Catholics helped shape America from the very beginning, even when they were unwelcome.

On The Drew Mariani Show, Dr. Matthew Bunson reflects on the often-overlooked role of Catholics in the founding and development of the United States. As the nation approaches the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, he encourages a renewed appreciation for the Catholic contribution to what he describes as an extraordinary experiment in democratic life.

From the earliest days of the colonies, Catholics were present, though not always accepted. In many regions, especially under English rule, practicing the Catholic faith was restricted or outright forbidden. Laws in places like Virginia made it nearly impossible for Catholics to live freely, denying them the ability to own property or openly practice their religion. Priests who ministered to the faithful risked imprisonment, torture, or death.

Despite these challenges, Catholics persevered, and their presence remained steady. The founding of Maryland in 1634 marked a significant moment, offering a place of relative refuge for Catholics seeking religious freedom. Yet even this early attempt at tolerance was fragile and often disrupted by renewed waves of anti-Catholic sentiment.

Within this historical context, Dr. Bunson highlights the importance of the Carroll family, particularly John Carroll. As the first bishop and later archbishop in the United States, Carroll played a decisive role in shaping the institutional life of the Church in a new and uncertain nation. His leadership helped establish a stable foundation for Catholicism in America, guiding the faithful with wisdom and prudence.

More than a builder of structures, Carroll addressed a deeper cultural and spiritual question: can one be both fully Catholic and fully American? His life offered a clear answer. Through patient engagement and a willingness to work within the emerging framework of the republic, Carroll demonstrated that fidelity to the Church and loyalty to the nation are not in conflict.

His approach stands in contrast to the hostility Catholics often faced. Rather than responding with anger or withdrawal, Carroll chose a path marked by conviction and cooperation. This witness remains relevant today, as Catholics continue to navigate cultural pressures that challenge their place in public life. Dr. Bunson notes that while the forms of opposition may change, the underlying tension persists, now often expressed through secular ideologies that seek to sideline religious belief.

The discussion ultimately serves as a reminder that Catholics today are heirs to a rich legacy. The faith was not handed on easily, but through sacrifice, courage, and perseverance. Recognizing this history is not merely an academic exercise, but an invitation to live more intentionally as Catholics in the present moment.

By reclaiming the story of American Catholicism, the faithful can better understand their identity and mission. The same call that shaped the lives of early Catholics remains today: to witness to the truth, to contribute to the common good, and to do so with confidence rooted in faith.

The best way to listen to the Best of the Week is on our #1 Free Catholic App. It’s free, and always will be! To get and share the Relevant Radio app, check it out here.