Podcast Title: This Guy Sucked
Host: Dr. Claire Aubin
Episode: Welcome to This Guy Sucked
Release Date: March 9, 2025

Introduction to the Podcast

In the inaugural episode of This Guy Sucked, host Dr. Claire Aubin sets the stage for what promises to be a candid and critical exploration of historical figures. The podcast, aptly described as a "history podcast for haters, by haters," aims to peel back the often glorified layers of history to reveal the flaws and misdeeds of those who have shaped our past.

Dr. Claire Aubin introduces herself as a "certified hater," emphasizing her commitment to scrutinizing and challenging the legacies of historical personalities. She underscores the podcast’s mission: to provide a platform where historians can openly critique and dissect the lives and impacts of both well-known and obscure figures from history.

The Essence of Critique in History

Dr. Aubin opens the discussion with thought-provoking questions aimed at re-evaluating renowned historical figures. She asks, “Have you ever caught yourself wondering whether Charlemagne was really all that great?” (00:01), immediately setting a tone of skepticism towards traditionally revered individuals.

Key Discussion Points:

1. Historical Bias and Perspective:

   • Dr. Aubin highlights how even influential figures like Charlemagne had court historians who may have biasedly portrayed events to favor their patron.
   • A guest scholar elaborates on the commercialization of historical narratives, using the example of Samuel Cummings: “Because you could sell 10,000 to Costa Rica, but that same year, you could sell 250,000 to the United States, to Americans” (00:13). This underscores how economic interests can shape historical accounts.

2. Prejudices of Enlightened Thinkers:

   • The podcast delves into the contradictions inherent in celebrated intellectuals, such as Voltaire. Dr. Aubin provocatively states, “Or how much Voltaire hated poor people” (00:20), challenging the notion that enlightenment equates to the absence of prejudice.
   • A guest scholar counters this by asserting, “If one is indeed enlightened, one couldn't possibly hold any prejudices” (00:22), sparking a debate on the true nature of enlightenment and inherent biases.

3. The Role of Historians:

   • Dr. Aubin emphasizes the challenging nature of being a historian, “That's the job of being a historian sometimes is banging your head against the wall” (01:03). This metaphor reflects the frustration and persistence required to uncover and critique uncomfortable truths about historical figures.

Spotlight on Jerry Lee Lewis

A significant portion of the episode focuses on Jerry Lee Lewis, marking him as the first subject of critique. The guest scholar expresses strong disdain: “Well, today we're talking about Jerry Lee Lewis. I f. Cking hate this guy” (00:41), setting a no-holds-barred tone for the discussions to follow.

Notable Insights:

• Impact on Culture and Legacy:

  • The scholar discusses Lewis's influence on American music and why, despite his popularity, his legacy is marred by personal controversies and reprehensible actions.

• Educational Implications:

  • The episode touches on the academic challenges of teaching about flawed historical figures. The guest scholar remarks, “Usually after I'm done talking about Jerry Lee Lewis in my classes, it's just quiet. The students are like, are you okay?” (01:09), highlighting the discomfort that arises when delving into the darker aspects of beloved personalities.

Structure and Accessibility

This Guy Sucked promises a fresh and engaging format by featuring a rotating cast of scholars each week, allowing diverse perspectives on various historical figures. Each episode aims to balance academic rigor with accessible criticism, making history both entertaining and intellectually stimulating.

Key Features:

• Variety of Historical Figures: From universally known icons to lesser-known personalities, ensuring a wide range of discussions.
• Scholarly yet Relatable: Combining expert insights with a relatable tone, making complex historical analyses approachable for general audiences.
• Interactive Engagement: Encouraging listeners to rethink and question established historical narratives.

Conclusion

Dr. Claire Aubin wraps up the episode by reiterating the podcast's unique selling proposition: “No historically significant dead person is safe, and you might even learn something along the way. So why not join me and my rotating cast of highly qualified cynics for a new episode every Thursday on this Guy Sucked, available wherever you listen to podcasts” (01:15). This invitation encapsulates the show's commitment to providing fresh, critical perspectives on history, promising listeners both enlightenment and entertainment.

Notable Quotes

• Dr. Claire Aubin: “Have you ever caught yourself wondering whether Charlemagne was really all that great?” (00:01)
• Guest Scholar: “Because you could sell 10,000 to Costa Rica, but that same year, you could sell 250,000 to the United States, to Americans” (00:13)
• Host: “Learn why they were the worst from the people who know them best” (01:07)
• Guest Scholar: “Well, today we're talking about Jerry Lee Lewis. I f. Cking hate this guy” (00:41)

Final Thoughts

This Guy Sucked sets a bold precedent in the realm of historical podcasts by unapologetically critiquing figures who have long been celebrated. With Dr. Claire Aubin at the helm, listeners can anticipate a series filled with sharp analysis, engaging debates, and a willingness to challenge conventional wisdom. Whether you're a history enthusiast or someone looking to gain a deeper, more critical understanding of the past, this podcast offers a compelling new perspective every week.