Toast Herstory: Chopping the Tarts – A Detailed Summary

Released on August 14, 2025, "Toast Herstory: Chopping the Tarts" is an episode of The Toast podcast hosted by Claudia Oshry and Jackie Oshry. This episode delves into a mix of celebrity news, personal anecdotes, and listener advice, all delivered with the hosts' signature humor and candidness.

Introduction

The episode kicks off with the hosts exchanging playful banter about their outfits and the challenges of dressing up consistently. Claudia opens at [00:01], welcoming listeners warmly and humorously addressing their repeated appearances despite Jackie's recent childbirth. Jackie responds at [00:18], expressing her excitement and slight overwhelm about upcoming events, mentioning performances at Madison Square Garden and Chelsea Music Hall.

Notable Quote:

• Claudia at [00:01]: "Don't forget to hump someone you love."
• Jackie at [00:24]: "I'm running on adrenaline."

Fast 5 Stories

The Fast 5 segment covers five major news stories, each discussed with the hosts' unique perspectives and engaging commentary.

1. Dave Chappelle Attacked at Hollywood Bowl ([10:43] - [16:43]):

   • Summary: Claudia and Jackie discuss the shocking incident where comedian Dave Chappelle was physically assaulted on stage by an audience member wielding a knife and a replica handgun. They express concern over the security lapse at such a high-profile event and the broader implications for performer safety.
   • Notable Quotes:
     • Claudia at [11:32]: "I really feel bad for Dave Chappelle."
     • Jackie at [15:00]: "You don't get to charge someone with a knife and then say that the reaction is too big afterwards."

2. Lili Reinhart Criticizes Kim Kardashian Over Met Gala Diet ([18:03] - [23:52]):

   • Summary: The hosts delve into the controversy sparked by Lili Reinhart's criticism of Kim Kardashian's drastic weight loss for the Met Gala. They explore themes of body image, celebrity influence, and the double standards in public backlash against different celebrities.
   • Notable Quotes:
     • Claudia at [18:11]: "It's disgusting for celebrities to admit to starving themselves."
     • Jackie at [20:34]: "I took no issue with her sharing because by the way, what she did is..."

3. Post Malone Expecting First Child ([23:52] - [26:03]):

   • Summary: Claudia shares the exciting news that Post Malone is expecting his first child with his longtime girlfriend. The hosts express their surprise and joy, highlighting the traditional and heartfelt nature of his announcement.
   • Notable Quotes:
     • Jackie at [24:06]: "I'm excited for this next chapter in my life."
     • Claudia at [25:10]: "I love to see posts."

4. Intruder Disguised as a Priest at Windsor Castle ([27:52] - [33:10]):

   • Summary: The duo discusses a bizarre incident where an intruder posed as a priest and spent the night at Queen Elizabeth’s Windsor Castle. They critique the security measures and express disdain for the perpetrator’s deceitful actions.
   • Notable Quotes:
     • Claudia at [27:52]: "It was so abhorrent to intrude into a personal person's home."
     • Jackie at [29:15]: "Don't you think we all feel that way, right?"

5. Aaron Judge’s Heartwarming Moment with a Fan ([37:50] - [39:50]):

   • Summary: Ending on a positive note, Claudia and Jackie recount a sweet TikTok video where New York Yankees’ Aaron Judge gives a homered ball to a young fan, leading to an emotional moment shared between the boy and his father. They celebrate the unifying and heartwarming aspects of sports.
   • Notable Quotes:
     • Claudia at [38:10]: "It will bring a tear to your eye."
     • Jackie at [39:18]: "What could be better?"

TV Recap: Real Housewives of New Jersey ([40:05] - [44:52])

The hosts pivot to a recap of the latest "Real Housewives of New Jersey" reunion. They dissect the intense drama on the "left couch," focusing on the strained relationships and shifting dynamics among cast members. Claudia expresses disappointment over Jackie Goldschneider’s perceived demotion, believing it hinders the progress made in addressing toxic behaviors within the group.

Notable Quotes:

• Claudia at [40:36]: "The left couch is crumbling."
• Jackie at [41:17]: "Well, anything can happen. They haven't started filming."

Dear Toasters: Listener Advice Segment ([44:52] - [54:28])

In the Dear Toasters segment, Claudia and Jackie respond to listener emails seeking advice on personal matters.

1. Mother-in-Law’s Inappropriate Kissing ([46:11] - [47:35]):

   • Summary: A listener seeks guidance on addressing her mother-in-law’s habit of kissing her 8-month-old baby on the mouth, which she finds gross and inappropriate. The hosts advise setting clear boundaries and addressing the issue directly rather than waiting for her husband to intervene.
   • Notable Advice:
     • Jackie at [47:05]: "If you see it and it doesn't sit right with you, say please don't do that."
     • Claudia at [47:24]: "Do it when you see it. Don't let it fester."

2. Brother’s Girlfriend’s Explicit Instagram Photo ([48:44] - [51:32]):

   • Summary: Another listener is concerned about her younger brother’s new girlfriend who has shared an explicit photo on Instagram. Initially alarmed, upon viewing the photo, the hosts find it tasteful and advise not to interfere as it doesn’t appear harmful.
   • Notable Advice:
     • Jackie at [51:08]: "If you say anything, you're just gonna drive a wedge."
     • Claudia at [51:19]: "It's awkward. Take it off the Internet."

3. Booger Flicking Habit in a Relationship ([52:43] - [54:28]):

   • Summary: A listener updates on her previous query about her boyfriend’s habit of leaving boogers around the house. With the hosts’ advice to place more tissue boxes, she successfully mitigates the issue.
   • Notable Advice:
     • Claudia at [54:06]: "Keep tissues around the house so they're readily available."
     • Jackie at [54:18]: "Get him a box of tissues on his side of the bed."

Conclusion

The episode wraps up with celebratory remarks as Jackie prepares for her performances at Madison Square Garden and Chelsea Music Hall. Claudia and Jackie express pride and excitement for Jackie's upcoming shows, ending the episode on an uplifting note.

Notable Quotes:

• Claudia at [54:51]: "I love you."
• Jackie at [55:11]: "We’re so excited. You’re going to be amazing."

Key Takeaways

• Celebrity Security Concerns: The episode underscores the vulnerabilities even top-tier performers face, illustrated by the Dave Chappelle incident.

• Body Image and Celebrity Influence: Through the Lili Reinhart-Kim Kardashian controversy, the hosts explore the impact of celebrity actions on public perceptions of body image.

• Heartwarming Sports Moments: Aaron Judge’s gesture exemplifies the positive side of sports in uniting and uplifting individuals.

• Personal Boundaries and Communication: The Dear Toasters segment emphasizes the importance of setting clear boundaries and addressing issues directly in personal relationships.

Overall Impressions

"Toast Herstory: Chopping the Tarts" offers a balanced mix of serious discussions and light-hearted banter. Claudia and Jackie Oshry navigate through current events and personal stories with humor and empathy, making the episode both entertaining and insightful for listeners.

Notable Moments to Revisit:

• Claudia's heartfelt reactions and Jackie's humorous interjections provide a dynamic interplay throughout the episode.
• The resolution of listener advice showcases the hosts' practical and caring approach.

For those who haven't listened yet, this episode is a testament to the hosts' ability to blend pop culture commentary with genuine personal connection, making "The Toast" a must-listen for fans of engaging and relatable podcast content.