Mr. and Mrs. North: The Premature Corpse (EP4644)

Summary

Episode Summary: Mr. and Mrs. North – "The Premature Corpse" (EP4644)

Podcast: The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio
Host: Adam Graham
Episode Release Date: March 6, 2025

---

Introduction

In this captivating episode of Mr. and Mrs. North, titled "The Premature Corpse," listeners are transported to a suspense-filled evening in New York where secrets, lies, and deceit intertwine, leading to a gripping mystery. Hosted by Adam Graham, the episode delves deep into the complex relationships and hidden motives of the Hathaway family, ultimately revealing the dark truths behind a seemingly straightforward murder case.

---

Plot Overview

The story unfolds in the plush apartment of Ferdy Hathaway on a serene New York night. Shirley Hathaway arrives unexpectedly, creating immediate tension with Ferdy, Doug Hathaway's brother. Shirley confronts Ferdy with accusations of manipulating Doug for his wealth, igniting a heated argument that sets the stage for the ensuing mystery.

As the tension peaks, Doug Hathaway arrives, only to be confronted with Shirley's dramatic claims and physical altercation with Ferdy. The situation escalates when Ferdy accuses Shirley of attempting to manipulate him into aiding in Doug's downfall. Amidst the chaos, a mysterious phone call from Laura Arnold hints at foul play, leading Pam and Jerry North to investigate.

The investigation takes a pivotal turn when Doug Hathaway reveals a potential alibi involving a distinctive yellow convertible. However, inconsistencies in Doug's account and conflicting testimonies cast doubt on his innocence. The Norths employ a clever strategy by introducing a corpse to test Doug's honesty, ultimately unmasking him as the true culprit behind Ferdy Hathaway's murder.

---

Key Characters and Interactions

• Shirley Hathaway (Alice Frost): Ferdy's wife, whose aggressive demeanor and confrontations reveal deep-seated resentments and hidden agendas.

• Jerry North (Joseph Curtin): A perceptive publisher who, alongside his wife Pam, unravels the complex web of deceit within the Hathaway family.

• Pam North (Alice Frost): Jerry's astute partner, instrumental in piecing together the puzzle and exposing the truth.

• Ferdy Hathaway (Larry Thor): Doug's brother, whose murder becomes the central mystery of the episode.

• Doug Hathaway (Jack Webb): Ferdy's secretive brother, whose dubious alibi and interactions with Shirley raise suspicions.

• Laura Arnold (Guest Character): An insurance investigator whose involvement complicates the investigation.

---

Notable Quotes and Moments

1. Shirley Confronts Ferdy:

   • [03:07] Shirley Hathaway: "I want you, that's all. Can't you see that, Ferdy? It's always been."
   • [03:38] Ferdy Hathaway: "That's what you want me to think. But I know you. It's just another one of your schemes."

2. Pam and Jerry Discussing the Murder:

   • [06:15] Pam North: "The more I think about it, Jerry, the more I think his sister will have to be killed too."
   • [07:00] Pam North: "Jerry, it's Ms. Hathaway's apartment."

3. Introduction of the Corpse Ruse:

   • [12:00] Narrator: "We gotta see him. And it's not research. This is the real thing."
   • [21:03] Doug Hathaway: "That's the man."

4. Final Revelation:

   • [23:27] Pam North: "Oh, I don't think we'll have to wait for that, Bill. I know which one to believe."
   • [24:44] Pam North: "You see what I mean, dear? Poor Shirley."

---

Host's Commentary and Insights

After the dramatized narrative concludes, Adam Graham provides a thoughtful analysis of the episode's dynamics and storytelling techniques:

• Character Development: Graham highlights the transformation of the "Mr. and Mrs. North" series during the early 1950s, noting a shift towards more melodramatic and soap opera-like elements. He appreciates the complexity added to the characters, especially the clever maneuvers employed by Jerry North.

• Plot Mechanics: The host commends the use of the morgue ruse, where Jerry North introduces a corpse to test Doug Hathaway's credibility. However, Graham criticizes the plot for relying on the perpetrator's incompetence, arguing that Ferdy Hathaway's use of a distinctive car made him an easy target for such a ploy.

• Thematic Elements: Graham points out the themes of greed, manipulation, and familial betrayal that permeate the episode. He emphasizes how Shirley's antagonism towards Ferdy and Doug's questionable actions set the stage for the ultimate revelation of Doug as the murderer.

• Listener Engagement: Reflecting on audience feedback, Graham shares positive comments from listeners who adore the dynamic between Mr. and Mrs. North and appreciate the immersive storytelling that keeps them hooked.

Notable Host Quote:

• [27:12] Adam Graham: "This is one case where cleverness feels a bit wasted when the murderer is an idiot."

---

Conclusion

"The Premature Corpse" serves as a compelling installment in the Mr. and Mrs. North series, weaving a tale of deceit, ambition, and dark secrets within the Hathaway family. Through strategic investigative techniques and sharp dialogue, Pam and Jerry North unravel the truth, exposing Doug Hathaway's sinister motives. Adam Graham's insightful commentary enriches the listening experience, offering deeper understanding of the narrative's intricacies and the characters' complexities. This episode stands as a testament to the enduring allure of old-time radio dramas and their ability to captivate audiences with timeless mysteries.

---

Listener Feedback Highlights

• Doris: "I love this couple. They are so cute."

• UK Listener: "Listening on a windy night in the UK on February 19th. Thank you so much for keeping me company there."

• Instagram Follower: "Your uploads of Old Time Radio have given me so many hours of entertainment and even helped me to create my own hardball detective. Thank you for all these uploads."

Adam extends gratitude to listeners like Doris and the Instagram follower, acknowledging their support and enthusiasm for the series.

---

Acknowledgments

Special thanks to Pippin, a longstanding Patreon supporter since March 2022, currently contributing at the rookie level of $2 or more per month. Supporters like Pippin enable the continuation of high-quality content and the preservation of classic radio dramas.

---

Stay Connected

Subscribe to The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio on your favorite podcast platform or visit greatdetectives.net. Follow Adam Graham on Twitter @radiodetectives and Instagram for updates and behind-the-scenes insights.

---

This summary encapsulates the essence of "The Premature Corpse," providing both the narrative details and the host's reflections to enhance the listener's understanding and appreciation of the episode.

Transcript

[Adam Graham]

Welcome to the Great detectives of Old Time Radio from Boise, Idaho. This is your host, Adam Graham. In a moment, we're going to bring you this Week's episode of Mr. And Mrs. North. I do want to encourage you. If you are enjoying the podcast, please follow us using your favorite podcast software and our listener support and appreciation campaign continues. You can become one of our ongoing Patreon supporters for as little as $2 per month at pay patreon.greatdetectives.net now, we are getting into 1952 episodes of Mr. And Mrs. North, and we actually have a string of episodes right in a row after dealing with so many lost episodes over the first 435, of which 412 are lost. Here now from February 12, 1952, is the premature Corpse.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Thank heaven someone's come help me.

[Jerry North]

What's the matter? What's happening?

[Shirley Hathaway]

Oh, it's awful.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Oh, that's right, Mr. North. She's just fine.

[Pam North]

Yeah, her dress is all torn.

[Jerry North]

Yeah, I see.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

If we all cut that out.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Mr. Dog is crazy. Don't. Don't let him hit me again.

[Narrator]

Mr. And Mrs. North. Starring Joseph Curtin and Alice Frost. Listen as Pam and Jerry solve the mystery. The Premature Corpse. It's a beautiful night in New York. Clear, fresh, and in the snug apartment of Ferdy Hathaway.

[Doug Hathaway]

Warm.

[Narrator]

A night for music, for friendship, for love. And Shirley Hollis seems to have this last on her mind as she snuggles up to Ferdie on the sofa.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Aw, Ferdy, I was just getting comfortable.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I'm afraid I'll have to ask you to run along, Shirley. Some people are coming over in a little while.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Will they be here long?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I don't know. It's business. He's Jerry north, the publisher. They're going to discuss a book I've written.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Well, I'll wait till they leave. I want to talk to you, too.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Come here.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

What do you want?

[Shirley Hathaway]

Put your arms around.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Now look, Shirley.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Then I will. There. Hello, Ferdy.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

It's. It's getting awfully warm in here.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Yes, isn't it?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Yes, Birdie.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Is this what you want?

[Shirley Hathaway]

Oh, yes, darling. That's just what I want. Now, that didn't hurt, did it?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

You little cheat.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Ferdy.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

My brother's wife. What do you want with me?

[Shirley Hathaway]

You know I don't love Doug.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I knew it when you married him. But you loved his money. I tried to tell him, but he wouldn't listen.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I don't know why. You've always hated me.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Because you're a little Cheat. You married Doug for his money. And now.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Yes, now what? What do I want with you? You don't have money.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

You want something.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I want you, that's all. Can't you see that, Ferdy? It's always been.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

That's what you want me to think. But I know you. It's just another one of your schemes. I wouldn't put it past you even to try to get me to. To get rid of Doug for you. Now that you have his money. Is that what you want?

[Jerry North]

Is it?

[Shirley Hathaway]

Oh, poor, suspicious Ferdy.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

You didn't answer my question.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I know why you don't like me, Ferdy. It's not. Doug has nothing to do with Doug.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

You still didn't.

[Shirley Hathaway]

That stuffy superiority of yours, that stuffy righteousness. You're a Hathaway, and I was just a chorus girl. That's why you didn't want Doug to marry me. That's why you think you're too good for me.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

You're a cheat.

[Shirley Hathaway]

That's why I'm that Hathaway superiority. Well, how about Doug? I suppose he's not a cheat.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

What are you talking about?

[Shirley Hathaway]

I'm talking about your brother, a Hathaway, A crook.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

That's a lie.

[Shirley Hathaway]

You know it isn't. Well, maybe you don't. Maybe you've blinded yourself with that phony righteousness of yours until you can't see what's going on right in front of you.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

What do you mean, what's going on?

[Shirley Hathaway]

You say I married Doug for his money. Well, how did he make that money, huh? The Hathaway fortune.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Business.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Sure. Business. Some business. Black market. In the wartime.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

You're crazy.

[Shirley Hathaway]

It so happens I can prove it. And that's not all I can prove. If I have to. I know enough about Doug to send him to jail. How would you like that? A Hathaway in jail.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Get out of here.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Why don't you stop kidding yourself, Birdie? So your grandfather was Colonel Hathaway. You're just a hack writer. Your brother's a crook. Come on, off that high horse. You're no better than I am and no worse. We could be friends. Good friends.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Never.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Ferdy, look at me.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

You cheap, lying, dirty little.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I'm not taking any more of that. My God, I tried to be nice, but you don't want it that way. All right.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Hey, those nails are sharp.

[Shirley Hathaway]

And so are my teeth.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

You're asking for this. Put down that poker.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I will. On your head.

[Narrator]

No.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

No, you don't. Let me have it.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Oh, you're hurting me.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I haven't stopped. Don't try biting again, or I'll make sure you don't have any teeth left to bite with. Now, come on. Drop that poker.

[Shirley Hathaway]

All right.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

That's better. And now get out of here. I've got to get cleaned up before the Norths get here. What's so funny?

[Shirley Hathaway]

You're always concerned about impressions, aren't you, Ferdy? Well, brother, I promise you, you're gonna make a beautiful.

[Pam North]

The more I think about it, Jerry, the more I think his sister will have to be killed too.

[Jerry North]

What?

[Pam North]

But not shot. I think strangling would be better.

[Jerry North]

What on earth are you talking about, Ben?

[Pam North]

About Mr. Hathaway's book, of course. Well, what did you think?

[Jerry North]

I didn't know. The way you start a subject out of a clear blue sky.

[Pam North]

It wasn't a clear blue sky. It was a murky green elevator. And it's in Mr. Hathaway's building. So I. I should think you'd know what I meant.

[Jerry North]

I see. Well, let's go tell Mr. Hathaway the sister ought to be strangled. I'm sure he'll love the suggestion. It'll mean rewriting three chapters, but it'll make a story much stronger in one woman's opinion.

[Pam North]

Well, did Dr. Wallace.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Golly.

[Pam North]

So was that.

[Jerry North]

Sounded like it came from the apartment at the end of the hall.

[Pam North]

Jerry, it's Ms. Hathaway's apartment.

[Jerry North]

I wonder what.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Oh, thank heaven. Someone's come help me.

[Jerry North]

What's the matter?

[Doug Hathaway]

What's happening?

[Shirley Hathaway]

Oh, it's all.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Don't Listen to her, Mr. North.

[Shirley Hathaway]

He tried to kiss me. When I wouldn't let him, he hit me.

[Pam North]

Sherry address is all torn.

[Jerry North]

It.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

She's just trying to embarrass me, Mr. North.

[Jerry North]

Why would she try to do that?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

It's kind of hard to explain.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I hope that it is. You maniac.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Now, stop it, Charlie.

[Pam North]

Did you hit her, Mr. Hathaway? Her face looks bruised.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Well, yes, I guess I did.

[Shirley Hathaway]

But why?

[Laura Arnold]

Well, because she bit me.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Stop it, Shirley.

[Shirley Hathaway]

It's just an act.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

If you don't cut that out, Shirley, I'm gonna have to hit you again.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Mister, no, don't let him hit me.

[Doug Hathaway]

He won't.

[Jerry North]

Now, come on. Let's go in and see what this is all about.

[Shirley Hathaway]

No, no. I want to go home. I want to see Doug. I want my dog. Doug. Doug. It was awful. When I wouldn't let him make love to me, he. Well, he got like crazy. He said all kinds of awful things about you and me.

[Doug Hathaway]

All right, Shirley, forget it. It's over.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I can't, Doug. I. I'm afraid. He said he'd see you in jail.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

What?

[Shirley Hathaway]

That's right. He said you're a crook and he can prove it.

[Doug Hathaway]

Bertie said that?

[Shirley Hathaway]

Yes. He started talking about your tie up with gambling.

[Doug Hathaway]

What does he know about that?

[Shirley Hathaway]

I don't know. But he said he's going to make sure you get what's coming to you. Unless. Unless I. Oh, Doug, I can. Not even to save you. I can.

[Doug Hathaway]

All right, sweetheart, you won't have to. I can handle Ferdie.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Oh, he'll deny it. He'll make up some story.

[Doug Hathaway]

Don't worry.

[Shirley Hathaway]

If you don't believe me, you can ask the nods. They say.

[Doug Hathaway]

I believe you.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Shirley, I. I hate. Hate to have to tell you this about your own brother.

[Doug Hathaway]

Yeah, my brother. My dear, sanctimonious brother. We're just like him to keep his threat and run to the police. Now that he knows about me, I've got to figure some way to shut him up.

[Shirley Hathaway]

But how?

[Doug Hathaway]

I'll think of something. One thing's for sure. He's going to keep away from you. Or I promise you, surely I'll kill him.

[Bill Wagon]

What's the matter, Ferdy? Don't you like this restaurant?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Sure.

[Bill Wagon]

Laura, you're not eating?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I'm not hungry. Laura, I've got to tell you something. I don't know how to begin. Laura.

[Bill Wagon]

Yes, Ferdy?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I love you, Laura. You know that.

[Bill Wagon]

For someone who says he doesn't know how to begin, I'd say you're doing fine.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I only hope you believe what I'm going to tell you. My sister in law, Doug's wife Shirley, came over to my place last night.

[Bill Wagon]

Yes?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

She made a play for me.

[Bill Wagon]

What?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

She tried to get me to make love to her when I wasn't interested. She blew her top.

[Bill Wagon]

The woman's scorned.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

It's more than that. She doesn't want me. She wants to use me.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Use you?

[Bill Wagon]

What for?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I'm not sure, but. Well, you know she only married Doug for his money. Yes, I think she wants to get rid of Doug. I think she wants me to help.

[Bill Wagon]

Her get rid of him. How?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

How? Kill him.

[Bill Wagon]

Oh, no.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

You don't know Shirley like I do. Yeah, Laura, I'm pretty sure that's exactly what she wants.

[Bill Wagon]

Well, why are you telling me this?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Because I think Shirley's gonna try to go through with it with or without my help. So I've got to warn Doug.

[Bill Wagon]

Well, I still don't see he's not.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Going to want to believe me. Especially because she's probably filled him full of lies. But I. I may be able to convince him. I've got to. Maybe if I tell him some of the things she said about him.

[Bill Wagon]

What things?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Oh, it's beside the point. The point is she's gonna be afraid I may convince him. So she's gonna try to shut me up.

[Bill Wagon]

How?

[Ferdy Hathaway]

I told you about last night.

[Pam North]

Yes.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Well, she's already turned that around to make it look like I attacked her. Oh, yeah, and that she's poured it on Hetty to Doug. That's why I wanted to get to you first. I wanted you to hear this story from me, the way it really happened.

[Pam North]

I see.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Because you've got to believe me, Laura. I can't let her break us up. And she's gonna try. I know she is. If she can't shut me up one way, she'll try another. There's nothing she won't stop at to get what she wants. But it's not going to work. At least I hope it's not.

[Jerry North]

Hello?

[Narrator]

Hello, Jerry. This Bill wagon.

[Jerry North]

Oh, yes, Bill. How are you?

[Narrator]

Okay. Say, Jerry, what can you tell me about Freddy Hathaway?

[Jerry North]

Hathaway? I'm considering publishing a book he wrote. Why? Does he want to go to your office and do research on how the homicide squad works?

[Narrator]

No, no, it's the other way around.

[Jerry North]

What do you mean?

[Narrator]

We gotta see him. And it's not research. This is the real thing.

[Jerry North]

You mean he killed somebody?

[Narrator]

No, that's the other way around, too. Somebody kill him.

[Pam North]

Well, Jerry, I'm all ready. Let's go.

[Jerry North]

Pam, it hasn't been two minutes since I hung up the phone and you asked me to tell Bill we couldn't possibly get over to see him for at least an hour.

[Pam North]

Oh, we're not going to see Bill.

[Jerry North]

We're not?

[Pam North]

No.

[Jerry North]

But, darling, he wants to talk to us. I told him about the incident last night, and he wants all the details.

[Pam North]

Oh, we'll tell him later.

[Jerry North]

All right, dear. But if we're not going to see Bill right now, where are we going?

[Pam North]

To see Laura, of course.

[Jerry North]

Oh, yes, of course, Laura. That's a good idea.

[Pam North]

I thought you'd agree, darling.

[Jerry North]

There's just one thing, though.

[Pam North]

Oh, what's that, dear?

[Jerry North]

Who in blazes is Laura?

[Pam North]

Oh, you know, Jerry.

[Jerry North]

I do?

[Pam North]

Laura Arnold, Freddy Hathaway's girlfriend. Don't you remember? He mentioned her last night. He was afraid that she might hear about Shirley's accusation and might believe it.

[Jerry North]

Oh, that's right.

[Pam North]

And if she did believe it, it might make her angry.

[Jerry North]

You would think it might have made her angry enough to commit murder?

[Pam North]

Well, you never know. At least it's worth checking up on. As long as Bill wants us to give him information, maybe we can take him more than he counted on.

[Bill Wagon]

Yes?

[Pam North]

Are you Laura Arnold?

[Bill Wagon]

Yes.

[Pam North]

Well, I'm Pamela north and this is my husband, Jerry North.

[Bill Wagon]

Oh, the publisher. I've heard Freddie mention you. What do you want with me?

[Pam North]

We'd like to talk to you if we may.

[Bill Wagon]

Well, I'm. I'm pretty busy right now.

[Jerry North]

We'll only take a few minutes.

[Bill Wagon]

Well, all right. Come in. What's it about?

[Jerry North]

Ferdie.

[Bill Wagon]

What about him?

[Jerry North]

I'm afraid you're in for a bad shock, Ms. Arnold.

[Bill Wagon]

He's been murdered. Is that what you're trying to tell me?

[Jerry North]

Why do you ask that?

[Bill Wagon]

He said Shirley wouldn't stop at anything so. Well, naturally I've been afraid.

[Jerry North]

When did he tell you that?

[Bill Wagon]

Today at lunch.

[Pam North]

And that's the last you saw of him?

[Bill Wagon]

Yes. I came home right afterward about one. I've been here ever since.

[Jerry North]

Well, that's funny. When we asked if you were in just before we came up, the desk clerk said you got in only about 20 minutes ago.

[Bill Wagon]

Well, I. Mr. North, I'm frightened. I don't know what to do.

[Pam North]

Maybe we can help you if you tell us the truth.

[Bill Wagon]

Yes, here's the truth. I did have lunch with Ferdie. He told me about Shirley. Then we went back to his place and talked a while and I left. But about an hour later I realized I'd left my gloves up there. So I went back. And there he was on the floor, dead. I'll never forget how he looked. I don't want to think about it.

[Jerry North]

You'd better sit down, Ms. Arnold. There are a couple of things I'd still like to ask you. Because if we're going to help you, we'll have to know what we're doing. She says she was afraid you'd suspect her, Bill. That's why she wouldn't give a name when she phoned that she discovered the murder. And why she ran out before you got there.

[Narrator]

Uh huh. Well, I'll get around to her later. After I've had a talk with Hathaway's brother and the brother's wife.

[Pam North]

Find out if they own a yellow convertible, Bill.

[Jerry North]

Yes, that's right. Ms. Arnold says that a yellow convertible pulled away from in front of Ferdinand Place just as she arrived the second time.

[Narrator]

Did she Know the make?

[Jerry North]

No. She said she never saw one like it. It was very long and low and.

[Pam North]

It had a funny shaped back, kind of like. Well, the way she described it, it must look something like. Well, like the back of that car parked right in front of us.

[Jerry North]

Hey, Pam, that is, the car fits.

[Narrator]

A description to a T. And it's parked right in front of Douglas Hathaway's apartment. Let's go in and see what he has to say.

[Doug Hathaway]

I know you have your job to do, Lieutenant, but is it necessary to question me now? After all, it's quite a shock hearing my brother's been murdered.

[Narrator]

Well, suppose we question your wife. And from what I hear about last night, I don't imagine his death should make her too unhappy.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I didn't kill him, if that's what you're implying.

[Narrator]

I'm not implying anything. I just want to ask you some questions.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I suppose you want to know where I was. Well, I was right here. I've been home all day long.

[Pam North]

Was your husband with you?

[Shirley Hathaway]

No, he was at the office, Mrs. Norton.

[Pam North]

Then nobody was with you here. Nobody saw you.

[Shirley Hathaway]

The servants did. Part of the time anyway.

[Pam North]

And part of the time not.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Doug, are you going to let them seduce.

[Doug Hathaway]

No. Look, Lieutenant, I can't take this now. I don't feel up to questions and I certainly don't intend to sit by while you badger Shirley.

[Narrator]

Well, let's clear up the matter of the car at least.

[Doug Hathaway]

What about the car?

[Narrator]

Did you drive it to work this morning?

[Doug Hathaway]

Couldn't. It's brand new. Wasn't delivered until noon.

[Narrator]

Then you didn't have it with you at the office?

[Doug Hathaway]

I just told you.

[Narrator]

All right, all right, you didn't have it. And you, Mrs. Hathaway, you didn't go out at all.

[Shirley Hathaway]

How many times do I have to tell you?

[Narrator]

Well, then who did have the car?

[Shirley Hathaway]

Nobody. The salesman delivered it, left it out front and it's been there all afternoon.

[Narrator]

Well, if you want to get by with a story like that, you should get a car that's not quite so distinctive.

[Shirley Hathaway]

What do you mean?

[Narrator]

Tell her, Jerry.

[Jerry North]

Well, Mrs. Hathaway, it so happens your car was seen driving away from your brother in law's right after the murder. And with a custom job like that, there can be no mistake.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Well, I. There is a. I don't.

[Doug Hathaway]

All right, Lieutenant, I had the car.

[Narrator]

Oh, you did? Hathaway?

[Doug Hathaway]

Yes, I. I came home from the office early and picked it up. Went to see Ferdy, but I didn't kill him.

[Narrator]

Why'd you go there?

[Doug Hathaway]

I wanted to talk to him, but there was a man with him. What I had to say was private. Family matter. Didn't care to discuss it in front of a stranger, so I left.

[Narrator]

Who was the stranger?

[Doug Hathaway]

Ferdy didn't introduce us. Only there a minute. What did he look like? Tall, blonde, well dressed.

[Narrator]

You'd know him if you saw him again.

[Doug Hathaway]

Yes, but. Now, that's enough questions.

[Narrator]

Not quite. I. I said that's enough. Now, look, Mr. Hathaway, I'm just trying to find out what. Say, where are you going?

[Doug Hathaway]

Call my lawyer and see if I have to put up with this. Don't answer anything until I come back. Shirley.

[Shirley Hathaway]

When you know Doug better, Lieutenant, you'll know better than to try to cross him.

[Pam North]

What was that?

[Shirley Hathaway]

There must be someone in there with Doug. They're fighting.

[Jerry North]

It's all the shots. Come on, Bill. There's Hathaway on the floor.

[Doug Hathaway]

He got away. Window to the terrace.

[Narrator]

I'll go see what I can find. Jerry, and you stay with Hathaway and see if he's all right.

[Jerry North]

Right.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Doug. Oh, Doug. What happened?

[Doug Hathaway]

He was hiding in here. A fellow I saw at Ferdy's tried to slug me with a blackjack. But I heard him and turned. Just grazed the side of my head.

[Jerry North]

Yes, you've got a gash there.

[Doug Hathaway]

I put up a fight. He broke away, ran for the window. I fired at him. Guess I missed. Blow had me kind of woozy.

[Jerry North]

You're sure it's the same man you saw at Ferdy's?

[Doug Hathaway]

Positive.

[Narrator]

Well, I took a quick look outside. No sign of anyone now. Well, he could have crossed the terrace to another apartment or gone down the fire escape and ducked in below.

[Pam North]

But then he's still in the building.

[Narrator]

He'll be out of it before we can do anything about it, Pam.

[Doug Hathaway]

Then what do we do?

[Narrator]

Well, first of all, Hathaway, you stop being coy and give us a detailed description of this character. Or do you still want to call your lawyer?

[Doug Hathaway]

No, Lieutenant, you win. I'll tell you whatever I can.

[Pam North]

There's your coffee. Jerry. Jerry. Jerry North.

[Jerry North]

What? Pam?

[Pam North]

Your coffee. I know you don't like it cold.

[Jerry North]

Oh, thanks.

[Pam North]

Where were you?

[Jerry North]

What?

[Pam North]

Just now, in your thoughts. You were miles away.

[Jerry North]

I was thinking about the Hathaway case. It's been three days now and no sign of the mysterious stranger.

[Pam North]

Well, maybe they'll never find him. He had time to get far away.

[Jerry North]

But I don't think he did. That's what I've been thinking about.

[Pam North]

You think you know where he is?

[Jerry North]

Maybe. Anyway, I'll bet there's one place they haven't tried yet.

[Pam North]

Where's that?

[Jerry North]

The morgue.

[Pam North]

The morgue?

[Jerry North]

And somehow I have an idea it might yield results.

[Narrator]

Well, I have to admit that was a pretty good idea of yours, Jerry.

[Jerry North]

I don't know, Bill. Wait till we see if Hathaway identifies the body. Yeah. I could be wrong, but this seemed like the logical bet.

[Narrator]

Well, here's where we find out. Here's Hathaway.

[Doug Hathaway]

Morning, gentlemen. Good morning.

[Narrator]

Oh, good morning.

[Doug Hathaway]

Am I late?

[Narrator]

Oh, right on the nose, Hathaway. Well, should we go in and get it over with?

[Doug Hathaway]

Yes, let's.

[Narrator]

All right. Right through here.

[Doug Hathaway]

You really think it's the right man, eh, Lieutenant?

[Narrator]

Well, that's for you to say, Hathaway. He seems to fit the description you gave us. Well, here he is. Well, Hathaway.

[Doug Hathaway]

That's the man.

[Narrator]

Are you sure?

[Doug Hathaway]

Yes, Lieutenant, I'm sure.

[Narrator]

Well, Jerry, seems you were right.

[Jerry North]

Mm.

[Narrator]

You know, Hathaway, this is very interesting. Now, you say you saw this man at your brother's the day your brother was killed.

[Doug Hathaway]

That's right.

[Narrator]

Your brother was killed on Tuesday. But it so happens this fella died on Monday.

[Jerry North]

You see, Pam, I thought that if Hathaway was lying, he'd jump at the chance to strengthen the story. So I. I suggested that Bill show him a corpse that approximated the description he gave us.

[Pam North]

Yes. After all, a corpse couldn't talk back.

[Jerry North]

Right. And now that we've eliminated the mysterious stranger, we can concentrate on the real suspects. And Bill thinks he can wrap it up. That's why he asked us down here today.

[Narrator]

Come in. Now, Pam and Jerry.

[Jerry North]

How's it going, Bill?

[Narrator]

We've just started.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I don't see why you had to bring them in, Lieutenant.

[Narrator]

Because, Mrs. Hathaway, they were present when you had your unpleasantness with your brother in law.

[Shirley Hathaway]

All right, we had an unpleasant, sir, but it wouldn't make me kill him.

[Jerry North]

That depends on the reason for the scene, Mrs. Hathaway.

[Shirley Hathaway]

I told you the reason. He tried to make love to me.

[Jerry North]

I can suggest another. Yes, Jerry, suppose Mrs. Hathaway wanted to get rid of her husband.

[Shirley Hathaway]

What do you mean?

[Jerry North]

He has a lot of money, Mrs. Hathaway. Maybe that's what you married him for. Then you tried to get Ferdy to help you kill him. And when he received.

[Shirley Hathaway]

You're lying. You're lying.

[Narrator]

That's enough, Mrs. Hathaway.

[Pam North]

Now stop it.

[Jerry North]

Stop it.

[Pam North]

Ms. Hathaway.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Where his eyes out?

[Jerry North]

I believe you would.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Doug, help me. You know he was lying.

[Doug Hathaway]

Of course he was. So calm down, will you?

[Shirley Hathaway]

You don't believe him, Doug.

[Doug Hathaway]

I told you I don't. But this is no way to answer him.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Yeah. Yes, you're right. But he made me so mad.

[Jerry North]

I see. I did. You have a low boiling point, Mrs. Hathaway.

[Doug Hathaway]

You couldn't expect her to like what you were saying.

[Adam Graham]

North.

[Jerry North]

I didn't.

[Doug Hathaway]

You just said it to upset her.

[Jerry North]

I just said it because I wanted to see if it were true.

[Doug Hathaway]

What on earth gives you the idea.

[Jerry North]

That it might be things that Laura Arnold told us?

[Doug Hathaway]

So that's it. Laura wouldn't you know?

[Jerry North]

Why do you say that?

[Doug Hathaway]

Can't you see she's behind this whole thing? It all ties up now. I'll bet she's the one who claimed to have seen my car at Ferdy's too, wouldn't she?

[Jerry North]

What if she is?

[Doug Hathaway]

Lieutenant, you said I've been trying to shield Shirley. I have.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Mm.

[Doug Hathaway]

When you said my car was seen at Ferdy's, I could see Shirley was upset. She didn't know what to say. So I stepped in and said I'd been to Ferdy's.

[Narrator]

And you hadn't?

[Doug Hathaway]

No. But I thought Shirley might have. But now that I know she wasn't. At least not at the time of the murder.

[Narrator]

How do you know that?

[Doug Hathaway]

Because now I know when the murder happened. It's been in the paper.

[Narrator]

Well?

[Doug Hathaway]

Well, I did have the car at that time, but I was nowhere near Ferdy's. So if Laura says she saw me there, she's lying.

[Narrator]

It seems to come down to your word against hers. Well, I've sent for her too. So let's see what happens when she gets here.

[Pam North]

Oh, I don't think we'll have to wait for that, Bill. I know which one to believe.

[Narrator]

You do? Pen?

[Pam North]

Yes, Laura. Mr. Hathaway's still lying. So it looks like he's the murderer.

[Doug Hathaway]

Don't be ridiculous. Laura says she saw my car at Ferdy's. That means she had to be there herself.

[Pam North]

That's just it, Miss. Ha.

[Doug Hathaway]

So naturally she's going to. L try to play somebody else there too.

[Pam North]

She couldn't have been lying.

[Doug Hathaway]

Why not?

[Pam North]

You told us your car was brand new. It had been delivered just a short time before the murder.

[Doug Hathaway]

That's right.

[Pam North]

Well, then how could Laura have described it? Unless she really did see it at Ferdy's?

[Shirley Hathaway]

Jerry, get him.

[Jerry North]

I've got him. All right, Hathaway, sit down. Looks like you've told one lie too many. Oh, it's A beautiful day, isn't it, dear?

[Pam North]

Yes. Poor Shirley.

[Jerry North]

How do we come to Shirley out.

[Pam North]

Of a clear blue sky? The sky's clear. And you just mentioned the weather. So you see, there is a logical connection.

[Jerry North]

You win, dear. But why do you say poor Shirley?

[Pam North]

Well, it's quite obvious that she just married Doug Hathaway for his money. And now that he's caught for murder, they've broken him down about how he made his money.

[Jerry North]

His whole crooked house will come tumbling down.

[Pam North]

That's right, Jerry. And all his money is tied up.

[Jerry North]

And so poor Shirley gets none.

[Pam North]

You see what I mean, dear? Poor Shirley.

[Jerry North]

But somehow it doesn't break my heart. She knew Doug was a crook. Ferdie knew it, too. That's why Doug killed him, to shut him up. He claims Ferdy was always a tattletale as a kid. Hey, Pam, why are you stopping?

[Pam North]

Oh, I just want to look in this window. Look at that car, Jerry. Isn't it beautiful? It's sort of like the Hathaways car. Oh, it must be wonderful to be able to afford a car like that.

[Jerry North]

Even if you could, where would you ever find a parking space for it? In Manhattan?

[Pam North]

Well, if you didn't live in Manhattan.

[Jerry North]

But we do live in Manhattan, and we can't afford the car anyway.

[Pam North]

I know, Jerry. I'm just thinking. Don't you ever like to think of what it would be like to have a car like that?

[Jerry North]

I don't let myself.

[Pam North]

How do you prevent yourself?

[Jerry North]

Easy. I just walk over to the curb. Like so.

[Pam North]

Yes. And then.

[Jerry North]

Then I just shout. Like so.

[Doug Hathaway]

Hey, taxi.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

The adventures of Mr. And Mrs. North.

[Jerry North]

Are brought to you through the facilities.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Of the United States Armed Forces Radio.

[Adam Graham]

Welcome back. Well, sometime between January 1951 and February 1952, the melodrama in this series got amped up to the next level, giving it practically a soap opera tone. In some ways more extreme than Mr. Chameleon, although it's a very different style. However, I think that there were still some very good moments by the North. Jerry's Morg ruse was pretty good, though. This is one case where cleverness feels a bit wasted when the murderer is an idiot. I mean, the guy used a very distinctive car. He just got to go and visit his brother with murder on his mind and was tricked into committing the murder by his lying wife. And he stumbled into Jerry's morgue trap and then told a ridiculous lie that Pam caught that proved him guilty. But I think this is a story where the Norths, just being the Norse, really do save this one. Alright, well, listener comments and feedback and we have a couple of comments on YouTube. Doris writes, I love this couple. They are so cute. And another listener shares listening on a windy night in the UK on February 19th. Well, thank you so much. So glad to be able to keep you company there and then comment on Instagram. Just followed your Instagram. Your uploads of Old Time Radio have given me so many hours of entertainment and even helped me to create my own hardball detective. Thank you for all these uploads. Excited to hear your newest. Well, thank you so much. I appreciate your kind comments and good luck on your detective novel. Well, now it's time to thank our Patreon Supporter of the day and I want to go ahead and thank Pippin. Pippin's been one of our patreon supporters since March 2022, currently supporting the podcast at the rookie level of $2 or more per month. Thanks so much for your support Pippin. And that will do it for today. If you're enjoying the podcast, please follow us using your favorite podcast, Soft, and be sure to rate and review the podcast wherever you download it from. We'll be back next Thursday with another episode of Mr. And Mrs. North, but join us back here tomorrow for yours truly, Johnny Dollar Wear.

[Laura Arnold]

You can tell me this. Why did all those things happen late at night when those poor old folks wouldn't have any reason to be up and around when there wasn't anybody around who could help them until it was too late?

[Doug Hathaway]

Well, so far as that's concerned, why.

[Laura Arnold]

Sure, sure, folks have got to get up at night sometime for one reason or another. But they all had their own private and if they want anything from downstairs, like something to read or some hot milk, something like that, why, all they have to do is ring the push button in their room and my wife gets it for them. We do that all the time.

[Narrator]

Where is your wife, by the way?

[Laura Arnold]

Martha? Why, she's right here, Frank. Who's this you're blabbing off your mouth too? Why Martha, this is Mr. Johnny Dollar, insurance investigator.

[Shirley Hathaway]

Investigator, huh? Well, you can march yourself right out of here.

[Doug Hathaway]

Hold on just a minute, Mrs. Scott.

[Laura Arnold]

Just a minute nothing.

[Shirley Hathaway]

You get out of here and leave.

[Ferdy Hathaway]

Us alone, Mrs. Skinner.

[Laura Arnold]

If you don't, I'll throw you out. If you don't think I'm young and strong enough, then I'll show you strong.

[Narrator]

Enough to throw a little old lady out of a window or shove a.

[Doug Hathaway]

Couple of people downstairs.

[Adam Graham]

I hope you'll be with us then. In the meantime, send your comments to box Thirteenreatetectives.net Follow us on Twitter at radiodetectives and check us out on Instagram. Instagram. From Boise, Idaho, this is your host, Adam Graham, signing off.