The Toast Podcast: "The Super Bowl Sequel" (February 10, 2026)

Hosts: Jackie & Claudia ("Turdy") Oshry
Theme: Super Bowl Recap & Pop Culture Deep Dive

Episode Overview

This post-Super Bowl episode delivers a lively, witty, and highly relatable breakdown of everything buzzing from the big game to Olympics drama, celebrity sightings, and trending pop culture. Jackie and Claudia (Turdy) blend signature banter with pointed commentary on the game, ads, pop music, and viral stories, creating a fun, conversational recap that feels like catching up with friends.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Super Bowl 2026 Recap: Turdy’s Version

[15:00–18:30, 21:13–22:08]

• General Vibe: Both found this year’s Super Bowl lackluster and underwhelming compared to past years—less overall excitement in the game, halftime, and celeb sightings.

  • "People are already moved on where I think in years past, we've been talking about it for days and days and days." (Turdy, 15:33)
  • "It wasn't the most entertaining by any stretch of the imagination." (Turdy, 01:28)

• Game & Celebrities:

  • Seahawks’ strong defense led to less on-field excitement.
  • Noted an odd lack of compelling celebrity intrigue, with even Kim Kardashian's appearance met with apathy: "I know Kim was there with her man and, like, no one cares." (Turdy, 15:51)

Halftime Show (Bad Bunny & Guests)

[16:09–21:14]

• Bad Bunny’s Performance:

  • Turdy didn’t recognize songs or words but appreciated the "colorful," "positive," "joyful" Latin celebration.
  • "It was just like, celebrating family and love... and I do think that's very, you know, the Latin culture celebrates." (Turdy, 16:37)

• Guest Appearances:

  • Surprise at Alex Earl being featured ("I was shook"), and speculation about whether it truly fit the Miami/Latin theme.
  • Lady Gaga’s performance led to debate:
    • "It should have been a mashup. But it was a mess up." (Turdy, 19:25)
    • Both agree Gaga was amazing but the musical transition was awkward and misdirected.
  • Ricky Martin was a pleasant but not obvious choice; they enjoyed seeing special guests.

• Halftime Trend: Hosts declare readiness for a return of “pop girlies” or a big country crossover in future Super Bowls.

National Anthem & Pregame

[22:08–24:14]

• Claudia admits she "was wrong" about Charlie Puth, who delivered a respectful, moving national anthem:
  • "He had all the elements of it. He also played an instrument live... it was a great night for Charlie Puth." (Turdy, 23:42)
• Coco Jones impressed with her vocals though appeared "really nervous" (Jackie, 24:14).
• Comments on unique elements, such as a Green Day concert before kickoff.

Commercials & Pepsi Zero Sugar

[25:04–30:14]

• The women felt most commercials didn’t stand out—less focus on “making people be quiet” for ad breaks than in years past.
• Rave review for Pepsi Zero Sugar’s commercial and the “Pepsi paradox.”
  • Discussion of breaking free from brand labels: "Don't let the label decide. Let your taste decide." (Turdy, 30:00)
  • Jokes about being "vindicated" for being Pepsi fans before it was cool.
  • The theme thread: admitting when you’re wrong is empowering, as echoed in both the ad and episode.

2. Pop Culture & Olympics Highlights

Olympics & Figure Skating
[06:08–09:47, 33:26–37:28]

• Both express love for the Olympics, especially Winter events and U.S. figure skaters (shoutouts to Ilia Malinin ["The Quad God"] and the Bates/Gates ice dance couple).
  • "Ilia is like doing men's ice dancing... and it's kind of crazy looking." (Turdy, 07:51)
• They lampoon the mystery of figure skating commentary personalities (Johnny Weir & Tara Lipinski): "Their friendship is so real!" (Turdy, 09:15)
• Ongoing inside joke about “Colton Files” on Peacock—a plea for more reality TV drama access.

Utah Liardom’s Gold Medal
[33:26–37:28]

• Jake Paul’s fiancée wins speed skating gold and breaks an Olympic record; both shower praise on her sacrifice and national pride.
  • “She’s a Michael Phelps of her generation... the pride of her country.” (Turdy, 35:22)
  • Discussion about her influencer content and being beloved in the Netherlands.
• They reflect on the emotional journey, support for her move to Puerto Rico, and hope for future Paul American documentaries.

3. Fast Five Stories

(Selected pop culture headlines with signature commentary)

The Bachelorette Promo: Taylor Frankie Paul

[37:30–43:37]

• New season showcases Taylor’s personal, less-glam side; promo is critiqued as “low budget."
• Discussion morphs into Mormon representation in pop culture, sparked by a New York Magazine cover featuring "7 Mormon women."
  • Reflection on the rise of Mormon influencers, Salt Lake reality TV, and how seeking "perfection... makes for good TV." (Turdy, 43:26)
  • Comments on church discomfort with “imperfect” portrayals but agree it’s a “net positive” for perception.

Beckham Family Drama/Marc Anthony’s Statement

[44:25–46:13]

• Marc Anthony’s non-statement on the Beckham family feud sparks jokes about reading between the lines—“He said a whole bunch of nothing. But then a little at the end.” (Turdy, 44:55)
• Dive into mother-son dynamic at weddings—defending Victoria Beckham, relying on relatable “boy mama” TikToks.

Kardashians & Lewis Hamilton Rumors

[48:11–51:35]

• Kylie, Kim, and Khloe do the “Titanic Challenge”—speculation about men’s laughter heard (Lewis Hamilton? Timothée Chalamet? Not Rob Kardashian).
  • "Men should never laugh." (Turdy, 49:46)
• Lukewarm response to Kim dating Lewis Hamilton: "It's so not doing it for me." (Turdy, 50:22)
• Discussion pivots to personal Kardashian “ranking” and fans’ changing favorites.

4. Dear Toasters (Advice Segment)

[53:43–65:34]

Advice Q1: Excluded from family group chat

• Both agree it's likely a seniority thing, not personal. “Let the chats fall where they may.” (Turdy, 58:30)

Quote:
"There are definitely things you should be mad at him for... this is really not one of them." (Turdy, 57:54)

Advice Q2: Postpartum rage vs. justified anger (husband lied about vaping)

• Jackie: “It's not about the vape...” Empathy for hormonal changes and betrayal after childbirth.
• Turdy: Sides with wife, jokes: "Perhaps he's gay. Like, you can't stop sucking on the vape?"

Advice Q3: Husband wants to quit job with no plan

• They say: Don’t risk home stability for freelance dreams without a clear, developed plan.
• Jackie: “You never like quit your full-time job until your side hustle eclipses [it]." (63:17)
• Turdy: “As a man quitting a job and going out on your own is such a big thing... more precautions need to be put into place.” (65:21)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the Super Bowl's Buzz:
  "People are already moved on where I think in years past we've been talking about it for days and days and days." — Turdy [15:33]

• On the Halftime Show:
  "It should have been a mashup. But it was a mess up." — Turdy [19:25]
  "If you want me to like something, put a gospel choir in there. Like, I will be shaking my titties like, take me to church, mama." — Turdy [23:38]

• On Brand Loyalty & Growth:
  "Don't let the label decide. Let your taste decide." — Turdy [30:00]

• On Kardashians:
  "Men should never laugh." — Turdy [49:46]
  "It's so not doing it for me." (on Kim & Lewis Hamilton) — Turdy [50:22]

• On Relationship Advice:
  "Let the chats fall where they may." — Turdy [58:30]
  "My toxic traditionalist comes out in Dear Toasters. I'm like, sorry, this man is a provider. That's literally his job." — Turdy [62:47]

• On Olympics & Social Media:
  "She is this enormous... I didn't realize. And they had this, like, whole party for her. Did you see her, like, going on stage at this, like, Dutch party? Like, it's been such a fabulous saga of events." — Turdy [35:22]

Section Timestamps (HH:MM)

• 00:24 – Show open, catching up, episode plan
• 01:48 – Patriarchy & Women’s Health banter
• 06:08 – Olympics and sports highlights
• 15:00 – Super Bowl (game, celebs, halftime debrief)
• 21:13 – Halftime guest critique, Lady Gaga
• 22:08 – Anthems, Charlie Puth, commercials
• 33:26 – Olympics pop culture (Utah Liardom’s gold)
• 37:30 – Bachelorette promo, Mormon pop culture
• 44:25 – Beckham family drama/Marc Anthony
• 48:11 – Kardashians, Lewis Hamilton rumors
• 53:43 – Dear Toasters: advice segment

Tone & Style

The episode is candid, quick-witted, full of pop references, and self-deprecating. The sisters’ conversational rhythm keeps even cultural critiques playful and relatable, mixing deep-dives with tongue-in-cheek commentary: “Me too. Did I say that?” / “Roll the tape!” / “We need to stop pitting man against woman.”

Summary Takeaway

For those wanting a punchy but detailed dissection of Super Bowl 2026’s pop culture reverberations, this episode of The Toast nails it. From lackluster football to refreshing perspectives on feminist history, Olympic celebrations, and ever-scorching hot takes on celebrity romance and branding, Jackie and Claudia Oshry ensure listeners are part of the inside joke—whether on Super Bowl Monday or any old Tuesday.

End of Summary