Episode Summary: Sherlock Holmes – Death at Stonehenge (EP3534)

Podcast Title: Sherlock Holmes Presented by the Great Detectives of Old Time Radio
Host: Adam Graham
Release Date: August 19, 2021
Episode: Death at Stonehenge

Introduction

In this episode of "The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio," host Adam Graham delves into a classic Sherlock Holmes adventure titled "Death at Stonehenge." This particular episode features Richard Gordon as Sherlock Holmes, marking one of the earliest radio portrayals of the iconic detective. Released on March 15, 1933, this story presents a unique interpretation of Holmes, diverging from later, more familiar renditions.

Synopsis of "Death at Stonehenge"

Setting the Scene

Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson, weary from a perilous winter battling Professor Moriarty—a brilliant and malevolent adversary—decide to take a much-needed vacation in June 1889. Opting for the serene hamlet of Claverly on Grafton, they aim to engage in trout fishing, a stark contrast to their usual high-stakes investigations.

A Troubled Vacation

Upon arrival at the Crown of Roses Inn, Holmes exhibits an uncharacteristically subdued demeanor, likely a result of the intense mental and physical strain from previous confrontations with Moriarty. The first week of their stay is marred by incessant rain, preventing any fishing activities. Holmes retreats into a state of near-constant slumber, while Watson attempts to recuperate through his writing.

The Sixth Day: A Glimpse of Mystery

On the sixth day, Holmes abruptly awakens and expresses a desire to visit the nearby Stonehenge, wishing to witness the ancient druidic site under the mystical conditions of a solstice solilo. Despite Watson's concerns about the inclement weather and the potentially eerie atmosphere, Holmes is insistent, describing Stonehenge’s allure:

Holmes [Timestamp 08:15]: "Stonehenge in a mist at midnight... The solstice is the perfect time to observe its true essence."

Encounter at Stonehenge

Venturing out into the foggy night, Holmes and Watson arrive at Stonehenge, only to discover ominous signs suggesting recent human activity. The tranquility is shattered when they stumble upon the gruesome scene of an elderly man's murder—his head crushed by a massive stone. The unsettling discovery hints at dark rituals and ancient superstitions surrounding the site:

Holmes [Timestamp 15:42]: "These stones have witnessed centuries of barbaric sacrifices. But who today dares disturb their ancient rites?"

The Investigation Unfolds

Returning to the inn, they encounter Mary McPherson, a distraught young woman whose father has been murdered. Her fiancé, Dr. James, appears to be the prime suspect due to inconsistencies in his alibi and his questionable behavior, exacerbated by his struggle with alcoholism.

Holmes meticulously examines the evidence, uncovering that Dr. James suffers from a malarial fever contracted in Africa—a fact that undermines his memory and reliability. Through a series of interrogations and logical deductions, Holmes reveals that the true culprit is Ralph, a disturbed individual influenced by Moriarty's machinations, aiming to frame Dr. James to divert suspicion from himself.

Resolution

In a climactic confrontation, Holmes exposes Ralph's deceit, clearing Dr. James's name and unveiling the deeper conspiracy at play. The episode concludes with Holmes reaffirming the importance of keen observation and rational thought in solving even the most perplexing mysteries.

Host Insights and Reflections

Adam Graham provides insightful commentary on this particular episode, noting its historical significance as one of the earliest complete Sherlock Holmes stories adapted for radio. He reflects on Richard Gordon's portrayal of Holmes, which diverges from later interpretations by actors like Basil Rathbone and Orson Welles. Graham observes:

Adam Graham [Timestamp 31:00]: "The portrayal of Holmes here is markedly different—more melodramatic and theatrical, a reflection of the era's acting styles rather than the understated brilliance we associate with the detective today."

Graham also highlights the uniqueness of this episode being a standalone story, whereas other episodes from this period often served as segments within serialized narratives. He appreciates the archival value of the episode, offering listeners a glimpse into early 20th-century radio dramatizations.

Notable Quotes

• Holmes on Vacation Rationale:

  Holmes [08:15]: "Stonehenge in a mist at midnight... The solstice is the perfect time to observe its true essence."

• Holmes on Ancient Sacrifices:

  Holmes [15:42]: "These stones have witnessed centuries of barbaric sacrifices. But who today dares disturb their ancient rites?"

• Host's Commentary on Acting Style:

  Adam Graham [31:00]: "The portrayal of Holmes here is markedly different—more melodramatic and theatrical, a reflection of the era's acting styles rather than the understated brilliance we associate with the detective today."

Listener Feedback and Reviews

Adam Graham shares listener responses, highlighting both appreciation and critiques of the episode:

• Positive Feedback:
  Peter from Australia:

  "I'd like to thank Adam for all his hard work and keeping us entertained. Please keep it up. From Australia."

• Constructive Criticism:
  Polyplane:

  "I'm really enjoying these old-time radio shows. I'm just a bit too young to remember listening to them, but I can see why they were so popular back in the day."

Graham acknowledges the mixed reactions, emphasizing the historical context of the episode's production and performance style. He notes that while modern listeners might find the acting and pacing different from contemporary standards, these elements serve as valuable cultural artifacts.

Conclusion

"Death at Stonehenge" offers a fascinating exploration of Sherlock Holmes's character during a less familiar phase of his radio incarnations. Through Adam Graham's detailed narration and analysis, listeners gain not only an engaging mystery but also an appreciation for the evolution of radio drama and the enduring legacy of Sherlock Holmes in popular culture.

Additional Information

For more episodes and discussions on classic detective stories, follow Adam Graham on Twitter and Facebook. Listener comments and support can be shared via email at box13greatdetives.net.