The Book Lisp with Jon Ryan & Sarah Colonna: “Beach Vibes” by Susan Mallory - Full Discussion

Release Date: May 26, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of The Book Lisp, hosts Jon Ryan and Sarah Colonna dive deep into their comprehensive discussion of Susan Mallory's novel, “Beach Vibes”. Combining humor with critical analysis, Jon and Sarah explore the intricate dynamics and compelling characters that make this book a noteworthy addition to contemporary fiction.

Plot Overview

“Beach Vibes” centers around Beth, a woman navigating life post-divorce while managing her successful sandwich shop by the beach. The story thickens as Beth discovers her brother Rick has been unfaithful to her friend Janna, leading to a web of secrets and betrayals that test familial and romantic relationships.

• Sarah Colonna ([05:16]): “I really liked it. I did. I thought it was a good story. An interesting story. Sort of the dilemma of what it is to have your relative, your brother, be dating your friend and then find out that he's cheating and how to handle that.”

Character Analysis

1. Rick: The Antagonist

   • Jon Ryan ([06:30]) describes Rick as “a real piece of shit,” emphasizing his sociopathic tendencies and lack of empathy. Rick's manipulative behavior and constant disregard for others' feelings make him a central source of conflict.
   • Notable Quote ([07:04] Jon Ryan): “Rick is Rick the Dick.”

2. Beth: The Protagonist

   • Beth's journey from divorce to self-discovery is a focal point. Despite her financial success, she grapples with low self-esteem and the loss of friendships post-divorce.
   • Sarah Colonna ([16:33]) highlights Beth's emotional struggles: “She sees that her ex husband just got engaged on a fricking billboard right outside the Costco. … what?”

3. Janna: The Friend

   • Janna’s involvement with Rick complicates her friendship with Beth, leading to tension and heartbreak.
   • Sarah Colonna ([24:22]) reflects on Janna's predicament: “She’s more like. So you have to stop sticking your head in the sand about who he is and then choose what kind of relationships you want to have from there.”

4. Dex (Teddy): The Love Interest

   • Dex serves as a beacon of reliability and support for Beth. Their budding relationship provides a contrast to Rick’s toxicity.
   • Jon Ryan ([35:09]) praises Dex’s character: “He’s a good guy, and he’s an actor.”

5. Supporting Characters: Kai and Agatha

   • Kai: A young, insightful employee at Beth's sandwich shop who acts as a mentor figure.
   • Agatha: Beth’s aunt, who serves as the voice of reason, constantly warning Beth about Rick’s true nature.

Themes and Insights

1. Family Dynamics and Loyalty

   • The complex relationship between Beth, Rick, and their family underscores themes of loyalty and betrayal. Beth's protective nature towards her brother conflicts with her ethical stance towards her friend Janna.

2. Trust and Deception

   • Rick's deceit fosters an environment where trust is continually tested. Beth’s struggle to navigate her feelings of betrayal highlights the emotional toll of deceit within personal relationships.

3. Personal Growth and Self-Esteem

   • Post-divorce, Beth's journey towards rebuilding her life and self-worth is a testament to resilience. Activities like horseback riding symbolize her path to self-discovery and healing.

Critiques and Praise

1. Title Mismatch

   • Sarah Colonna ([14:07]) expresses confusion over the title: “It just didn’t feel Like a beach vibes fit the story.” She speculates that publishing strategies might have influenced the title choice.

2. Repetitive Character Traits

   • The hosts critique the repetitive nature of Rick’s characterization, particularly the phrase “he just is who he is,” which they find overused and predictable.
   • Jon Ryan ([14:51]) notes: “They kept saying that because we’re going to find out he’s not who he is is what I felt.”

3. Character Development

   • Despite some criticisms, Jon and Sarah praise the development of peripheral characters like Kai and Agatha, who add depth and richness to the narrative.
   • Jon Ryan ([43:08]): “One of my favorite parts is I really liked the peripheral characters... they’re really good, like, to help tie that story together.”

4. Engaging Plot

   • The suspense and unfolding of Rick’s true nature keep listeners engaged, prompting them to continue reading to uncover the truth.
   • Sarah Colonna ([49:20]): “I blew right through it. I read it in like two days because I was like, what's going to happen? When is this guy going to get busted for being a dick?”

Notable Quotes

• Sarah Colonna ([05:04]): “Yes, we are. This is week four. We're gonna do our full review...”
• Jon Ryan ([07:04]): “Rick is Rick the Dick.”
• Sarah Colonna ([14:07]): “It just didn’t feel like a beach vibes fit the story.”
• Jon Ryan ([14:51]): “They kept saying that because we’re going to find out he’s not who he is is what I felt.”
• Sarah Colonna ([45:28]): “A lot of times when people haven't conquered something in life, it has to do with them getting on a horse.”
• Jon Ryan ([49:15]): “She was more about battling against other people's.”

Conclusion and Ratings

Jon Ryan rates “Beach Vibes” a 10.5/12, praising its intricate plot and character interplay despite some minor flaws.

Sarah Colonna gives it a 3.75/5, appreciating the engaging storyline and character development but noting repetitive elements and title mismatch.

• Jon Ryan ([46:25]): “He is Rick the Dick.”
• Sarah Colonna ([48:14]): “I would have given her a three and three quarters martinis out of five.”

Both hosts express eagerness to explore more works by Susan Mallory, indicating a strong recommendation for listeners seeking a novel rich in emotional complexity and engaging storytelling.

Final Thoughts

Jon and Sarah wrap up their discussion by commending Susan Mallory for crafting a compelling narrative that balances humor, drama, and intricate character relationships. They encourage listeners to explore Mallory’s other works and participate in their Book Club for continued literary discussions.

• Sarah Colonna ([49:21]): “Great pick, John. Lots of fun.”
• Jon Ryan ([50:36]): “Thank you.”

Stay Connected:

• Patreon: Access exclusive content and bonus discussions for just $5 a month.
• Instagram: Follow The Book List for updates and behind-the-scenes insights.
• Facebook Group: Join Book List Spinners to engage with fellow listeners and participate in ongoing conversations.

Thank you for tuning into The Book Lisp. Happy reading!