U Up? – “I Love My Boyfriend But I’m Scared To Move In Together”

Host: Jared Freid
Special Co-Host: Tess Tregellis
Date: March 13, 2026

EPISODE OVERVIEW

This episode of U Up? features comedian and Betches creator Tess Tregellis as co-host alongside Jared Freid. The main theme centers on navigating modern relationship milestones, with a focus on anxieties around moving in together for the first time. Listeners’ emails prompt discussions on honesty in relationships (the “8 out of 10” rating debate) and pre-cohabitation jitters. Throughout, Tess and Jared balance humor and vulnerability, blending personal stories with actionable advice for listeners facing similar situations.

KEY DISCUSSION POINTS & INSIGHTS

1. Meet the Co-Host: Tess’s Relationship Backstory

[00:55 – 08:26]

• Tess opens up about a tough day (her childhood dog passed away), setting a candid tone, but insists she’s bringing “dead dog energy” in the best way.
• She shares how she met her boyfriend:
  • Did a comedy bit running around in a wedding dress.
  • Childhood acquaintances who reconnected after he saw her comedy show video.
  • “He was supposed to go on a date that night and canceled to come to my show.” (03:58)
• Both hosts agree familiarity from growing up together helped their connection.
• Tess self-describes:
  • “I am an overthinking, people pleasing, hopeless romantic.” (07:43)
• Dating advice: Be authentic, embrace your quirks, and the right person will match your energy.

2. Red Flag or Deal Breaker: Rating Your Partner’s Attractiveness

[15:07 – 28:24]

• Listener Email: A woman’s fiancé tells her she’s a “solid 8 out of 10” and “definitely above average.” She’s unsettled, wondering if this brutal honesty is a red flag.
• Hosts’ Reactions:
  • Tess: “I would be hurt by that for sure.” (18:40)
  • Jared: “Your girlfriend, when it comes to your significant other, they are something magical to you.” (19:25)
  • Both dissect how ratings devalue intimacy, pointing out that romantic partners should be each other’s hype people.
  • Tess: “His ideal of a 10 out of 10 has to be her.” (19:51)
  • Jared: Critiques how men mimic internet humor (Dave Portnoy’s “pizza rating” bit), saying it’s lazy and unoriginal when applied to people:
    “You are trying to play someone else’s bit.” (23:02)
• Key Advice:
  • Don’t reduce love to numbers; “grow out of 8 out of 10 and change into ‘my beautiful wife.’” (25:28)
  • If honesty hurts your partner, communicate the emotional impact and ask for real change.
• Memorable Moment:
  • Tess introduces the word "pulchritudinous": “Women love words. Numbers? Not interested. Tell me I’m eloquent, beautiful, pulchritudinous.” (24:16)
• Both agree: This wouldn’t be a deal breaker for an established couple but requires serious conversation and a change in attitude.

3. Main Topic: Moving In Together For the First Time – Navigating Anxiety

[30:55 – 43:09]

• Listener Email: 26F anxious about moving in with her boyfriend (28M) after over a year together, even though their relationship is great.
  • Fears include: Changing routines, “what if” overthinking, loss of independence, and avoidance tendencies (“I’ve always thought of myself as an anxious attachment”).
• Tess’s Perspective:
  • She is about to move in with her boyfriend after living alone for 5 years, echoing the writer’s anxieties.
  • “There will be conflict. I’m really worried about my digestive system and how I’m going to go to the bathroom. One toilet. We got a sound machine.” (33:13)
  • On couples’ dynamics: Tess admits she’s probably the messier partner but has adapted and grown a lot.
• Jared’s Take (the "walk dance" analogy, actionable reassurance):
  • Having moved in and broken up before, Jared reassures: “It works out. It’s fine. You’re gonna be okay.” (34:45)
  • Warns against attaching too much weight to logistical excuses ("we’re doing this because NYC is expensive") — urges embracing excitement and “idiot delusional loser” energy: Just be happy about the new chapter.
  • “You're moving in together because you want to...and that's a wonderful thing. It might not work out, but it probably will.” (36:37)
• Advice for Overthinkers:
  • Repeat the positives:
    "I can afford it. I have a great place. I'm moving in with someone I like." (39:00)
  • Don’t let anxiety about logistics (mattresses, couches) overshadow the big picture.
  • Jared: “If you end up breaking up with each other. You’ll be fine.” (43:05)
• Fun Banter:
  • Tess and Jared riff about indecision over couch shopping, diffusing tension with jokes about “getting it for free” and coupon-hunting.
  • Jared’s “bring up any issue and I’ll break it down” shtick reassures listeners — all concerns can be resolved with the right attitude.

MEMORABLE QUOTES & MOMENTS

• On vulnerability as a strength:
  Tess: “I learned to handle myself and like someone else will too.” (08:03)

• On reducing people to numbers:
  Jared: “Don’t think you are deserving of going the route of mogul CEO [with ratings], because you’re not.” (23:13)

• On getting excited (despite anxiety):
  Jared: “Be a idiot, delusional loser and get excited...That will wash away all the other stuff.” (37:00) Tess: “This is good for me to hear too.” (37:01)

• On cohabitation logistics:
  Tess: “I am the creative director of this endeavor...I want to see all the options, try all the couches.” (41:25)

NOTABLE TIMESTAMPS

• 00:55 – Tess’s intro, relationship background, “dead dog energy.”
• 07:43 – Tess’s hopeless romantic “mantra.”
• 15:07 – Introduction to the “Red Flag or Deal Breaker” – 8/10 rating conundrum.
• 19:25 – Jared’s perspective: “They are something magical to you.”
• 24:16 – Vocabulary highlight: “pulchritudinous.”
• 33:13 – Tess on moving in, bathroom logistics, personal anxiety.
• 34:45 – Jared on moving in, breakups, and survival.
• 36:37 – Reframing moving in: Do it for love, not NYC rent.
• 39:00 – The only things that matter: “I can afford it...” mantra.
• 41:25 – Tess as “creative director” of couch shopping.

OVERALL TONE & TAKEAWAYS

This episode blends relatable humor with surprisingly earnest advice. Both hosts validate listener anxieties but consistently reframe relationship milestones as exciting opportunities for growth and self-discovery — not just logistical hurdles. Vulnerability, direct communication, and not overthinking are recurring themes; so is a playful, sometimes irreverent tone.

Key Takeaways:

• Don’t undermine romance with harsh “honesty” — be your partner's cheerleader.
• Moving in is a big step, but not an irreversible risk: Feeling anxious is normal, but don’t let fear override excitement.
• Small logistical conflicts (e.g., mattress, couch) are natural; teamwork and humor help.
• Embrace delusion and joy — focus on what matters: love, security, a home together.

CLOSING REMARKS

[43:36]
Tess: “This was so fun.”
Jared: “If you are a listener this deep, that means you had a good time...I want, Jared, your opinion on this f*cking sucks. That’s okay.” (44:04)
Tess: “And I’d like to just live in delusion, so please don’t comment anything other than beauty and pulchritudity.” (44:10)

--

Subscribe, rate, and follow for more dating comedy and no-nonsense advice!

For more: @u.up.podcast on Instagram, and subscribe for bonus content and ad-free episodes.