Podcast Summary: The Toast Files with Natalie Joy Viall Hosted by Jackie & Claudia Oshry | Released: June 24, 2025
Introduction and Guest Welcome
The episode kicks off with hosts Jackie and Claudia warmly welcoming Natalie Joy Viall as the first-time guest co-host.
Jackie [00:05]: "Happy Tuesday. I am in studio today with a first time Toast guest or co-host. It is Natalie Joy Viall. Welcome to the Toast."
Natalie expresses her excitement to join the show, highlighting her extensive podcasting and TV-watching habits.
Natalie [00:38]: "Hello. Thank you for having me. So excited."
Building Connections and Industry Insights
The hosts delve into their relationship with Natalie and mutual connections, particularly focusing on Nick Rile, a longtime friend of The Toast.
Jackie [01:43]: "I started following you after your wedding. I thought you're at. Your wedding was so beautiful."
Natalie reminisces about meeting Claudia at an event and their subsequent interactions on social media.
Natalie [01:14]: "I feel like I met Claudia once at the Gypsy Rose event right in New York. And I think I was very largely pregnant."
Navigating Public Perceptions and Media Interactions
Discussions reveal past interactions with Nick Rile, including moments of public misunderstanding and the evolution of their friendship.
Jackie [02:04]: "When we started our show, that was when he was like in his villain era."
Natalie shares a humorous anecdote about Claudia's appearance on Nick's podcast, highlighting Claudia's sarcastic remarks during the COVID period.
Natalie [03:14]: "Claudia was clowning on your man?"
Jackie [03:34]: "I don't know any of this... This is news to me."
Reality TV Recaps and Personal Insights
A significant portion of the episode centers around reality TV shows, particularly "Love Island" and "The Bachelor." The hosts and Natalie discuss recent episodes, character developments, and personal opinions on the show's dynamics.
Jackie [09:52]: "But how do you, like, structure your life so that you can watch all this television and also, like, just be a present human being in the world and a mother."
Natalie outlines her and Nick's podcasting schedule, emphasizing their focus on reality TV recaps and deeper analyses.
Natalie [04:19]: "Yeah, check out that... Monday, Wednesday, Friday... They have their own segments like Ask Nick and reality recaps."
Influencer Culture and Authenticity
The conversation shifts to the influencer landscape, with both hosts critiquing the shift from relatable content to high-end, often unaffordable endorsements.
Natalie [34:04]: "The ones that I'm losing interest... they're making links to designer brands and it's like, well, you've lost me."
Jackie [35:18]: "Which is why influencers who never claim to be relatable kind of crush it, really."
They discuss the challenges influencers face in maintaining authenticity as their follower base grows and their content shifts towards more exclusive brands.
Personal Relationships and Podcast Dynamics
Jackie and Natalie explore the dynamics of running a podcast together while maintaining a healthy personal relationship. They commend each other's ability to balance the "good cop, bad cop" roles during interviews.
Jackie [45:14]: "But it's so like, you guys are. You were made for it and you, like, really balance out like, his shtick with like, just a female perspective."
Natalie shares experiences from hosting intense interviews, such as with Sherry Papini, and how she naturally gravitates towards the empathetic role.
Natalie [45:24]: "I can't. Like always good cop. And I think it does work for us."
Fast 5 Stories Segment
The "Fast 5 Stories" segment covers a range of topics from celebrity news to pop culture updates. Notable discussions include:
-
Taylor and Travis' Summer Activities
- Jackie [23:10]: "They are actually in Nashville right now for George Kittle's tight end university training camp kickoff."
- The hosts speculate on Taylor's motivations and support for Travis during NFL events.
-
Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders' Salary Increase
- Natalie [30:05]: "The Dallas Cowboys cheerleaders are breaking down their 400% salary increase."
- Discussion on the impact of increased pay and the significance of their Netflix show in elevating their status.
-
Love Island Recap and Critique
- Jackie [65:55]: "Last night, Casa More kicked off early in the episode."
- The hosts express frustration with recent developments and the direction of the show, criticizing the lack of genuine connections and the increase in sexual content.
-
Ryan Murphy's New Show "American Love Story"
- Natalie [56:37]: "Her hair colorist... breaking down what Ryan Murphy got wrong in the show."
- Critique of the casting and styling choices in the new series, highlighting discrepancies between real-life personalities and their on-screen representations.
-
Influencer Collaborations and Fashion News
- Jackie [50:07]: "Kim Kardashian is announcing her collaboration between Roberto Cavalli and Skims Swim."
- Analysis of celebrity partnerships and their impact on fashion trends, with personal opinions on the practicality and appeal of such collaborations.
Relationship Anecdotes and Personal Stories
Throughout the episode, Jackie and Natalie share personal stories about their relationships, including challenges faced and milestones achieved.
Natalie [41:43]: "Nick was like, I really want to date you. And he was like, no, it's not going to happen."
Jackie recounts her experiences supporting her partner through personal and professional endeavors, highlighting the balance between personal life and media engagement.
Jackie [40:57]: "I booked a ticket immediately. And then I was like, oh, I'm, like, seeing some friends."
Influencer and Social Media Dynamics
Discussion touches on the evolution of influencers' authenticity and the shift towards high-end brand endorsements, leading to a disconnect with original followers.
Natalie [34:04]: "They don't give you the jute. No, they were like strictly shopping Amazon and then they made so much money that now they're like, like only wear designer and now they only post and link their designer and it's like, well, you've lost me."
Closing Remarks
The episode concludes with the hosts expressing gratitude towards Natalie for her participation and encouraging listeners to follow her and her various podcasts.
Jackie [93:14]: "You're more patient than I am."
Natalie [93:23]: "We are on the vows. Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and Natalie Joy. Two ends, two Js."
Jackie wraps up by thanking listeners and teasing future episodes.
Jackie [93:28]: "Thank you all for listening. We'll be back tomorrow with another party episode."
Notable Quotes
-
Natalie [33:22]: "I think they're America’s team. Like, they're the richest team in the league. Like, I'm like, then why can't they play better?"
-
Jackie [71:44]: "If I call one of them Zach, I'll probably... That's so funny."
-
Natalie [55:37]: "I do feel like we should normalize the bush. That's my personal opinion."
Conclusion
This episode of The Toast offers a blend of reality TV critique, personal anecdotes, and discussions on influencer culture, all enriched by Natalie Joy Viall's insights and experiences. The hosts maintain a conversational tone, interspersed with humor and candid reflections, making it engaging for both regular listeners and newcomers interested in entertainment and media analysis.