The NoSleep Podcast: Season 23, Episode 2 – "NoSleep Podcast S23E02"

Release Date: July 13, 2025

Overview

In Season 23, Episode 2 of The NoSleep Podcast, Creative Reason Media Inc. delivers three spine-chilling horror stories that delve into the supernatural and the uncanny. This episode, free from advertisements and introductory segments, immerses listeners in tales of haunted mansions, eerie bake sales, and the lingering spirits within a grieving family's home. Below is a detailed summary of each story, highlighting key moments and notable quotes with proper attribution.

1. The Grey House

Authors: G. Rene Cowles
Performers: Jeff Clement, Matthew Bradford, Graham Rowett
Timestamp: [05:38] – [15:09]

Summary:

Matthew Bradford and Graham Rowett narrate the harrowing experience of two brothers exploring the desolate Grey House, a burned-out mansion perched on the edge of a canyon. Despite warnings and the house's ominous reputation, the brothers, Jay and Matthew, decide to investigate the ruins.

Upon entering, they encounter unsettling signs: pried boards sealing off areas, tracks in the dirt, and a pervasive sense of unease. The interior is a macabre tableau of soot-stained walls and skeletal patterns left by the fire. In the dining room, a chandelier and drapes move inexplicably, hinting at a supernatural presence.

As they delve deeper, the brothers face malevolent shadows and grotesque entities. A particularly terrifying figure resembling a bear with horns and fangs stalks them from the shower stall. The house exerts a sinister pull, drawing them toward a dark pit surrounded by hooded figures chanting, "You are not welcome here."

In a desperate struggle, fear and adrenaline drive them to escape, but Jay is tragically succumbed to the forces within, leading to Matthew's own perilous plight. As Matthew fights to free himself, he witnesses apparitions of the mansion's tormented souls, including the ominous hooded figures who eventually retreat, leaving him traumatized and forever marked by the Grey House's dark legacy.

Notable Quotes:

• Matthew Bradford [05:38]: "He might seem harmless enough, but you'd do best to avoid him. Let him deal with his own suffering in peace."

• Matthew Bradford [09:19]: "He sounded scared at last. The more I resisted, the sicker I felt."

• Jeff Clement [12:51]: "If I go, I take you with me."

• Matthew Bradford [15:09]: "He hadn't cut her hair in the two years she'd been ill. Her birch white face was plain and gentle."

2. The Cupcake Stand

Authors: Theodore Snapdragon
Performers: Waffea White, Mary Murphy
Timestamp: [20:10] – [33:50]

Summary:

Waffea White narrates her unsettling encounter at a seemingly innocent bake sale on a dead-end road. Drawn by the meticulously crafted cupcakes, she approaches the stand run by an old woman whose eerie presence is juxtaposed with the delightful treats she offers.

The old woman, portrayed with a thinly veiled malevolence, entices Waffea to taste one of her free cupcakes. Despite feeling an inexplicable sense of dread, Waffea succumbs to curiosity and takes a bite. The cupcake, initially sweet, reveals a horrifying twist as it resists being swallowed, transforming grotesquely within her mouth.

As Waffea experiences excruciating pain and physical distortion, she realizes the sinister nature of the cupcakes: the old woman is ensnaring souls, turning them into perpetual sweetness. Her transformation completes as she shrinks and loses her corporeal form, becoming part of the cupcake tableau forever.

Notable Quotes:

• Waffea White [25:20]: "How much is this cupcake?"

• Jeff Clement [25:23]: "I just love to see people eating my cupcakes. I love to add a little sweetness to this world."

• Waffea White [25:44]: "Something about how the woman spoke made my skin crawl."

• Jeff Clement [29:28]: "No one else really understands, but I do this for you. It's better this way. The sacrifice is worth it."

3. The Warwick House

Authors: Connor Gunnan
Performers: Mike Delgadio, Matthew Bradford, Graham Rowett, Sarah Thomas
Timestamp: [36:56] – [76:59]

Summary:

Graham Rowett and Sarah Thomas unfold the tragic saga of the Warwick House, a residence steeped in history and haunted by the lingering energies of past souls. The story centers on the Gray family grappling with the death of Helen Gray, with each member processing grief differently.

Caleb Gray, a blind six-year-old, senses the malevolent presence within the house as he searches for his mother's violin bow for her casket. His journey is fraught with eerie manifestations, including spectral figures and ominous sounds that suggest the house itself is alive with restless spirits.

Alan Gray, the father, and Emma, his 15-year-old daughter, argue over the proper way to honor Helen's memory. Their conflict underscores differing coping mechanisms: Alan's practicality versus Emma's emotional turmoil. As the night progresses, the supernatural activity intensifies, culminating in apparitions interacting with Caleb and revealing the house's tormented past.

In a climactic reunion, Helen's spirit leads the accumulated souls of the Warwick House in a farewell, allowing the family to find solace. The episode highlights themes of grief, acceptance, and the enduring connection between the living and the departed.

Notable Quotes:

• Sarah Thomas [40:42]: "You still haven't decided?"

• Mike Delgadio [51:23]: "Dad, I think I'm mad, too."

• Sarah Thomas [50:29]: "I guess there's a funny thing about grief for adults."

• David Cummings [84:14]: "Our tales may be over, but they are still out there. Be sure to join us next week so you can stay safe, stay secure, and stay sleepless."

Conclusion

Season 23, Episode 2 of The NoSleep Podcast masterfully intertwines atmospheric storytelling with haunting narratives that linger long after the episode concludes. From haunted mansions and soul-consuming cupcakes to the profound depths of familial grief, each story invites listeners to confront their fears and the unknown. As always, The NoSleep Podcast delivers its signature blend of suspense, emotion, and supernatural horror, cementing its place as a premier source of auditory terror.

Note: This summary omits advertisements, intros, outros, and non-content sections as per the request, focusing solely on the core narratives presented in the episode.