
Today's Mystery:Johnny investigates a series of fires at a chain of New England grocers. Original Radio Broadcast Date: May 4, 1958 Originating from Hollywood Starring: Bob Bailey as Johnny Dollar; Byron Kane; Harry Bartell; Virginia Gregg; Jack...
Loading summary
A
Limu Gamu and Doug Limu and I always tell you to customize your car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual. But now we want you to feel it. Cue the emu music. Limu. Save yourself money today. Increase your wealth. Customize and save. We save. That may have been too much feeling. Only pay for what you need@libertymutual.com Liberty Liberty Liberty Liberty Savings Fairy underwritten by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company and affiliates, excludes Massachusetts. What do you think makes the perfect snack? Hmm, it's gotta be when I'm really craving it and it's convenient. Could you be more specific? When it's cravinient. Okay. Like a freshly baked cookie made with real butter, available right down the street at am, pm. Or a savory breakfast sandwich I can grab in just a second at am pm. I'm seeing a pattern here. Well, yeah, we're talking about what I crave, which is anything from am, pm. What more could you want? Stop by AMPM where the snacks and drinks are perfectly craveable and convenient. That's cravenience am pm. Too much Good stuff. Welcome to the Great Detectives of Old Time Radio from Boise, Idaho. This is your host, Adam Graham. In a moment, we're going to bring you this week's episode of yours truly, Johnny Dollar. But first, I do want to encourage you if you're enjoying the podcast, to follow us using your favorite podcast software. Also, when you are making your travel plans, remember johnnydoller air.com johnnydollerair.com is our price affiliate link. So when you book a reservation through there, part of your purchase price goes to support the Great detectives of Old Time Radio at no additional cost to you. So remember, when making travel plans, check johnnydoller air.com first. Well now, from May 4, 1958, here is the Carson Arson matter from Hollywood. It's time now for Johnny Dollar. This is Jim Parris at Worldwide Mutual. Don't tell me Jim. Let me guess, what are you talking about? The reason you call me. I can smell the smoke all the way over here at my apartment. Oh, also, I heard something about the fire on a news broadcast a few minutes ago. Yes, somewhere out on Albany Avenue. He said. Yes, it's the cash and save market over the other side of town. And since your company insured it, you want me to go over and take a look? A good look. Johnny, you thinking of possible arson? I am. Okay. Why? That store is just one of a chain. Hartford, Boston, Providence, Springfield, Lowell. Yeah, yeah, I see. But how does that make it arson? This is the Fourth one to go up in as many weeks. Oh. The outfit that owns them having financial troubles? The outfit that owns them is one man. Oh. John Wakefield Carson. Then I repeat my question, Johnny. If he is burning up his own markets, if you can prove it, you can save our company a lot of money. That might cost you a lot of money, Jim. What do you mean? Wait till you see my expense account. Bob Bailey in the exciting adventures of the man with the action packed expense account. America's fabulous freelance insurance investigator. Yours truly, Johnny Doll. Expense account submitted by special investigator Johnny Dollar to the Worldwide Mutual Insurance Company home office, Hartford, Connecticut. Following is an account of expenses incurred during my investigation of the Carson arson. Matter expense account item one, a dollar and a quarter for a taxi from my apartment to the offices of Worldwide where I hope Jim Paris could give me a to go on. He did very little. First loss four and a half weeks ago was the market up in Thompsonville. How much loss in Thompsonville? $41,204. That was the smallest one in the chain. Uhhuh. The following week the one over in Fall river burned to the ground. And the claim on that? Some 58,000 odd dollars. Nothing odd about that much though. And the loss in Lowell was a bit over 64,000. How much the claim will be on this one here in Hartford remains to be seen. How much coverage does he have on it? Around 100,000, I believe. Yes, 106,000. And that's probably what he's gonna claim. Look, you can still see the smoke out there. Yes, and the telephone report I just got says it looks like a total loss. Will you go over and take a look at it? John Wakefield. Curse. That's right. His office is up in Boston. That's where his newest biggest market is. Oh. How much insurance on that one? Nearly half a million. It's one of the largest, most modern supermarkets. You better get over and see him in a hurry. You want me to get there before that one goes up, don't you? Expense account item 2. 450 for a cab to the scene of the fire way out on Albany Road. Three or four fire companies were hard at it, but it was easy to see there wasn't a chance of saving much. It struck me that this location, part of a brand new residential area, was about as far from an established fire company as it could be. I wondered for a moment if this was delivered. I finally ran down Hal Gibbons, an old pal and one of the best men a Narsen squad ever had. Stick your nose up in the Air and take a deep one. Johnny, you smell it? Well, it's not kerosene, Hal. I don't think it's gasoline either. No, but it's something highly inflammable. The boys of that chemical truck could get it out. Might learn something first. These stores always stock a lot of cleaning fluid, stuff like that. Most of them are not inflammable. Well, how about. Johnny, look out. Go. Hey, maybe we better move back away. Yeah. Must have got a pretty big start on the fireman, Hal. Sure, because it's so far out. It's like the markets in Thompsonville and Fall River. And Lowell too. Oh. Kind of makes you wonder, doesn't it? At this point, I'm more than just wondering, Johnny. Have you come up with anything? Those other towns are out of my bailiwick, but I know all the boys in the departments. Have they come up with anything? No. That's why I feel I've got to get the first lead, if there is one right here. Has old man Carson showed up? No, not doing any of the fires. He just sits calmly in his office in Boston. Mutters something philosophical about the vagaries of fortune and lets you go at that and files a big fat insurance claim. I think I want to see that guy Carson. I don't think it'll do you any good, but go to it. Know anything about his financial situation? He's loaded. Multimillionaire. And, boy, what a queer one. What's that mean? A regular nut. Always quoting Shakespeare, the Bible. Poetry by a good businessman. You sure he hasn't got some big investments? Something like that, that went bad on him recently? I'm sure there has to be some. Get back, I tell you, you gotta stay back at the line. Wanna keep your job, you tell your chief I'm here, and I wanna know why this fire got. Now, look, miss, I got orders. Don't choke on them. It's all right, Jerry. I'll take care of her. Whatever you say, Mr. Gibbons. But I got orders. Okay. Well, Ms. Carson, it looks like you're losing another market. This is the fourth one. The fourth one in a little over a. Hey, don't I know you? I'm afraid I haven't had the pleasure. It's Margaret Carson. This is Johnny Dollar, the insurance investigator. Good. Now maybe we'll get somewhere. No, this is Walter. Walter. Oh, yes, Margaret, my fiance. Mr. Dollar. Walter Smith. Smith. Hello, Walter. Mr. Gibbon. Walter handles the legal end of things for dad. Oh, I see. Next, president of the company, Walter I in the grocery business. Oh, no, no, sir. Thank you. The legal end is enough for me. What do you think about these fires? Four in a row? Well, if I were you, Mr. Dollar, I'd suspect arson. Walter, for heaven's sake. Why, Walter? Someone trying to put Mr. Carson out of business? Something like that. Put Father out of business with a couple of fires, Ms. Carson. Come on, Walter. We've seen all we need to make the final report to dad. Goodbye, Mr. Garland. See ya. Like a motive, Johnny? That Waller character. If he marries Margaret Carson and he doesn't seem to like the grocery business. Yeah, but if he could get the money from it. Yeah, I see what you mean. Act two of yours truly, Johnny Dollar. In a moment. Our flag now numbers 50 stars and behind each star there stands yet another flag representing one of the 50 states. South Dakota's state flag was inspired by a song. South Dakota is the Sunshine State. A stenographer named Ida Anding designed the flag with a sky blue background and a blazing sun in the center. And the words South Dakota, the Sunshine State in gold around the sun. Later, the state seal was inserted over the sun. A seal representing mining and agriculture, the prime pursuits of the state. The state's banner also carries the motto, under God, the people rule. South Dakota State flag. The flag of the 40th state to enter the Union was adopted on March 8, 1909. And now, Act 2 of yours truly, Johnny Dollar and the Carson arson. Expense account, item 3, 20 cents. Phone call from a booth near the scene of the fire. I wanted more information from Jim Paris at Worldwide Mutual. Information about the policies covering the 13 cash and saved markets, four of which had recently gone up in flames. I waited in the phone booth until Jim called me back. Johnny Dollar. Jim Here. Oh, good. All right. Here's a list of markets, Johnny, in the order of insurance coverage, starting with the smallest amount. Go ahead. Thompsonville, Fall River, Lowell, Hartford. That's the same order in which they burn. Exactly. Okay, which remaining store has the next biggest coverage? Salem. Okay, I'll start with Salem. What are you thinking of, Johnny? It's just a hunch, Jim, but. Well, I'll call you later. Item 4, 5 doll and a quarter for a camp. Back to my apartment. Item 5, $21. Even mileage in my own car. Hartford to Salem, Mass. Despite burning up the highway, it was almost dark when I pulled into Salem. It was well after dark when I finally located the Cash and Save market again. The store was far outside of town and it was a long way from the nearest firehouse. I don't know exactly Why, I went there instead of the main office in Boston. After all, it was the same day as the Hartford fire and the others had all been about a week apart. As I said before, call it a hunch, but as I pulled up in front of the place, I saw the shadow of a man dart furtively around the back of the building. As I reached the far corner of the building, I stopped. But with only the sliver of a crescent moon, I could see no one. Somewhere ahead of me, I heard a door open. Then silence again. But somebody had entered that building. Slowly, cautiously, I felt my way along the wall. And then I came to it. An open door storeroom. But inside it was pitch black. I drew my gun and carefully, quietly fell around for a light switch. After stumbling gently against a big packing case, I found it. I hunched down behind the case and flicked it on. All right, where are you? I heard you. I saw you come in here. Now look, I got a gun, so don't try anything funny. You hear me? Where are you? Right. Huh? Over your head. Oh, I must have been out a long time. I came to lying in a cot in the back room of Salem police headquarters. A couple of gallon jars. Can you hear me? Yeah. Yeah, I can hear you. Yeah, well, it was a couple of big gallon jars of kosher pickles that he dropped on top of your head. He? Officer, I like to split your head open. So he brought you in here to headquarters and had the doc look you over up. Easy now. Doc says no permanent harm done. He'll give you a shot to make you sleep and rest. Now, how about this cup of hot coffee? Yeah, sure. And about a dozen aspirins. My head feels like. There you are. Thanks. But you. You said he. And according to him, you left yourself wide open when you sneaked in there after him. And then to turn on the lights. Son, you've got a lot to learn. Okay, so I pulled a boo boo. But do you know who it was that slugged me? Of course, son. He brought you here. Who? Owner of the market. What? Mr. John Wakefield Carson. Item 6. $2 more mileage on my car. This time down to Boston and the main office of Cash and Save Mark to the private office of John Wakefield. Carson, please be calm of mind. All passion spent, Mr. Dollar. What? That's from Milton. Please sit down. Now look, Mr. Carson, about last night. Ladoc plays tricks upon us all. It did so in bringing us together last night. How did you know I was going to investigate that market of yours up in Salem? I didn't Know. But look you, young man. Yeah. The fires which destroyed those four markets did so in order their value to me. So I found out. Possibly. Then the next to go would be the store in Salem. For that indeed is next in order of value. It figures. Or perhaps twas mere coincidence those accidents occurred in that order. Accidents, Remember, Coincidence breeds further coincidence. That's a quotation from Brasco. Now Listen to me, Mr. Carson. For that reason, I decided to inspect the Salem store myself. Inspect it, huh? Make sure there'd be no possibility of spontaneous combustion. There, there. Let's get one thing straight right now, Mr. Carson. I think those fires were set. And if you'll come down to earth. Possible. I suppose. It was Shakespeare who said, fire answers fire. Through their paley flames, each sees the other zumbered face. Listen to me, will you? Oh, of course. I think you set those fires, or had them set by Mr. I think you were going to burn down the store in Salem until I came along. When I saw you there, I thought that was you. Oh, sure, sure. All right, tell me this. What do you plan to do with the insurance money if you get it? Rebuild bigger and better stores where the old ones stood? No. Or did you find out you hadn't made them big and modern enough for those real estate developments where they were located and decided the cheapest way for you to go? No. To build again where tragic dealt the fates. Forget the fancy quotes and answer my question, Shier said. You tread upon my patience, sir. Look, it's enough to make a deacon swear. Answered by James Russell. Mr. Carson. What disposition of the funds I choose to make is mine alone to settle and from my heart. Carson, enough. I've had enough of this. Now be on your way. No, wait a minute. Gone dollar and irk me. Now, no more. Now you wait. From your heart, you said. Now I have said enough. Henceforth, my lips are sealed. Okay, okay. But you know something? I think you've told me who might have set those fires. And if you'll answer me just one more question. No. Okay. We'll see. Act three of yours truly, Johnny Dollar. In a moment. Sometimes we may wonder why a football team doesn't quit playing and walk off the field when it finds itself 50 points behind with only a few minutes of play to go. What is that indomitable spirit that fills men with hope and keeps them going in spite of terrific odds. Keeps them going just to play the game according to the rules, just to get the job done as well as they know how this kind of spirit pervaded the feelings of heavy bomber Crews of the 9th Air Force on that day of glory. August 1, 1943. The day of one of the most secretly planned surprise bombing missions of World War II. The day of the low level attack on the Romanian oil refineries at floeshte. More than 170 B24 heavily loaded bombers took off in a swirl of red dust from Benghazi, Libya, to bomb a highly defended priority target. The element of surprise in the low level attack was to be one of their greatest weapons. But things went wrong from the start. Three planes exploded during takeoff operations. Eleven more aborted due to engine trouble. Of those that reached the target area, less than one third returned to home base. The leaders of the mission encountered navigation difficulties and difficulty in identifying the specific targets. And due to the loss of that elemental hope, surprise, they also encountered devastating enemy firepower from flak and fighters. The mission was partially successful, but a horrifying experience. Five Medals of Honor were awarded to the heroes of the Ploest arrayed for valorous action above and beyond the call of duty at any time. The men would have been justified in turning back. But they had a code of conduct that made them want to see the unequal game through to the end. It was a job that had to be done. A charge of the Light Brigade in the air as they flew down the valley of death to glory. And now, act three of yours truly, Johnny Dollar and the Carson Arson expense account. Item seven. 80 cents. Phone call to Hal Gibbons and the arson squad back in Hartford. Yeah, Johnny, I finally found plenty in the remains of that fire. And it was arson by some rank amateur. That's why it was hard to spot. What do you mean? When a pro sets ablaze, we know what to look for. I see. What about the other three fires? I called the boys in those cities immediately. Heard back from them this morning. Same story. All right. Have you checked on Walter. What's his name? The fiance of Carson's daughter? You mean stepdaughter? Stepdaughter I have, and that's what stops me. Alibis, huh? Perfect. Walter Smitton couldn't possibly have started those fires. I didn't think so. Huh. Now, that boy may call himself a lawyer, Hal, but he just hasn't the nerve to. Gumption, but who else? He stands to benefit if he marries Margaret Carson. And surely you don't think Carson himself. Johnny, call the Boston police, will you? Have them meet me at Carson's office. What for? Maybe to make an arrest. Do that for me, will you? Hunch Maybe it was more than a hunch. Now, sure, I know there was no real clues in the case, but maybe for once I could get along without them. I went back to Carson's office and I must confess, tried a little bluff court. You'd hailed me into court? That's right. Unless you open up and tell me what I want to know. Very well. Speak to me as to thy thinkings as thou dost, and you can forget the quotations. Walter Smitton is your lawyer, isn't he? A timid, but an eager lad who saved me many a fall. You like him? Like a son. I would he were my son. Or as the Bible says, a wise son maketh a hand. All right, all right. Oh, yes, yes. You have a stepdaughter, Margaret? Alas, I have. Okay. Now, who is to get the insurance money? You may collect. Well, that, sir, is none of your concern. You're gonna talk now, Mr. Carson, or in some family matter, who gets it. I. I pledged to my wife before she died that Margaret would have all monies from any profit, any monetary gain of any kind, of any of my ventures. That would include the insurance money. I see. That, Mr. Dollar, was my pledge. And, oh, how I have rued it. Why do you say that? She's not of my blood, Mr. Dollar. She has no soul for art or poetry. And since she's come of age, she's made so many demands upon me. Money, money, money. That's all she. Unlike water, she's so bold, aggressive, headstrong. Were it not for Walter, I'd mistrust her every move. But if he's in love with her because she demands he be. And why? So she can use his legal guidance in her fight to take this business away from me. All right, Mr. Carson. I haven't notified the authorities yet, but I found proof that Margaret is the one who started those fires. You what? And you just told me why. Because the money would go to her. Oh, Mr. Dala, I'm glad I've suspected. Yes, but because of family honor. No, no, no. I'm glad you have proof. Long last, it will take her. Take this millstone from about my neck. True, Margaret? Well, Dolly, you'll never live to tell the authorities that gun. Unless you'd like to make a deal, Johnny. It'd be worth a lot of money to you. I'd even promise not to set any more fires. Oh, you were right, Mr. Dollar. Unless I'm mistaken, Margaret, the man who just came in. What man? Who heard your little confession is from the police department. You trying to make me look around so you can grab for this gun? Oh, no. Fact remains, he's standing right in back of you. That's right. Margaret. No. Oh, my hands. My hair. How sharper than a serpent's tooth. Is an ungrateful child. Yeah. The company will have to pay on those four markets. And the courts will have to take care of market. I'm sure they will. And next time. Well, give me something clean to work on, will you? I hate this kind of stuff. Expense account total, including the trip home, $56.90. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Our star will return in just a moment. Our flag now numbers 50 stars, and behind each star there stands yet another flag representing one of the 50 states. Oklahoma's state flag depicts an Osage warrior's circular buckskin shield from which hangs seven eagle feathers. Across the shield is the Indian's calumet, or pipe of peace, crossed with the white man's peace symbol, the olive branch. On the shield are small crosses, the Indian's graphic sign for stars indicating lofty ideals or a purpose for high endeavor. The background of the flag is a field of blue, the blue of the Oklahoma sky signifying loyalty and devotion. The important symbols, however, are the calumet and the olive branch. These override the shield, the symbol of war, and bespeak a predominant love of peace by a united people. Oklahoma state flag. The flag of the 46th state to enter the union was adopted on April 2, 1925. Now here's our star to tell you about next week's story. Next week, the Rolling Stone matter. Remember that old saying about a rolling stone? Well, it applies here with a vengeance. Join us, won't you? Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar, starring Bob Bailey, originates in Hollywood and is produced and directed by Jack Johnstone, who also wrote today's story. Heard in our cast were Virginia Greg, Byron Kane, Harry Bartel, Jack Edwards, Joe Kearns and Forest Lewis. Be sure to join us next week, same time and station for another exciting story of yours truly, Johnny Dolly. This is the United States Armed Forces Radio and Television Service. Oh, what you eating? The new banana split cookie from AM pm. All freshly baked with real butter with banana, chocolate and strawberry flavors. Wow, that sounds amazing. Can I have a bite? I'm sorry, but no. But you can't split the banana split. Not even a little? Not even. Even a crumb. What if. No, please. Mine when it's too legit to split. That's cravinience. Get a 3 pack for 99 cents with our app, am pm too much good stuff. Plus tax where applicable. Prices and participation may vary. Terms of conditions apply. Welcome back. I can understand why Mr. Carson stopped cooperating with Johnny. It's an understandable reaction to a overzealous accusations, not actually based on anything other than vague suspicions. It's probably one of Johnny's worst flaws as an investigator. He jumps to conclusions and makes full throated allegations with no real evidence. And it turns off the insured from cooperating, even if they're innocent. And also can lead Johnny to falsely suspect someone for longer than he should. Though I will say Carson's successes in business is kind of unlikely. And I don't mean just due to the constant quotations. Although yeah, that probably doesn't help. But it was emphasized that all of these locations were built out in the middle of nowhere, far from vital services. I mean, can you imagine promoting the grand opening? Come out to our store. It is convenient to nothing else in this town. I mean location, location, location. And particularly with something like a market. You don't build those out in the middle of nowhere. You want to make it easy for people to shop with you. That's just not where you put supermarkets. I was a bit less sympathetic than usual to Johnny's request for a cleaner case. This wasn't all that hard and he well paid for it. And so, to Johnny's request, I'll have to be like Mr. Carson and borrow a phrase from a great work to provide an appropriate answer. You knew the job was danger when you took it. Super Chicken 1967. The teaser was amusing to me. I don't remember what happens in the next episode, but I'm just trying to imagine. A rolling stone gathers no moth, but with a vengeance. I wonder if it will live up to the hive. Well, we'll find out next week. All right. Listener comments and feedback Now Listener comments and feedback. And we just have a simple thank you, Adam, regarding the wayward money matter over on YouTube. Well, thank you so much. Now it's time to thank our Patreon supporter of the day. And I want to thank Claudia, patreon Supporter since October 2021, currently supporting the podcast at the Detective Sergeant level of $7.14 or more per month. Thanks so much for your support, Claudia. And that will do it for today. If you're enjoying the podcast, please follow us using your favorite podcast software. And if you're enjoying the podcast on YouTube, be sure to like the video, subscribe to the channel, and mark the notification bell. All great things that help our YouTube channel to grow. We will Be back with you next Friday with another episode of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar. But join us back here tomorrow where we turn to the great adventurers of Old Time Radio and bring you an episode of Cloak and Daggerware. Hello, Mike. Well, if it isn't Frank Marshall. Ain't it awful? Come in. Thanks. You. You never drink candy? Your bottle of beer and deluxe in the bar. Help yourselves. Better take it easy, Marshall. You don't know how I need it. I got a small idea. I've been listening to the radio. Then you know I'm hot. Well, you got the thermometer held in. Jaja and Porfirio. They got a tri state alarm out. I didn't kill San demarco. You will send a big bitch. Letting a man get away with that could ruin your business. That does me a thing. It does when they find your gun next to his body and a button off your coat in his hand. What about the bellboy? What bellboy? The kid from the Chelsea Arms who identified you from one of your pictures as the man who asked him for DeMarco's room number. I tell you, it's a frame. How did you come here? They can mail me for harboring a fugitive and that means my license. Okay, Mike. Sorry I bothered you. Wait a minute. You say this is a frame? I swear it. If you're lying to me, I give you my word. Wouldn't I be a SAP to let anybody see me going into DeMarco's room? That's what I was thinking. Sounded like the killer went out of his way to be spotted. And while I might buy that button they found in DeMarco's hand, when you add it to the other things, like the gun, it's too much. Can you believe me? You're staying here, aren't you? Thank Hal. I won't forget to give it. You got any idea who might be behind this routine? No. Well, obviously it had to be somebody who could pass for you. Now, who do you know about your size? Oh, a hundred guys. Name one. Well, Steve Burns. Where can I find him? He's out on the coast. That's a big help. Then he saw the nomination. I tell you, the million guys. I'm still waiting for number two. Well, Alan Crane. Who's he? A guy who used to work for me. Did you fire him? Yes. He didn't have nerve enough for the business. Well, then the Chris Crane sounds like a likely suspect. You're out of your mind. Alan's yellow. He'd never have enough guts to pull a deal like this. Ever hear the story of a worm that turned? I hope you'll be with us then. In the meantime, send your comments to box Thirteenreatetectives.net Follow us on Twitter at radiodetectives and check us out on Instagram instagram.com greatdetectives From Boise, Idaho, this is your host Adam Graham signing off. You just realized your business needed to hire someone yesterday. How can you find amazing candidates fast? Easy. Just use Indeed. Stop struggling to get your job post seen on other job sites with Indeed sponsored jobs. Your post jumps to the top of the page for your relevant candidates so you can reach the people you want faster. According to Indeed data, sponsored jobs posted directly on indeed have 45% more applications than non sponsored jobs. Don't wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed and listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit to get your jobs more visibility@ Indeed.com Arts just go to Indeed.com Arts right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring Indeed is all you need. Lowes knows that no matter your paint project, saving is at the top of your list. That's why when you shop today, you can buy one. Get one free. Select Valspar and HGTV Home by Sherwin Williams one Coat coverage Interior paints via rebate Shop these deals in store or online. Today at Lowe's, we have help you save. Selection varies by location while supplies last. Discount taken at time of purchase. See Sales Associate for details. Offer valid 821 93. You don't need to be ripped, you just need the right shirt. Epic Fits gives you a clean, confident silhouette. Snug on the arms, soft on the skin, generous where it counts. And with deals like $15 per tee, they won't break the bank. Visit epicfits.com today. Epic fits t shirts that get it.
Episode: Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar – The Carson Arson Matter (EP4784)
Date: August 22, 2025
Host: Adam Graham
This episode features the classic old-time radio detective drama "Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar," specifically the case titled “The Carson Arson Matter.” Johnny Dollar, the “man with the action-packed expense account,” investigates a series of fires at a chain of supermarkets, all insured by Worldwide Mutual. Suspicion of arson rises as Dollar seeks to uncover whether these are accidents, insurance scams, or something more personal. Host Adam Graham provides insightful post-story commentary, critiquing both the detective work and the story’s plausibility.
Jim Paris: “If he is burning up his own markets, if you can prove it, you can save our company a lot of money.” (04:45)
Hal Gibbons: “Must have got a pretty big start on the fireman, Hal. Sure, because it's so far out. It's like the markets in Thompsonville and Fall River. And Lowell too. Kind of makes you wonder, doesn't it?” (10:10)
Carson: “Please be calm of mind. All passion spent, Mr. Dollar. That's from Milton.” (25:50)
Margaret Carson: “Unless you'd like to make a deal, Johnny. It'd be worth a lot of money to you. I'd even promise not to set any more fires.” (38:28)
Carson: “How sharper than a serpent's tooth is an ungrateful child.” (39:25)
Adam Graham: “You knew the job was danger when you took it.” — Super Chicken, 1967 (45:44)
| Timestamp | Segment | |-----------|-----------------------------------------| | 03:30 | Johnny contacted by Jim Paris | | 05:20 | Discussion of suspicious arson pattern | | 08:15 | Onsite investigation at latest fire | | 13:20 | Meeting Margaret Carson & Walter Smith | | 16:35 | Linking insurance coverage to fires | | 22:05 | Johnny ambushed in Salem store | | 25:50 | Carson’s philosophical musings | | 27:50 | Boston office confrontation | | 32:45 | Arson evidence: amateur vs. pro | | 35:40 | Motive revealed: Margaret’s inheritance | | 38:10 | Margaret’s confession and police arrest | | 39:25 | Carson’s “serpent’s tooth” quote | | 43:10 | Adam Graham’s critical commentary | | 45:44 | “You knew the job was danger…” quote |
Johnny Dollar's Deadpan Wit:
“Wait till you see my expense account.” (04:56)
Walter Smith's Boldness:
“Well, if I were you, Mr. Dollar, I'd suspect arson.” (13:25)
Carson's Literary Wall:
“Fire answers fire. Through their paley flames, each sees the other's umbered face.” (26:30)
Margaret’s Brazen Offer:
"Unless you'd like to make a deal, Johnny. It'd be worth a lot of money to you." (38:30)
Adam Graham’s Wrap-Up:
“I was a bit less sympathetic than usual to Johnny's request for a cleaner case... You knew the job was danger when you took it.” (45:44)
For newcomers and nostalgic fans alike, this episode stands as a compelling blend of suspense, character study, and sly radio-era humor—capped off by Adam Graham’s accessible, witty critique and listener feedback segment.