What makes a monster? In this spine-tingling episode, Josh and Sarah welcome back fellow podcasters Sean and Carrie from the hit show Ain't it Scary with Sean and Carrie to explore one of the internet's most notorious creations: Slender Man.

From creepypasta legend to real-world tragedy, discover how this faceless, tentacled entity became modern folklore and what it reveals about our relationship with monsters. Four podcasters who love things that go bump in the night dive deep into digital horror, viral legends, and—because it's The Thing About Witch Hunts—somehow end up discussing the Salem witch trials.

Whether you run toward mysterious figures in the woods or away from them, this episode will make you question why we create monsters and what happens when fictional nightmares bleed into reality.

Episode Highlights🎃 What is Slender Man? - The origins of the internet's most infamous boogeyman

👻 Creepypasta to Crisis - How digital folklore goes viral in the modern age

🕯️ Monster Theory - Why do we need monsters? Why do we treat humans as monsters?

🔮 Salem Connections - The unexpected link between witch hunts and modern monster-making

🎙️ Skeptic Meets Spooky - Sean and Carrie return with their signature perspectives on the paranormal

About Our Returning GuestsSean & Carrie host Ain't it Scary with Sean and Carrie, where a skeptic and a believer explore the unknown, unsolved, unbelievable, and just plain weird. With their passion for history and uncovering truth, they bring complementary perspectives to every mystery they tackle.

KeywordsSlender Man, creepypasta, digital folklore, internet legends, monsters, witch hunts, Salem witch trials, paranormal podcast, horror podcast, Ain't it Scary, folklore, urban legends, monster theory, viral horror, true crime

Listen & SubscribeDon't wander off the path—subscribe to The Thing About Witch Hunts and join us every episode as we explore the monsters, myths, and witch hunts throughout history.

Also check out: Ain't it Scary with Sean and Carrie wherever you listen to podcasts!

Keep the porch light on. 🎃

Links

Ain't It Scary With Sean and Carrie Podcast

Sign the Petition: MA Witch Hunt Justice Project

Join One of Our Projects

The Thing About Salem Podcast

Ain't Slender Man Scary? with Sean and Carrie