
Loading summary
Dave Anthony
We're going on tour. And this is.
Gareth Reynolds
It's been a while.
Dave Anthony
March 2025 is when our tour is happening. First of all, we're going to Tempe, Arizona, maybe our favorite city of all time.
Gareth Reynolds
It's the best.
Dave Anthony
That is on March 16th. And then we go to Albuquerque, New Mexico, maybe our favorite city ever, we've ever gone to. That's on March 17th. And then we go to Oklahoma City.
Gareth Reynolds
Which is our fav. We often say that it's our number one.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, it's our number one. The best city I've ever been to. That's on March 18th. On March 19th, we're going to be.
Gareth Reynolds
In Tulsa, Oklahoma, our favorite city, without question.
Dave Anthony
And then we head to Dallas, Texas, on March 20th.
Gareth Reynolds
Our favorite city.
Dave Anthony
There's never been a better city than better.
Gareth Reynolds
If you don't like it, you're a Dallas hole.
Dave Anthony
Thank you. And then we go to Houston, Texas, on March 21. City, which is by far the best city. And then we end our tour in Austin, Texas, on March 22 at the Cap City Comedy Club.
Gareth Reynolds
It's the best in the entire world. Number one city in the world.
Dave Anthony
You can get tickets@dollop podcast.com tour. You're listening to. I know what it is. You're listening to the Dollop on the All Things Comedy Network. This is an American history podcast where each week I read a story from American history.
Gareth Reynolds
Stop it, buddy. Not this week. Because it's a part two to the part one. Gareth Reynolds. Who knows what the topic is gonna be about. You're listening to Dollop on the All Things Comedy Network. You know the deal here. Each week we. I read a story from American history. Well, this week to my friend and my best friend, Dave Anthony.
Dave Anthony
Hey.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay.
Dave Anthony
All right.
Gareth Reynolds
Let's just jump in. Well, it's the same date. It's May 30th. May 31st, 1st, 1889. Year of Indiana Jones's dad, probably.
Dave Anthony
Wow. Oh, wow. That's intense.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. And I thought about saying that for years.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Yep. Yep. Okay. So do you remember where we left off, Dave? Do you remember what was happening?
Dave Anthony
The damn problem.
Gareth Reynolds
There's. The dam has gone.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
So the dam at the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club. Just fly the damn.
Dave Anthony
Anyway.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, excuse me. The sluice is loose. Okay. So look, it was absolute bedlam. The impact of the flood was so much worse because of all the things the flood was kind of picking up along the way. Sometimes there was so much debris that the flood would actually stop and only to build up Bigger because of the kind of debris bulge.
Dave Anthony
So it was making dams as it went down.
Gareth Reynolds
It was kind of self damning, self taming. And. And then it would like projectile itself out, picking up steam, making the flood bigger. So and then, and then that would just mean that the flood would go and then it would pick up more debris because it was moving faster and cool. And you know, for the most part it's going down the Kahnema riverbed. So it's kind of just like, you know, shredding all these places down the riverbed, but it's super overwhelming places.
Dave Anthony
You mean houses and people?
Gareth Reynolds
I don't know. We'll see. You could see the trees and the telegraph poles flying through it. Bridges, if it were to hit one, would hold it for about 10 minutes sometimes, but then eventually would give out and then the flood would have nice big chunks of bridge in it too. Mineral Point was a small city with about 30 houses along a single street. It was parallel with the river and got absolutely hammered first. By the time the flood had gone through, it didn't look like there was ever a city there at all.
Dave Anthony
That's kind of weak.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah, I mean, it's.
Dave Anthony
Make a stand.
Gareth Reynolds
Are you talking to the property? Okay, that's interesting. That's a take.
Dave Anthony
This is a. This is a podcast about property.
Gareth Reynolds
This episode or this show, just in general.
Dave Anthony
It's about property and property rights and good property.
Gareth Reynolds
I do feel like you kind of keep saying what this. Like this is.
Dave Anthony
It's a real estate podcast.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay. Anyway, the telegram that we discussed in episode. In episode. In episode one, that was sent to Mineral Point.
Dave Anthony
Let me just say, what was the name of the city that just got wiped out?
Gareth Reynolds
Mineral Point.
Dave Anthony
Mineral Point. Right now, right after this flood passes, there's a lot of good land for grabs, for sale. You can move in and you can get some really good deals.
Gareth Reynolds
Right. Okay, that just seems. I don't. Okay, so. So there was a telegram sent by Emma Ehrenfeld, if you remember, in episode one, she finally sent the telegram. But the operator in Mineral Point never got it. I mean, he was forced to leave his tower. He said the first warning he received was seeing people floating by in their.
Dave Anthony
Houses, which is a bad. That's late.
Gareth Reynolds
It's better than a telegram because it kind of lets you. You go, oh, okay, yeah.
Dave Anthony
Then there's something bad.
Gareth Reynolds
There might be a flood. You're keyed into it at that point.
Dave Anthony
What time is it? It's the middle of the night, right?
Gareth Reynolds
No, no, it's like early afternoon. Right. Now it's like maybe three, two, three, something like that. So it was all gone. 16 people died. Also, Emma Ehrenfeld, who had sent the telegraph to Mineral Point and other places, also didn't survive the flood. So she didn't.
Dave Anthony
And how many lots are we talking about?
Gareth Reynolds
Lots.
Dave Anthony
Like housing laws.
Gareth Reynolds
I'm not going to get into the property stuff. I just.
Dave Anthony
It's just. It's a property podcast.
Gareth Reynolds
It really isn't. And you just. I mean, we did a first episode and it wasn't a property. So it feels like you're just saying that now. So in the recounts after Mineral Point was gone, one man explained a conversation between him and another resident. So this guy says, quote, he says, mineral Point is all swept away and the people swept away and my whole family is gone, end quote. I says, quote, is that so? End quote. And I says, do you know anything of my family? And he says, quote, no, I don't. I think they were all drowned. End quote.
Dave Anthony
So that's a.
Gareth Reynolds
So there is just a catch up.
Dave Anthony
It's a very brief conversation.
Gareth Reynolds
I think that's why it ended up in here. It seemed very conversational. Like, you see the game last night? Yeah, See the game. Down to a field goal in overtime. That was close, huh? Yeah. All right, see you later. Get a new wife. All right, see you later. So next was East Conemaugh, where the rail yard was located. There were nine locomotives that were stored there on that day, and then there were additional 20 that were waiting on the tracks for the weather to pass.
Dave Anthony
So now we're talking about property.
Gareth Reynolds
Now we're. If you want to get into it. We are. Yeah. This is rich guy stuff. This is. There you go. So many of the stranded passengers had left the trains due to the delay, but some of them just stayed on the trains to wait it out. I would have 100% been a stay on train, wait it out kind of guy. Engineer John Hess was pulling seven cars into town on the Bellis train when he was stopped by a flagman who told him Hess said, quote, I don't suppose we have laid there more than 20 minutes until we heard the flood coming. We didn't see it, but we heard the noise of it coming. It was like a hurricane through wooded country, which is. A lot of it is about how people heard it. First people heard. Is that regular?
Dave Anthony
Sure.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay. The first thing he could see were trees on the move. More than a flood. So they were all very confused when they would first see it because it did just look like a forest was Attacking.
Dave Anthony
Sure.
Gareth Reynolds
And then the water. They'd eventually see the water chaser. There was also a. Something they like. The first sign of water they saw was actually a mistake. They called it, I think, the black mist. So the first thing they saw was like a Tim Burton movie kind of coming at them like a Sleepy Hollow. Cool. Yeah, very cool. Very cool at first, but then you go, oh, what the. You know, and then. Well, then you're talking to a guy and you're going, you know, hey, do you know anything of my family? And he's going, oh, no, it's over.
Dave Anthony
Here's me telling the story. First the mist came, and then nothing. And I said. I said, whoa. And then your family was gone.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. I hears me. You be him.
Dave Anthony
Okay. I hears me.
Gareth Reynolds
No, you go. Did you hear anything in my family? No. Hell no.
Dave Anthony
Did you hear anything about my family?
Gareth Reynolds
No, they'll be fine. Oh. And then I go home. I go, man, I hope he. Someone else told him. Okay, so. All right. So the first thing he sees are these trees on the move. The water at this point is coming in at 75ft high. That's.
Dave Anthony
That's very high.
Gareth Reynolds
It's very high. And it really fluctuates throughout this, so it's hard to fully know it. I think it was changing in heights again based on where it was sort of stopping. Where it was like kind of hitting into a bridge and. And like that. So there were. It. It fluctuates in. In height. And people.
Dave Anthony
For people in other countries, it's like 23 meters.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. And for people in England, it's nine twiggies.
Dave Anthony
Don't ever say that again.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay, so. So Hestes is coming.
Dave Anthony
It's hot, right?
Gareth Reynolds
I'm okay. You're hot.
Dave Anthony
Yeah. But I might lose the shirt. I might have lose the shirt. I have a tropical disease of some sort.
Gareth Reynolds
Oh, loop bit you?
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. Okay, so. Okay, so the trees are moving. He sees it coming. And Hess sees this. And remember, he's on his train still. And like an action hero, Hess turns to another engineer and said, quote, the lake's broken.
Dave Anthony
That's. He's right.
Gareth Reynolds
He's right. And Hess jumped into action and shouted that all the men and women around needed to run. But he stayed on the train. Why?
Dave Anthony
Because you don't abandon your train.
Gareth Reynolds
Because Hess was on a mission. A whistle mission.
Dave Anthony
Oh, he's gonna whistle.
Gareth Reynolds
The a wishing.
Dave Anthony
He's so he's gonna. He's gonna whistle to warn people. But is he gonna drive the train? Is he gonna take off while the whistling. Do we have a Paul Revere situation happen? And let's just also add that it wasn't really Paul Revere. There was someone else on that.
Gareth Reynolds
Hey, hey, hey. No, no, no, no. I'm teaching. I'm teaching, I'm teaching. Stop, stop, stop, stop. Some context. The train whistle was actually very important to an engineer. Engineers would play around with their tune, their tone, their tenor to make sure it sounded just right for them. It was like a logo, but, you know, a whistle. The whistle was part of the man, the job, the passion. Why, gosh, it mattered as much as the train he conducted. Okay, so anyways, here comes Dave Anthony. So anyways, Hess gets on the train, and he gets the train train steaming and moving. And not only was he holding his whistle down physically, but he eventually tied it down with rope. And what Hess was doing was exactly what you said. He was trying to Paul Revere, even though he's a fake, trying to warn as many people.
Dave Anthony
Train moves slow.
Gareth Reynolds
The train moves slow.
Dave Anthony
I mean, it's a joke.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, he. He doesn't have much time, so it's not like he's, you know, I don't know how many people he saved necessarily. But yes, it's, you know, it's not like. It's like he's not flooring a. Like a Tesla or something.
Dave Anthony
It's on fire.
Gareth Reynolds
So. So what he was doing was trying to warn as many people as possible that could hear it. He said, quote, I didn't know what else to do. I didn't see what else I could do. End quote. And by net, it worked. The Hess whistle kept going as he got closer to Kahnema, where he lived, and people heard it and ran for higher elevation and somewhere.
Dave Anthony
How did they know, just hearing the whistle, that they had to run for higher ground?
Gareth Reynolds
So they are so familiar with what a train whistle does.
Dave Anthony
So if a train whistle is doing.
Gareth Reynolds
Like, you hear like a choo choo.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
But if this was going well, it's really going like. And like there's a flood. Like, they like their Pete. There's a huge storm, so people, like, freak out. So people.
Dave Anthony
So these people are weirdos?
Gareth Reynolds
These people are trained weirdos.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
I don't know what to tell you. And. And then. So he takes the train all the way to where he lives.
Dave Anthony
Yeah. At his house.
Gareth Reynolds
And literally. And he just jumps off it. And he gets to his house just in the nick of time. He saved countless lives there in Kahnema and in Woodvale.
Dave Anthony
This is like the guy who saved all Those people's lives in Altadena a couple months ago.
Gareth Reynolds
Never heard of him. What did he do?
Dave Anthony
He's this random. He's just. He's this dude who graduated from, like a climate, some sort of climate, you know, degree. And he. And I've always followed him, and he's just talks about going up in the park and Altadena and stuff. And in the middle of the night, he put out on a Facebook group. He said, everybody get out. And that was like two hours before the fire hit. He saved, like, many lives.
Gareth Reynolds
It's like his Facebook's a train whistle.
Dave Anthony
Right? And he. Apparently on Facebook, he typed in that's why.
Gareth Reynolds
Because people hear that and they know.
Dave Anthony
Yeah. And so it was just T o o o o o T lag train. I'm gonna turn on the ac.
Gareth Reynolds
You keep. Okay. All right. Okay. All right. So full trains and pretzel track. We're now in the flood waters ahead. So the train station gets pretty much demolished. Some survive. Some of the people on the trains obviously don't make it. Some do.
Dave Anthony
Now, there's a pretty big lot there, so I think get in there. Sears or larger company, It's a good location.
Gareth Reynolds
This is a long time ago and this is a while ago.
Dave Anthony
Maybe movie theaters.
Gareth Reynolds
This is a while ago. I don't think they had that.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, but it's a good piece of land.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay. Some of the trains were Pullman's, just so, you know, just for a callback. Okay, so now it's 407, like an hour. Yeah, no, it's been a little longer.
Dave Anthony
Okay. And now two towns in an hour.
Gareth Reynolds
No more than a few. There's a few towns, but those are the main ones. Okay, so at 407, I mean, it's. It's a river, so it's like it is going for a while, going down. It's kind of like. I think they call it a river. That's what it is. Yeah, it's a river. I can't remember what they call it. It's not horseshoeing, but something like that. Where, like, as it would get to the.
Dave Anthony
Sure. It sloshes.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay. So at 407, it was time for Johnstown. All right.
Dave Anthony
Oh, no, wait, that's bad.
Gareth Reynolds
It's all bad. The flood hit in three different directions through the city. About 40 miles per hour at this point.
Dave Anthony
How many people are living there?
Gareth Reynolds
In Johnstown, there's quite a lot. I mean, thousands.
Dave Anthony
Okay.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. So 40 miles per hour. Truly a wall of water consuming everything. It got near Cambria Iron from. Remember Daniel Morell, his company. Whatever. There we go. So Cambria Iron, the Daniel Morrell company we talked about in the first one. The guy with the neck beard that people really enjoyed. Yeah, Good guy visual. He's a great guy. Cambria Iron had been fulfilling some orders for barbed wire at the time that it got totally leveled by the flood.
Dave Anthony
I don't like this at all.
Gareth Reynolds
So the flood now had barbed wire in it, too.
Dave Anthony
Oh, my God.
Gareth Reynolds
Which is good, because you want barbed wire, you want trains, you want all that stuff in your flood. You want bridges. So like we said, so now there's barbed wire, trains, parts of the bridge and the flood. It's great.
Dave Anthony
It's a lot of stuff.
Gareth Reynolds
It's a lot of stuff. It's like a Pier one Imports.
Dave Anthony
Like, if I'm downstream, I'm just gonna probably not get in it.
Gareth Reynolds
I also would think about the people who could kind of dig in there for stuff they've want.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Like, if you want barbed wire, this could be great for you. Or a train. I mean, if your guy was. I mean, most of us pine for trains, especially back then.
Dave Anthony
It's all up for grabs. Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
No, you could just be a melon real quick. Yeah. The waters were also picking up houses in Johnstown. The waters. So, like, they were. They were like demolishing houses before. But in Johnstown, the waters hit a wooden house with a woman who was baking. The house was ripped from its foundation and flipped on its side and the oven for baking fell over. And then so the house caught on fire. So a firehouse is now being moved by the rush of water. Get it? And now you've got a fire flood. So now you gotta flood with fire.
Dave Anthony
Well, that's on her.
Gareth Reynolds
I agree. And that we've just. That's something we've just started to get into in America again when we're lighting fires on oceans and stuff.
Dave Anthony
But look, if you hear the rumble of a flood, you turn off the stove.
Gareth Reynolds
I agree. And that's how it worked back then.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Known staples of the city were gone or destroyed or burned. All of the above. Roofs, trees, telegraph poles, pieces of bridge, box, train cars. And like we said that sweet as barbed wire. Also a ton of dead animals and people. As the flood crossed through town, it hit a bridge at the end of the city and was kind of stopped. It was sort of halted. At this point, it was covering approximately 30 acres. There were 1600 wood structures. In was like a makeshift dam due to all the solid waste that had kind of accumulated which is good.
Dave Anthony
Well.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, good. You know, that it, like, I mean, self stopped kind of.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, stopping is good.
Gareth Reynolds
There's none of this.
Dave Anthony
But you can get some. Now you can get some fishing in a little recreation.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, but. Well, but hold on, because with all the debris. With all the debris, there's people trapped in it. And they can get out. No, they can't. And the worst thing that could possibly happen happened, which is then that debris caught fire.
Dave Anthony
Jesus Christ.
Gareth Reynolds
It's hard to know exactly what happened, how a massive dam of debris was now smoking on fire. Now, maybe it was, but that. What they think is that it was a derailed train tank car that was in the mix, and some coals had spilled from the train car.
Dave Anthony
Classic.
Gareth Reynolds
And. And then, so, you know, like, 80 more people died from there, from the fire. Now I also think.
Dave Anthony
Imagine being stuck in a flood.
Gareth Reynolds
It'd. Honestly, I'm trying not to go too dark because, you know, it's not funny, but the accounts of.
Dave Anthony
It's insane.
Gareth Reynolds
The accounts of what people were hearing are just horrific. I mean, they're just like. You know. And, like, people are trying to help people. All right, so the total death toll was 2002. Now, I think what also happened was, like, when it kind of stopped its momentum here, a lot of it, like, rushed back and, like, did another pass through Johnstown, too. So Johnstown completely gets. Yeah, like, it, of all of them, is the one that just completely gets, so. Look, David, obviously there is a tremendous amount of darkness in this event.
Dave Anthony
Dave, we don't need the formal.
Gareth Reynolds
I'm teaching you. I'm your professor today, and I'm pretty cool.
Dave Anthony
It makes it a little stale.
Gareth Reynolds
Hey, I'm pretty cool, but I'm not gonna be that cool. But how about this? Maybe after class we can go to the Common, and you and I could smoke a J bone, play a little Frolf. Don't tell your mama.
Dave Anthony
Frolf.
Gareth Reynolds
Mm.
Dave Anthony
What is Frolf?
Gareth Reynolds
Frisbee Golf.
Dave Anthony
Okay. Just read your story.
Gareth Reynolds
Hey, I want to talk to you about.
Dave Anthony
You're not cool.
Gareth Reynolds
You seem pretty down lately. Talk to your teacher's also cool.
Dave Anthony
You. I'm down.
Gareth Reynolds
Hey, teach.
Dave Anthony
You're not my teacher.
Gareth Reynolds
Say teach.
Dave Anthony
You're a guy reading a story, Buddy.
Gareth Reynolds
You didn't know any of this. I knew it.
Dave Anthony
Get back to the.
Gareth Reynolds
I read over one and a half books.
Dave Anthony
Maybe I'm really uncomfortable. Hey, no.
Gareth Reynolds
Hey, maybe after class we can go do some milkshakes, try to. You look so mad. What's going on at home? Yeah, no, you know, what's going on?
Dave Anthony
We'll go do milkshakes after.
Gareth Reynolds
What's wrong? Is your dad. Is your dad doing something?
Dave Anthony
He's dead.
Gareth Reynolds
What'd he die from?
Dave Anthony
He died in a fire after a dam crashed through the town.
Gareth Reynolds
Damn.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, damn's right. That's where the phrase came from.
Gareth Reynolds
That's tough, man.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Maybe you come over to my house later tonight and we can watch the Never Ending Story.
Dave Anthony
Okay. Why don't you just finish this and we'll get on with.
Gareth Reynolds
This is an ending story. Well, we'll watch tonight. It'll be a little. Hey, all right. Chill, man. All right. Obviously, there's a tremendous amount of darkness in this event. So rather than focus on all the deaths because they're very dark, I'm going to tell you some amazing stories of survival and heroism. Like when Victor Heiser went to go check on his family's horses in the barn when the epic storm was going on. And then the flood hits and it hit the barn and the barn was lifted up. Like a lot of the other places was fully lifted up. So his dad and he had just built like a trap door from the barn to, like, the roof.
Dave Anthony
Sure.
Gareth Reynolds
So Victor quickly ran to the roof through the trapdoor in the barn, and then he was up on the house. So while the house is moving down the floodwaters, he's made his way to the top, to the roof. He's kind of barn surfing. Sure. As he took off, he sees that one of his neighbors houses is still actually standing. So he kind of walks to the edge of his roof and he. Jackie Chan jumped off of the barn roof.
Dave Anthony
Is he at any time during this, is he yelling yahoo?
Gareth Reynolds
I don't. They don't have that. I think. I don't think these people were celebrating it as much of maybe you.
Dave Anthony
What about Cowabunga?
Gareth Reynolds
That he did yell. Yeah, Other people yelled that, too. Okay, so. So he Jackie Chans off of that barn of his family's barn roof onto the neighbor's house, and then he gets onto their roof. And as soon as he gets onto their roof, that caves in.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
And so that caves in and he falls. And he kind of is hanging on the edge on one of the eaves of the building, but the water is rushing beneath him. And he's trying to get his foot up, but he can't get a foothold. And eventually he's so tired his fingers gave in and he falls off the building onto a piece of debris. It's someone else's roof. So he lands on this roof debris. And now he's rushing down the flood water on the roof. So he's roof boarding, they call it. And it became a huge thing in the X Games as he cruised down the flood. He was pat. He was passing other people from the neighborhood who are also debris kayaking, literally. He sees these people who run a fruit stand, and he's like, hey, what's going on? You know? And they're like, I mean, he's not like that, but he's like, yeah, he's crazy.
Dave Anthony
Did you go get any strawberries?
Gareth Reynolds
Did you? The new strawberries come in and. And so. So he holds on. He surfs down the water. Trees are passing over him. Like he's ducking trees, dodging them. And then a train car literally kind of just goes over him.
Dave Anthony
I don't like.
Gareth Reynolds
And now the roof splits apart, and he gets on a half of it. And that half, because of what the train did, just kind of gave him momentum. And he said, quote, that he shot out from beneath the freight car like a bullet from a gun. And now he's headed towards this brick building that's still in place. And he jumped off of the wood ski to the roof, where he was now with others who were surviving this ordeal. None of them like him, but still, quote, I was able to hop to the roof and join a small group of people already stranded there, End quote. And he checked his pocket watch right before the barn took off and right after he got to safety, and the whole thing took 10 minutes.
Dave Anthony
I mean, it's all right. He should have had his video going on his phone. Like, that would be a great TikTok.
Gareth Reynolds
This would be good for GoPros. But he didn't even have one.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, I guess you could be great to have, like a head.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah, that would have been smart to have some sort of head out.
Dave Anthony
So it sounds like he blew it a little bit.
Gareth Reynolds
When you read back a lot of people like this stories. I don't think they thought he blew it. Yeah, but it's good to get fresh eyes on stuff like that. I think you're kind of providing something that is helpful and maybe that'll be fun tonight when we go get some pizza. Keep on with the story teaching David. Hey, that would be so whack. Jack off. Okay. There's also a story of two men who were leaning out of opposite windows, like, across from the flood, and of small white buildings, and they were using long sticks to try to rescue as many people as they could. And as the floodwaters Are gaining. One of them had a baby. One of them had a baby, huh?
Dave Anthony
In the water. Someone's got a baby.
Gareth Reynolds
I don't think it was a baby they saved from the water. I think there was a. It might have been. I mean, look. Shit. There are a lot of accounts of people pulling a lot of people out of this shit. So there. I mean, there is. Well, anyway, so one of them has a baby and shouts to the other person across the way. And they said, quote, throw that baby over here, end quote. And the other one shouted, quote, do you think you can catch her? End quote. And the other guy says, no, quote, we could try.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, give it. We'll give a shot.
Gareth Reynolds
So he. The other guy tosses the baby 15ft over the water into the arms of another guy, and that guy caught it and the baby.
Dave Anthony
But the baby broke.
Gareth Reynolds
No, no baby survived.
Dave Anthony
Because when you throw a baby that far, I mean, they say, don't throw a baby 20ft because that's definitely gonna break. But like a 15 foot, you got like a 75% chance of just snapping it.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, this is why when people see them, people throw their kids into pools and stuff like that, there's a lot of people like, hey, take. This is why you do it.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
You train in the off season for the event. Yeah, of course. So it's really about, you know, how you've got to know, look, a baby will fly.
Dave Anthony
They fly.
Gareth Reynolds
I mean, you know what I mean? It's like two footballs.
Dave Anthony
Especially if someone is good at baby throwing. And that's why I think we should bring this back to the Olympics.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. In la, which we're all excited about. Absolutely. Yeah. That's gonna be good. Another guy just surfed the whole time on a mattress for four miles and survived.
Dave Anthony
I mean, that's. Yeah, yeah, I would do that. That'd be me.
Gareth Reynolds
There's gotta be. That guy was like, definitely at the.
Dave Anthony
End, like, I can't believe it floated that long without sinking, but. Okay.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, another family stayed in their house all night and just floated on their bed the whole night, I'm guessing.
Dave Anthony
Sure, why not?
Gareth Reynolds
It probably had a wood base and. But they just floated. Again, mixed in here are a lot of stories that are not anywhere like this.
Dave Anthony
Well, I want to just say, as far as the floating in the house story, their story sucks.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. It's not great. I think you'll like this one. One guy named Leroy Temple was counted as dead, but was actually very much alive. After the flood carried him away from his home, he hit the Stone bridge. Got out, climbed this embankment, and immediately walked to Massachusetts, where he was from originally. So he literally went far of a walk. Is that. I mean, it's a distance. It's maybe under a thousand. It's still fucking. It's crazy to go from bridge to Boston. Hundreds of hundreds of miles.
Dave Anthony
But look, you get out, you're like, well, nothing here.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. Or you're just like, well, fuck that. Like, that's what I would do after, like climb. You know what I mean? That's like what you feel like doing. People in Johnstown thought it was a myth. Thought his story was made up. Because there were a lot of made up stories. Thought his story was a myth. But 10 years later he returned and everyone's like, holy shit, there you are. Yeah. He's like, cool, I'm alive. I just went to Massachusetts for a while.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, I took a break. This place is a bummer.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah.
Dave Anthony
It's also good to get out of the place you were born in.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, he was born in Massachusetts.
Dave Anthony
Never mind.
Gareth Reynolds
So, you know, it's not actually. I'd say it's just good to get out of the places that are flooding.
Dave Anthony
With the places under 75.
Gareth Reynolds
A train flood.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. Okay, so, Dave. The destruction was still unfathomable, incomparable. It was and remains to be the deadliest flood in the history of the United States.
Dave Anthony
Okay, so let me ask you this. We'll get into this now. Who didn't pay? Go ahead.
Gareth Reynolds
Who didn't pay?
Dave Anthony
Who didn't pay for the crime?
Gareth Reynolds
Well, I don't know. What do you mean? I don't get into that. This is.
Dave Anthony
You're not going to talk about how no one was held accountable?
Gareth Reynolds
Come on. You think that's what this is all about? Yes. One out of every three bodies was unidentified. Basically, one person out of every 10 that was around died. And Johnstown got it worse. There was more like, you know, nine out of every nine. But America, you know us, we love tragedy porn.
Dave Anthony
We do.
Gareth Reynolds
So America couldn't stop reading about the flood. His estimates were all over the map is how many people passed away. Some papers were estimating 10,000 and higher.
Dave Anthony
I agree with that.
Gareth Reynolds
The Pittsburgh. I don't think that's right. The Pittsburgh Post Gazette was so sought after that it had to shrink its page size. Yeah, so that it could print enough editions.
Dave Anthony
I've done that.
Gareth Reynolds
It was called the Great Calamity or the Nation's Greatest Calamity or the Historic Catastrophe. The papers kept printing the names of all the dead. It Was kind of one of those morbid press fascinations fueled by people unable to get enough Right. So not knowing where. And that also is like we do that now but back then. So that's the thing. Like we are so into that now. Like reading about the awful stuff. But back then, I mean this just had to be like as good as does itch that.
Dave Anthony
Yeah. People like it. People like a disaster story. Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
And then. But what is this one is obviously a huge disaster. So you should be have some sort of interest or intrigue. But the. You know, it's like now we'll go like a hiker got stabbed. Right. We got a kick out every.
Dave Anthony
You know, things called the hicker.
Gareth Reynolds
Nice. So not knowing where the interest pieces should stop. The Philadelphia Press had a story on June 5 about the undertakers in the area. So this is where they're kind of finding the bott.
Dave Anthony
They're busy.
Gareth Reynolds
They're busy. They're busy.
Dave Anthony
The busy.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, that's what this story really is about. Undertakers in the area. Read quote. One of the most ghastly and nauseous sights to those unaccustomed to scenes of death is the launching arrangement for the undertakers. These men are working so hard that they have no time for meals. And huge boilers of steaming coffee, loaves of bread and dried beef and preserves are carried into the channel house and placed at the disposal of the workers.
Dave Anthony
And you don't want to get the beef and the people mixed up.
Gareth Reynolds
Along comes one weary toiler, his sleeves rolled up, an apron in front of his perspiring profusely despite the cold damp weather. He was just finishing washing a clammy corpse, has dabbed it with cold water, manipulated it about on the boards. And in the interval before the body of another poor wretch is brought in, gets a cup of coffee and a sandwich with dripping hands, he eats his lunch with relish, setting his cup occasionally beside the hideous face of a decomposing corpse and totally oblivious to his horrible surroundings.
Dave Anthony
Does the sandwich have relish on it or is he relishing the sandwich?
Gareth Reynolds
I think, well, you. He eats his lunch with relish. I think he's having a side of relish. Now, I want to point out. That's a wild first question. That's a wild follow up.
Dave Anthony
Let's get the. The basic sandwich.
Gareth Reynolds
I don't think the first like they. They're talking about how this guy, he's not washing his hands right, but he's like.
Dave Anthony
I think the important thing here is.
Gareth Reynolds
What'S he eating like let's, they got into that. But the idea, I mean, you know what he's eating, it's just to be so specifically like was it, was it relish on the sandwich or was it separate relish?
Dave Anthony
The Dollop is brought to you by Neutrophil.
Gareth Reynolds
Dave.
Dave Anthony
You know, the pros, they got their little secret strategies for peak performance and how to, you know, get through it. But what we're talking about here is the, the secret strategy for keeping your hair in the game.
Gareth Reynolds
Yep.
Dave Anthony
Keep your hair.
Gareth Reynolds
Some pros are trying to win the game and keep their hair in the game.
Dave Anthony
If you've noticed a little bit of thinning, get ahead of it with neutral. If you've got a little bit of thinning situation, you know, get a little bit weaker up there, maybe you want a little, little more volume. Nutrafol takes a science back approach to help you go th fuller hair from the inside out. I started using Nutrafol and immediately, not immediately, it takes like three to six months. But people were like, your hair looks thicker. What have you done to your hair? Someone asked me if I got plugs. Someone asked me if I was using Rogaine. My hair.
Gareth Reynolds
Someone asked why you in their living room, you weren't supposed to be there, all that stuff.
Dave Anthony
The only thing I've been doing different is neutral. Thinning hair, very common, really is amazing. Thinning hair, very common, very frustrating for a lot of people. It can be from a bunch of different things. Stress, nutrition, hormone, lifestyle, a lot of factors. And Nutrafol can help you.
Gareth Reynolds
Great.
Dave Anthony
Nutrafol is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplement brand trusted by over one and a half million people in just three to six months. Go from a hat guy to a hair guy with thicker, stronger, faster growing hair with less shedding. Nutrafol's hair growth supplements are physician formulated using 100 drug free ingredients. Their patented technology provides consistent, reliable results. And men also reported no compromise in sexual performance, which is big for you.
Gareth Reynolds
Huge.
Dave Anthony
You love sex. So start your hair growth journey with neutral for a limited time. Neutrophil is offering our listeners $10 off your first month subscription and free shipping when you go to nutrival.com men and enter the promo code the Dollop. Find out why over 4, 500 healthcare professionals and stylists recommend Nutrival for healthier hair. Nutriful.com men spelled n u t r a f o l.com promo code the dollop that's nutriful.com man promo code the Dollop Ness Gareth, Dave, the doll was also brought to you by litter robot.
Gareth Reynolds
Oh, my Lord.
Dave Anthony
There's a million reasons you love your cat. There is one reason that your cat is a problem, and that is Gareth.
Gareth Reynolds
No, it's not me in the house. Well, they use the bathroom in the house. And it's like I told this story about when I moved out of my apartment. I was trying to get my security deposit back, and the landlord was like, yeah, we just gotta get the cat litter smell out. And I was like, what? I like, didn't even notice. It was like a dirty little secret. I trul. When we were at Matt Farah's place the other night. Farah's place the other night, he's asking about the litter robot. I'm like, dude, it is an absolute game changer if you have a cat or cats.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, it's four.
Gareth Reynolds
Is he doesn't he has a catio. It's insane what he's got going on over there. But you. You really, you. It is a game changer. The litter is pretty much taking care of itself. All you have to do is take a little bag out of the bottom. Whatever you want to do. Once, twice a week. It rotates the litter. It cleans it. It te. I know on my phone when he's going to the bathroom. There's an app for that. I'm into it.
Dave Anthony
I get messages.
Gareth Reynolds
I want you off of that immediately. I did not know you were on that, but I want you off of it.
Dave Anthony
They got to know when you're.
Gareth Reynolds
But it tells you when it's full down there. It's just the best. And he loves it. Your house smells better. I've literally had people walk in and be like, it doesn't smell like cat. Which again, it's not great. With the world I was living in before, it is the best. Cannot recommend it enough for.
Dave Anthony
There you go. So as a special offer to our listeners of the show, go to Stop Scooping.comDollop and use promo code Dollop to save an additional $50 on any litter robot bundle. That's $50 off any litter robot bundle at StopScooping.comDollop and use Promo code Dollop. Stop Scooping.comDllop Promo code Dollop.
Gareth Reynolds
Nice.
Dave Anthony
So if I'm surrounded by bodies and I'm here we go, wiping them down, I'm doing this. I'm probably famished. After a while, I'm going to eat.
Gareth Reynolds
Sure.
Dave Anthony
And. And. And you just eat. You eat on your job site. It's no different than a guy who's on a construction site. You see him, the picture, and they're. They're up on the steel beam and they're eating their sandwich or they're eating at work.
Gareth Reynolds
It's different. So you're just vastly different.
Dave Anthony
So you're just eating at work.
Gareth Reynolds
It's vastly different. It's vastly different.
Dave Anthony
Are you saying that he should have like a break room?
Gareth Reynolds
I think that's better because I do think you're. The odds go up that some guy is going to forget and just start eating a guy's hand and then start like, you know, performing whatever autopsy stuff he has to or post mortem stuff he has to. On a sandwich.
Dave Anthony
That he wipes his mouth and then.
Gareth Reynolds
With another guy's hand and then he.
Dave Anthony
Wipes the corpse's mouth. Yeah, he's not thinking.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, he's just eating brain.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
You know, because he thinks it's the relish, which is actually a good point about the relish.
Dave Anthony
This is how the, the next part of the story, which is the zombie outbreak.
Gareth Reynolds
No, I'll handle again, I'll handle. Don't talk about what's coming up or where you think this is going.
Dave Anthony
And let's not forget to get swim lessons.
Gareth Reynolds
It's not a bad. Not a bad point at all. My camera's off. Okay, so the funniest piece of journalism.
Dave Anthony
Well, also, it's interesting that you framed it that way.
Gareth Reynolds
I also took out the thing about a fake Paul Revere that they made up. Oh, yeah, they made up. They made up their own fake Paul Revere and he was this guy named. I can't remember what his name was.
Dave Anthony
Toots the Horn.
Gareth Reynolds
He's the guy, he's the guy who came and he was telling everybody and let's go.
Dave Anthony
There's a flooded.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. So he existed in the papers for like three years or two years.
Dave Anthony
And it wasn't real.
Gareth Reynolds
It was not real. Okay. So the funniest bit of journalism, I think was this Johnstown woman who was called a bride. She wasn't even called a woman. They were like a Johnstown bride who was quoted as saying, quote, today they took five little children out of the water who had been playing Ring around the Rosie. Their hands were clasped in a clap which even in death did not loosen. And their faces were still smiling. So they're having a good time. I just, they immediately. People were like, that's not. No, that wouldn't happen. They weren't frozen. Like, no, they're in demolition.
Dave Anthony
The water hits.
Gareth Reynolds
He seems up. No, no. Once the water Hits you like this, they're probably freaked out if they existed.
Dave Anthony
You be the water, I'll be the kid.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay. Water. Coming, coming, coming, coming, coming. Okay. So the second it touches you. So it is a little terminatory. Yeah.
Dave Anthony
You grab and then the smile goes up and you're.
Gareth Reynolds
I just don't believe the smile would hang. I don't think. I think that looks. Drowning. 1889 called bullshit. 1889, drowning takes a couple minutes.
Dave Anthony
And how long does it take to lose a smile? Three.
Gareth Reynolds
A lifetime. Okay. Another hero was Ms. Clara Barton, who was brought in from the recently started American Red cross. She was 67 years old and set up headquarters in a railroad car that was not being used. She made. She made herself a makeshift desk and she started sending out orders immediately. She got construction underway for temporary houses for those who'd lost their homes and had surveys to see how many people in the area needed any attention. She and the Red Cross did an amazing job, and she was promised they would stay as long as there was work to do. We are always the last to leave the field. End quote. And she meant it. She stayed a full five months, never leaving once. David, She's a reminder of what can be done when funding goes to organizations to help people in disasters.
Dave Anthony
So she just, without permission, took over a rail car.
Gareth Reynolds
No, that's not. You're framing her as a villain.
Dave Anthony
What I heard.
Gareth Reynolds
This is a person who helped.
Dave Anthony
What? Sounds like she just went in and commandeered someone else's property.
Gareth Reynolds
No, no.
Dave Anthony
Okay.
Gareth Reynolds
She's helped. She set up a office in a train. I mean, that's what you're mad about.
Dave Anthony
Everybody has.
Gareth Reynolds
No, like, she's a hero.
Dave Anthony
I just think you got nobody.
Gareth Reynolds
Nobody has poured water on her.
Dave Anthony
It just. At some point you got to ask. No. Who's taking the risk?
Gareth Reynolds
All right, so. Excuse me. Who said you could be here? You come in. I need to see some identification, please. This is not okay. You work for the railroad, The Red Cross.
Dave Anthony
The fuck is.
Gareth Reynolds
I never heard of that.
Dave Anthony
Get out of here, you fucking deadbeat.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, that's what I love now, too. Like, when you see, like, that's why I just don't. We're so accustomed now to when there's a natural disaster, everything being like, will you donate to the American Red Cross? It's like, we. We should. We have the money. Like, get. Put it.
Dave Anthony
Why don't you take some of that bomb money?
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah, why don't you take the bomb money and just go to like. But instead, they're just like, these People. I mean, again, it's not. It's not a lack of sympathy for those who are in disasters. It's just like you. You do it. You have all the.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
You took all of our money. Yeah, okay. But for all the people like Clara, there were also a bunch of idiots who also. I should say Colonel Unger and John park, or, sorry, John park and. And Hess, were also viewed as heroes. Has the whistle guy. John park, the guy who went down and told them all. Anyway, for all the people like Clara, there were also a bunch of idiots who showed up for the wrong reasons.
Dave Anthony
These guys.
Gareth Reynolds
I love these guys. You're going to like this guy.
Dave Anthony
These are the best guys.
Gareth Reynolds
Like the religious lunatic who went by the name Lewis the Light, who wore nothing but long red underwear and handed out hand bills with dumb written on them, like, quote, death is man's last and only enemy. Extinction of death in his only hope. Your soul, your breath ends by death. We whoop, we're all in the soup. Who's all right? Louis the Light.
Dave Anthony
I mean, is any of that wrong? No.
Gareth Reynolds
Is any of the right. Yeah, okay. Phil's Lewis Delight. Yeah, I don't know.
Dave Anthony
He's. He's.
Gareth Reynolds
Red, long underwear, walking around town.
Dave Anthony
I mean, you're now mad at a guy who's basically like a flood. Santa Claus.
Gareth Reynolds
First of all, you're the one who was getting mad at Clara for just taking a.
Dave Anthony
She's a freeloader. It doesn't sound like this guy's taken over any property.
Gareth Reynolds
No, but he's okay.
Dave Anthony
I mean, there's always a crazy guy. The crazy religious guys are always there.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, and also, I took this out good for time, but there's a lot of. A lot of xenophobia, too. A lot of stuff about the hunkies, the Hungarians. Every immigrant was called a hunky now. And anyone who wasn't just like a traditional American was called a hunky. They were being blamed for a lot of. There's a lot of disgusting, like, cartoons of like, you know, these kind of dingy dudes trying to take advantage. There were a lot of people taking advantage of the situation. There were even people showing up at the Red Cross and getting free handouts and shit like that. But a lot of it for a while was obviously blamed on immigrants because America's gonna. America, let's remember this land was okay. So donations did pour in from everywhere. Trains with first aid supplies kept coming in. Tons of lumber, furniture, barrels of embalming fluid or pine tar. Minneapolis sent a lot of flour Walla Walla gave a carload of potatoes. Cincinnati was generous enough to give £20,000 of ham.
Dave Anthony
Oh, that.
Gareth Reynolds
That's kept coming.
Dave Anthony
Classic Cincinnati. They still do that today?
Gareth Reynolds
They do. Cincinnati always makes it. Ham rain.
Dave Anthony
Yeah. They're like, who needs ham?
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. And you're like, not now.
Dave Anthony
We're good.
Gareth Reynolds
We need another disaster. We have too much ham. Okay. We need. We're gonna blow up. That was government building.
Dave Anthony
I mean, that's the thing is when they start blowing shit up just to get the ham out, it's really well.
Gareth Reynolds
Because when you give them, when you grant the hand budget, it's like they need to spend it. So to get it. To get it re. Re.
Dave Anthony
Upped.
Gareth Reynolds
You know what I mean? Yeah, yeah. All right. But Dave, you were alluding to this before jumping ahead, but what about South Fork? Well, Davey boy David. Sweet Dan. There were now more and more rumblings about the responsibility that they had in the event.
Dave Anthony
You know what, pointing fingers is dumb, but. Okay.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay. Colonel Unger, remember him? He was. He was running the. He's running the place now because Rough died.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
So Colonel Unger and John park were finally reached for comment and they both spoke. Unger told the Pittsburgh Post that they did everything they could to prevent the disaster. And he kind of lamented the fact that the club was about $150,000 in the hole, but he didn't really do.
Dave Anthony
Everything he could because, like, he didn't let them clean off the drain in time. And.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, it wasn't even really a drain at this point. But. Yeah. Yeah, you're right. You didn't let him remove the fish. The fish gate thing still, you know what I mean?
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Again, you're forgetting that it was a buck of fish.
Dave Anthony
Also, he's a colonel, so.
Gareth Reynolds
He's a colonel.
Dave Anthony
Leave him alone.
Gareth Reynolds
They said that when he went back to his place after all this, he collapsed. Like, he had a dramatic collapse, like. And the victim, John park, again, still considered a hero, told the New York son, quote, no blame could be attached to anyone for this greatest of horrors. It was a calamity that could not be avoided.
Dave Anthony
Quote, why is John park considered a hero?
Gareth Reynolds
Because he was the one who, when the dam was. He thought it was about to fail. He saw it kind of cresting. He took his horse and got to town in 10 minutes to tell them to send the. The telegram off. He was shouting to everybody. So he. He told the son that the problem was, quote, storm after storm. And he said, quote, by 12:00, everybody in the Kanama region did know or should have known of their danger.
Dave Anthony
That's right.
Gareth Reynolds
End quote.
Dave Anthony
That's right.
Gareth Reynolds
It's not right.
Dave Anthony
It's on. It's on the individual.
Gareth Reynolds
It says so America. Well, I don't know. One member of the South Fork fishing and Hunting club named James McGregor said there was no problem with South Fart. South Park Park. South Park, South Fork. He said he thought the whole thing was just a big misunderstanding. He even boasted the quote. He even boasted, quote, I am going there to fish the latter part of this month. As for the idea of the dam ever being condemned, it is nonsense.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
We have been putting in from 20,000 to $15,000 a year at South Fork. We have all been shaking hands with ourselves for some years and being pretty clever businessmen, we should not be likely to drop that much money in a place that we thought was unsafe. No, sir. The dam is just as safe as it ever was. And any other reports are simply wild notions and.
Dave Anthony
Okay. I mean, there's no proof of that ever being wrong.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, it's also so much like today where he does, you know, what we always do, which is just equate money with intelligence or capability.
Dave Anthony
Look, I'm successful, so I do think I have money.
Gareth Reynolds
So you can let me fix everything.
Dave Anthony
History of littered with rich idiots.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah, And I mean, it really does bring you to now like where you're just like, what the fuck? And the amount of people are just like, he has so much money. How do you think he got it on the back of everybody around him? Of course we're talking about Jesse the body Ventura. Lewis Clark, who was a club member, told the New York Herald that after talking to some engineers, he wasn't even sure if the dam was the issue at all.
Dave Anthony
Right.
Gareth Reynolds
Very Republican.
Dave Anthony
She's right. Yeah. It was a. It was a parts around the dam.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, he. He's saying it could have been another dam entirely.
Dave Anthony
Thank you.
Gareth Reynolds
James Reed, another member, echoed that and said, quote, in the absence of any positive statement, I will continue to doubt, as do many others familiar with the place, that it really let go. It might have been a different dam.
Dave Anthony
Yep.
Gareth Reynolds
So second, now we're doing the double dam theory.
Dave Anthony
Well, have you heard and this is.
Gareth Reynolds
Of the Grassy dam?
Dave Anthony
Well, this is a pretty common thing that happens in the situation. But have you heard of a ghost.
Gareth Reynolds
Damn, is that with Bill Cosby?
Dave Anthony
Yeah. So the ghost dam will let go and that will cause other dams to then. So it's not necessarily in the material world, but often a ghost dam is at fault.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, that's what it is. Pretty. It does show you how up their own asses they are to be like, we gotta figure out which dam did this when they have no damn. They have no damn left. And they are just like, all right, there's definitely a dam.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, it was damn.
Gareth Reynolds
We got to figure out which dam did it.
Dave Anthony
Who up our dam?
Gareth Reynolds
So, as you would imagine, people are now getting pissed. On June 3, reporters from Johnstown went to the dam and started reporting back and kind of ended a lot of the speculation that the dam had not done the damage.
Dave Anthony
How many. How many days after was that?
Gareth Reynolds
This is a few days. Okay, it's pretty quick. After. They then also began tracing the history of the dam back, which was bad news for the club. Like we said, he took the sluices out. There's just. There's bad swelling in the middle. There's. There's the cresting issue. There's the drop, the dip. That Monday night, a group of furious men from Johnstown went to the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club looking for any members who may have been hanging around.
Dave Anthony
Hanging?
Gareth Reynolds
Hanging. Well, that'd be great. When they couldn't find anybody, they just broke into some of the cottages by smashing the windows and destroyed the furniture, which is a letdown. I mean, so you come all that way, you want to do something, make.
Dave Anthony
Love, and have a nice weekend.
Gareth Reynolds
I would definitely be banging. Yeah, there's no doubt. You just definitely whoever, too. I'm not.
Dave Anthony
No. I mean, I think it's. This is about romance.
Gareth Reynolds
I just. You know what I do? I'd bang the bearskin rug, okay? I just toss it over chair with some of your other buddies. I take one of those sluices right there.
Dave Anthony
What?
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah. Got a bear hole. Fucking. You know what I mean? Right there in front of your friend. You're just going like, we're going to show these guys who's boss.
Dave Anthony
This is.
Gareth Reynolds
Oh, man.
Dave Anthony
This is 100 worse than the flood. No.
Gareth Reynolds
Come on. I'm about to flood. No. Oh, my damn. My damn. None of that.
Dave Anthony
No.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay. You're looking out the window.
Dave Anthony
I'm for long for Lauren. Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Forlorn. So they. They. It seems like they were genuinely gonna go kill Colonel Unger, but he could not be found.
Dave Anthony
They should have.
Gareth Reynolds
People were pissed. A lawyer in Allegheny county, which is right there, said, quote, I predict there will be legal suits with possible criminal indictments as a result of this catastrophe.
Dave Anthony
I predict there won't.
Gareth Reynolds
I am told that the South Fork Club has been repeatedly warned of the safety of Its dam. And it comes from good authority, end quote. But it also, it wasn't helping. The optics were terrible. All the members, as soon as the storm lifted, just left. None of them stuck around to help the people who'd been affected so greatly. And once the specifics were getting out about Rough and how he'd, quote, rebuilt the dam, people were furious. Then H.W. brinkenhoff, a renowned engineer, and M. Wellington and F.B. burt and P.B. acronym. Come on, that one's fake. But all the others are real. All from Engineering News showed up. And on June 5, they had rendered their own verdict to the New York sun with a headline that read, quote, cause of calamity. Cause of the Calamity. The Pittsburgh fishing club, chiefly responsible. The waste gates closed when the club took possession, end quote. So the club was on the hook in their opinion. Quote. There was no massive masonry nor any tremendous exhibition of engineering skills and designing the structure, putting it up. There was no masonry at all. In fact, not any engineering worthy of the name. The dam was simply a gigantic heap of earth dumped across the course of a mountain stream between two low hills.
Dave Anthony
That works.
Gareth Reynolds
It does. Does not.
Dave Anthony
It does.
Gareth Reynolds
It doesn't work.
Dave Anthony
Okay, what are you, a beaver now?
Gareth Reynolds
No, that would be way more helpful. But more and more people are coming out talking about how terrible the dam was, how even when it got rebuilt, they were scared. Well, people were talking about it. People were like, for a long time were like, that's not good. Like, people would even go like, even you, like Daniel Morell in the first episode, he's going like, hey, what the fuck? Like there's so there's definitely people down there. But it is one of those things where it's like, it is like the wildfires. It's like you are very accustomed to, like they were accustomed to flooding because there was a lot of rain and stuff or, or you know, however it was happening. But the full on tragedy, you don't, you can't even if you know it's coming. Like, you're like, well, what the fuck am I going to do? They're not going to do shit, right? So you're just sitting down there waiting. Finally a jury of coroners said, quote from the testimony and what we saw on the ground that was, there was. It was not sufficient water, nor was the dam constructed sufficiently strong nor of the proper material to stand the overflow. And hence we find the owners of the dam were culpable and not making it as secure as it should have been. Especially in view of the fact that a population of many thousands were in the valley below. And we hold that the owners are responsible for the fearful loss of life and property resulting from a breaking of the dam. End quote. So now the story goes viral. All the websites are snagging it, picking it up. It's on Perez, Drudge. It's on Drudge. It's Breitbarted, cnn, Daily Wire. Daily Wire.
Dave Anthony
All the great ones.
Gareth Reynolds
All the goats. Yeah, Slate, Slate. Which is still awesome. The headlines like, quote, the club is guilty, quote, neglect caused the break. Quote, shall the officers of the fishing club answer to the terrible results? A week later, the New York Times had a headline that read, quote, an engineering crime. The dam of inferior construction according to the experts.
Dave Anthony
And what's an expert?
Gareth Reynolds
Well, an engineer. Someone who was. Someone who was like, it's debatable. No, no, no, no. It's 100% not. It truly.
Dave Anthony
Is it okay to act? Can I ask questions about it?
Gareth Reynolds
Can I be the teach and then your data?
Dave Anthony
Well, I like.
Gareth Reynolds
If you want to ask questions.
Dave Anthony
Okay, shut me down. I'm just saying it's okay to like, not everybody knows everything. And it's okay to, like, be like, maybe the engineers weren't right here. Like, it's okay to ask questions.
Gareth Reynolds
It is. I'm with you.
Dave Anthony
Yeah. Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
I just think it's when those people are in power. You know what I mean? You can't doja dam.
Dave Anthony
Well, it sounds like maybe the engineers. Who's paying them? You know, where are they getting their. Their engineering materials?
Gareth Reynolds
So are you. Are you. You're doing the thing where you're just sort of saying like, empty thoughts just to kind of just asking questions. Okay, but it's a bad question.
Dave Anthony
This is free speech.
Gareth Reynolds
Speech. Okay, so science is about asking questions, and it's not science. It truly appeared that no actual engineers this will help were brought in to take a look at what they were doing. The dam also never appeared to have actually been inspected by anyone, quote, who by any stretch of charity could be regarded as an expert.
Dave Anthony
Why would you inspect it if it's working well, it's holding the water. It's working well, so you don't need an inspection.
Gareth Reynolds
Till now, it was just Richmond doing whatever they wanted as quickly and as cheaply as they wanted, and they didn't care. But maybe it wasn't even beyond what happened at the club. A great paragraph. Again, most of this is from the book the Johnstown flood by David McCullough. This is a great passage from the book, quote, for despite the progress being Made everywhere. Despite the growing prosperity and the prospect of even more of an abundant future, there were strong feelings that perhaps not all was right with the Republic. And if the poor Hungarians of Johnstown were signs of a time to come when a hunky could get a job quicker than a real American, then the gentlemen of the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club were signs of something else that was perhaps even worse. Was it not the lakes of them? Was it not for the likes of them that were bringing in the hunkies, buying legislatures, cutting wages and getting a great deal richer than was right or good for any mortal man in a free democratic country? People were beginning to think a little more about just what it was they might be losing and to whom. And the more they thought about it, and especially the working men, the less they liked.
Dave Anthony
Blah, blah, blah. You know what I mean? Like, whatever.
Gareth Reynolds
I mean, it sounds like it's not in either way.
Dave Anthony
These guys don't want jobs. Is that what I'm hearing?
Gareth Reynolds
No, they want jobs. Well, they're just, you know, it's the same.
Dave Anthony
Yeah. It's never stopped.
Gareth Reynolds
It's never stopped.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Which is country is. That's what this podcast is about? It never has stopped.
Dave Anthony
Oh, no, I don't think so.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah, because it's not a. Whatever you called it at the beginning, a property podcast.
Dave Anthony
It's a property podcast.
Gareth Reynolds
Nope. But it is. It's just like, I don't know this. When I first heard about this, I was like, oh, sake. It just. They just don't. Okay, well, anyway, they don't care. They don't care. I mean, you are not gonna be held accountable. I know, but even then, most of us don't. You think, like, most of us would be, like, the right thing to do factors into your thinking.
Dave Anthony
Well, yeah, but they're not that.
Gareth Reynolds
But they get there because they don't have that part of their brain.
Dave Anthony
Well, that and the richer. There's tons of studies, the richer you get, the less empathy you have.
Gareth Reynolds
Go. You put your hand there. Thank you. Among all the failings of the dam, it was becoming clear that if they had just removed the fucking fish guards, it would have made a huge difference. And, you know, maybe it wouldn't have stopped it, but it would have helped prevent it a little bit.
Dave Anthony
So you just pull in the fish sentries. You're like, hey, you guys, drop your guns. You don't need to be there. We don't need fish guards right now.
Gareth Reynolds
They were the, like, the greats that.
Dave Anthony
Were on we get any name you want for them. But, yeah, guards.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay. Yeah, they weren't. There's. And we're not talking like a fish army. Well, it's actually the Navy.
Dave Anthony
It's a fish guard that we're talking about.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay.
Dave Anthony
They're keeping an eye on them.
Gareth Reynolds
Okay. Okay. Quote. To preserve game for some Pittsburgh swells, the life lives of 15,000 were sacrificed. Again, the numbers, that's a lot.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
This is not what it was. So feeling the heat, the club members started to pony up a little bit of money. Oh, yeah. They started to try to buy their way out of it. Henry. Henry clay frick gave 5,000, which would be around 170,000 a day. The Mellon family, who was involved, I didn't even get into them, but the Mellon family gave a thousand. Andrew Carnegie gave 10,000. You think that's nothing? One asshole gave $15, which would be 500 in today's money. It cost 800 to join. 800 to join. He gave 500 in today's money. You get $15. It's like a dude at a strip club, like, throwing pennies on. Hank. Hank, can we talk to you over here? Hanky. Okay. So when litigation was finally brought, though, it pretty much stalled out. Yeah, they couldn't bring any criminal cases for a couple of reasons. One, because Roth, who had made a lot of those decisions, was dead. And they didn't think that the club as an entity could be at fault. It was made up of a bunch of members, but the club itself was. Again, there's obviously going to be some lawyering around the edges because these are very rich people.
Dave Anthony
You. You sue the club and then everyone who's part of the.
Gareth Reynolds
But it's like Enron. Like, you can't blame Enron.
Dave Anthony
Yeah, I can.
Gareth Reynolds
Enron didn't do anything. Enron's a class organization.
Dave Anthony
No.
Gareth Reynolds
So, but Enron, there was a couple of. Oopsie.
Dave Anthony
The guys who ran the club, or.
Gareth Reynolds
There were a couple of. If you're listening, there were a couple of Oopsie poopsies in the club. But the club was healthy. Plus, there were a lot of points being made that this flub, this flub, this flood, was so unique that they couldn't have prepared for it. It was. They had not seen anything like it.
Dave Anthony
You know why it was unique? Because they did a dam about. Any engineers. They just.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, the flood, the amount of rain was. Like I said, we don't know exactly how much it was because the guy who was supposed to, like.
Dave Anthony
So worst case scenario, which is what you make a dam for yes.
Gareth Reynolds
It's like the levees in New Orleans. It's like. You go. You go. Yeah, well, okay. What if the. What fucking. The worst thing happens? What are you gonna do? Again, these are very rich guys influencing this area. So the American Society of Civil Engineers dragged their feet in investigating because of who they were investigating. And when their findings finally came out, it favored the club. They basically said that you can't prove it was negligence. And the flood was so bad, even with the drain pipe issue, even with drain pipes, it still might have failed. You know. Plus, what year is this again? This is 1889. So it is true. Also, like, when this is going on, like, Carnegie is.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
He's in Paris. Then he goes to Scotland to golf. Yeah. And like, all these people are dead and their lives are completely ruined. Their businesses, all that stuff. Stuff. And they. One guy offered $15.
Dave Anthony
They don't. They don't give a.
Gareth Reynolds
They have. They are our worst. Yeah. Okay. So these are the richest men of the era. So, you know, they were rich, and the rich people always win. So who gives a. The only way to do it was with individual lawsuits instead of one big criminal one. So individual lawsuits were brought, but when a suit was brought, they would move it around a lot to kind of delay it. And then when it was finally going, it would be in the area. And still, so much of the area was still a steel town, like Cambria Steel, like, still stayed open after this. They need money and jobs more than ever. So, like, you'd get a couple of those guys on a jury and, you know, whatever. So nothing happened. Arguably, the saddest lawsuit of the lot was brought from the club over to the club from a guy named Jacob Strayer, who was a lumber dealer. He sued the club for $80,000 in lost goods. And they did the thing. The case was kind of bouncing around from court to court. Like I said. Club was always changing the venue. Then five years into the lawsuit, Strayer figured out that his lawyer, without his knowledge, had actually already settled the case out of court for $500 and died shortly thereafter. And Strayer went bankrupt, and that was the end of it.
Dave Anthony
Well, I mean, that.
Gareth Reynolds
Awful.
Dave Anthony
It's silly.
Gareth Reynolds
It's a story of a lawyer. I mean, but that's illegal.
Dave Anthony
You can't. You got it.
Gareth Reynolds
Well, that's why he died right after. Yeah, I'm.
Dave Anthony
And, yeah, he was gonna die.
Gareth Reynolds
I gotta get out of here. Spent $500 and then he took off.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
So in other words, the club just completely, fully got away with it. With no accountability. Got away with it.
Dave Anthony
That's what happens to rich people in this country. That's why we are where we are. Because for years and years, there's no laws for the rich.
Gareth Reynolds
No, because they influence. I mean, they. Again, it comes down to the thing we always talk about, which is just you can't. You can't have this system where money is literally everything. Money is literally everything. Then people are going to do everything to get it. Yeah. And the sick people will get all of it, and they'll do anything to get it, and they'll treat the regular people like to get it.
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
And so they just ruin everything. And it's just like on this scale now, I mean, and this was a poor town. This was not like. This was like a small, working class poor town. And they were doing all right. And then everything got taken away from them. The difference from then till now is that, you know, they actually. There was work, like, there was an outpour. There were. There was, like, help coming. They were. The government was assisting. There was stuff going on. Now, I mean, what. It's West Virginia, right, Where it's just like, they still have. Not, like Trump has not addressed the floods there. And, you know, that's just kind of how it goes. All right, so in August 1889, the North American Review had an article called the Lesson of Kahnema. In it, Major John Wesley Powell, when writing about the dam, said it had not, quote, properly related to the natural conditions, end quote. And at the end of the article, he stated, quote, modern industries are handling the forces of nature on a stupendous scale. Woe to the people who trust these powers, to the hands of fools. End quote. That's the story of this fork fishing and hunting club and how they killed thousands of people.
Dave Anthony
So it's a happy. Good. That had a good ending. It's a good story.
Gareth Reynolds
It's a good story. It's a fun story. It's cool. It's just cool. So what's up? It's good. It's good. Good. This, like I said, the Johnstown flood by David McCullough. I was there on the History channel, on YouTube. Flood destruction, flood, fire destruction. The Great Johnstown Flood, and some stuff from NPS history dot com. And that's it. That's a. That's that goddamn nightmare. So.
Dave Anthony
Yay.
Gareth Reynolds
You want to go out with your teach for maybe some pizza?
Dave Anthony
Yeah, we'll get some pizza and maybe.
Gareth Reynolds
Do some sluice pipes. Put them on a bear rug.
Dave Anthony
Do the leapfrog thing. You were talking about.
Gareth Reynolds
Absolutely. Do all that stuff. Will it ever change, Dave?
Dave Anthony
Nope.
Gareth Reynolds
Do you think the worse it's getting now, we might be getting close to some breaking point?
Dave Anthony
It could totally.
Gareth Reynolds
Will the dam break, so to speak?
Dave Anthony
Oh, yeah, the dam's gonna break in some way.
Gareth Reynolds
But they just have so much.
Dave Anthony
They do. They have a lot.
Gareth Reynolds
And now they're gonna have robot dogs with the flamethrower dogs that are not going to be capable. I mean, that's the good news. We will be living in, like the stupid version of.
Dave Anthony
Yeah. The first time they set out robots to keep control of everybody, it's gonna be a.
Gareth Reynolds
Like, you saw that robot, like, beating the out of like someone in China, right?
Dave Anthony
Yeah.
Gareth Reynolds
Yeah, that's pretty cool. All right, well, there you go. That's. That's that. So shout out to the rich people. Yeah. Thank you.
Dave Anthony
No, thank you.
Gareth Reynolds
Thank you. Thank me. Hey there, doll heads. This is Gareth Reynolds. You know me. I'm from the Gare Force, part of the Dolla podcast. Love you, doll heads. Listen, I'm gonna be doing some stand up comedy. You can go to GarethReynolds.com for all tickets of information. Naples, Florida, March 24. Charlotte, April 13. Raleigh, April 14. Virginia Beach, Virginia. April 15. Richmond, Virginia. April 16. Magoobies in Lutherville, Baltimore, whatever the hell you want to call it. April 17. April 18. April 19. Then I'll be in Winnipeg, Canada, May 29. May 30. May 31. I'll be in Chattanooga, Tennessee on August 8. August 9. Go to garethreynolds.com I'll also be in the Comedy Fort in Fort Collins the following weekend. More dates being added coming at you. Garethreynolds.com you're part of the Gare Force, not the Garmy. Stop calling it that. It's getting weird. Another guy has that. It's Gare Force. Please help me. Love you mean it. Gareth Reynolds dot com.
Podcast Summary: The Dollop with Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds – Episode 676: The South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club Part 2 - Reverse Dollop
Release Date: March 25, 2025
In episode 676 of "The Dollop with Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds," titled "The South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club Part 2 - Reverse Dollop," hosts Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds continue their exploration of the tragic Johnstown Flood of 1889. This episode delves into the catastrophic failure of the South Fork Dam, the ensuing flood, the impact on the community, and the subsequent lack of accountability among the affluent members of the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club.
The episode begins with Dave and Gareth engaging in their characteristic humorous banter about their upcoming comedy tour, highlighting their favorite cities ([00:00]-[01:22]). However, they swiftly shift focus to the main topic, reintroducing listeners to the events surrounding the Johnstown Flood and setting the stage for a deeper dive into Part 2 of their historical journey.
Gareth provides a vivid description of the flood's onset, emphasizing the overwhelming force of the water and the massive debris it carried, including trees, telegraph poles, bridges, and train cars ([[02:20]-[03:58]]). Dave humorously critiques the destruction, leading to a discussion about the vulnerability of small towns like Mineral Point, which was virtually wiped out by the flood.
Notable Quote:
The hosts highlight remarkable stories of survival and heroism amidst the chaos of the flood. Engineer John Hess emerges as a pivotal figure who used his train whistle to warn residents, effectively saving countless lives in areas like Kahnema and Woodvale ([06:49]-[12:18]). Gareth draws parallels between Hess's actions and those of a "Paul Revere," underscoring his critical role in the disaster's immediate aftermath.
Another compelling narrative involves Victor Heiser, who survived by "surfing" atop his family's barn roof and navigating through debris with extraordinary resilience ([20:13]-[22:19]).
Notable Quotes:
Following the devastation, the media erupted with extensive coverage, often sensationalizing the disaster. Newspapers like the Pittsburgh Post Gazette labeled the event as "the Greatest Calamity," amplifying public fear and outrage ([29:00]-[30:28]). The hosts discuss how this relentless media attention fueled societal anxieties, particularly targeting immigrants, notably labeling Hungarians derogatorily and blaming them for exacerbating the crisis ([43:54]-[46:14]).
Notable Quote:
A significant portion of the episode addresses the lack of accountability among the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club members. Despite clear evidence of negligence—such as faulty dam construction and inadequate maintenance—the wealthy club members largely escaped legal repercussions ([55:00]-[62:00]). The duo highlights cases like Jacob Strayer's lawsuit, which was dishonestly settled by his lawyer without his knowledge, leading to Strayer’s bankruptcy and the club’s impunity ([63:31]-[67:02]).
Notable Quotes:
In the concluding sections, Dave and Gareth reflect on the broader implications of the Johnstown Flood, drawing parallels to contemporary issues surrounding property rights and societal empathy. They argue that the historical lack of accountability among the wealthy continues to resonate today, contributing to ongoing social and economic disparities ([64:25]-[67:02]).
Notable Quote:
The episode wraps up by emphasizing the enduring lessons from the Johnstown Flood—particularly the dangers of unchecked power and the critical need for accountability in the face of natural disasters. Dave and Gareth encourage listeners to reflect on how similar injustices persist in modern society, making the historical tragedy of Johnstown both a cautionary tale and a mirror to present-day challenges.
Final Thoughts:
Additional Insights:
Heroic Acts: Clara Barton of the American Red Cross played a crucial role in organizing relief efforts, staying in the affected area for five months to provide aid ([40:10]-[40:35]).
Cultural Commentary: The hosts interweave humorous and satirical comments about modern parallels, such as comparing historical heroes to contemporary online saviors and critiquing societal tendencies to idolize tragedy.
Resource Recommendations: Dave and Gareth suggest David McCullough’s "The Johnstown Flood" for listeners interested in a comprehensive understanding of the event.
Final Notes:
Episode 676 of "The Dollop" offers a rich, engaging, and thoroughly researched account of the Johnstown Flood, blending historical facts with the hosts' signature humor and insightful commentary. By highlighting both the heroism and the systemic failures that led to the disaster, Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds provide a compelling narrative that resonates with contemporary discussions about power, accountability, and societal responsibility.
For those interested in delving deeper into the Johnstown Flood and its historical context, "The Dollop" episode serves as both an entertaining and informative resource, bridging the gap between past tragedies and their lessons for today's society.