The Toast – Episode: "I Love Your Family, Brooks"
Hosts: Jackie & Claudia Oshry
Date: September 18, 2025
Episode Overview
On this Thursday episode, Jackie and Claudia bring their signature blend of sisterly banter, pop culture dissection, and lifestyle commentary to the week’s hottest stories. The duo dive into personal life updates, internet drama, late-night television upheaval, iconic celebrity moments, the world of credit card perks, and major developments in reality TV—all with their trademark dry wit and swirlitude.
Highlights and Key Discussion Points
1. Twin Vibes & Swirly Start to the Day (00:05–03:01)
- The sisters reveal (with mock scandal) that they're once again wearing matching gray sweatsuits—Jackie's from Loft, Claudia's from (not-French) Roller Rabbit.
- Jackie’s sweatsuit is less expensive, but both are sponsor gifts—normalizing relatable influencer perks.
- Banter about gratitude, "gray Thursday" moods, and finding small joys.
“We keep doing this. I like to think of it because like we're like-minded swirlies...But sure, make it nasty now get nasty. That if you're twins like such cuties.” – Jackie (00:38)
2. Personal Life Updates: Bread & Anniversaries (03:02–06:33)
- Claudia updates on her husband Ben’s sourdough journey—he’s baked only two loaves, prompting demands for daily bread.
- Jackie pushes for daily baking: “Practice makes perfect.”
- Claudia recaps her “fabulous” anniversary dinner at New York’s Polo Bar—no celeb sightings, but plenty of “toaster” recognition.
“Maybe you were the celebrity everyone was looking at.” – Jackie (05:29)
- Nostalgia about Claudia’s wedding, bridesmaid dresses (Vera Wang for David's Bridal), and Jackie’s “Bob era.”
3. Pop Culture Talks: Summer I Turned Pretty & Cowboys Doc (06:34–09:50)
- Claudia hasn't watched the "Summer I Turned Pretty" finale; Jackie teases news related to the format, not spoilers.
- Jackie and her husband are mid-way through Netflix’s “America’s Team” (Dallas Cowboys doc), learning why the Cowboys own that brand.
- Claudia shares a wild tidbit from the Charlie Sheen doc: Dr. Paul Nassif saved Charlie with a 911 call (“All roads lead back to Bravo!”).
4. Health Realness & Bizarre Compliments (09:51–12:35)
- Jackie recounts an awkward doctor’s visit: “I got a fistful of doctor. I had a pelvic examination, like, literally up to his elbow in my—”
- Relatable women’s health frustrations.
- At a coffee shop, Jackie gets told: “You look like one of those new dolls. Like a Labubu. You look like a Labubu, but pregnant.” Claudia concludes, “This person is autistic...I do think it's a compliment.” (11:07)
- Banter on if being compared to a “doll” is kind.
5. Dancing With the Stars Votes & Pop Culture References (12:36–15:23)
- Heated confusion over DWTS voting systems—ten votes per couple, which they call “preposterous” and possibly a money grab.
- “Wow, you really are disgusting!” Family quotes, 2000s movies, and tracking reference accountability (from "Matilda" to "White Chicks").
MAIN STORY DEEP DIVES
6. The Shakeup in Late Night: Jimmy Kimmel Cancelled (20:41–34:29)
Timestamp: 20:41–34:29
Context:
- Jimmy Kimmel Live has been pulled off ABC (syndicate Nextar first, then Disney entirely) after comments regarding Charlie Kirk’s murder and spreading misinformation about the shooter’s motives.
The Toast Take:
- Jackie and Claudia analyze free speech, tone, and business realities, highlighting audience alienation and misinformation.
- Claudia: “You did a bad job at your job last week, and so you got [fired]...when you’re not able to be played on a lot of television...you have no show.” (26:52)
- Both agree on the outdatedness of the late-night format: “It’s just sort of this like really old, outdated format...becoming a dead format.” – Claudia (30:48)
- Speculate if the cancellation is political or just business. Jackie insists: “I think they’ve just had enough now.”
Memorable Moment:
“Outside of this issue...his show should be canceled. He’s not funny. Nobody watches it.” – Claudia (26:49)
The Future of Late Night:
- Discussion if a podcaster or new media figure will fill the void.
“It’s not the future. Yeah, those are my thoughts.” – Claudia (34:29)
Impact on “Love Thy Nader” (Jimmy Kimmel is an EP on the sisters’ show):
- Jackie: “Whether or not he gets fired as executive producer...the show will be the show...They need to leave him on the side of the road.” (38:13)
- Claudia: “Now is not the time for loyalty, Brooks.” (38:40)
7. Brooks Nader on ‘Watch What Happens Live’ (34:36–38:25)
- Brooks addresses rumors about dating tennis pros Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner: “A lady never kisses and tells, especially twice. That’s just not nice.”
- Andy Cohen and Mark Ronson give her a standing ovation—“Andy doesn’t get up for anyone!” They gush over Brooks’ charisma and energy.
“First of all, the standing ovation. I didn’t know Andy could get up...he doesn’t get up for anyone.” – Claudia (35:54)
8. Finance News: Hailey Bieber x Chase Sapphire Card (38:50–45:54)
- Hailey Bieber’s ad for Chase Sapphire Reserve sparks a deep dive into influencer banking.
- Jackie tells her “wrong card” saga (Preferred vs. Reserve; Platinum vs. Gold Amex), with Claudia playing credit card advisor.
“Platinum sounds better than gold.” – Jackie (41:18) “You're always getting the wrong card.” – Claudia (41:08)
- Tangent about credit card perks, why brands are after Hailey, and the odd creative of the campaign.
9. Taylor Swift to Appear on Graham Norton (52:03–56:05)
- Taylor to make rare TV appearance for “Life of a Showgirl” album release—on UK’s Graham Norton show.
- Panel includes Cillian Murphy, Greta Lee, Jodie Turner Smith, Domhnall Gleeson.
- The hosts find it an odd choice: “Why Graham?” “She's always got a reason for everything.” (55:59)
- Speculate about her rollout strategy and reflect on her quiet album promo.
10. Summer House NYC Spin-Off Announcement (56:19–64:09)
- Bravo teases a Summer House spin-off, “In The City,” about cast members’ NYC lives as they age out of Hamptons-partying.
- Hosts see this as an “exit strategy” for older stars like Lindsay.
- “I need Lindsay Hubbard on tv, and I don’t think Summer House is right for her anymore.” – Claudia (57:10)
- Discussion about cast, show title, lackluster announcement, and Bravo’s struggles with NY-based ensemble shows.
“This announcement is very womp, womp, womp.” – Jackie (59:48) “They should’ve had more to announce, more to show us, to get us excited.” – Jackie (60:49)
- Extended regrets over Bravo not returning to the “legacy” Real Housewives of New York cast.
11. Iconic Throwback: The Bratz Movie Deep Dive (65:05–68:29)
- Jackie and Claudia descend into a Bratz movie rabbit hole, reciting cast facts and marveling at director Sean McNamara’s career—from “Raise Your Voice” to “Soul Surfer” and beyond.
- Plans for their own future documentary: “The Turny Lou life story must be directed by Sean McNamara.” (67:46)
Notable Quotes
- “Maybe you were the celebrity everyone was looking at.” – Jackie (05:29)
- “This person is autistic...I do think it's a compliment.” – Claudia (11:07)
- “You did a bad job at your job...and you get fired for doing a bad job.” – Jackie (25:29)
- “Now is not the time for loyalty, Brooks.” – Claudia (38:40)
- “You're always getting the wrong card.” – Claudia (41:08)
- “This announcement is very womp, womp, womp.” – Jackie (59:48)
Timestamps for Key Segments
- Twin Outfit Banter / Opening: 00:05–01:30
- Bread & Anniversaries: 03:01–06:33
- Wedding Nostalgia: 06:04–07:42
- Pop Culture Roundup (Cowboys, Charlie Sheen, DWTS, Labubu): 07:53–12:35
- DWTS Voting System Rant: 13:07–15:23
- Jimmy Kimmel Cancellation / Late Night Future: 20:41–34:29
- Brooks Nader/Andy Cohen Segment: 34:36–38:25
- Hailey Bieber x Chase Sapphire / Credit Card Chat: 38:50–45:54
- Taylor Swift on Graham Norton: 52:03–56:05
- Summer House NYC Spin-Off: 56:19–64:09
- Bratz Movie / Sean McNamara Deep Dive: 65:05–68:29
Tone & Language
The episode is brisk, witty, irreverent, and deeply conversational, with the sisters oscillating between pop culture dishing, personal anecdotes, and sharp media commentary. Their inside jokes, pop references, and mid-2000s nostalgia run throughout, maintaining a laid-back yet plugged-in podcasting style. They also model clear boundaries for sponsor conversations, always looping back to listener value and inside jokes.
For Listeners Who Missed the Episode
This episode is a swirly ride through major headlines, influencer life mishaps, and late-night TV politics—layered with Jackie and Claudia’s unmistakable humor, candor, and pop culture savviness. You’ll leave with hot takes on everything from celebrity credit cards to Bravo’s ever-evolving cast wars and even a surprisingly moving tribute to secondary-market cashmere. And above all, “nothing is forever—except swirlitude."