aged 26, following claims as to his true paternity, in December 1915, Mussolini will return to the loving embrace of Rachele and they will formally tie the knot. There remains a possibility that Mussolini is a bigamist. There is speculation too that he is marrying a stepsister. No matter. Benito and Rachele will go on to have four more children. Sons Vittorio Bruno, Romano and another daughter, Anna Maria. It's not just the recent war in Libya. On the continent of Europe, the storm clouds are gathering. By 1914, the great powers seem set on a collision course. Since 1882, Italy has been part of the Triple Alliance, a military defensive pact between itself Germany and Austria Hungary. As it stands currently, an outbreak of hostilities will drag Italy into direct conflict with the Entente of Britain, France and Russia. There are many in the corridors of power who are no longer convinced of the merits of such an arrangement. But too late. On June 28, 1914, the spark ignites the tinderbox. The heir to the Austrian throne, Archduke Franz Ferdinand and his wife are assassinated in Sarajevo by a Serbian radical. Austria bombards Belgrade. Germany and Russia mobilize. France, then Britain are called to honor their own military obligations. There's a question over whether the war is truly defensive on the part of the Triple Alliance. This affords Italy some wiggle room. At first she remains neutral, but the question is left hanging. The PSI, naturally are opposed to Italy's involvement. The proletariats of Europe should be fighting the bourgeoisie, not each Other, as before, the anti War brigade takes to the streets in Milan's Piazza del Duomo. There are cavalry charges made against the mob and it doesn't let up. Mussolini is fully supportive of the protestors helping rip up the city's tram lines with a pickaxe.
Historian 2
Anti militarism is a big thing in Italy. And the clash between anti militarism and militarism, between the army and the people, if you like, is a huge division in Italian society. People are shot in 1914 in a place called Ancona by the army, and there's a huge uprising right across that area known as Red Week. And Mussolini is writing articles saying, this is great, this is a revolution. This is what should happen. So, you know, it's a very turbulent time, socially and politically, on the eve of the First World War. And much of that will change with the war, including Mussolini himself, who undergoes a radical transformation.
Narrator
You can say that again. After some reflection, Mussolini is about to perform the mother of all U turns. Libya was a colonial war, but this is different. He reconsiders. Plus, the fall of the French Republic and the rise of the reactionary Germanic states would be a mortal blow to liberty in Europe. And war anyway, according to Marxist doctrine, is the prelude to civil disorder, to revolution, is it not? In which case, taking part would actually further the socialist course.
Historian 1
He demonstrated his ruthlessness, his rejection of compromise. These are traditional socialist ideas, you know, kind of harking back to what Karl Marx had written, following on from what Lenin had done with the Bolshevik Revolution. And yet, on the other hand, we can see him as something of a political chameleon because he changed his colors exactly when it suited him.
Narrator
What's more, to further the revolution, Mussolini argues, Italy should extract itself from its pact with the Central Powers. It should join the other side. Giulia Albanese is Professor of Modern History at the University of Padua. She is the author of the March on Rome and editor of Rethinking the History of Italian Fascism.
Historian 1
This was his way into politics. And this was one of the reasons it was so easy for him to pass from a position of Rigid Neutralism, July 1914, to a position in which it was a possibility of war in October 14th, from a position of clear acceptance of the war in November 14th. So it's a few months that managed him to pass from a position to another. There were in the Socialist Party a group of people that were less and less convinced of a position of neutrality. He was able to relate to other groups that were perceiving war as a Possibility for a revolution.
Narrator
Mussolini's is not an isolated view, but his conversion is perceived as a shocking act of heresy by the PSI. On October 26, 1914, he is forced to resign his position at its newspaper. He signs off with a scathing editorial. As editor of Avanti, I address my first word to you, the young men of Italy, the young men of the factories and the universities, those who are young in years, young in spirit, the young men belonging to a generation to whom fate has given the task of making history. It is a word which in normal times I would never have used, but which today I am forced to utter loudly and clearly, in sincere and good faith, the fearful and fascinating word war. Two weeks later, he launches a rival newspaper, Il Popolo d'italia, the People of Italy, which will become his own personal mouthpiece. It comes complete with proto Fascist slogans on its masthead. Who has iron, has bread and revolution is an idea which has found bayonets. It will also turn out that Mussolini is a little more capitalist, a little more opportunist than you might think. The British secret service has been lining his pockets to the tune of £100 a week to bang the war drums, to agitate for Italy to join the Entente, an enormous sum. The French, apparently, have also had a hand in bankrolling il Popolo. It's November 25, 1914. We're in a hall in Milan, the Casa del Popolo. We're here for the convention of the Italian Socialist Party. 3,000 have crammed in, many travelling for miles around. It's been a busy evening, lots to discuss. But the biggest motion to be put before the room is the final item on the agenda. Should Benito Amulcari, Andrea Mussolini, a member of its own directorate, be stripped of his party membership? For someone of Mussolini's statue, it is an extraordinary fall from grace. The motion to defenestrate him passes with an overwhelming majority.
Historian 2
You know, Mussolini had always been anti war, anti imperial, anti colonial. He'd gone to prison for opposing the Libyan War of 1912. The socialist movement is pretty opposed to the war. The majority of Italians either don't want the war or indifferent. Some of them are very radically against the war. And Mussolini suddenly, from one moment to another, writes these articles in favor of the war. And this is a great betrayal. Mussolini, for the socialists, is a great traitor. His argument for this is actually a left wing argument and it comes from a certain tradition of nationalism in Italy, is that war will make Italians. This is a war of national liberation. We will gain the territory that is legitimately ours. There are bits of Italy that are still not Italy, you know. It's not necessarily a radical break with certain parts of the tradition in Italy, but it is a radical break with the socialist movement.
Narrator
Mussolini is given his moment. He takes to the stage to make his farewell address. Amid howls of Judas, he stands before them. Down at heel, he wears a shabby suit that's too small. He has a thick moustache with several days worth of beard stubble, not quite the imposing figure of repute. There are coins thrown, even a chair. But he doesn't flinch. Do not think that by taking away my membership card you will take away my faith in the cause. He blasts with full theatrical flourish against an almighty hiss, as if he were a pantomime villain. He assures them that history will be his judge. Amid the groans and by now, not a little applause for his sheer effrontery, he signs off with a grimace, an index finger jabbed to the heavens. You think to sign my death warrant, but you are mistaken. Today you hate me because in your heart, heart of hearts, you still love me. And with it, he descends from the stage and strides down the aisle towards the exit. Out there on the streets, he knows he's far from alone. Nationalists, dissenting socialists and others are marching to a similar beat, not least the new conservative Prime Minister, Antonio Salandra. There's been work going on behind the scenes. A secret seduction on the part of Britain and France promises to Italy of rewards of territory in the Alps, along the Dalmatian coast, of expansion in Africa. Anything to get her into the scrap. On April 26, 1915, these dealings will be acknowledged formally as the Treaty of London. A month later, on May 23, hostilities are declared, initially against just Austria, Hungary. Mussolini celebrates in Il Popolo, in characteristic style. From today onwards, we are all Italians and nothing but Italians. Now that steel has to meet steel. One single cry comes from our hearts. Viva Litalia. Italy and Mussolini are going to war. In the next episode, wounded at the front, Mussolini's war ends early. Feeling cheated by the peace settlement, he forms a political movement stuffed with disgruntled army veterans. This new National Fascist party will soon storm to power via an audacious march on Rome. That's next time.
Real Dictators: Benito Mussolini Part 1 – Italy’s Fascist Godfather
Hosted by Paul McGann
The episode opens with a vivid recounting of Benito Mussolini's execution on April 29, 1945, in Milan’s Piazzale Le Reto. As narrated, the crowds gathered to witness the gruesome display of Mussolini and his mistress, Clara Petacci, hanging alongside loyalist corpses. The chaotic scene underscores Italy's tumultuous final days during World War II.
Narrator [00:00]: "These cadavers are those of the partisan's enemy and one in particular. He is a big prize. The scalp of all scalps... Benito Mussolini."
This stark portrayal sets the stage for exploring Mussolini's transformation from a revered dictator to a fallen tyrant, emphasizing the dramatic shifts in his legacy.
The narrative delves into Mussolini's origins, highlighting his birth on July 29, 1883, in Predappio, Italy, to Alessandro Mussolini, a blacksmith and anarchic socialist, and Rosa Garibaldi, a devout Catholic schoolteacher. This dichotomy between his father's radicalism and his mother's religiosity laid the foundation for Mussolini's complex personality.
Historian 1 [07:27]: "Mussolini's an important historical figure because, of course, he was the ruler of a fascist dictatorship. He was also the first Fascist."
Mussolini's turbulent youth is characterized by violence and intellectual curiosity. His expulsion from a convent boarding school at nine for violent behavior marked the beginning of his contentious relationship with authority. Despite his rebellious nature, Mussolini exhibited a knack for oratory and writing, foreshadowing his future political endeavors.
Historian 3 [08:19]: "Hitler in fact borrows it, he plagiarizes it. It's the sorcerer's apprentice... Mussolini is a huge enigma."
At seventeen, Mussolini became an elementary schoolteacher, but his disdain for the profession led to his dismissal. His subsequent exile to Switzerland exposed him to revolutionary socialism, deepening his involvement with socialist movements. During this period, Mussolini engaged in violent altercations and illicit activities, which both hindered and honed his leadership skills.
Helen Roche [17:00]: "He was born into a radical family. His father was a sort of anarchist blacksmith. And I think all of that marks him."
After enduring hardship and multiple arrests in Switzerland, Mussolini returned to Italy in 1905. His fervent anti-imperialist stance during the Italo-Turkish War earned him notoriety and eventual leadership within the Italian Socialist Party (PSI). As editor of the party’s newspaper, Avanti!, Mussolini's fiery rhetoric and charismatic speeches significantly boosted his prominence.
Historian 2 [08:10]: "Mussolini invented fascism. So without Italy, you don't get fascism. Without Mussolini, you don't get Fascism and Hitler."
Mussolini's personal life was marked by tumultuous relationships and moral ambiguity. His multiple affairs, including a brief marriage to Ida Dalser, and abusive behavior towards women illustrated the darker facets of his character. These actions not only alienated him from his peers but also hinted at the authoritarian and ruthless traits that would define his dictatorship.
Helen Roche [17:24]: "Mussolini... has comrades, he has people, acolytes, entourage, who are absolutely, you know, faithful to him... He doesn't have friends, he has lovers."
The outbreak of World War I was a turning point for Mussolini. Initially a staunch anti-militarist and anti-war socialist, he experienced a radical shift towards supporting Italy's involvement in the conflict. This transition was driven by his belief that the war would serve as a catalyst for revolution and national resurgence.
Historian 1 [50:28]: "He demonstrated his ruthlessness, his rejection of compromise. These are traditional socialist ideas... he changed his colors exactly when it suited him."
Mussolini’s pro-war stance led to his expulsion from the PSI in October 1914. Undeterred, he launched his own newspaper, Il Popolo d’Italia, which became a platform for his burgeoning nationalist ideology. His defiance and charismatic leadership attracted like-minded individuals, setting the groundwork for his eventual establishment of the Fascist movement.
Historian 1 [51:19]: "He was able to relate to other groups that were perceiving war as a possibility for a revolution."
The episode concludes with Mussolini’s pivotal decision to support Italy’s entry into World War I, effectively severing ties with the Socialist Party. His unwavering support for the war and his ability to mobilize public sentiment positioned him as a rising political force, poised to reshape Italy’s future.
Narrator [55:45]: "Italy and Mussolini are going to war. In the next episode, wounded at the front, Mussolini's war ends early. Feeling cheated by the peace settlement, he forms a political movement stuffed with disgruntled army veterans. This new National Fascist party will soon storm to power via an audacious march on Rome. That's next time."
Complex Personality: Mussolini's blend of intellectual prowess and violent tendencies made him a multifaceted leader, capable of both inspiring and instilling fear.
Political Transformation: His shift from socialism to nationalism and eventually fascism demonstrates a pragmatic, albeit opportunistic, approach to power.
Impact on Italian Society: Mussolini’s actions and policies significantly altered Italy's political landscape, laying the groundwork for authoritarianism and militarism.
Legacy and Influence: Mussolini's establishment of the Fascist ideology influenced other totalitarian regimes, most notably Nazi Germany under Hitler.
Historian 3 [08:19]: "Hitler in fact borrows it, he plagiarizes it. It's the sorcerer's apprentice... Mussolini is a huge enigma."
Historian 1 [07:27]: "Mussolini's an important historical figure because, of course, he was the ruler of a fascist dictatorship. He was also the first Fascist."
Narrator [55:45]: "Italy and Mussolini are going to war. In the next episode..."
This comprehensive summary encapsulates Mussolini’s early life, his rise within the Socialist Party, his controversial personal life, and his pivotal shift towards nationalism and war support. By weaving together historical narratives with expert analysis, the episode paints a detailed portrait of a man who would become one of history's most infamous dictators.