Detailed Summary of "Stories Podchats: Easter Candy Bracket"

Release Date: April 11, 2025

In this lively episode of the Stories Podchats, hosts Amanda Weldon, Kelsey Lee, and Daniel Hines embark on a whimsical journey to crown the ultimate favorite Easter candy through a spirited bracket-style competition. Joined by guest Brock Rackets, the trio delves into various Easter treats, sharing personal anecdotes, playful banter, and heartfelt opinions to determine which candy truly stands out during the festive season.

1. Introduction to the Easter Candy Bracket

The episode kicks off with a brief and humorous exchange about the hosts' moods, quickly transitioning into the main topic: an Easter Candy Bracket. Daniel introduces the concept, explaining that they will pit different Easter candies against each other in head-to-head matchups, ultimately selecting a favorite.

Notable Quote:

• Amanda Weldon [02:12]: "Now, I'm very... Okay. Okay, good. Okay. Thank you. Thank you so much. I appreciate that."

2. Round 1: PEZ vs. Cadbury Creme Egg ([04:26] - [07:09])

The first matchup features PEZ dispensers against the classic Cadbury Creme Egg.

• Kelsey Lee expresses a love for PEZ but admits a personal dislike for the Cadbury Creme Egg, humorously stating, "I don't like Cadbury Creme eggs. I know I should" ([04:53]).

• Amanda Weldon passionately defends the Cadbury Creme Egg, highlighting its indulgent appeal despite acknowledging its polarizing nature: "They're too gooey and they're so... So I think they are kind of a polarizing candy to like. Many people don't love them. I love them" ([05:06]).

• Daniel Hines reminisces about his love for both PEZ and Cadbury Eggs, sharing his enthusiasm for cracking the eggs into a bowl like an omelet ([05:52]).

Outcome: PEZ advances, while Cadbury Creme Egg faces initial criticism but remains a strong contender.

Notable Quotes:

• Kelsey Lee [04:53]: "I prefer a PEZ. But I'm absolutely okay with the Cadbury Creme Egg moving forward, because I understand that that's a fault of mine."

• Amanda Weldon [05:06]: "I could eat all four easy in like two minutes. Like not two minutes, but like I could eat them all in one sitting, which is like kind of a lot of gooey candy."

3. Round 2: Whopper Robin Eggs vs. Sweet Tarts Chicks and Bunnies ([08:00] - [09:32])

The competition intensifies with Whopper Robin Eggs against Sweet Tarts Chicks and Bunnies.

• Kelsey Lee firmly prefers Sweet Tarts, mentioning, "I prefer the sweet tart" ([08:18]).

• Amanda Weldon shares her disdain for Whopper Robin Eggs, citing their strange taste: "They're gross and weird. I do not like Whopper Robin eggs as a candy" ([08:21]).

Outcome: Sweet Tarts Chicks and Bunnies move forward, while Whopper Robin Eggs are eliminated.

Notable Quotes:

• Kelsey Lee [08:18]: "I prefer the sweet tart. I don't like a Whopper."

4. Round 3: Chocolate Marshmallow Easter Eggs vs. Peeps ([09:32] - [11:29])

In this round, Chocolate Marshmallow Easter Eggs go head-to-head with the fluffy Peeps.

• Daniel Hines shares a funny story about overindulging in Peeps during his youth, leading to an aversion: "I bought the entire leftover inventory for, like, $6 and got so sick on Peeps, I haven't been able to eat a Peep since I ate so many stale Peeps" ([12:09]).

• Kelsey Lee concurs, humorously declaring, "Peep you later" ([11:27]).

Outcome: Peeps are moved on from, while Chocolate Marshmallow Easter Eggs continue their sweet journey.

Notable Quotes:

• Kelsey Lee [11:27]: "Peep you later."

5. Round 4: Reese's Pieces Carrot vs. Cadbury Caramel Egg ([12:00] - [15:58])

This matchup pits Reese's Pieces Carrot against the Cadbury Caramel Egg.

• Kelsey Lee favors the Cadbury Caramel Egg, appreciating its innovation and taste, while acknowledging her previous dislike for Cadbury Creme Eggs: "Personally, I would absolutely prefer the Cadbury caramel egg because I do not like the cream inside the Cadbury Creme Egg. But like I said earlier, quote me. That's a me problem*" ([33:28]).

• Amanda Weldon echoes this sentiment, highlighting the portability and deliciousness of Cadbury Mini Eggs, subtly shifting the focus towards the upcoming mini eggs: "But the Cadbury Mini Eggs are more portable" ([37:17]).

Outcome: Cadbury Caramel Egg advances, while Reese's Pieces Carrot is eliminated.

Notable Quotes:

• Kelsey Lee [33:28]: "I would absolutely prefer the Cadbury caramel egg because I do not like the cream inside the Cadbury Creme Egg."

6. Round 5: Jelly Bean vs. White Chocolate ([16:00] - [18:35])

The hosts debate between Jelly Beans and White Chocolate varieties.

• Kelsey Lee shares her lukewarm feelings towards both, stating, "I don't like a Jelly Bean very much. I don't like the texture of them. I don't like the taste of them" ([17:03]).

• Amanda Weldon reminisces about Jelly Beans being Ronald Reagan's favorite candy but remains non-committal about their appeal: "It's the candy Ronald Reagan loved" ([30:54]).

Outcome: Both Jelly Beans and White Chocolate are moved on from, emphasizing a preference for more decadent sweets.

Notable Quotes:

• Kelsey Lee [17:03]: "I don't like a Jelly Bean very much. I don't like the texture of them. I don't like the taste of them."

7. Round 6: Cadbury Mini Egg vs. Bubblegum Eggs ([22:00] - [25:05])

In a sweet showdown, Cadbury Mini Eggs take on Bubblegum Eggs.

• Amanda Weldon praises the Cadbury Mini Eggs for their crunchy texture and delightful taste, contrasting them with the less appealing Bubblegum Eggs: "They are so crunchy. It's, it's, it's like a high quality..." ([32:48]).

• Kelsey Lee shares a nostalgic story about sharing Cadbury Mini Eggs with a friend during high school, highlighting their enduring appeal: "We bought three family size bags of mini eggs, and we froze them in individual Ziploc bags, and we would take one out every other week and share it." ([23:37]).

Outcome: Cadbury Mini Eggs triumph over Bubblegum Eggs, securing their place as a fan favorite.

Notable Quotes:

• Daniel Hines [24:46]: "I might have told this story before, but when I was..."

• Kelsey Lee [23:37]: "We bought three family size bags of mini eggs, and we froze them in individual Ziploc bags, and we would take one out every other week and share it."

8. Round 7: Chocolate Bunnies - Hollow vs. Solid ([25:05] - [27:41])

This round examines the merits of Hollow Chocolate Bunnies versus Solid Chocolate Bunnies.

• Amanda Weldon prefers hollow bunnies for their ease of consumption and less messiness: "I prefer a hollow chocolate bunny because you can eat half in one sitting and then like, the other half, like, later in the day." ([25:32]).

• Kelsey Lee agrees, valuing the melt-in-your-mouth quality of hollow bunnies over the cumbersome solid ones: "I want it to, like, melt. I want that to, like, melt in your mouth." ([26:27]).

Outcome: Hollow Chocolate Bunnies advance, while Solid Chocolate Bunnies are eliminated.

Notable Quotes:

• Amanda Weldon [25:32]: "I prefer a hollow chocolate bunny because you can eat half in one sitting and then like, the other half, like, later in the day."

9. Round 8: Cadbury Creme Egg vs. Cadbury Caramel Egg ([33:18] - [35:57])

A face-off between Cadbury Creme Egg and Cadbury Caramel Egg sees the hosts navigate their loyalties and taste preferences.

• Kelsey Lee leans towards the Cadbury Caramel Egg due to its melodious flavor, despite her lingering preference for Mini Eggs: "I would absolutely prefer the Cadbury caramel egg because I do not like the cream inside the Cadbury Creme Egg." ([33:28]).

• Amanda Weldon acknowledges her own split loyalty but ultimately supports the Caramel Egg for its taste and convenience: "I think the Cadbury Mini Egg is nice and neat." ([37:17]).

Outcome: Cadbury Caramel Egg emerges victorious over the Creme Egg.

Notable Quotes:

• Kelsey Lee [33:28]: "I would absolutely prefer the Cadbury caramel egg because I do not like the cream inside the Cadbury Creme Egg."

10. Round 9: Reese's Chocolate Peanut Butter Egg vs. Cadbury Mini Egg ([36:53] - [41:15])

In the penultimate battle, Reese's Chocolate Peanut Butter Egg squares off against the beloved Cadbury Mini Egg.

• Kelsey Lee passionately advocates for the Mini Egg, declaring it her favorite candy of all time: "It's my favorite candy of all time. I think, like, wow. It's so... they're so good." ([37:01]).

• Amanda Weldon concurs, highlighting the Mini Egg's portability and satisfying crunch: "I think that the Cadbury Mini Egg is nice and neat." ([40:42]).

Outcome: Cadbury Mini Eggs are crowned the ultimate favorite Easter candy, celebrated for their delectable taste and nostalgic charm.

Notable Quotes:

• Kelsey Lee [37:01]: "It's my favorite candy of all time. I think, like, wow. It's so... they're so good."

• Amanda Weldon [40:42]: "I think that the Cadbury Mini Egg is nice and neat."

11. Final Remarks and Easter Preparations ([41:43] - [45:46])

As the bracket concludes, the hosts share additional thoughts on Easter candies not featured in the competition, such as Kinder Surprise Eggs and Sour Patch Kids. They reminisce about past Easter traditions, share funny stories, and emphasize the importance of enjoying treats responsibly.

The episode wraps up with light-hearted reminders about dental hygiene, tying it back to their sugary discussions: "We love candy. We also love brushing our teeth." ([43:33]).

Notable Quotes:

• Kelsey Lee [43:22]: "We love candy. We also love brushing our teeth."

• Amanda Weldon [43:35]: "Yeah, don't forget to do that."

Conclusion

The Easter Candy Bracket episode of Stories Podchats offers a delightful exploration of beloved Easter treats through engaging discussions and friendly competition. From the crunchy allure of Cadbury Mini Eggs to the nostalgic charm of PEZ dispensers, the hosts provide insightful and entertaining perspectives on what makes each candy special. Ultimately, Cadbury Mini Eggs triumph as the favorite, embodying the sweet spirit of Easter cherished by families everywhere.

Listen to the full episode here to join Amanda, Kelsey, and Daniel in their festive candy showdown!