The Book Lisp Podcast Summary: "Meet Me At The Lake" Full Discussion
Hosted by Jon Ryan & Sarah Colonna
Release Date: July 28, 2025
Book Discussed: Meet Me at the Lake by Carly Fortune
Introduction
In the July 28, 2025 episode of The Book Lisp, hosts Jon Ryan and Sarah Colonna dive deep into Carly Fortune’s summer romance novel, Meet Me at the Lake. Known for their engaging and humorous take on diverse literary genres, Jon and Sarah unpack the intricacies of this psychological thriller set against the backdrop of a serene lakeside resort.
The Perfect Summer Read
The discussion kicks off with Jon and Sarah deliberating what constitutes the quintessential summer read.
Jon Ryan emphasizes simplicity:
“It's a romantic story of summer love that takes place near a beach or water. That's it. That's all you got to do.” [01:14]
Sarah Colonna builds on this by highlighting additional elements:
“We got a resort, we got references to Dirty Dancing. We got lovers, we got family history. It's nice. I liked all those things.” [01:14]
Canadian Influences and Setting
Delving into the book’s setting, both hosts note the prevalence of Canadian cultural references, reflecting Carly Fortune’s heritage. They discuss specific locales and cultural markers like Weber’s Burger and the iconic Tim Hortons.
Sarah Colonna mentions:
“We all got Tim Hortons... Weber’s Burger. Do you ever heard of her?” [02:03]
This segment underscores how the Canadian setting enriches the narrative, adding authenticity and local flavor.
Character Analysis
Fern and Will
A significant portion of the discussion centers around the protagonists, Fern and Will. Sarah is intrigued by Fern’s lingering resentment towards Will for not meeting her at the lake a decade prior, while Jon critiques Will’s inconsistent behavior.
Sarah Colonna reflects:
“Fern... she's got a real chip on her shoulder for since then.” [25:08]
Jon Ryan voices frustration:
“Oh, Sarah did this and this and this... You can go back.” [25:08]
They explore the depth of Fern’s character, her struggles with past trauma, and her journey towards self-acceptance. Jon specifically addresses Will’s flaws, pointing out his lack of balance and commitment.
Jon Ryan states:
“He has no balance. It's all or nothing. All the way around.” [18:42]
Maggie and Family Dynamics
The discussion also delves into Fern's relationship with her late mother, Maggie, and the impact of her diaries on Fern’s personal growth.
Sarah Colonna notes:
“The mom, Maggie and her diaries play kind of a character in the book.” [28:02]
Jon Ryan adds:
“It's like Maggie’s never in this book. She's only in this book through the memories of Fern and through her diary entries.” [28:15]
This exploration highlights how past generations influence present relationships and personal identities.
Themes: Love, Guilt, and Personal Growth
Jon and Sarah examine the central themes of the novel, such as the enduring impact of first love, guilt over past mistakes, and the journey toward personal empowerment.
Sarah Colonna summarizes Fern’s arc:
“She ends up kind of comes to her own at the resort and doing her own thing and, and, and kind of raising them back out of the ashes.” [12:53]
Jon Ryan discusses the emotional baggage:
“...she was alluding to this huge mistake she made as a teen, but she wouldn't say what it was.” [46:08]
These themes are intricately woven into the narrative, providing a rich tapestry of emotional and psychological development.
Criticisms and Frustrations
While generally positive, the hosts voiced specific frustrations with the characters' decisions and plot developments.
Sarah Colonna critiques:
“I just was wondering why Fern had to run around. I mean, he ditched her the day of her big dance... why it's so hard for this guy to just say.” [24:33]
Jon Ryan echoes similar sentiments:
“...he takes off for a month at a time when things aren't going his way.” [22:56]
Their candid critique offers listeners a balanced view, acknowledging both the strengths and shortcomings of the book.
Notable Quotes
Throughout the episode, several poignant and humorous quotes stand out:
-
Jon Ryan on Will’s inconsiderate behavior:
“You don't just ghost someone after two dates.” [24:45]
-
Sarah Colonna on reading diaries:
“I don't want to know anything... I don't want to read a single page of that.” [32:33]
-
Sarah Colonna on character parallels:
“The roses are the characters in the book that I assume John and I will be one day.” [30:20]
Ratings and Final Thoughts
In their concluding remarks, Jon and Sarah rate the book, reflecting their overall impressions.
Jon Ryan gives:
“10 out of 12 beers.” [49:23]
Sarah Colonna provides:
“I’m gonna give it four and a half out of five.” [49:56]
Their ratings encapsulate their enjoyment of the book while acknowledging areas for improvement, particularly regarding character development and relationship dynamics.
Upcoming Features and Recommendations
The hosts wrap up by promoting their Patreon-exclusive content, including bonus chapters and short stories related to Meet Me at the Lake. They also tease their next book pick, "Sometimes I Lie" by Alice Feeney, promising another engaging and thrilling discussion.
Sarah Colonna enthusiastically encourages:
“I really like it. We will read more by her, I'm sure.” [48:02]
Conclusion
Jon Ryan and Sarah Colonna’s discussion of Meet Me at the Lake offers a comprehensive and engaging analysis of Carly Fortune’s novel. Their blend of insightful critique, humor, and personal reflections provides listeners with a nuanced understanding of the book’s strengths and areas for improvement. Whether you’re a fan of summer romances or psychological thrillers, The Book Lisp delivers a well-rounded and entertaining review that’s sure to pique your interest in the next literary adventure.
For more discussions, ratings, and exclusive content, join Jon and Sarah on Patreon and become part of the Book Lisp community today!