
Today's Mystery:Johnny is sent to investigate a claim that a ghost is haunting a small New Jersey town. Original Radio Broadcast Date: May 18, 1958 Originating from Hollywood Starring: Bob Bailey as Johnny Dollar; Virginia Gregg; Forrest Lewis;...
Loading summary
A
This is the story of the 1. As a custodial supervisor at a high school, he knows that during cold and flu season, germs spread fast. It's why he partners with Granger to stay fully stocked on the products and supplies he needs, from tissues to disinfectants to floor scrubbers, all so that he can help students, staff and teachers stay healthy and focused. Call 1-800-GRAINGER Click grainger.com or just stop by Grange Granger for the ones who get it done. This is the story of the 1. As a maintenance supervisor at a manufacturing facility, he knows keeping the line up and running is a top priority. That's why he chooses Grainger. Because when a drive belt gets damaged, Grainger makes it easy to find the exact specs for the replacement product he needs. And next day delivery helps ensure he'll have everything in place and running like clockwork. Call 1-800-GRAINGER click granger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.
B
Welcome to the Great Detectives of Old Time Radio from Boise, Idaho. This is your host, Adam Graham. In a moment, we're going to bring you this week's episode of yours truly, Johnny Dollar. But first, I want to encourage you, if you're enjoying the podcast, to please follow us using your favorite podcast software. Our listener support and appreciation campaign continues. You can become one of our ongoing Patreon supporters for as little as $2 per month at patreon.greatdetectives.net but now, from May 18, 1958, here is the Ghost to Ghost matter.
A
From Hollywood. It's time now for Johnny Dollar. Hi, Johnny. This is Art Price, International Press Service. Oh, holy smoke. Art, what are you doing up at this hour of the morning? I'm on the night desk and I'm sorry to have to wake you up. So am I. Listen, I just got a call, a real frantic one from a guy who insisted on having your phone number. Well, did you give it to him? He said he's an insurance man and it was about some insurance matter, so, yes, I did. Well, why'd he call you? Yeah, and puzzles me, too. But he was so excited, so, well, so frantic. Well, he probably called the first person he could think of and he said it was a big emergency. Oh, did he give you any details? No. And Johnny, it's aroused my curiosity. Let me know what it's all about, will you? Yeah, sure, sir. Promise? Okay, I promise. Bob Bailey and the exciting adventures of the man with the action packed expense Account. America's fabulous freelance Insurance investigators, yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Expense account submitted by special investigator Johnny Dollar, the State Unity Life Insurance Company, Home office, Hartford, Connecticut. Following is an account of expenses incurred during my investigation of the ghost to ghost matter. I'd no sooner rolled over in the hope of getting back to sleep when the phone beside my bed started jangling again. Oh, nuts. Johnny Dollar, this is Oscar H. Trimley, Mr. Dollar Tremley. I represent State Unity, live here in Lake City, New Jersey. Oh, look, are you the man who called Art Price over an international press service? Yes, yes, I did get your phone number. I. And you knew he'd have it, your being such a famous investigator and all that. Yeah, well, you could also have got it from Universal Adjustment Bureau, your insurance directory. The long distance operator. Oh, dear. I guess I've been so upset over this whole thing that it never occurred to me. But can you come down here to Lake City, Mr. Dollar? Right away? Well, it depends. What's this all about? Ian McAndrews. Who's Ian McAndrews? Oh, don't you know? He's the man who founded Lake City. So what's happened to him? He's dead, Mr. Dollar. Or rather, he isn't. Well, that is to say, he died, Mr. Dollar, about five years ago. And, well, in due time, of course, we paid off the claim on his life insurance policy. $55,000. Everything in order and perfectly all right. Well, then. But now. Oh. Oh, no, Mr. Dollar, you. You just won't believe it unless you come here and see for yourself. Won't believe what? Ian McAndrews has come back. Huh? Either he or his. His ghost has come back here. Oh, now, wait a minute. No, it's true. It's absolutely True, sir. Ian McAndrews is haunting Lake City. So please come as quickly as you can. I. I'll think about it. Oh, dear. Is that the best answer you can give me? Yeah, I'm afraid so. Until I see how things line up for me these next couple of days. Goodbye, Mr. Tremble. Think about it. I can hardly wait to grab a train. But I didn't want Oscar Trimley to know that because I had a strong suspicion that if you can catch a ghost off guard, you'll be one up on him. Expense account. Item 1. The promised phone call to Art Price and International Press. Are you kidding, Johnny? No, I'm deadly serious, Art. But a ghost in the little new church? Yeah. Yep, I'll keep in touch. Then I remembered Nancy. Nancy Turner, an old flame, or rather a young old flame, she'd said. Something one time about taking up investigation of the supernatural. So. Expense account, item 2. Another dime for another call. You old rascal. Johnny, you haven't called me in ages. Well, you know how it is. Look, Nancy, did you ever go ahead with your study of psychic investigation? Psychic? Oh, no, Johnny. I found I'd have to read a couple of hundred musty old books, so I gave it up. Oh, well, that's too bad. Oh, why? Well, I. I've got to run over to Jersey to investigate a haunted. A haunted town. How thrilling. Except that such a thing is impossible. Oh, it is, sure. But I kind of thought that maybe you were still. Well, I guess we better forget it. Forget it? Nothing. I'm going with you. Oh, no, no, wait, I. No excuses. I'll put on my face and another dress and be waiting by the time you can get. Yeah, but look, honey, I. Huh? Johnny. Okay, Nancy, I'll pick you up. Item three, 1085, taxi and TR for two to New York. Item four, 50 bucks deposited on a rental car. When we got into Grand Central Station, we crossed over into Jersey and hit Route 22 for Somerville and points west. And every mile of the way, Nancy chatted away like a magpie. She kept quoting some of the stuff she had read on the subject. A lot of authorities who decided that some of the reports on haunted towns and houses and people, things like that, had decided there was something really supernatural about them. And, you know, after a while, I began to wonder if. I began to wonder. Act two of yours truly, Johnny Dollar. In a moment, our flag now numbers 50 stars. And behind each star there stands yet another flag representing one of the 50 states. Kansas State flag is dark blue and in the center is the state seal surmounted by a large sunflower, the official state flower. The seal reflects the history of Kansas, the train of ox wagons going west. For most of the great roads pass through Kansas. An Indian is depicted chasing a herd of buffalo, recalling the words of the official state song. Oh, give me a home where the buffalo roam. For this truly was the home of the buffalo and Indian. The east is represented by a rising sun and the promise of future prosperity is indicated by the steamboat on the river and the farmer plowing the field. Above a mountain range are 34 stars. For Kansas was the 34th state admitted to the Union. Overall is the state motto. Ad astra per aspera to the stars through difficulties. Kansas State flag. The flag of the 34th state to enter the union was adopted on March 23, 1927. And now Act 2 of yours truly Johnny Dollar and the ghost to ghost matter. Lake City. Nestled in among the soft rolling North Jersey hills, but a kind of has been town. I saw the reason for that in the abandoned mill. The old McAndrews Cotton Mill at one side of the lake. The same old story. I guess when a town's main industry closes down, it kind of goes to pot. Nonetheless, it was a charming little place, population all maybe 4 or 500. When we finally located Oscar Tremley's insurance office we found a bit of a gathering there. And Mr. Dollar, that is Ms. Turner and Mr. Dollar, this is Charlie Reed Foster and Tony Gray. We're sort of local businessmen's club, Johnny, you know. Okay, now let's get to the point. Sit down, sit down. Thank you. Johnny. I thought over the phone that you were turning us down. Well, I. I changed my mind. And when I thought of Nancy and her knowledge of the supernatural. Good, that's what we need. Yes, you're right. Well, I am interested in the subject. We're all a little worried about it. Tony isn't kidding. I think we're a pretty level headed bunch but, well, this thing has us scared. That's putting it mildly. If it really is his ghost that's plaguing us now. You don't seriously believe in ghosts? I'll tell you this, I never did before. But now. Well, wait and you'll see. Gee, Johnny. Well, suppose you tell me what's going on. Well, no, no, no, no, Johnny, you'll have to see for yourself. And here. Yes, Charlie, and here. And that means waiting until midnight. Midnight? Sure, Mr. Dolly. Well, just. Why Bill, you. You'll see. Yes, and meantime you can look around. Say, aren't you quite a fisherman, Johnny? I'd rather fish than eat. But now look, if you. Oh, I love to fish too. Oh, the lake's full of nice bass, Charlie. You can fix them up with a boat, can't you? Sure can. Yes, but if I'm going to arrange for a place for Ms. Turner to stay overnight. Big glad to. Well now Johnny, you'll stay at my home. All right, fine, but now at least tell me. Oh no, I want you to see for yourself at midnight. Now meantime, good fishing. Right. I've got to get back to the shop for Mrs. Bixley starts screaming about her high five. See you later. Yeah, and I'll come back to the office and arrange somewhere for Ms. Turner to stay. See you later. See you, Tony. Now if you folks will come over to the print shop with me, we'll pick up the Keys to my boat and some tackle and you can be on your way. Look, can't you at least give me some idea? No, no, not a thing until midnight. Oh, and we'll all have dinner together at the hotel. Mr. Trouble. Mr. Turner. You fellas of the boss, I guess. Fishing, Nancy, I'd love it. I'll even give you some of the fast strike hooks I use. Okay, then, let's go. There was something slightly screwy about the whole thing. And I don't mean just the talk of a ghost, but when I go fishing, and at company expense, well, who's to complain? So Nancy and I spent the rest of the day on the lake. Matter of fact, she caught the big one. By dinner time, we were starved. And the little hotel served us not only excellent cocktails, but a regular banquet, complete with champagne. You enjoying it, Ms. Turner? I love it. Only why don't you call me Nancy? Sure, why not? Charlie, I'll tell your wife. Tony, you stay out of this. Mrs. Trimley, about this ghost, the champagne, you know, comes from the old Leland Stanford Vineyard. Oh, yes, and it's fine. Finest I know. But it's time we talk about your ghost. Hey, you land any big ones out on the lake? Yeah, Bill. Nancy got a four pounder, but now, listen, would you? Another thing about this fine California. Nice to see you navigating the boat, Nancy. Listen, I got one last year, weighed six and a half. Please, will you tell me a little bit about. All I want to know is. So I got nowhere. But then finally, after a lot more food and wine and chatter, we drove off in Tony's car. Now, I'm stopping here in the middle of town, Johnny, because it's the best place to be when things start popping. Like what? Hey, when are you fellas gonna stop this run around and start making sense? You'll see. You'll see. I'm all excited. Look, Johnny. Yeah, Charlie. You see the old tower clock? Almost midnight. So what about it? Old McAndrews passed away at the stroke of midnight, Johnny. Personally, I think that has something to do with this. You still haven't told me with what? Wait, listen. There goes the tower clock. Oh, midnight. Count them, Johnny. That was four, five. And, Johnny, see how all the lights are flickering along the streets? That happens every night and no reason for it. Look, Bath. Millions of bats coming out of that clock tower. Yeah, yeah, I see him, but I don't. What, under the sun, is that? That's the ghost wailing. Oh, now, wait a minute. That scream fills the air. Comes from everywhere. It's a horrible sound. Darling. Easy, honey. No, listen. Didn't you hear that clock struck 13? Yes, Johnny. Why, yes, you ask me, the devil's in old MacAndrew's ghost, that's why. It comes out of his house every night. Out of his house. Right, Johnny. And wait till you see what's there. Right. Act three of yours truly, Johnny Dollar. In a moment. Famous words of wisdom spoken by great men of thought never die but are carried on through history by the people who feel them and love them. When Benjamin Franklin said, they that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety, he was speaking for all men in all countries. In May 1945, when the 1st Marine Division was making an assault on Okinawa, pharmacists mate William D. Halliburton, Jr. Serving with a Marine rifle company, left his place of safety during a terrific counterattack by the enemy. In spite of the deadly accuracy of the concentrated fire around him, Halliburton unhesitatingly dashed across a draw and up a hill into an open bombarded field to render first aid to a fallen marine. When his patient was struck a second time, Halliburton placed himself in the direct line of fire in order that he might shield his patient and continue to treat him. Though he could have sought safety until his company advanced and covered him, his first thought was for the wounded man. It was only when the slashing fury of the shrapnel and bullets mortally wounded him that Halliburton was unable to continue his duty. His unwavering code of conduct in the fight for liberty earned him his grateful country's highest award, the Medal of Honor. And now, act three of yours truly, Johnny Dollar and the ghost to ghost matter is the front door of this old house always left wide open. Yeah, Johnny, sure. You want to go in? Sure. Come along, Nancy. I. I'm coming. Sorry. There was more lighting. Rock. Oh, that's nice. Slammed right in our faces. I knew it unlocked, though. Let me have that flashlight, Tony. Here, here. No sign of wires or strings on it. Come on. Okay. Come on, fellas. Now, Johnny. Yeah, Bill? As you can see, there's just one big room downstairs. Here, Johnny. Easy, Nancy, easy. Don't you see? Look, I admit this is all pretty strange, but a ghost? What else? We've been over this house with a fine tooth comb. Listen. You hear that? Somebody. Somebody's walking on the ceiling. Listen. Oh, yeah. That's the kind of stuff you hear. Poltergeist. Noisy spirits. You can hear them, but you can't See them? Don't you see, Johnny? It can't be anything normal or natural. Is that the end? No, sir. The. The old ghost has a regular. See? Hear those shutters banging? There's no wind out there. Why. Why didn't you tell me it'd be like this? Johnny, let's look. Yeah. Lights moving around somewhere outside. You can see the reflection in the trees. But they're green ghost lights. Johnny, look, this is a rocking chair. It's rocking in front of the window where old MacAndrews used to sit and look out on the town before he died. Give me the flashlight. Here. No strings or wires on this, either. Well, well, that's the end of it. The same crazy routine every night. It's the ghost of Ian McAndrews. That's all there is to it. Well, from what you fellas are showing me tonight, it kind of looks that way. It is, Johnny, but tomorrow I want to investigate these things in broad daylight. I investigated, all right. The old house, the clock tower, everything I could find. And thanks to the help of the boys, we covered a lot of ground. Result? Nothing. Meantime, I noticed that the town, the sleepy little town of Lake City was being mobbed. People from all over streets jam with. With cars. And as we sat down at lunch in the hotel. Ms. Waitress, will you please bring me another cup? Oh, dear. She didn't hear me. Where'd they all come from? Yeah, business has certainly picked up around here. Why, yes, I noticed that. Any idea why, Bill? Not the least. No wonder Tony couldn't be with us for lunch. Charlie's at his print shop getting out an extra. Hey, excuse me. Excuse me. Are you Johnny Dollar, the investigator? Yeah, that's right, man. Can I use you? Now, just let me get a picture. Now, wait, hold it, hold it, hold it. Okay, Johnny, thanks. Thanks a lot. Hey, that photographer's from one of the New York papers. No kidding. Really? Listen, if Art Price at International Press gave out the word about this ghost story. Oh, now, Johnny. Okay, Nancy, you all finished, then? Oscar, Bill, we're going to leave the check with you and. You mean leave town? Yep. Going back to Hartford. Johnny, I've investigated. I've come up with nothing. So there's no point in staying around any longer. Oh, Johnny. Thanks a lot, fellas. And, Oscar, I'll send you my expense account. Come on, Nancy, give up? Hardly. Sure, Nancy and I hit the highway, but for only a few miles. Then shortly after dark, we drove back. And for a couple of hours, for three or four hours. Well, anyhow, shortly before Midnight, Nancy and I walk quietly up on the porch of Oscar Tremblay's insurance office. You mean you didn't leave a message at my office to be here tonight? I certainly didn't. I found a message from Charlie. Are you kidding? Somebody left a message at my print shop to be here, and I got one at my radio shop. Well, I'll be honest now. I want. Of course, they couldn't know your handwriting. Wait a minute. There's somebody outside. Huh? Johnny. Good evening, gentlemen. Why, I thought you'd left town. Johnny, what are you doing back there? That's right. I wanted you to think so. Oh, listen. The old tower clock has started to strike midnight. Oh, yeah, that's five, six. Boys, I suddenly realized that in all my investigation this morning, I was being handicapped by what I thought was help. What's that? I had too much help. Two or three of you were with me every second. Oh, we wanted to be sure you wouldn't overlook it. That's right. You wanted to be sure I would overlook a few things. Wait. That's 1112. Hey, it only struck 12. That's right. No ghostly whale tonight, is there? I know. No, fellas, no, because the ghost is no more. You found the ghost, Johnny. I found out that he's one of you. Maybe all of you alone, without your careful guidance. I finally located that sub cellar in the old MacAndrews house. You did? And that mess of complicated electrical stuff that was making the weird sound effects. The rocking chair, the banging shutters and so on. Very clever, your handiwork, Bill. Sure, sure, But. But, Johnny. Oh, fellas, it was a wonderful publicity stunt, especially after international press was notified. But. But you did that not only for your radio and electronic shop, Bill. For your real estate business, Tony, Your print shop and newspaper, Charlie. And your insurance business, Oscar. Well, now, John, for the whole town. It's gonna put Lake City on the map again. Which is to say, the motive wasn't entirely selfish. No, of course it was. Okay. Okay, man. And because of that, and that alone, I won't give you away. Provided the Ghost of Ian McAndrews never walks the streets of Lake City again. Well, you can be sure of that, Johnny. Donald, I don't know. I suppose I ought to really hit you over the head with this expense account, but after all, the cause was a kind of worthy one. So I'll be honest with it for a change. And it was fun to have Nancy Turner along. Expense account total, including mileage on the rental car, less deposit, 3150 yours truly, Johnny Dollar, our star will return in just a moment. Our flag now numbers 50 stars, and behind each star there stands yet another flag representing one of the 50 states. North Dakota's state flag consists of a field of blue bordered with a knotted yellow fringe. Centered is a bird with outspread wings and with open beak, the eagle, king of birds, symbol of supreme authority, power, strength and nobility. The left talon of the eagle grasps a sheaf of arrows representing the Indians of North Dakota. The right foot grasps an olive branch signifying peace. On the breast of the eagle is a shield with seven red and six white stripes signifying protection by the Union of the States. A scroll bearing the word e pluribus unum. One out of many passes through the eagle's beak. 13 stars for the original 13 states are over the scroll above the stars is a sunburst for the continual sunshine in the state. North Dakota's state flag, the flag of the 39th state to enter the union was adopted on March 26, 1929. Now here's our star to tell you about next week's story. Next week, the most dangerous, exciting incident of my whole career. I break out in a cold sweat whenever I think of it, so join us, won't you? Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Yours truly, Johnny Dollars, starring Bob Bailey, originates in Hollywood and is produced and directed by Jack Johnstone, who also wrote today's story. Heard in our cast were Virginia Gregg, Forest Lewis, Joseph Kern, Russell Thorson, Sam Edwards and Bob Bruce. Be sure to join us next week, same time and station, for another exciting story of yours truly, Johnny Dollar. This is Roy Rowan speaking. This is the United States Armed Forces Radio and Television Service.
B
Welcome back. I appreciated Johnny's overall initial instinct to surprise the town with showing up. His big problem was that they were all in on it and so kept him busy. So they were able to get through things set up. But Johnny's overall instinct of stealth is actually what pays off in the end. I did find Nancy's inclosure and her insistence on being included was funny. Well, I. I was calling you up because I wanted to see if you decided to become an expert. Now, becoming an expert would mean actually having to study up on the subject, so I decided not to do it. Oh, well, there's a supernatural case. No, you. Well, then I'm going. Well, you don't actually know anything. Sure, I've read a couple of booklets I picked up in gas stations. Don't worry, you'll be fine. I've got some stuff to tell you about what Some authorities have said. But Johnny liked having her around, so I can't complain too much about that. And any week that you get to hear Virginia Gregg act is a good week. Listener comments and feedback and we turn to Facebook, where a listener comments. The very last place Johnny Dollar went was Little Rock, Arkansas. Actually, no. I will say that towards the end of Bob Bailey's run, there is a case that is set in Little Rock, but that's not even the Last Bailey episode. The last episode, period, had Johnny journeying to Wethersfield, Connecticut, after the previous week when he went to Bronxville, New York. That, of course, is the era of the program that we're looking forward to, where they realized that the audience, even though Johnny could technically go anywhere, you know, if he just stays around New York, Connecticut and New Jersey, that makes the research more convenient. All right, well, now it's time to thank our Patreon Supporter of the day. Thank you to Joel, patreon Supporter since July 2021, currently supporting the podcast at the Detective Sergeant level of $7.14 or more per month. Thanks so much for your support, Joel. And that will do it for today. If you're enjoying the podcast, please follow us using your favorite podcast software. If you're enjoying the podcast on YouTube, be sure to like the video, subscribe to the channel and mark the notification bell. We will be back next Friday with another episode of yours truly, Johnny Dollar. But join us on Saturday as we turn to the great adventurers of Old Time Radio and Cloak and Dagger, where.
A
Gentle Colonel Couldn't make it otherwise. Glad you came. Can't make it now, maybe. What are you talking about? Tell Colonel Briere. Heavily fortified. More than we thought. Saw myself. 80 pieces of 105 millimeter artillery behind the lines. Germans are digging in. Well, come on, sit back and tell them yourself. Hey, couldn't you have celebrated later? Made it this far. Needed a drink to make it all the way. Tell Colonel we're heavily fortified. Heavily fortified.
B
Miller, I hope you'll be with us then. In the meantime, send your comments to box Thirteenreatetectives.net follow us on Twitter at radiodetectives and check us out on Instagram. Instagram.com from Boise, Idaho, this is your host, Adam Graham, signing off.
Podcast Summary:
The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio | Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar: The Ghost to Ghost Matter (EP4795)
Aired: September 5, 2025
Host: Adam Graham
Featured Detective: Johnny Dollar (portrayed by Bob Bailey)
In this episode, “The Ghost to Ghost Matter,” freelance insurance investigator Johnny Dollar is called to Lake City, New Jersey, to unravel the mystery behind the supposed haunting of the town’s founder, Ian McAndrews—who's reportedly returned from the dead as a ghost. With a mix of skepticism and curiosity, Johnny is drawn into a web of eerie nighttime phenomena, local superstition, and, ultimately, a well-engineered hoax. The episode expertly combines suspense with humor, and showcases the charms of small-town Americana and golden-age radio craftsmanship.
Johnny is Awakened Early:
Johnny receives a frantic call from Art Price at the International Press Service, alerting him to a mysterious insurance emergency.
Oscar H. Trimley’s Plea:
Oscar Trimley from Lake City’s State Unity Life office insists Johnny must come at once, claiming that "Ian McAndrews... has come back... Either he or his ghost has come back here." (04:09)
Memorable Quote:
“Ian McAndrews is haunting Lake City. So please come as quickly as you can.”
—Oscar H. Trimley [04:30]
Daytime Probing Yields Nothing:
Johnny checks the clock tower, the house, and the town, but finds no explanation for the phenomena—until he notices a flood of tourists arriving.
Johnny’s Departure Is a Ruse:
Johnny pretends to leave but doubles back to observe. He discovers the businessmen all received “messages” to meet, but none had written them—Johnny realizes something is amiss.
The Mystery Solved:
Johnny reveals that the supernatural events were all fabricated by the businessmen as a publicity stunt to resurrect Lake City’s fortunes.
“You found the ghost, Johnny.”
—Oscar H. Trimley [25:46]
“It was a wonderful publicity stunt. But you did that not only for your radio and electronics shop, Bill—for your real estate business, Tony… your insurance business, Oscar—well, for the whole town.”
—Johnny Dollar [25:51]
Highlights Johnny’s strategic stealth and successful investigation.
Comments humorously on Nancy’s enthusiastic but shallow knowledge of the supernatural:
“Sure, I’ve read a couple of booklets I picked up in gas stations. Don’t worry, you’ll be fine.”
—Adam Graham, paraphrasing Nancy [27:42]
Praises Virginia Gregg’s performance as Nancy Turner:
“Any week that you get to hear Virginia Gregg act is a good week.” [28:10]
Listener Feedback:
Graham clarifies a listener’s question about Johnny Dollar’s travels and concludes by thanking Patreon supporter Joel.
“Ian McAndrews is haunting Lake City. So please come as quickly as you can.”
—Oscar H. Trimley [04:30]
“Forget it? Nothing. I'm going with you.”
—Nancy Turner [06:54]
“If you ask me, the devil’s in old MacAndrew’s ghost, that’s why.”
—Charlie [17:55]
“You found the ghost, Johnny… it was a wonderful publicity stunt.”
—Oscar H. Trimley & Johnny Dollar [25:46–25:51]
| Timestamp | Event | |------------|-----------------------------------------------------| | 02:14 | Johnny gets initial call about the ghost | | 06:54 | Nancy insists on joining the case | | 09:15 | Arrival in Lake City; townspeople dodge questions | | 15:58 | Midnight haunting sequence begins | | 21:30 | Town flooded by tourists; Johnny becomes suspicious | | 24:50 | Johnny exposes the hoax | | 27:12 | Host's post-show commentary |
The episode balances dry wit and tongue-in-cheek skepticism with classic small-town intrigue and a light dose of supernatural excitement. The dialogue is crisp, character-driven, and filled with playful banter. The show leans into Golden Age radio tropes while gently lampooning the gullibility and resourcefulness of both out-of-towners (like Johnny and Nancy) and the town’s desperate entrepreneurs.
Summary for New Listeners:
This episode is a deft mix of mystery, comedy, and Americana, wrapped in a supernatural premise that ultimately reveals the lengths to which a struggling town will go to turn its fortunes around. It’s a perfect showcase of Johnny Dollar’s shrewdness and charm—and a treat for fans of vintage detective drama.